Neutron Irradiation and Postirradiation Examination of Chromium-Coated Framatome M5 Cladding
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Aumand, Matthieu [Framatome Inc].
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This study investigates the mechanical behavior of High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) irradiated M5FRAMATOME cladding under simple and complex loading conditions through axial tensile and reversible cyclic bending. Axial tension specimens were pre-machined prior to HFIR irradiation while cyclic bend specimens were inserted as intact tubes. Tests articles were neutron-irradiated to 4 and 16 dpa, and specimens were tested at ORNL's hotcell facilities. The axial tension tests were conducted under constant displacement control, and the reversible cyclic bend tests were performed using ORNL's Cyclic Integrated Reversible-Bending Fatigue Tester (CIRFT) apparatus. Results showed that mechanical response of Cr-coated and uncoated M5FRAMATOME cladding were similar and independent of irradiation dose for axial tension tests, while Cr-coated specimens’ reversible cyclic bend behavior differed from uncoated counterparts. For all tests, irradiation temperature showed a significant impact on the mechanical behavior. Below 280°C, all axial tensile specimens whether coated or not behaved similarly. Above 280°C, YS and UTS showed decrease with increasing irradiation temperature. A similar behavior was also observed in cyclic bend tests as well. The mechanical damage during cyclic bend tests was linked to damage accumulation in unirradiated Cr-coated zircaloy-4 specimens, and the effect of irradiation temperature was related to changing characteristics of defect mobility during high temperature irradiation.
In January 2025, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) sponsored a technical workshop with fuel vendors that provided a forum for increased collaboration on backend fuel cycle research. The workshop reviewed observations of thermal annealing of irradiated zirconium alloys in simulated dry storage conditions and discussed implications to the industry’s interest in reducing wet storage to optimize operational flexibility and the expected trend of increasing discharge burnup (and decay heats), which could lead to an increase in dry storage temperatures. One approach to accommodate increased decay heats in dry storage is to increase the regulatory temperature limit during dry storage, which is now 400°C. However, this could lead to thermal annealing of the cladding, which will tend to increase creep rates, creep strains, and ductility while decreasing yield strength. These considerations are compounded by bonding between the pellet and cladding at high burnup, which results in the pellet carrying more load during fuel rod deformations, especially in bending, which is the dominant deformation phenomenon in canister drop analyses. Because the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) recommends yield strength as a primary failure criterion for accident analyses in storage and transportation, particularly for canister drop scenarios, the purpose of the workshop was to develop options for alternative failure criterion that could replace yield strength in canister drop analyses. Topics discussed were (1) the regulatory framework, (2) the effect of thermal annealing on microhardness and tensile properties of cladding materials, (3) the effect of thermal annealing on fuel rod failure during bending, bending fatigue, and pinch loading, and (4) an alternative failure criterion for canister drop analyses. This paper provides a summary of the key discussions and outcomes of the workshop