Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Balash, Peter C.

Publications and source records attributed to Balash, Peter C..

A Review of PJM Interconnection's April 13, 2018, Response to National Energy Technology Laboratory's Report on Reliability, Resilience and the Oncoming Wave of Retiring Baseload Units

In a March 2018 report entitled Reliability, Resilience and the Oncoming Wave of Retiring Baseload Units , the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) analyzed the fleet performance of market areas impacted by a 13-day storm known colloquially as the “Bomb Cyclone.” Special attention was paid to northeastern areas, as these were most impacted. With respect to PJM Interconnection LLC (PJM), the report found that 1) without coal units, the system would have experienced shortfalls; 2) approximately 25 gigawatts (GW) of heretofore underutilized coal-fired plants provided crucial capacity, lending the system resilience; 3) nearly 28 GW of natural gas-fired capacity did not deploy, due to severe spikes in natural gas prices caused in turn by constrained gas deliverability, in the face of tremendous space heating demand and transmission deliverability constraints on the bulk electric system. In April 2018, PJM issued a response that argued the NETL analysis was misplaced, asserting that gas-fired capacity was available and that it could have been called into service but was not, due to “economics.” This brief represents NETL’s reaction to PJM’s assertions in its April 2018 response.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Modeling Electric Generation Capital Costs with Uncertain Future CO 2 Pricing

As new environmental regulations are reevaluated and various tax subsidies begin to expire, the outlook for investors in power generation may be more uncertain than ever. There are many electric power generation studies and forecasts published by a wide array of entities from private consulting firms to government agencies and national labs. These studies show which power generation technologies are favored to be constructed under the assumptions within each future scenario, and many people in businesses and government use these studies for planning purposes and decision-making. One common need for assumptions in these studies is the rate of return investors will require for constructing new generation. It is shown in this paper that for each one percent added to the cost of capital (CoC) above a base level, the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) increases by 1-to-4 percent for generation with a 30-year life and debt term, a length commonly used for conventional generation. Therefore, if analysts make a distinction in the CoC for different technologies without quantitative support, it could result in misleading technologies being chosen as favored when facing regulatory uncertainty. The practice of adding a penalty (percentage adder) to the CoC was initially discovered in the Annual Energy Outlook, published by the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). This paper presents the framework typically used in scenario analysis for selecting a CoC, consistent with the practice in long-range planning models that seek to identify the best future generation technologies for meeting electricity demand. Examples are provided on why full specification and consistency is necessary to obtain accurate results for any scenario. It is also shown in this paper how the mischaracterization of regulatory uncertainty to address the uncertainty about CO2 mitigation in a scenario can lead to a misleading outcome when applying a risk penalty to the CoC. The analysis presented shows that applying a 3-percentage penalty to the CoC for fossil generation implies a different price per ton for each generation technology, which suggests the uncertainty about CO2 regulations would best be addressed through pricing sensitivity analyses rather than penalties added to the CoC.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

China Energy Perspective

This presentation discusses the energy perspective of China, the world's most populous country which has the highest overall energy demand. China is the largest producer of coal and the second largest consumer of oil.China will need to rely heavily on imports to meet rising energy demand. Development of China’s energy infrastructure significantly lags energy demand. China’s largest oil fields are mature and production has peaked, leading to a focus on developing largely untapped reserves in the western interior provinces and offshore fields.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗