Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Amy F Fagan

Publications and source records attributed to Amy F Fagan.

‘Trapped Wave’ Resonances in Jets From Plug Nozzles

An experimental study is conducted investigating the characteristics of ‘trapped wave’ (TW) resonance tones occurring with nozzles having a center plug. The pressure fluctuation spectral peaks due to these ‘guided’ or ‘trapped’ waves when the nozzle contains a center plug occur at nondimensional frequencies that are an order of magnitude larger than those noted with simple round nozzles. It appears that the exit gap width of the plug nozzle is the characteristic length-scale that dictates the corresponding TW frequencies. The results of this study further our understanding of this phenomenon as it relates to other complex nozzle geometries.

instability↗

Flow, Noise and Thrust of Supersonic Plug Nozzles

A model-scale experimental study is conducted with a plug nozzle exploring the performance of various plug geometries for supersonic aircraft concepts. All data are acquired with a given outer nozzle that is convergent and has an exit diameter of 2 inches. The shape of the centrally placed plug is varied from conic with various half-angles (lengths), to method of characteristics (MoC) designs, as well as truncated and porous geometries. Noise and schlieren flow visualization data, presented in an earlier paper, are briefly reviewed first. The focus in this paper is on the thrust performance. A newly constructed thrust stand is used to acquire data covering a nozzle pressure ratio (NPR) range from transonic (‘landing and takeoff’, LTO) to supersonic (‘cruise’) conditions. Back-to-back measurements allowed assessment of relative performance. A plug with its ‘crown’ located somewhat inside the nozzle, rather than near the exit, is found to perform better. A longer 10° plug performs better than a shorter 22° plug. A porous plug, that significantly suppresses broadband shock associated noise, is found to incur a modest thrust loss that might be an acceptable tradeoff near LTO conditions. A companion numerical simulation for some of the plug geometries yields data trends bearing reasonable agreement with the experimental results.

jets↗

Flow, Noise and Thrust of Supersonic Plug Nozzles

Nozzles with internal mixers and external plugs are candidates for supersonic aircraft concepts. A fundamental experimental investigation is being conducted at NASA Glenn Research Center (GRC) to assess the optimum performance of external plugs. The focus is on noise reduction potential during landing and takeoff (LTO) operation of the aircraft while maintaining optimum thrust performance. Earlier results on flow field and noise of plug nozzles were presented in the 2022 AIAA Aeroacoustics Meeting [1]; see also [2] for a review of the plug nozzle literature.

Jets↗

Flow and Noise from Supersonic Plug Nozzles

Nozzles with external plugs are candidates for propulsion of future supersonic aircraft. A model-scale experimental study is conducted exploring the flow and noise characteristics of various plug nozzles. For a given outer nozzle, the plug geometry is varied from conic with various half-angles (lengths) to plugs designed by the method of characteristics (MoC) as well as truncated and porous plugs. So far, noise characteristics and schlieren flow visualization data have been acquired. Limited numerical simulations have also been done addressing thrust performance. The simulations show that the MoC plugs out-perform the conic cases, especially around high Mach number cruise conditions. The experimental data, however, show that the MoC plugs are noisy relative to the conic cases at low Mach number landing and takeoff (LTO) conditions. The increased noise (with MoC at LTO) is accompanied by unsteady turbulent structures and increased jet spreading, as seen in schlieren pictures. At LTO, the longest conic plug is found to be the least noisy. Furthermore, a porous surface on the long conic plug effectively suppresses broadband shock associated noise (BBSN) at higher Mach numbers. Thus, a dilemma remains. MoC design gives best thrust performance at cruise but it is noisy at LTO. A long conic plug, on the other hand, is quieter at LTO but may have unacceptable thrust at cruise.

jets↗

Contrails Measurement and Testing Capabilities in NASA's Particulate Aerosol Laboratory

The NASA Glenn Research Center Particulate Aerosol Laboratory (PAL) is a ground test facility for studying emissions and contrails at upper atmospheric conditions. The facility consists of a small-scale combustor that generates hot combustion gases and soot nanoparticles, which flow through a transition pipe into a jet nozzle, which exhausts into an altitude chamber. Thermodynamic conditions experienced in flight are matched in the altitude chamber, allowing the study of ice particle formation of simulated aircraft engine exhaust plumes. A non-intrusive optical diagnostic technique based on Mie scattering provides ice particle size, number density, and mass density. A suite of commercial extractive particle measurement instruments provides estimates of soot number density, size, and black carbon mass distributions. Measurements are presented for various fuels at chamber conditions covering an altitude range of 20,000 ft (6 km) to 45,000 ft (14 km) altitude and ambient temperatures from -48°C to -68°C. The data presented demonstrate the effect of soot number density, altitude, and fuel-to-air equivalence ratio on the contrail ice particle formation. Ice mass density measurements are compared to values predicted by a thermodynamic plume similarity solution.

Optical Instrumentation↗

Study of a Plug Nozzle for Supersonic Aircraft Concepts

Nozzles with external plugs are candidates for the exhaust system of supersonic aircraft concepts in an ongoing research effort at NASA. As part of that effort a fundamental study is being conducted at NASA Glenn Research Center (GRC). Experimental and limited numerical simulation results from this study, for a plug nozzle with a convergent nozzle (cowl),have been reported in recent publications[1,2]. Conventional method-of-characteristics (MoC) design for the plug requires that the flow is choked at the nozzle exit. This is why a sharp convergence of the cowl is invoked in such a design in most previous studies [3-5], leading to the earlier choice of the convergent cowl. Such a nozzle, however, is not suitable for supersonic flights because of large boat tail drag suffered by its outer surface. The boat tail drag consideration dictates that the cowl be more or less cylindrical in shape. While various other shapes have been studied in the past [6], essentially a cylindrical shape is adopted in the larger research program at NASA. The cylindrical shape has certain advantages. With the plug crown located somewhat inside the nozzle, the flow experiences convergence and divergence as with a C-D nozzle. By translating the plug, different throat-to-exit area ratio could be achieved to obtain fully expanded condition at different values of NPR. This offers a relatively easy active control strategy for the nozzle geometry throughout the flight regime from landing and takeoff (LTO) to cruise conditions. A plug nozzle model mimicking the geometry being considered in the NASA program, i.e., having a cylindrical exit, have been fabricated recently for continued fundamental studies. Some of the plugs used with the earlier convergent cowl [1] are readily adopted to this model. In addition, a few other plugs have been obtained following a numerical optimization study [7]. The various configurations are to be investigated for thrust, noise and flow fields, with complementing numerical simulations. Thrust data for a variety of configurations as well as limited noise data are in hand. Further explorations including schlieren visualization are to be conducted in the near future. The proposed paper is to summarize all these results. In the following, a few key results obtained so far are described.

jets↗

Study of a Plug Nozzle for Supersonic Aircraft Concepts

A plug nozzle with a cylindrical cowl is studied. The geometry is adopted following commercial supersonic aircraft concepts considered in an ongoing NASA program. For the given cowl, the plug geometry is varied that includes shapes developed by a numerical optimization study as well as porous plugs. Experimental data on noise and flow field are discussed with an eye for minimum noise at low nozzle pressure ratios (NPR2) representing landing and takeoff (LTO) conditions. NPR up to about 4.7 is covered in the experiments. Limited thrust data with accompanying numerical simulation results are also presented. Results show that a plug designed for optimum thrust at cruise is noisier while a plug designed for optimum thrust at LTO has less noise, throughout the NPR range covered. The results also show that a plug nozzle can generate transonic tones and excess broadband noise (EBBN) at lower NPR, apart from well-known screech tones and broadband shock associated noise (BBSN) at higher NPR. A long porous plug is found to effectively suppress all these aberrant noise components while suffering less than 1% loss in thrust coefficient.

Jets↗