Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Allain, Jean Paul

Publications and source records attributed to Allain, Jean Paul.

Discovering tungsten-based composites as plasma facing materials for future high-duty cycle nuclear fusion reactors

Abstract Despite of excellent thermal properties and high sputtering resistance, pure tungsten cannot fully satisfy the requirements for plasma facing materials in future high-duty cycle nuclear fusion reactions due to the coupled extreme environments, including the high thermal loads, plasma exposure, and radiation damage. Here, we demonstrated that tungsten-based composite materials fabricated using spark-plasma sintering (SPS) present promising solutions to these challenges. Through the examination of two model systems, i.e., tungsten-zirconium composite for producing porous tungsten near the surface and dispersoid-strengthened tungsten, we discussed both the strengths and limitations of the SPS-fabricated materials. Our findings point towards the need for future studies aimed at optimizing the SPS process to achieve desired microstructures and effective control of oxygen impurities in the tungsten-based composite materials.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Tungsten erosion and divertor leakage from the DIII-D SAS-VW tungsten-coated divertor in experiments with neon gas seeding

Collector probes have been used to examine tungsten divertor leakage in a variety of scenarios with low-Z impurity seeding during operation with the new tungsten-coated SAS-VW divertor in DIII-D. Measurements of tungsten deposition on collector probes inserted into the far Scrape-off-Layer (SOL) are used to deduce how efficiently tungsten leaks out of the closed, V-shaped divertor after it is eroded from the target surfaces. Qualitative differences in the tungsten deposition patterns across the collector probes provide clear experimental evidence that the SOL conditions depend on the low-Z impurity seeding conditions. These measurements show that in scenarios where neon gas is injected into the plasma, the tungsten divertor leakage and SOL transport depend on the poloidal location from which the neon is injected. In particular, neon injection from the Inner Midplane and Outer Midplane appear to each result in higher divertor leakage by a factor of 2 to 3 compared to cases with neon injection from either the SOL Crown or from the SAS-VW divertor itself.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Effects of transition metal carbide dispersoids on helium bubble formation in dispersion-strengthened tungsten

Abstract The formation of helium bubbles and subsequent property degradation poses a significant challenge to tungsten as a plasma-facing material in future long-pulse plasma-burning fusion reactors. In this study, we investigated helium bubble formation in dispersion-strengthened tungsten doped with transition metal carbides, including TaC, ZrC, and TiC. Of the three dispersoids, TaC exhibited the highest resistance to helium bubble formation, possibly due to the low vacancy mobility in the Group VB metal carbide and oxide phases. Under identical irradiation conditions, large helium bubbles formed at grain boundaries in tungsten, while no bubbles were observed at the interfaces between the carbide dispersoid and tungsten matrix. Moreover, our results showed the interfaces could suppress helium bubble formation in the nearby tungsten matrix, suggesting that the interfaces are more effective in trapping helium as tiny clusters. Our research provided new insights into optimizing the microstructure of dispersion-strengthened tungsten alloys to enhance their performance.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Review of Recent Progress in Plasma-Facing Material Joints and Composites in the FRONTIER U.S.-Japan Collaboration

The plasma-facing components (PFCs) of future fusion reactors will have intricate structures and require multiple materials because no one material can simultaneously satisfy all the requirements of the component. The dissimilar material joints in PFCs must withstand extreme thermal and stress gradients under neutron irradiation. The Fusion Research Oriented to Neutron Irradiation and Tritium Behavior at Material Interfaces (FRONTIER) U.S.-Japan collaboration seeks to explore and explain the behavior of internal solid interfaces in PFCs under neutron irradiation. The first step of the collaboration was to identify the leading PFCs that should be studied further and prepare them for the next step, which will include neutron irradiation. Different strategies for material development are being pursued worldwide to produce robust PFCs. Here, in this work, an overview is presented of some of the most promising materials in the areas of copper alloys, tungsten-copper composites, tungsten-steel composites, additively manufactured tungsten, particle-reinforced tungsten, and tungsten and SiC fiber composites. Each material’s fabrication and benefits are described, and some discussion of remaining questions is given.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

First lithium experiments in HIDRA and evidence of helium retention during quasi-steady-state stellarator plasma operations

Recent experiments in Hybrid Illinois Device for Research and Applications (HIDRA) have had operational discharges between t discharge = 60 and 1000 s using electron cyclotron resonant heating (ECRH) of the plasma. This means that quasi-steady-state plasma discharges reach conditions to study long-pulse plasma material interactions (PMIs). The newly commissioned HIDRA-Material Analysis Test-stand PMI diagnostic is used to place a drop of lithium onto a heated tungsten surface, transfer the sample in-vacuo and expose it in a helium plasma. Helium is of interest as there is an open question to whether lithium will be able to remove helium ash in real fusion devices. The introduction of the W-Li sample in HIDRA resulted in evaporation of lithium into the helium plasma during a 600 s pulse and caused a reduction of over 90% in neutral pressure during the discharge. It was also observed that the plasma density and temperature increased by over 2.5 times. Using spectroscopy and a helium collisional radiative model, the peak temperature and density of the helium plasma can be monitored during the discharge. During lithium evaporation, as significant lithium ionization occurs, there is a 85% drop in the HIDRA vessel neutral pressure, despite a constant flow rate of He gas. This reduction in neutral pressure is supported by spectroscopy data with corresponding reductions in He I line intensities (587 nm, 667 nm, 706 nm, and 728 nm), as well as those of other impurities. At one point in the discharge a lithium plasma is created, as indicated by an increase in Li + emission and a complete reduction in He + emission, but the electron density jumps from ne = 3 × 10 18 m –3 to over ne = 8 × 10 18 m –3 while the core temperature stays relatively constant between Te = 16 eV and 20 eV. Once lithium has completely evaporated from the sample and the majority of the ionized lithium has diffused from the plasma to the vessel walls, pressure and spectroscopy data paired with He collisional radiative model calculations shows a re-establishment of a helium plasma in a low recycling regime. In this regime, the density drops down to ne = 2 × 10 18 m –3 and the electron temperature increases from T e = 20 eV to over T e = 50 eV indicating an increase in helium heating efficiency. This is also indicated by the He+ emission re-establishing and having a higher intensity. Here, we show the results from the first lithium campaign in HIDRA. In the presence of lithium, and in particular when lithium ions are present, the helium disappears from the plasma via an as of yet unknown complex relationship that needs to be further studied. The most likely explanation is that the lithium ions are distributed around the vessel and able to trap helium to the surface turning HIDRA into a large gettering surface. These results have potential implications on future plasma facing component design using liquid lithium for impurity and recycling control using limiters and divertors.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Upgrade of the Materials Analysis Particle Probe (MAPP-U) to decipher the impact of lithium-based surfaces on NSTX-U plasma behavior

Understanding the plasma wall interaction (PWI) remains a critical issue for the feasibility of thermonuclear magnetic fusion energy solutions. Key issues with PWI mechanisms in fusion tokamak reactors include: evolution of surface chemistry and its role on hydrogen retention. In particular how low-Z coatings such as lithium can impact the behavior of plasma at the edge and in the core. PMI (plasma-material interactions) are particularly important for strategies that involve low-recycling regimes and the use of lithium PFS (plasma-facing surfaces) to attain them, as in the case of NSTX-U. Recent reports have indicated the importance of access to the evolving plasma-facing surface during and in-between plasma discharges. Changes in surface chemistry and morphology due to ion bombardment and the difficulty of diagnosing plasma-facing surfaces, especially reactive surfaces, complicate the development of a predictive understanding of the wall and its interaction with the plasma. Consequently, this impairs the ability to design advanced PFC materials for future plasma-burning fusion reactors and appropriate PMI code validation. The Materials Analysis Particle Probe (MAPP) is an established and on-going PMI probe diagnostic system compatible with the highly chemically reactive system of lithium and boron coatings adopted by the NSTX-U research program. MAPP is the first PMI diagnostic to capture the surface physics and chemistry in-vacuo in a fusion tokamak system and correlate this data to controlled plasma shots. Currently MAPP captures this information at a fixed radial location at the NSTX-U outboard divertor region. The MAPP diagnostic has enabled understanding of the near-surface and surface chemistry of complex evolving lithiated and borated carbon-based PFC surfaces retention and transport of hydrogen. Coupled to atomistic simulations in collaboration with P. Krstic of Stony Brook U. MAPP has been very successful in achieving high-impact scientific research in its current grant period evidenced by two invited review articles and over 20 peer-reviewed manuscripts and over 40 contributed and invited presentations at both national and international conferences.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Report on the Second MPEX User Research Forum

The Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX) User Research Forum (MURF), a 2 day workshop, was held virtually on September 13–14, 2021, to seek community input for MPEX, a new high-power linear plasma device that is currently being built at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). This was the second MURF workshop. The first MURF workshop was held in October 2019 in La Jolla, California, and focused exclusively on the definition of the surface analysis station for MPEX. MPEX is designed to address crucial R&D gaps in plasma material interactions (PMI) for future fusion reactors. The MPEX plasma source and heating systems will allow plasma exposures of plasma-facing materials and components to prototype fusion reactor divertor plasma conditions. The MPEX design accommodates the introduction of previously neutron-irradiated materials for fusion reactor-relevant plasma exposures. This capability will be unique worldwide. The US fusion program has advocated for such a device in numerous community reports in recent years, and now ORNL is building this new device. MPEX is a Major Item of Equipment project executed by the US Department of Energy’s Office of Science Fusion Energy Sciences.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Design and Analysis of an Advanced Three-Point Bend Test Approach for Miniature Irradiated Disk Specimens

Candidate tungsten armor materials in a magnetic confinement fusion device must be able to withstand thermal variation that leads to internal stresses caused by the impinging heat load. In addition, the thermomechanical properties of these materials are degraded by irradiation-induced defect accumulation. Fission reactor–based irradiation data are used to predict the fusion neutron damage and property change. This study examines the motivation and design of a custom-designed three-point bend test for neutron-irradiated disk specimens that are 3 mm in diameter to be able to define the flexural strength of advanced tungsten materials, alloys, and composites—and to the extent that embrittlement occurs after neutron irradiation. The theory provided shows a calculation for the flexural deflection and shear deflection due to the small-geometry constraints. A finite element deformation analysis is performed to evaluate the mechanical stress field of disk bend specimens. The stress values above 80% of the maximum stress are concentrated in 2.4 mm of the 3.0-mm length of the centerline across the tungsten disk diameter. A bend test fixture has been designed and fabricated to enable testing of these specimens with precisely engineered tolerance and minimal machine compliance. This fixture will be able to be placed inside a universal testing frame at elevated temperatures for the mechanical property evaluation of future neutron-irradiated disk specimens.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development of the materials analysis and particle probe for Proto-MPEX

The Prototype Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (Proto-MPEX) is a linear plasma device being used in plasma source research and development (R&D) for the proposed MPEX. Once the R&D is completed, this device can also be used to perform plasma–material interaction studies. To perform these studies, a new materials analysis and particle probe (MAPP) has been constructed. The MAPP’s components are a sample holder and manipulator and a custom vacuum chamber with ports to facilitate surface chemistry diagnostics. The MAPP’s overall design enables rapid sample turnaround and in vacuo surface characterization. The surface analysis vacuum chamber has ports for x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, thermal desorption spectroscopy, back-scatter ion scattering spectroscopy, forward-scatter ion scattering spectroscopy, and direct recoil spectroscopy. The sample manipulator and holder is a Lesker/UHV Multi-Centre Analytical Stage, which is used to place the samples in the exposure region of the Proto-MPEX or the analysis position in the MAPP vacuum chamber. The sample holder has a heating capability of up to 1200 °C for heated exposure and for desorption studies. In this work, we present the MAPP’s design and the first tungsten sample exposure with ex situ analysis that shows a surface deposition layer on the exposed target, highlighting the need for additional in situ measurements on the Proto-MPEX.

Beers, C. J. (ORCID:0000000150985459)↗

Summary Report on the Refined User Requirements for U.S. Fusion Prototypic Neutron Source

The Fusion Prototypic Neutron Source (FPNS) is proposed as an urgent near-term facility necessary for understanding D-T fusion neutron degradation processes in materials and for the development of high-performance radiation tolerant materials for fusion power reactors. This facility is central to our goal of predicting the behavior of materials in the harsh D-T neutron environment and calibrating and verifying the materials performance models necessary to support design of next-generation fusion reactors. Key FPNS performance metrics were previously defined for the cost-efficient facility necessary to adequately and expediently resolve key materials science knowledge gaps required to move to next-step fusion devices. This brief report is intended to expand upon this previous metrics discussion as an aid to selecting the most desirable FPNS concept and enabling a facility that meets the program needs.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Deciphering the PMI Surface Chemistry of Lithium-Based PFCs and its Effects on High Performance Plasmas in NSTX

The primary aims or objectives of the proposed work here focus on the dynamic measurement (Illinois PI Allain) and atomistic-based multi-scale computational atomistic simulations (UTK PI: Wirth) of: 1) lithium coatings with re-deposited hydrogenated carbon surfaces and high-Z substrates, 2) lithium coatings on boronized ATJ graphite surfaces and high-Z substrates and 3) lithium coatings on ATJ graphite and high-Z substrates with variation in temperature. Three main primary tasks are proposed to address each of the primary objectives listed above: 1) dynamic in-situ irradiation with D+, He+ species of lithium coatings with variation in interface substrate morphology (e.g. smooth vs rough, fuzz vs nanostructured); 2) validation and coupling with multi-scale computational simulations connecting the irradiated surface to the plasma edge; 3) extrapolation to long-pulse conditions (e.g. function of flux vs fluence studies). In primary objective #3, temperature-based effects will be studied to evaluate three primary mechanisms: a) D uptake and recycling, b) erosion, and c) surface melting and evaporation as a function of substrate morphology and chemistry.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Advanced grazing-emission X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy with small-angle neutron scattering for in-vivo surface composition and defect/morphology surface evolution in tokamak PMI

The dynamic and extreme conditions of thermonuclear fusion tokamak plasmas render material surfaces almost impossible to examine in real-time, surface-sensitive conditions. However, combining particle-probe techniques that are not charge-state dependent open the possibilities of in-vivo diagnosis of the plasma-material interface. The reconstituted surfaces of plasma-facing components ranging from first-wall to divertor-component regions in the device vary depending on the complex plasma transport characteristics of the device. For example, in ITER it is predicted that fluxes of the order 10 22 to 10 24 and incident charged-particle energies of 100’s to 1000’s of eV will reach the surface while in the divertor regions within the private-flux and near the inner and outer-strike points would vary from a few eV to 100’s of eV governed by the complex Chodura magnetic sheath dynamics. This means that the penetration range of most charged-particle fluxes would range between 1-100’s of nm (e.g. for fuel particles of D and T and He).

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗