Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Baglietto, Emilio

Publications and source records attributed to Baglietto, Emilio.

At least 19 records

Validation of URANS and STRUCT-ε turbulence models for stratified sodium flow

Simulations of a transient stratified sodium experiment are carried out using a classic unsteady RANS model and the second-generation URANS model, STRUCT-ε. Turbulence modeling challenges and their implications to stratified flow prediction are discussed in the context of other sources of error. Input errors are discussed and addressed; discretization error is calculated to be less than 5% of the inlet velocity, for 80% of the domain; and remaining errors in temperature distributions are attributed to the turbulence model. Qualitative flow features from the simulations are presented and discussed. Compared to the experiment, the STRUCT-ε turbulence model provides a more physically accurate prediction of temperature and momentum mixing in key regions of the domain. Quantitative measures such as the L 2 norm of the temperature discrepancy demonstrate the improved performance of the STRUCT-ε approach. In conclusion, the magnitude of the temperature fluctuations is very well-predicted by the STRUCT-ε, while URANS overpredicts them by approximately 50%.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Challenge Problem 1: Preliminary Model Development and Assessment of Flexible Heat Transfer Modeling Approaches

This report presents the modeling progress of a university consortium studying flexible modeling for turbulent heat transfer. In the context of advanced nuclear reactor design, where challenges include non-unity Prandtl fluids, free and mixed convection, and transitional flow, computational fluid dynamics methods are underutilized due to low confidence in modeling approaches and high computational cost. This report evaluates the performance of engineering CFD models in diabatic, buoyant turbulent flow. It finds that all turbulence models including several variants of the k-ε and k-ω models struggle to predict accurate turbulent momentum and heat transfer in such flows. The Nusselt numbers have been compared between the models and the DNS data, where calculations have been performed for each case and trends have shown a good agreement between DNS estimated Nusselt numbers and available correlations as well as experimental data. A novel DNS correlation for high Pr cases as they are transitioning from mixed convection to natural convection has been proposed. While Nusselt number errors relative to DNS range from 20% to 50%, the models capture similar trends to DNS with respect to Nusselt suppression and amplification under varying levels of buoyancy effect. This report also highlights model form error as a significant contributor to CFD predictions and proposes a framework for quantifying model error and improving confidence in CFD calculations. To improve the predictive capability of engineering CFD models, data-driven approaches for turbulence models are investigated. Theoretical frameworks based on the invariant tensor / vector basis neural networks for prediction of Reynolds stresses and turbulent heat fluxes are employed. The models are developed using direct numerical simulations data for forced convection flows of different fluids in vertical planar channel domain. The framework is implemented in spectral element solvers Nek5000 / nekRS and has shown a potential for future development and consideration of mixed convection flows.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Progress Toward Simulating Departure from Nucleate Boiling at High-Pressure Applications with Selected Wall Boiling Closures

Recently, a Eulerian-based two-fluid computational fluid dynamics (CFD) framework with a wall heat flux partitioning approach has been intensively investigated for departure from nucleate boiling (DNB) simulation under the U.S. Department of Energy–funded Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) program. Understanding of the DNB characteristics over a range of pressurized water reactor–like operating conditions and accurate prediction of boiling crisis in the nuclear power system have been grand challenges because of the large impact of DNB on reactor safety and operational economics. The ultimate goal of this task in the CASL program is to introduce a robust multiphase CFD–based DNB modeling framework that is capable of characterizing an entire boiling history in which the wall boiling mode experiences the following through multiple stages of heat transfer mode: (1) single-phase convective heat transfer, (2) nucleate boiling heat transfer, and (3) identification of the departure of nucleate boiling. To validate the CASL boiling model, we have benchmarked simulated DNB over three different flow channel configurations (pipe flow, 5 × 5 fuel bundle with mixing vane tests, and 5 × 5 fuel bundle without mixing vane tests) against experimental measurements, and the validation result with open literature is reported. The DNB detection criteria in the simulation are checked by monitoring the peak wall temperature, wall dryout factor, and net energy balance. In addition to the DNB performance test, some preliminary sensitivity results on closure model selection are reported to address the prediction capability of local void profile against measurements. The boiling simulation tested in this study exhibits a maximum deviation of 24% from the measured DNB value in a high-pressure (i.e., 138 bars) subcooled pipe flow test. The ranges of operating conditions are as follows: 1650 to 2650 kg/m 2 ·s for mass flux and 8.5 to 96 K for subcooled inlet temperature. The deviation is even reduced to 7% when the subcooled temperature is less than 40 K. Besides accuracy, base practice guidelines for DNB detection criteria are tested by monitoring three simulation variables: (1) maximum wall temperature, (2) wall dryout factor (i.e., K-value), and (3) energy balance. Numerical robustness of DNB simulation is largely achieved in most of the validation test except for a few high subcooled test cases.

42 ENGINEERING↗

An Efficient 1-D Thermal Stratification Model for Pool-Type Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors

Investigating thermal stratification in the upper plenum of a sodium fast reactor (SFR) is presently a technology gap in SFR safety analysis. Understanding thermal stratification will promote safe operation of the SFR before its commercial deployment. Stratified layers of liquid sodium with a large vertical temperature gradient could be established in the upper plenum of an SFR during a down-power or a loss-of-flow transient. These stratified layers are unstable and could result in uncertainties for the core safety of an SFR. In order to predict the occurrence of the thermal stratification efficiently, we developed a one-dimensional (1-D) transport model to estimate the temperature profile of the ambient fluid in the upper plenum. This model demands much less computational effort than computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes and provides calculations with higher fidelity than historical system-level codes. Two flow conditions were considered separately in the current study depending on if in-vessel components are presented in the upper plenum. For the condition where in-vessel components, specifically the upper internal structure, are presented, we assumed that the impinging sodium was evenly dispersed in the ambient fluid within the distance between the bottom of the in-vessel component and the jet inlet surface. For the condition where no in-vessel components are presented, we assumed that the impinging sodium was evenly dispersed in the ambient fluid within the jet length, which was determined through data-driven trainings. The newly developed 1-D model showed similar performance with the CFD model in both cases. However, due to the assumption of flat profiles of the impinging jet axial dispersion rate, nonnegligible discrepancies between the 1-D prediction and the measured data were observed.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Direct Numerical Simulation of Turbulent Flow Inside a Differentially Heated Composite Cavity

In this work, turbulent flow inside a modified differentially heated cavity at high Rayleigh number (Ra ~ 10 9 ) has been studied through fully resolved direct numerical simulation (DNS) using the high-order spectral element method code Nek5000. The flow configuration includes two separate physical phenomena: the natural recirculation itself, and the flow inside a curved channel. Simulations have been carried out using both the Boussinesq approximation and the low-Mach compressible formulation. Significant discrepancies between the two methods inform of the extreme caution that should be exercised when using the Boussinesq approximation in the limits of its applicability. The DNS solutions are analyzed in terms of polynomial-order convergence and Reynolds stress budgets, and the turbulence quantities and velocity profiles are presented as a reference for the validation of turbulence models.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Gen-0 BWR Modeling Application and Validation (L3 Milestone THM.P18.01)

This milestone report describes the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) work conducted for completion of the thermal hydraulics Methods (THM) Level 3 milestone L3:THM.P18.01 Gen-0 BWR Modeling Application and Validation. The extension of existing boiling closure designed for Pressurized Water Reactors (PWRs) to the high void fraction condition of Boiling Water Reactors (BWRs) is one of the challenges for Multiphase Computational Fluid Dynamics (M-CFD) applications. In the efforts aimed at developing the advanced boiling closure for BWRs, the baseline closure model, so-called ‘Zero’ closure, has been developed by leveraging the experience gained through the Numerical Nuclear Reactor project. This baseline closure model is physics-based, simplest and robust, but it does not contain any explicit descriptions of the complex high void fraction mechanisms. This is a continuation of the CASL thermal-hydraulic study to develop and assess the CFD-BWR models. In FY-17, the applicability has been evaluated against the international OECD/NRC BFBT benchmark data. In the present work, we assessed the capability of CFD-BWR model for void drift phenomena in the modern BWR fuel designs which make use of both full-length and part-length rods.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Thermal Stratification Modeling and Analysis for Sodium Fast Reactor Technology

General discussion of thermal hydraulic phenomenon present in sodium fast reactors during known reactor transients. Specifically, this research focuses on presenting research focused on modeling thermal stratification in the upper plenum of a sodium fast reactor. An experimental facility was built to provide validation for both computational fluid dynamic and system code analysis.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Thermal Stratification Modeling for Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors: A Status Update

Thermal hydraulic behavior in the upper plenum of pool- type sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) is a major concern, as many design challenges are concentrated in this region. As SFR designs aim for licensing and commercialization, it is important to accurately analyze and predict the thermal-hydraulic behavior in this region during accident scenarios, specifically thermal stratification. Thermal stratification models are currently a major source of uncertainty in most system codes for all types of power plants. Most system codes, including SAS4A/SASSYS-1, a system level code developed by Argonne National Laboratory (Argonne), use very coarse meshes that cannot capture the complexities of the stratification phenomena. While the commonly employed lumped-volume based models for thermal stratification are able to run in a matter of seconds, they result in approximate results and can only handle simple cases. Other 2-D and 3-D methods, such as computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models, can analyze simple configurations with higher fidelity, but come with a relatively large computational expense. Finding a modeling solution that is both accurate and computationally efficient has proven difficult. This paper provides details of a review and gap analysis of the various modeling approaches proposed to date and explores a path forward for future thermal stratification modeling efforts, with a focus on developing new models for the SAS4A/SASSYS-1 system code.

Morgan, Sarah↗

Evaluation of DNB Predictive Capability in Multiphase Boiling Model of STAR-CCM+

The current milestone report is to evaluate the predictive capability of the existing boiling model in the commercial Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) package (so called, STARCCM+ 11.04.012), and validate the numerical calculation of a boiling curve with identification of departure from nucleate boiling (DNB) point by comparing with experimental measurements in the literatures. The current work directly demonstrates the DNB predictive capability in multiphase boiling model for nuclear reactor applications, which is tightly coupled with the CASL mission goal and evolving need from the nuclear industry. The boiling model tested here is based on the heat flux partitioning RPI approach (so called Generation-I boiling model in STAR-CCM+). A traditional experimental DNB test with a vertical pipe flow performed by Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), and a realistic 5x5-bundle fuel bundle with non-mixing vane DNB test conducted by Westinghouse Electric Company (WEC) are selected as reference experimental measurement. A baseline DNB simulation methodology is reported and its predictive capability is evaluated qualitatively as well as quantitatively with existing experiments. A parametric study of the microscopic boiling closure relations is investigated. For the pipe flow DNB validation study, the calculated DNB from the current study demonstrates good agreement with measured DNB data. The maximum deviation is observed less than 20%. The trend behaviors of DNB in varying operating conditions are similar with the observation reported in the literature. In addition, a meshing strategy for 5x5 bundle case is reported, some challenges on 5x5 bundle DNB model are also discussed. The current study provide a fundamental insight on the usefulness and limitations of the generation-I boiling model approach and may contribute to an advanced boiling model development for a practical nuclear thermal hydraulic application.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗