Engineering topics

Birkinshaw, Mark

Publications and source records attributed to Birkinshaw, Mark.

4 records

NASA NTRS2003

Constraints on the Energy Density Content of the Universe Using Only Clusters of Galaxies

We demonstrate that it is possible to constrain the energy content of the Universe with high accuracy using observations of clusters of galaxies only. The degeneracies in the cosmological parameters are lifted by combining constraints from different observables of galaxy clusters. We show that constraints on cosmological parameters from galaxy cluster number counts as a function of redshift and accurate angular diameter distance measurements to clusters are complementary to each other and their combination can constrain the energy density content of the Universe well. The number counts can be obtained from X-ray and/or SZ (Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect) surveys, the angular diameter distances can be determined from deep observations of the intra-cluster gas using their thermal bremsstrahlung X-ray emission and the SZ effect (X-SZ method). In this letter we combine constraints from simulated cluster number counts expected from a 12 deg2 SZ cluster survey and constraints from simulated angular diameter distance measurements based on using the X-SZ method assuming an expected accuracy of 7% in the angular diameter distance determination of 70 clusters with redshifts less than 1.5. We find that R, can be determined within about 25%, A within 20%, and w within 16%. Any cluster survey can be used to select clusters for high accuracy distance measurements, but we assumed accurate angular diameter distance measurements for only 70 clusters since long observations are necessary to achieve high accuracy in distance measurements. Thus the question naturally arises: How to select clusters of galaxies for accurate diameter distance determinations? In this letter, as an example, we demonstrate that it is possible to optimize this selection changing the number of clusters observed, and the upper cut off of their redshift range. We show that constraints on cosmological parameters from combining cluster number counts and angular diameter distance measurements, as opposed to general expectations, will not improve substantially selecting clusters with redshifts higher than one. This important conclusion allow us to restrict our cluster sample to clusters closer than one, in a range where the observational time for accurate distance measurements are more manageable. Subject headings: cosmological parameters - cosmology: theory - galaxies: clusters: general - X-rays: galaxies: clusters

Molnar, Sandor M.↗

NASA NTRS2003

Constraints on the Energy Content of the Universe from a Combination of Galaxy Cluster Observables

We demonstrate that constraints on cosmological parameters from the distribution of clusters as a function of redshift (dN/dz) are complementary to accurate angular diameter distance (D(sub A)) measurements to clusters, and their combination significantly tightens constraints on the energy density content of the Universe. The number counts can be obtained from X-ray and/or SZ (Sunyaev-Ze'dovich effect) surveys, and the angular diameter distances can be determined from deep observations of the intra-cluster gas using their thermal bremsstrahlung X-ray emission and the SZ effect. We combine constraints from simulated cluster number counts expected from a 12 deg(sup 2) SZ cluster survey and constraints from simulated angular diameter distance measurements based on the X-ray/SZ method assuming a statistical accuracy of 10% in the angular diameter distance determination of 100 clusters with redshifts less than 1.5. We find that Omega(sub m), can be determined within about 25%, Omega(sub lambda) within 20% and w within 16%. We show that combined dN/dz+(sub lambda) constraints can be used to constrain the different energy densities in the Universe even in the presence of a few percent redshift dependent systematic error in D(sub lambda). We also address the question of how best to select clusters of galaxies for accurate diameter distance determinations. We show that the joint dN/dz+ D(lambda) constraints on cosmological parameters for a fixed target accuracy in the energy density parameters are optimized by selecting clusters with redshift upper cut-offs in the range 0.55 approx. less than 1. Subject headings: cosmological parameters - cosmology: theory - galaxies:clusters: general

Molnar, Sandor M.↗

NASA NTRS2000

Extragalactic Radio Jets and Intergalactic Medium 2

During the mid 1990s, the ROSAT satellite provided the highest resolution X-ray imaging, with useful X-ray spectroscopy, and excellent sensitivity. ROSAT"s PSPC and HRI instruments gave us our first high-quality data on the AGN phenomenon in nearby galaxies - the central theme of this research project. Initially this project concentrated on separating the AGN-related component of the X-ray emission from thermal radiation from the surrounding atmospheres in radio galaxies. There was ample reason to believe that this separation would be possible, although earlier work had taken the view that the X-ray emission from radio galaxies is either wholly AGN-related (and hence of sub-arcsec scale), or wholly from the galaxy and cluster atmospheres (and hence of scales - 10 arcsec or more in the low-redshift radio galaxies that we chose to study). First with the PSPC, and then with the HRI, we proved that a wide range of AGN core X ray emissivities could be found, and that the generic radio galaxy produces both AGN-related and atmosphere-related X-radiation. We demonstrated that there is a close relationship between the core X-ray power and the core radio power, and found instances in which the hot atmospheres of the galaxies must be participating in cooling flows, and other cases where those atmospheres are relatively stable. In some cases, there is a clear active relationship between the extended radio emission and the X-ray atmospheres: thus in NGC 326, we interpret the distorted radio structure as evidence of buoyancy as the radio plasma rises through the cluster atmosphere. In 3C 449, we can see that the radio plasma is displacing the X-ray emitting gas. In a further case (NGC 1265), we hoped that the motion of a radio galaxy through a cluster atmosphere would be apparent though the wake that it might establish - unfortunately, other structure in the atmosphere of the Perseus cluster tends to dominate our X-ray image, and no useful limits could be placed on the strength of the wake. In the light of so-called "unified" models of AGN, it is expected that the low-power radio galaxies studied under these programmes are the unbeamed counterparts of BL Lac objects. Accordingly, we predicted that BL Lac objects, as a class, should show X-ray halos from atmospheres similar to those associated with radio galaxies. The difficulty with studying this is that BL Lac objects tend to be X-ray bright, and the halos then vanish under the wings of the point response function. We found a BL Lac with less of a dynamic range problem, mapped it with the ROSAT HRI, and duly found an atmosphere (Hardcastle et al. 1999). Unfortunately for unification models, this atmosphere is exceptionally dense, so that it must be participating in an intense cooling flow. The implications of this for unification models are far from clear, and further work is under way.

Birkinshaw, Mark↗

NASA NTRS1997

Cluster-Induced Fluctuations in the Microwave Background Radiation

The research proposed was to detect, map and interpret the Sunyaev-Zel dovich (SZ) effects in two samples of distant clusters of galaxies with the OVRO 40-m telescope: an optically selected sample of 26 clusters at the North Ecliptic Pole, and an X-ray selected sample of clusters based on the Einstein Medium Sensitivity Survey, to make small maps of the strongest cluster SZ effects using the OVRO 40-m telescope, to combine the SZ and X-ray data for well-detected clusters to determine the value of the Hubble constant and set limits to the value of the deceleration parameter, and to study the properties of cluster atmospheres using the SZ effect.

Birkinshaw, Mark↗