Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Aliberti, Gerardo

Publications and source records attributed to Aliberti, Gerardo.

ZPRD Database: ZPPR-15 Monte Carlo Results

The ZPPR-15 experiments [1] were mockups of a 330 MWe Integral Fast Reactor (IFR). The ZPPR-15 assembly consisted of a clean, two zone, approximately circular core surrounded by a thin depleted uranium (DU) blanket with sodium (Na) cooling and a thick stainless steel reflector. The ZPPR-15 program was conducted in four phases: A, B, C, and D. Each phase was marked by a particular composition of the reference assembly, with the last three being representative of the three stages of the IFR fuel cycle. This report documents all MCNP [2] runs of the ZPPR-15 loadings that were included in the ZPRD database on GitLab. In the present work, eigenvalues and associated standard deviations were computed for each ZPPR-15 loading with the use of the three data libraries (ENDF/B-VII.0 [3], ENDF/B-VII.1 [4] and ENDF/B-VIII.0 [5]). Relevant results from the obtained outputs are also discussed in this report with two main objectives: a) provide and evaluate updated calculated values with respect to previous reports, notably Refs. [6] and [7] that were based on the use of the ENDF/B-VII.0 library. b) address any change in the observed reactivity effects relevant to the analysis of the experimental data when a different data library is used (previously reported results were mostly based on the use of ENDF/B-VII.0 data only).

Aliberti, Gerardo↗

Software Validation Work With The ZPPR-15 Data

The analysis activities for fast reactors involve using many different pieces of software that are relied upon for their predictive capabilities. For this software to be considered reliable, documented proof that the predictions of the software are accurate is required. In this manuscript, the validation work that covers some of the Argonne software used in fast reactor design activities is discussed and displayed. This validation work includes neutron and gamma flux distributions, reaction rate distributions, and reactivity worth. In an ideal world, a reactor development program would have access to a comprehensive set of experimental facilities to help inform the design aspects of the reactor itself. While thermal-hydraulics experiments, and to a limited degree mechanical experiments, can be carried out today for validation needs, neutronics related experimental facilities are rather impractical because of the lack of experimental facilities. Given the desired time table for construction of new reactors, the reconstitution or creation of new neutronic experimental facilities is untenable and thus those reactor development programs must rely upon any available experimental measurements that are qualitatively similar to the design. While a methodology has been proposed to assess the similarity between the past experimental measurements and the reactor itself, that aspect is beyond the scope of this manuscript. In this manuscript, the focus is entirely placed on the analysis results for a series of experiments carried out at the ZPPR facility in Idaho in the mid-1980s. In this regard, this manuscript only shows the validation of the stated neutronics software for specific loadings of the ZPPR reactor. Because of the fuel form, its proposed enrichment, and the material content of the reactor core, the ZPPR-15 experiments were identified as potential validation data for the reactor. The ZPPR-15 experiments were intended as mockups of a 330 MWe Integral Fast Reactor program which was a follow on program to the Clinch River Breeder Reactor. In the ZPPR-15 series of experiments, measurements of the neutron spectrum, control rod worth, sodium void worth, foil reaction rate distributions, Doppler worth of heated samples, gamma dose, and axial expansion worth were all carried out and published. In many cases, these reactivity coefficients are good candidates to validate the reactivity coefficient calculation scheme used by the analysis software and included in the safety analysis activities of fast reactor development projects today. This manuscript discusses the modeling methodology and accuracy of the calculated experimental results using the LANL software MCNP and the ANL software package ARC (Argonne Reactor Codes). As will be shown, for many of the experimental measurements, the two software packages are found to be good predictive analysis tools for those experiments. In other cases, problems with the analysis methodology or underlying cross section data are exposed which indicates where predictive analysis is not as reliable. Finally, in some of the measurements the conclusion is reached that the experimental measurement cannot be reproduced with the analysis software as it is simply too difficult.

Aliberti, Gerardo↗

Irradiation Thermo-Mechanical Modeling and Analysis of University of Missouri Research Reactor HEU Fuel Plates

The University of Missouri Research Reactor (MURR) located in Columbia, Missouri is one of six U.S. High Performance Research Reactors (USHPRR), including one critical facility, that is actively collaborating with U. S. Department of Energy (DOE) National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) Material Management and Minimization (M3) Office of Reactor Conversion and Uranium Supply to convert from the use of highly enriched uranium (HEU; $\geqslant$ 20 wt% U-235) to low-enriched uranium (LEU; <20 wt% U-235) fuel. A new type of very high-density LEU fuel based on an alloy of uranium and 10 wt% molybdenum (U-10Mo) is expected to allow the conversion to LEU of MURR, as well as four other USHPRR.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Analysis of ZPPR-15 experimental data for VTR software validation

As part of the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) program, extensive validation work is being performed to demonstrate the fidelity of the Argonne Reactor Code (ARC) software package presently used for the core design studies. It is anticipated that this software will be also used for initial operations although additional software may be introduced at a later time to supplement or replace some components. The validation work was focused on accumulating reactor models that are consistent with the VTR and thus can be used to validate the accuracy of predictions made by the software used to design and operate the VTR. The U.S. does not have any active experimental facilities that can neutronically mockup the VTR core design. However, in the past, the U.S. had extensive experimental facilities for fast reactor neutronics. In that regard, the ZPPR-15 experiments carried out at ANL during the 1980s work best because the fuel form is closest to the VTR design, there is a considerable amount of processed data available for use, and existing staff are already familiar with the experimental machine and measurements. Because of previous collaborative work, many of the ZPPR-15 loadings of interest have already been processed into MCNP and preliminary ARC models, and a full uncertainty quantification has already been completed for many of the ZPPR-15 measurements. This manuscript covers the recent analysis work on the ZPPR-15 experiments and compares it with the experimental results. With respect to the ARC software components, this manuscript focuses on validation of the MC 2 , DIF3D and GAMSOR using the ZPPR-15 experimental data.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Sodium Void Worth and Control Rod Worth Measurements in ZPPR 15

Sodium void worth and control rod worth were measured in Phases A, B, C and D of the ZPPR15 experimental program. Sodium voiding was simulated by replacing stainless steel cans containing sodium by empty stainless steel cans of the same sizes. The control rod worth measurements were measurements of simulated control rods (CRs) and simulated empty control rod positions (CRPs). A CRP consisted of a 2 x 2 array of drawers filled with sodium plates. A CR consisted of a 2 x 2 array of drawers containing alternating columns of boron carbide plates and sodium plates in the front 18 inches and just sodium plates in the back 18 inches. The ZPPR staff published the measured sodium void worths and control rod worths and the statistical uncertainties in the measured values. In reality, the published uncertainty for each of these measurements is only one component of the total uncertainty. There are additional contributions from uncertainties related to measurement technique, plate compositions and reproducibility. However, the dominant uncertainty for the sodium void worth and control rod worth measurements is the uncertainty in βeff which is required to convert from the natural measurement units, cents, to the calculation units, pcm or Δ/k 1 k 2 . A full uncertainty analysis was performed for the sodium void worth and control rod worth measurements. The significant uncertainties were quantified, and a total uncertainty was derived for each sodium void worth or control rod worth measurement. The ZPPR-15 experimental records were used to create detailed as-built Monte Carlo models of the sodium void worth and control rod worth configurations. These models were used to compute the sodium void worths and control rod worths. (C/E – 1) and the related uncertainty in (C/E – 1) were derived for the measured worths.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Analysis of Neutron Spectrum and Control Rod Worth Measurements in Several ZPPR-15 Loadings

This paper discusses the analysis of neutron spectrum and control rod reactivity worth measurements with deterministic and Monte Carlo methods. Deterministic results are obtained with 3D reactor models generated with the BuildZPRModel tools developed at ANL. The Monte Carlo simulations are performed with MCNP6 and are based on 3D models that include all geometric details ('as built' models). This study also shows the application of the cross section processing options recently implemented in BuildZPRModel that are based on the leakage and TWODANT method to take better into account the coupling effects among the different reactor zones.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Comparative study on neutronics characteristics of a 1500 MWe metal fuel sodium-cooled fast reactor

Under the cooperative effort of the Civil Nuclear Energy R&D Working Group within the framework of the U.S.-Japan bilateral, Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA) have been performing benchmark study using Japan Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor (JSFR) design with metal fuel. In this benchmark study, core characteristic parameters at the beginning of cycle were evaluated by the best estimate deterministic and stochastic methodologies of ANL and JAEA. The results obtained by both institutions show a good agreement with less than 200 pcm of discrepancy on the neutron multiplication factor, and less than 3% of discrepancy on the sodium void reactivity, Doppler reactivity, and control rod worth. The results by the stochastic and deterministic approaches were compared in each party to investigate impacts of the deterministic approximation and to understand potential variations in the results due to different calculation methodologies employed. From the detailed analysis of methodologies, it was found that the good agreement in multiplication factor from the deterministic calculations comes from the cancellation of the differences on the methodology (0.4%) and nuclear data (0.6%). The different treatment in reflector cross section generation was estimated as the major cause of the discrepancy between the multiplication factors by the JAEA and ANL deterministic methodologies. Impacts of the nuclear data libraries were also investigated using a sensitivity analysis methodology. Furthermore, the differences on the inelastic scattering cross sections of U-238, ν values and fission cross sections of Pu-239 and µ-average of Na-23 are the major contributors to the difference on the multiplication factors.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Investigation of Heterogeneity Effects on Calculated Sensitivities of the ZPPR-15B Assemblies

In past years, sensitivity studies of ZPR and ZPPR assemblies were carried out with deterministic codes for several purposes, such as uncertainty estimation of calculated parameter values, cross section adjustment, representativity analysis. etc.. However, these sensitivity studies used simplified R-Z models of ZPR/ZPPR assemblies where the multi-group cross section data was obtained from the homogenized material compositions of each reactor zone. The main reason for this simplification was the lack of a deterministic path able to compute sensitivity coefficients for complicated 3D geometries in transport theory. Also, each ZPR and ZPPR assembly consists of several different drawers each containing different plate types and plate arrangements and it was felt that performing sensitivity calculations with an equivalent R-Z reactor model would capture most of the feedback while the heterogeneity effects were believed to be of second order. Recently a new code, BuildZPRModel, was developed at ANL that automatically generates the inputs for cross section processing and core calculation of heterogeneous ZPR and ZPPR assemblies for 3D transport calculations. Additionally, the PERSENT code (recently developed at ANL as well) is able to carry out sensitivity calculations in transport theory on 3D geometries. With the benefit of the newly developed codes, a sensitivity study was performed for the heterogeneous model of ZPPR-15B assemblies 96 and 102 generated by BuildZPRModel. The results were compared with the sensitivities computed with the use of fully homogenized R-Z reactor models, in order to quantify the impact of heterogeneity effects neglected in the analysis performed in past years. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Investigation of Heterogeneity Effects on Calculated Sensitivities of the ZPPR-15B Assemblies

In past years, sensitivity studies of ZPR and ZPPR assemblies were carried out with deterministic codes for several purposes, such as uncertainty estimation of calculated parameter values, cross section adjustment, representativity analysis. etc. However, these sensitivity studies used simplified R-Z models of ZPR/ZPPR assemblies where the multi-group cross section data was obtained from the homogenized material compositions of each reactor zone. The main reason for this simplification was the lack of a deterministic path able to compute sensitivity coefficients for complicated 3D geometries in transport theory. Also, each ZPR and ZPPR assembly consists of several different drawers each containing different plate types and plate arrangements and it was felt that performing sensitivity calculations with an equivalent R-Z reactor model would capture most of the feedback while the heterogeneity effects were believed to be of second order. Recently a new code, BuildZPRModel, was developed at ANL that automatically generates the inputs for cross section processing and core calculation of heterogeneous ZPR and ZPPR assemblies for 3D transport calculations. Additionally, the PERSENT code (recently developed at ANL as well) is able to carry out sensitivity calculations in transport theory on 3D geometries. With the benefit of the newly developed codes, a sensitivity study was performed for the heterogeneous model of ZPPR-15B assemblies 96 and 102 generated by BuildZPRModel. The results were compared with the sensitivities computed with the use of fully homogenized R-Z reactor models, in order to quantify the impact of heterogeneity effects neglected in the analysis performed in past years.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Physics challenges for advanced fuel cycle assessment

Advanced fuel cycles and associated optimized reactor designs will require substantial improvements in key research area to meet new and more challenging requirements. The present paper reviews challenges and issues in the field of reactor and fuel cycle physics. Typical examples are discussed with, in some cases, original results.

advanced fuel cycles↗

Physics challenges for advanced fuel cycle assessment

Advanced fuel cycles and associated optimized reactor designs will require substantial improvements in key research area to meet new and more challenging requirements. The present paper reviews challenges and issues in the field of reactor and fuel cycle physics. Typical examples are discussed with, in some cases, original results.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗