Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Andrew E Lovejoy

Publications and source records attributed to Andrew E Lovejoy.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2024

Pull-off Behavior of Stitched Composite T-Joints

T-joints are key structural elements that connect opposing surfaces, thereby providing the load path between flat or curved panels (i.e., upper and lower wing skins) and transverse components (i.e., stiffeners). Due to the low interlaminar strength of polymer matrix composites and their geometrical discontinuities, these joints are vulnerable to pull-off loads. To address these issues, through-thickness reinforcements can be employed to enhance the interlaminar capability of these type of joints. In this study, T-joints were manufactured using through-thickness stitching in dry carbon preforms and cured using the vacuum-assisted resin transfer molding (VARTM) process. Stitched and unstitched T-joints were tested under pull-off loading conditions, and surface strain fields were obtained using a 3D digital image correlation system. The ultimate load, displacement, and absorbed energy of the stitched T-joints were greater than their unstitched counterparts by approximately 16%, 34%, and 58%, respectively. Failure mechanisms were identified by examining fracture surfaces using optical microscopy. Results demonstrate that through-thickness stitching significantly improves the damage tolerance of T-joints, which highlights the effectiveness of stitching to enhance the structural integrity of large aerospace components.

VARTM↗
NASA NTRS2023

Reduction in Computational Cost of Progressive Failure Analysis of Composite Structures

Designing aircraft structures requires efficient modeling approaches to iterate on multiple structural configurations to achieve an optimal design. Typically, damage tolerance is not considered at the design stage because of the high computational cost in its implementation within a finite element modeling approach. Therefore, analytical or empirical approaches are often used to size critical damage-tolerant structures once an optimal design is determined. In this study, the Progressive Release eXplicit Virtual Crack-Closure Technique (PRX-VCCT) is assessed for its capability to cost-effectively evaluate skin stringer separation of a blade-stiffened panel that is subjected to seven point bend loads. An initial verification study was performed to evaluate PRX VCCT to accurately simulate skin-stringer separation with respect to existing cohesive element approaches. Furthermore, the influence of element size, ranging from 0.10 in. to 0.40 in., on the total computational time using the PRX-VCCT is investigated. The results indicate that the PRX-VCCT can be used to accurately simulate skin stringer separation using large element lengths (0.40 in.). Additionally, a significant reduction in the computational time to simulate skin stringer separation is observed using the PRX-VCCT. Large-scale progressive damage analysis using PRX-VCCT can be implemented early in the design cycle of composite structures without requiring a global-to-local modeling approach.

Composites↗
NASA NTRS2023

Lessons Learned from Large-Scale Aerospace Structural Testing

Large-scale testing of aerospace structures is frequently the final step in a development project to validate the structural performance, and that step typically involves a large cost and time investment. To ensure that the testing provides the required data, avoiding errors that can result in an unsuccessful test and failure to meet objectives is critical. Five lessons learned are presented herein to provide insight to those conducting tests in order to help them avoid known pitfalls that may result in an unsuccessful test. Five large-scale tests are described, and include two composite wing tests, a composite hybrid-wing body center section test, a full-scale 27.5-ft diameter metallic barrel test, and an 8-ft diameter metallic barrel test. Problems identified during the testing and mitigation approaches to solve the problems are presented, then the lessons learned are identified and discussed.

Lessons Learned↗
NASA NTRS2022

Optimization Approach for Wind Tunnel Fan Blade Strain Gage Correlation with Test Fixture Unknowns

NASA has a significant maintenance challenge with the aging wind tunnel infrastructure across the Agency. Some wind tunnel fan blades, such as those in the National Transonic Facility at NASA Langley Research Center, have been in use for far longer than their planned 10-year lifetime. No detailed analytical models of the fan blades from their initial fabrication were created. To support the fabrication of either new, nominally identical fan blades or newly designed fan blades, accurate analytical models of the existing fan blades are necessary to demonstrate an understanding of the capabilities of the existing fan blades. Additionally, the existing documentation of the testing of the existing fan blades has gaps. In this report, a process for improving test-analysis correlation for these wind tunnel fan blades is discussed. This process involved a detailed study of unknown parameters in test fixture parameters from the old and incomplete test documentation. To improve correlation, these unknown parameters were used as design variables in an optimization study to minimize the error between test data and computed structural responses. Legacy strain gage data from tests conducted in 1981 were compared with results from a finite element model created in 2019. The use of test data from 1981 was necessary because none of the existing fan blades could be spared for use in destructive structural testing. While this process was demonstrated for wind tunnel fan blades, this process could be utilized for evaluating unknowns in test fixtures for other structural test configurations.

wind tunnel↗
NASA NTRS2020

Structural Analysis of Wind Tunnel Blades for the National Transonic Facility

NASA has a significant maintenance challenge with the agency’s aging wind tunnel infrastructure. Wind tunnel blades, such as the ones in the National Transonic Facility at NASA Langley Research Center, have been subjected to damage from impacts and fatigue. Accurate analytical models of these blades are necessary to either recertify replacement blades to be built or for redesign of these blades. In this paper a process for generating structural finite element models of these wind tunnel blades is presented. The model developed in this paper was analyzed under loading conditions from tests conducted on the original blades and the results are compared with legacy strain gage data.

Brian H Mason↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Test and Analysis Correlation of Standard and Hybrid Standard/Thin-ply Composite Notched Test Specimens

Hybrid composite laminates, a combination of standard-and thin-ply layers, are structurally efficient and can offer opportunities for weight savings over composite laminates composed of only standard-thickness plies. Three hybrid laminates and three standard laminates were tested and analyzed to provide a baseline comparison for not only weight savings and strength benefits of the hybrid stacking sequences, but also to provide fidelity for progressive failure modeling techniques using the two different laminate designs. The standard and hybrid composite specimens were designed to have the same thickness and in-plane stiffness properties, as closely as possible, and were loaded with axial tension and axial compression. Small notched specimens were tested under compression and tension loading, and larger intermediate specimens were tested under tension loading, only. The finite element modeling represented the as-designed panel dimensions as well as the real-life testing conditions through various boundary conditions. The progressive failure modeling and analysis technique described, exhibited very good correlation with the hybrid test specimens, and therefore is appropriate for use in future investigations into more appealing stacking sequences. The progressive failure modeling can also be used to determine the proper usage of thin-ply materials in order to determine the most ideal strength benefits over their standard-ply counterparts.

Alana Zahn↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Improving Structural Test and Analysis Correlation Using Digital Image Correlation Boundary Measurements

Simplified idealizations, such as clamped or simply supported, are commonly used as support boundary conditions in modeling and analysis of tested aerospace structures. However, these simplifications are not always appropriate and characterization of the response of non-rigid boundaries is often required to improve test and analysis correlation. While e analysis models are typically modified to better represent the test, this modification is often not practical due to the complexities of the boundary response. A study is conducted to examine the use of digital image correlation (DIC) to measure the boundary support structure response and then to adjust the test data to remove the effects of the boundary response in order to improve test and analysis correlation. A high-aspect ratio composite wing test is the subject of the study. Three sources of boundary flexibility contributing to rigid body rotation of the test wing are identified and quantified using both DIC and conventional test data. The wing displacement test data are adjusted using DIC data for these sources. Wing displacement test data is also adjusted using direct measurement of wing rotation from a DIC system that monitored the top surface, root region of the wing, and using available conventional instrumentation. The adjusted data exhibits improved test and analysis correlation and demonstrated the benefit of using DIC along with conventional instrumentation to collect and interpret test data.

Andrew E Lovejoy↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Investigating Transverse Ply Thickness and Cracking Effects on the Tensile Strain to Failure of Thin-ply, Cross-ply Carbon Composites using X-ray Computed Tomography

The effect of 90°-ply thickness on the fibre direction tensile failure strain of cross-ply laminates was investigated by designing four different cross-ply composite laminate configurations with 90° blocks of varying numbers of plies adjacent to a central block of 0° plies. The range of 90° block thicknesses evaluated included conventional ply thicknesses to allow for comparisons with conventional ply geometries. The central 0° ply block was subjected to primarily longitudinal tension with a small component of transverse tension due to the layup and thermal residual stresses. Advanced instrumentation, including acoustic emission and X-ray computed tomography, was used to detect and visualize damage accumulation in the specimens. It was found that decreasing the thickness of the 90° ply blocks reduced transverse matrix microcracking up to the point where no full-width transverse cracks developed prior to ultimate failure. A small degradation of the fibre direction failure strain in the central 0° plies was found as the 90°-layer thickness increased in the laminates, which corresponded with the development of edge/transverse cracks.

Tamas Rev↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Stitched Composites with Three-Dimensional Stitch Paths

Stitched composites have been shown to exhibit damage tolerance and to reduce weight compared to traditional layered composites through unitization of the structure by elimination of fasteners. Stitching capabilities have been incorporated into the Integrated Structural Assembly of Advanced Composites (ISAAC) system at NASA Langley Research Center with the introduction of two stitching heads. Stitching path control was initially implemented as straight lines in space, as was done for previous stitching development. However, more complex stitched structures such as a wind tunnel blade or around cutouts within a fuselage or wing skin, require that the stitching paths be implemented as three-dimensional (3D) stitching paths in space. Unfortunately, control programming output by an existing preprocessor program cannot stitch these curved paths due to problems that arise in stitch formation and the introduction of side forces on the needles using the conventional programming approach whereby the head is simultaneously controlled through translations and rotations. This lack of capability is most significant for the single-sided stitching head, where two needles are in the preform at the same time for the majority of the stitching process. A means to program 3D stitching paths in space was developed whereby the translation and rotation of each stitch were decoupled, thereby eliminating the problems associated with current control programming approach. Using this newly developed stitching path definition and control programming, complex stitching paths have successfully been stitched at the ISAAC facility. The ability to stitch general 3D stitching paths in space enables the use of stitching on more complex parts.

carbon-epoxy↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Lessons Learned from Large-Scale Aerospace Structural Testing

Large-scale testing of aerospace structures is frequently the final step in a development project to validate the structural performance, and that typically involves a large cost and time investment. In order to ensure that the testing provides the required data, avoiding errors that can result in an unsuccessful test and failure to meet objectives is critical. Presented herein are five lessons learned to provide insight to those conducting tests in order to help them avoid known pitfalls that may result in an unsuccessful test. Five subject large-scale tests are described, and include two composite wing tests, a composite hybrid-wing body center section test, a full-scale 27.5-ft diameter metallic barrel test, and an 8-ft diameter metallic barrel test. Problems identified during the testing and mitigation approaches to solve the problems are presented, then the lessons learned are summarized.

Lessons Learned↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Lessons Learned from Large-Scale Aerospace Structural Testing

Large-scale testing of aerospace structures is frequently the final step in a development project to validate the structural performance, and that typically involves a large cost and time investment. In order to ensure that the testing provides the required data, avoiding errors that can result in an unsuccessful test and failure to meet objectives is critical. Presented herein are five lessons learned to provide insight to those conducting tests in order to help them avoid known pitfalls that may result in an unsuccessful test. Five subject large-scale tests are described, and include two composite wing tests, a composite hybrid-wing body center section test, a full-scale 27.5-ft diameter metallic barrel test, and an 8-ft diameter metallic barrel test. Problems identified during the testing and mitigation approaches to solve the problems are presented, then the lessons learned are summarized.

Lessons Learned↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Finite Element Analysis Validation for Stitched, Blade-Stiffened Aerospace Structures

Increased performance and manufacturing rates for aircraft or spacecraft structures may be achieved using stitched and resin infused composite structures. In order to carry out design and analysis of stitched composites, 2-dimensional (2-D) and 3-dimensional (3-D) modeling approaches for stitched and non-stitched carbon fiber vacuum-infused parts were developed. These analysis approaches will be compared with data from previous test specimens tested at the NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC) under tension and bending load conditions. The preliminary results presented herein for the 2-D and 3-D models capture the strain patterns observed in digital image correlation (DIC) data for stitched, blade-stiffened specimens tested in either tension or bending. The analysis method study presented for these specimens is part of a larger analysis development effort planned for stitched composites, with the modeling practices developed here contributing to those that may be applied to a new set of blade- stiffened test specimens that are currently being manufactured for testing as well as the design of a blade stringer pull-off test. These future tests are expected to provide opportunities to validate the developed modeling approaches for predictive purposes, and to provide opportunities for further refinement of the modeling approaches.

HiCAM↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

On the Representation of Through-The-Thickness Reinforcements in Finite Element Analysis of Stitched, Blade Stiffened Panels

Modern aircraft employ laminated composites for their tailorable in-plane properties, high specific strengths, and high specific stiffnesses. However, laminated composites exhibit relatively poor interlaminar properties without through-the-thickness reinforcements. Quantifying the necessary amount of through-the-thickness reinforcements is necessary to reduce cost and meet damage tolerance certification requirements. In this study, a discrete superposed cohesive element (DSCE) approach is applied to represent the mixed-mode delamination behavior of stitched stiffened panels subjected to seven-point bending. This approach is compared to a one-dimensional embedded spring element (ESE) method. The DSCE approach uses two superposed bilinear traction-separation laws to obtain a representative load-displacement response determined from interlaminar tensile and shear tests. Additionally, several stitch configurations (unstitched, stitched, and overstitched) are evaluated in terms of their load-displacement response and crack-arrestment capability. Results indicate that the DSCE and ESE approaches show good agreement with respect to the predicted load-displacement response, but the ESE method tends to overpredict the crack growth behavior by approximately 13%. Stitches were not observed to fail during skin-stringer separation. Using an overstitched laminate with stitches near the flange edge provides the greatest crack-arrestment capability. Furthermore, the skin retains 92% of its stiffness after skin-stringer separation occurs.

composites↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Manufacture of Hybrid Standard-Ply/Thin-Ply Carbon/Epoxy Panels for Notched Test Specimens

Weight is a critical metric for aerospace structures, and one possible way to reduce weight is to improve performance using hybrid standard-ply/thin-ply laminates from a single material system. Previous studies showed benefits for stiffness, strength, reduced damage after impact, and increased compression-after-impact strength for these hybrid laminates. Another study suggested that performance of compression-loaded notched hybrid laminate specimens performed better than standard-ply laminates under compression, but the standard-ply laminates performed better under tension loading. However, analysis predicted the failure load and mode better for the hybrid laminates. An analytical study determined several hybrid laminate designs to use in a follow-on testing regiment that is planned to further study the notched hybrid composite performance under compression and tension load. Described herein is a manufacturing method to efficiently manufacture hybrid laminates using automated fiber placement using a 16-tow head where 8 tows are standard-ply and 8 tows are thin-ply. The method saves time in that it eliminates the need to change spools of material when switching from standard-ply to thin-ply lamina, and reduces the waste associated with changing of spools. The method is ideal for small manufacturing operations or research facilities that have only a single head, and the method was successfully applied at the NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC) Integrated Structural Assembly of Advanced Composites (ISAAC) facility to manufacture nine panels that will be used for the follow-on notched specimen testing of hybrid and standard laminates.

composite↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Modal Test and Analysis Correlation of Wind Tunnel Blades for the National Transonic Facility

NASA has a significant maintenance challenge with the aging wind tunnel infrastructure across the agency . Wind tunnel blades, such as the ones in the National Transonic Facility at NASA Langley Research Center, have been subjected to damage from impacts and fatigue. Accurate analytical models of these blades are necessary to either recertify replacement blades to be built or for redesign of these blades. In this paper an upgraded finite element model of these wind tunnel blades with the capability of representing damage is presented. An eigenvalue analysis of the structural model is performed, and the boundary conditions are adjusted to simulate the natural frequencies obtained by experimental testing of a set of twenty five blades in 1992. Additional numerical studies of the effect of delamination damage on the natural frequencies of the blade are conducted using the tuned finite element model.

wind tunnel↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Improved Method for Increased-Rate Stitched Composites Manufacturing

Stitched composites, as defined herein, are created by stitching a dry preform, infusing the preform with resin and curing the resin. Stitched composites have been shown to have benefits over unstitched composites for stiffened structures, including improved damage tolerance, reduced weight, and fewer fasteners. However, conventional stitched composite structure production is very time and manual-labor intensive, and therefore is not conducive for high-rate production of commercial aircraft main structure. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Hi-Rate Composite Aircraft Manufacturing (HiCAM) Project has the objective to increase the manufacturing rate for future composite aircraft. Stitched resin infused (SRI) composites are one of the technologies being considered under the HiCAM Project, but to be viable, production rates must be increased (i.e., production time reduced). Previous work has shown that it is possible to reduce the time required to stitch a dry composite preform, such as a skin with integral stiffeners, but the stitching process is a small portion of the total time required to produce a stitched preform. To significantly reduce overall stitched preform production time, a study was undertaken to examine a new stitching method that would yield time reduction in the pre- and post-stitching activities that include all portions of a stitched preform production with the exception of the actual stitching process. The new method resulted in significant reduction in production time, from 27% to 40%, while at the same time reducing the costs associated with fabricating a stitched preform by eliminating stations within the production line, simplifying tooling, reducing labor, and reducing consumables.

Stitching↗