Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Betzler, B. R.

Publications and source records attributed to Betzler, B. R..

Transformational challenge reactor design characteristics

The Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program was conceived with the goal to reduce costs and time frames associated with advanced reactor deployment by leveraging developments in advanced manufacturing, advanced materials, data science, and rapid prototyping and testing. The final deliverable of the TCR program was to be an operational test of a novel reactor design. The TCR core design incorporates a dense tri-structural-isotropic/SiC fuel form and volumetrically efficient yttrium hydride moderator, both of which were manufactured and characterized under the TCR program. The TCR is a 3 MW{sub th} He-cooled experimental nuclear reactor designed to reach a total integrated burnup of less than 24 effective full-power hours to keep the radioactive source term to a very low level. TCR design process revealed a positive moderator coefficient; however, the negative doppler coefficients for the fuel and thermal expansion of fuel, moderator, and core support plate yield an overall negative reactivity coefficient. Calculated fuel element temperatures and stresses are well within safety margins. The maximum hypothetical accident (i.e., de-pressurized loss of forced cooling) yields only a modest increase in reactor temperatures that are all within safety margins. This paper summarizes the high-level TCR design characteristics, which were derived from neutronics, thermohydraulics, thermomechanics, and safety analyses.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Multiphysics Analyses of the Bottom Components of the 3D Printed Transformational Challenge Reactor

This research presents multi-physics analyses on the bottom components of the Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) facility. These components include the bottom axial reflector and the steel exit cone. The bottom axial reflector is made of pure silicon carbide elements hosting helium cooling channels These elements are 3D printed and therefore can host any arbitrary shape of the helium cooling channels. The design of the bottom reflector considers the neutronics and thermo-fluid dynamics performances as well as the manufacturing process optimization. More precisely, the best design of the bottom reflector reduces neutron leakage by avoiding straight cylindrical helium channels that facilitate neutron leakage, minimizes the helium flow pressure drop, and reduces the number of 3D printed silicon carbide pieces. The exit cone steel structure collects the hot helium from the bottom fuel assemblies and channels the cold helium to the top of the fuel assemblies. The steel simultaneous contact with hot and cold helium flows sets a large thermal gradient. Different designs of the exit cone are proposed to reduce the steel equivalent stress from the helium thermal load. The multi-physics analyses have been performed using Ansys Fluent, Ansys Mechanical, STAR-CCM+, and Serpent computer programs.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Serpent and MCNP Calculations of the Energy Deposition in the Transformational Challenge Reactor

This paper focuses on the calculation of the energy deposition in the Transformational Challenge Reactor by two major Monte Carlo codes: Serpent and MCNP. The first software computation relies on Kinetic Energy Released per unit Mass (KERMA) factors while the second one relies on Q-values. The results from these two independent computation methodologies are in very good agreement; however, Serpent runs much faster than MCNP (for the same computational model) and allows for a detailed energy deposition distribution from a 1-mm-side square mesh with a relative statistical error between 0.5% and 1%. This detailed energy deposition is suitable for multiphysics analyses aimed at design optimizations. In order to calculate the energy deposition, Serpent needs enhanced ACE files (distributed by the software developers). Unlike other Monte Carlo software that uses inputs based on Python or Java languages, the Serpent input syntax is very similar to that of MCNP; a Python script can convert a MCNP input to a Serpent input in seconds. For simulations not requiring the calculation of the energy deposition, Serpent can also read nuclear data from MCNP ACE files, which eventually improves the comparison of the results of the two codes.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Application of Shift Ex-Core Calculations to a Detailed MSR Model

This report documents the collaborative research conducted between Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) on applying the Monte Carlo neutronics code Shift to calculate the radiation dose rates for a detailed molten salt reactor (MSR) model based on the Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (MSBR). In this work scope, the ANL and ORNL teams worked together and applied Shift to calculate the radiological environments of this detailed MSR facility modeled with explicit geometries. The radiological conditions within the MSR facility were modeled for when the reactor is at two different operation modes: normal full power and drained state. The FW-CADIS hybrid method in Shift was applied successfully to calculate the ex-core neutron and gamma dose rates for the MSBR at full power. Dose rate maps showed that in the current MSBR numerical model, potential pathways exist for neutrons and gammas to stream through the 8-foot concrete shield to reach the top of the MSBR reactor cell. Neutron and gamma dose rates within the drain cell were also calculated for the MSBR at the drained state by integrating the source terms obtained from an ORIGEN-S depletion calculation into the Shift simulation. The results indicate that in the drained state, the delayed gammas from the depleted fuel salt are the main contributors to the dose rates, which suggests that a steel liner in the tank model must be added for calculating the dose rates in the drain cell.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Artificial Intelligence for Multiphysics Nuclear Design Optimization with Additive Manufacturing

The geometric flexibility of additively manufactured metals and ceramics generates a very large and open design space that requires advanced modeling and simulation tools for physics simulations and the rigorous definition of design problems. This effort deploys artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) algorithms to understand the design space, evaluate potential designs, and more efficiently generate optimized results. The Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program is leveraging advances in several scientific areas—including materials, manufacturing, sensors and control systems, data analytics, and high-fidelity modeling and simulation—to accelerate the design, manufacturing, qualification, and deployment of advanced nuclear energy systems. Through a manufacturing-informed design approach, the TCR program seeks to integrate digital data for rapid nuclear innovation; accelerate the adoption of advances in manufacturing, materials, and computational sciences for nuclear applications; and dramatically reduce deployment costs and timelines for new nuclear reactor technologies. This report documents efforts under the TCR program to leverage advanced modeling and simulation techniques driven by AI/ML algorithms on high-performance computing (HPC) systems to yield more optimized TCR core designs. A multiphysics ML surrogate model was developed to run on the HPC architectures. The surrogate model is trained on high-fidelity simulation data of coupled neutronics and thermofluidics and is used to quickly evaluate thousands of candidate core designs in parallel, which drives the evolution of the cooling channel shapes to minimize temperature peaking and material stress. Outcomes from these activities provide design information and feedback into the core design efforts.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Transformational Challenge Reactor preconceptual core design studies

In the nuclear industry, a manufacturing-informed design approach has the potential to yield the most benefit from advanced manufacturing. By leveraging advanced materials, data science, and rapid testing and deployment, manufacturing-informed design can drive down costs and development times, ultimately improving future commercial viability. This approach is being demonstrated in the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program. Preconceptual design activities for TCR have been focused on analyzing and maturing four reactor core design concepts: two fast-spectrum and two thermal-spectrum systems. Furthermore, the designs were iteratively modified and analyzed, and subcomponents were manufactured in parallel over weeks instead of months or years. To meet key program initiatives (e.g., timeline and material use), several constraints—including fissile material availability, component availability, materials compatibility, and additive manufacturing capabilities—were factored into the design effort, yielding small cores less than one cubic meter in volume with near-term viability. Additionally, the TCR program has made significant progress on development of advanced moderator materials such as yttrium hydride, advancing the feasibility of gas-cooled thermal spectrum systems using less than 250 kg of high-assay low enriched uranium (HALEU) and occupying less than 1 m3. Each of the two resulting thermal designs uses a different fuel form: traditional UO2 ceramic fuel and tristructural isotropic (advanced TRISO) fuel particles embedded inside a SiC matrix. Core neutronics and thermal performance for these systems were assessed and summarized. Evaluation of the performance metrics for these two moderated designs has yielded the downselected TCR design: a TRISO-fueled and yttrium hydride moderated gas-cooled reactor.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Two-Dimensional Neutronic and Fuel Cycle Analysis of the LEU-Fueled Transatomic Power Molten Salt Reactor

A recent Third Way report detailing $1.3 billion in private investment in advanced reactor technology includes several liquid-fueled molten salt reactor (MSR) concepts. Interest in these MSR concepts is driven by the enhanced safety, economic, and promising fuel cycle benefits of these advanced reactor concepts. The US Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Nuclear Energy established the Gateway for Accelerated Innovation in Nuclear (GAIN) to provide private companies pursuing innovative nuclear energy technologies with access to the technical support necessary to move toward commercialization. GAIN activities in 2016 included competitive selection of projects for vouchers to fund applicant-specific work at national laboratories. One of these GAIN small business voucher awards was to Transatomic Power Corporation (TAP) to work with Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) to perform neutronic and fuel cycle analysis and design of TAP's innovative MSR concept. The initial phase of this project is to perform two-dimensional (2D) analysis with ORNL-developed tools to verify TAP-calculated metrics and to develop an understanding of the effects of fuel feed and isotopic removal rates to prepare for the more complex three-dimensional (3D) analysis in coming phases. Design information was based on the TAP white papers wherever possible. This summary discusses the results of this initial phase of the collaboration between ORNL and TAP.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Reactor Physics Analysis of Transitioning to a Thorium Fuel Cycle with Molten Salt Reactors

Commercial power reactors operating in the United States are light-water reactors (LWRs) fueled with low-enriched uranium (LEU) in a once-through fuel cycle; the important fissile isotopes are {sup 235}U, {sup 239}Pu, and {sup 241}Pu. In a thorium fuel cycle, the fertile isotope {sup 232}Th is converted into {sup 233}U, a fissile isotope that is not naturally occurring. In transitioning from the once-through fuel cycle to the thorium fuel cycle, the availability of man-made {sup 233}U presents a challenge: without it, the initial fissile material fueling the first reactors built in this transition is not the fissile isotope that the reactor is breeding. The transition requires an alternate fissile material until enough surplus {sup 233}U is available to start up additional reactors. In liquid-fueled molten salt reactors (MSRs), the fuel is dissolved into molten salt, which is continuously circulated through the core, simultaneously undergoing irradiation, chemical treatments and separations, and feeds. MSRs are an attractive technology in which the thorium fuel cycle can be deployed, as the {sup 233}U bred from {sup 232}Th is continuously being recycled back through the core. The bred fissile material is immediately available to fuel the core without processing or fuel fabrication. After start-up, only a fertile {sup 232}Th feed is necessary to sustain criticality in the MSR. But, in single-fluid MSRs, the initial fissile and fertile materials are mixed into the same molten fuel salt, complicating separations of initial and bred fissile materials. In solid-fuel systems, these materials are often separate. This analysis herein builds on previous work modeling thorium-fueled MSR start-up. It is based on unit cell representations of the graphite-moderated, 2250 MWt Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (MSBR). This paper discusses the start-up of the first MSR in the transition to a thorium fuel cycle and identifies challenges and limitations of fuel cycle deployment with this reactor technology. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Calculating infinite-medium {alpha}-eigenvalue spectra with a transition rate matrix method

The time-dependent behavior of the energy spectrum in neutron transport was investigated with a formulation, based on continuous-time Markov processes, for computing {alpha}-eigenvalues and eigenvectors in an infinite medium. For this, a research Monte Carlo code called TORTE was created and used to estimate elements of a transition rate matrix. TORTE is capable of using both multigroup and continuous-energy nuclear data, and verification was performed. Eigenvalue spectra for infinite homogeneous mixtures were obtained and an eigenfunction expansion was used to investigate transient behavior of the neutron energy spectrum. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Eigenvalue sensitivity studies for the Fort St. Vrain high temperature gas-cooled reactor to account for fabrication and modeling uncertainties

Uncertainties in the composition and fabrication of fuel compacts for the Fort St. Vrain (FSV) high temperature gas reactor have been studied by performing eigenvalue sensitivity studies that represent the key uncertainties for the FSV neutronic analysis. The uncertainties for the TRISO fuel kernels were addressed by developing a suite of models for an 'average' FSV fuel compact that models the fuel as (1) a mixture of two different TRISO fuel particles representing fissile and fertile kernels, (2) a mixture of four different TRISO fuel particles representing small and large fissile kernels and small and large fertile kernels and (3) a stochastic mixture of the four types of fuel particles where every kernel has its diameter sampled from a continuous probability density function. All of the discrete diameter and continuous diameter fuel models were constrained to have the same fuel loadings and packing fractions. For the non-stochastic discrete diameter cases, the MCNP compact model arranged the TRISO fuel particles on a hexagonal honeycomb lattice. This lattice-based fuel compact was compared to a stochastic compact where the locations (and kernel diameters for the continuous diameter cases) of the fuel particles were randomly sampled. Partial core configurations were modeled by stacking compacts into fuel columns containing graphite. The differences in eigenvalues between the lattice-based and stochastic models were small but the runtime of the lattice-based fuel model was roughly 20 times shorter than with the stochastic-based fuel model. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗