Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Acharya, Vishal

Publications and source records attributed to Acharya, Vishal.

Dynamics of coupled thermoacoustic modes: Noise and frequency spacing effects

Practical combustion systems consist of multiple thermoacoustic modes that are linearly stable or unstable at a wide range of frequencies. When coupled, the modal interactions are a strong function of the frequency spacing between them – having very significant implications on interpretation of linear stability or instability of modes from experimental data. Frequency spacing between the modes particularly influences the stability and existence of potential limit cycle solutions. In this paper, we extend earlier deterministic studies to include the effects of noise, studying how deterministic dynamics change with the addition of noise and the simultaneous impact of frequency spacing (i.e., closely, or widely spaced). Specifically, this paper characterizes three key effects of noise, which are (1) distribution of limit cycle amplitudes (“diffusion”), (2) shift in the average limit cycle amplitudes (“noise induced drift”), and (3) introduction of new bifurcations that are not present in the deterministic system. Key conclusions from this work are that in highly noisy practical environments, a deterministic/ low noise analysis will not be sufficient to explain even critical qualitative features of the system – such as existence of stable limit cycles or their amplitudes. Furthermore, the nature of noise-induced effects on nonlinear modal interactions can be fundamentally different for degenerate, closely spaced, and widely spaced modes.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Finite flame thickness effects on Kolmogorov-Petrovsky-Piskunov turbulent burning velocities

KPP (Kolmogorov-Petrovsky-Piskunov) solutions of the reaction-diffusion equation have application in various physical phenomena occurring in biology, ecology, and reacting flows. In particular, these solutions are commonly used in turbulent combustion to scale turbulent burning velocities. Subject to certain conditions on reaction rate profile through the flame brush and turbulent diffusivity, this theory relates the turbulent burning velocity to the derivative of the reaction rate ($\tilde{ω}$) at the leading edge of the flame brush ($d\tilde{ω}$/$d\tilde{c}$ | $\tilde{c} =$0 ). Such waves are often referred to as “pulled fronts.” However, turbulent flames never actually satisfy the KPP conditions for a pulled front, as the turbulent flame brush, parametrized here by the thickness δ t , consists of an ensemble of laminar flamelets of thickness δ, where ε=δ/δ t $\ll$ 1 is very small, but nonzero, and $d\tilde{ω}$ /$d\tilde{c}$ tends to zero at the brush leading edge for high activation energy, combustion-type kinetics. Here, this paper analyzes these effects on KPP wave solutions, parametrized by ε=δ/δ t and Zeldovich number Ze focusing on whether turbulent flames retain their pulled front character and what the correction to the KPP wave speed is. Variational solutions of the reaction-diffusion equation show that the solution can be expanded in powers of 1/|ln⁡ε|. Both numerical and asymptotic results are presented, showing that the wave still exhibits pulled front solutions but with significant corrections to the KPP result. The leading order correction is of the form |ln⁡ε| –2 and independent of Ze. Higher order corrections are function of both ε and Ze. However, the dominant factor influencing the wave speed correction is due to the finite ε, with Ze exhibiting a weaker effect.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Optimum Injector Parameters for Thermoacoustic Stability in a Multi-Nozzle Can Combustion System

Abstract High-frequency transverse instabilities are an important concern in can combustor configurations. In these configurations which are typically operated with multiple injectors around a central injector, each injector is subjected to different parts of the acoustic mode shape and thus respond differently for the same instability mode. Recent work by the author has modeled the response of premixed flames to excitation by natural high-frequency transverse modes in a can combustor both in the center and outer nozzles. The stability of these acoustically non-compact flames was assessed using the Rayleigh criterion (Rayleigh Integral denoted as RI) and not the overall unsteady heat release as is the case for compact flames. Several key control parameters were studied, namely — flame angle, swirling strength, nozzle location. For non-axisymmetric modes such as the commonly occurring 1-T mode, both radial and azimuthal offsets of the nozzle location affected stability. The framework was applied to an optimization study to identify the optimal combination of parameters that minimizes RI for the different nozzles in the multi-nozzle system. In this study, a N-around-1 configuration was studied, and the results indicated that the different nozzles needed to be operated at different flame angles and swirl numbers to result in an overall minimum RI. However, the specific response of the different injectors was not considered. The helical mode distribution at each injector varies as we azimuthally go around the combustor’s injector distribution and thus the most amplified mode and the resulting flame response would be different. To minimize RI, it is important to determine the injector configurations that result in a hydrodynamic profile that minimizes the individual RI for each nozzle. The resulting relationship between the injector’s flow and local hydrodynamics can then be used in a hydrodynamics study of an individual injector so that the most optimal injector is chosen depending on its location in the combustor dump plane.

Acharya, Vishal↗

Experimental Investigation of Interactions Between Two Closely Spaced Azimuthal Modes in a Multinozzle Can Combustor

Thermoacoustic instabilities in annular or circular combustors are often coupled with azimuthal modes. These modes can be characterized by a spin ratio (SR), which quantifies the dominant mode between two counter-rotating waves, and a phase difference between them, which is directly related to the orientation of the antinodal line. This study investigates the instability amplitudes, SR, and phase difference of two closely spaced (3% of their mean frequency), yet distinct azimuthal modes; one is the first azimuthal (1A) mode, and the other is a combination of first azimuthal and first longitudinal (1A1L) mode. Each mode itself consists of two peaks that are spaced even more closely in frequency (0.8%). Furthermore, distinct harmonics at 2× and 3× of these frequencies, presumably associated with nonlinearities, are also evident in the spectra. Each mode is bandpass filtered in spectrum to analyze them separately. For the 1A mode, the SR and phase difference exhibit a variety of behaviors—including quasi-periodic standing waves, spinning waves, and intermittency—depending on operating conditions such as thermal power and azimuthal fuel staging. Similar trends are observed for the 1A1 L mode. Moreover, there is clear coupling between the 1A and 1A1 L modes, as their SRs are almost synchronized during the quasi-periodic standing wave. This synchronization is observed in phase differences as well, but not in the instability amplitude. For spinning dominant wave conditions, the SRs of each mode have similar average values, but they fluctuate in a seemingly random fashion. For the phase difference, both average and fluctuation are not correlated. In contrast, the instability amplitudes are strongly correlated, with modulation of the 1A mode leading to that of the 1A1 L mode. Furthermore, these results clearly indicate that complex coupling occurs across closely spaced frequencies under instability conditions, coupling that must be understood in order to capture limit cycle dynamics.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗

Nonlinear dynamics of combustor azimuthal modes: Experiments and modeling

This paper provides an experimental and theoretical investigation of azimuthal instabilities in a lean, premixed combustor. It presents data from a high Reynolds number, industrial-scale facility with multiple fuel stages that enable variation of radial and azimuthal symmetries. The combustor exhibits a variety of behaviors – including standing, spinning, mixed waves, and intermittent behaviors, as well as periodic limit cycles and quasi-periodic oscillations – depending upon varying power and azimuthal symmetry. A second key objective of this paper is to present a weakly nonlinear framework that is used to understand and interpret these results, showing the influence of eigenmode degeneracy, background noise, and azimuthal non-uniformities in mean quantities such as temperature and flame-acoustic coupling. In particular, this analysis shows the importance of the linear instability growth/damping rate and azimuthal non-uniformities in controlling the relative prominence of standing, spinning, or mixed waves at the limit cycle, as well as the preference in the spinning direction. It also shows the conditions under which single frequency or quasi-periodic oscillations are dominant, and how these are more fundamentally influenced by azimuthal non-uniformities and background noise.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Optimum Multinozzle Configuration for Minimizing the Rayleigh Integral During High-Frequency Transverse Instabilities

This paper develops a formalism for optimizing nozzle location/configuration with respect to combustion stability of high-frequency transverse modes in a can combustor. The stability of these acoustically noncompact flames was assessed using the Rayleigh integral (RI). Several key control parameters influence RI—flame angle, swirling strength, nozzle location, as well as nozzle location with respect to the acoustic mode shape. In this study, we consider a N-around-1 configuration such as typically used in a multi-nozzle can system and study the overall stability of this system for different natural transverse modes. Typically, such nozzles are distributed in a uniformly circular manner for which we study the overall RI, and for cases where RI > 0, we optimize the nozzle distribution that can reduce and minimize RI. For a fixed geometry such as a circular configuration, the analysis shows how the flame's parameters must vary across the different nozzles, to result in a relatively stable system. Additionally, for a fixed set of flame parameters, the analysis also indicates the noncircular distribution of the N nozzles that minimizes RI. Overall, the analysis aims to provide insights on designing nozzle locations around the center nozzle for minimal amplification of a given transverse mode.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Modal dynamics of high-frequency transverse combustion instabilities

This paper investigates the modal dynamics of self-excited high frequency transverse instabilities in a multi-nozzle, swirl-stabilized can combustor. It utilizes results from multiple pressure sensors to decompose the disturbance into clockwise (CW) and counter-clockwise (CCW) waves, enabling a reconstruction of the pressure amplitude, phase, anti-nodal line location, and spin ratio. While these types of decompositions have been demonstrated on small scale combustors, particularly annular combustors, this is the first study to analyze these results for a high power, multi-nozzle can combustor. Its particular focus is in characterizing the system evolution in phase space and the nature of the system attractors under linearly unstable conditions; results are presented in spin ratio-phase difference space, so that limit cycle oscillations appear as fixed points. Results are shown for conditions where three different attractors dominate (standing, CW, and CCW) but are taken for very long time periods (~50,000 cycles) so that the system's interaction with these attractors can be observed. For the standing mode-dominated case, the phase portrait shows spiral trajectories converging to a single fixed point. For the spinning mode dominated cases, however, multiple fixed points and saddle points were observed, and the trajectories showed a more complicated structure. It was also shown that even though the CW mode is dominant, this mode intermittently switches to standing or CCW modes for short period. These results suggest that the strength of each attractor depends on test conditions and that random noise stochastically perturbs the system so that large regions of the phase space are explored. Lastly, one interesting observation is that the angular velocity of the anti-nodal line linearly varies with the spin ratio under standing-mode dominant conditions.

42 ENGINEERING↗

The Sensitivity of Chemical Kinetic Models on Flame Transfer Functions in Acoustic Fluctuation Environments with Varying Equivalence Ratios

Various factors affect the heat release response of flames – thermodynamics, hydrodynamics, acoustics, etc. The coupling of heat release rate and acoustics, in particular, is essential to the design of combustion devices so as to avoid adverse effects during their operation. Modeling flames in acoustic environments requires an accurate understanding of the fundamental physics that occurs when flames interact with a fluctuating pressure field. Over the past couple of decades, researchers have been quantifying the impact of this fluctuating pressure field on the unsteady heat release rate. The flame transfer functions computed have also been shown to depend on the level of detail in the chemical kinetic model. This paper attempts to bridge the gap between these studies to understand how sensitive the flame transfer function is to various kinetic models. The problem is studied by performing multiple one-dimensional simulations using the low-Mach solver NGA. The detailed GRI-Mech 3.0 will be used for comparison. Also, the pressure amplitude and reactant equivalence ratio are varied to understand how the environment affects this sensitivity.

Girdhar, Anant↗