Statistical evaluation comparing strength of new and aged nuclear grade HEPA filters
Not Available
21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗
Engineering topics
Bliss, Mary
Publications and source records attributed to Bliss, Mary.
Impact of lowering potassium contamination in liquid scintillation cocktails for ultra-sensitive radiation detection
Intrinsic 40 K radioactive backgrounds from impurities of natural K in liquid scintillation cocktails have previously been demonstrated to limit their use in ultra-sensitive applications. Here, this work explores two methodologies in parallel for the reduction of 40 K backgrounds in the cocktails, and lays the groundwork for use in ultra-sensitive applications. In one method, alternative low-K liquid scintillation matrix constituents were identified and in the other, a simple purification method for single components and finished cocktails was developed. Both methods were verified via ICP-MS analysis. Liquid scintillation counting of selected purified cocktails demonstrated background reduction, improved stability, and enhanced performance. The best performing purified cocktail was also counted on a custom-built ultra-low background liquid scintillation counter, with results below the detector background.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Mass spectrometric investigations into 3D printed parts to assess radiopurity as ultralow background materials for rare event physics detectors
The mass concentrations of 232 Th and 238 U in several 3D printing filaments and printed polymer parts are reported as measures of their radiopurity. In order to minimize background signals in rare event physics detectors, radiopure polymers are necessary as dielectric and structural materials in their construction. New data are reported for polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), polyphenylene sulfide (PPS), and two forms of polyetherimide (PEI, branded ULTEM 1010 and 9085). Data for starting filaments and both simple and complex printed parts are reported. PVDF filaments and simple printed beads, were found to have values of approximately 30 and 50 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, while a more complex spring clip part had slightly elevated 232 Th levels of 65 pg g -1 , with 238 U remaining at 50 pg g -1 . PPS filament was found to have concentrations of 270 and 710 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, and were not chosen to be printed as those levels were already higher than other material options. ULTEM 1010 filaments and printed complex spring clip parts were found to have concentrations of around 5 and 7 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, illustrating no significant contamination from the printing process. ULTEM 9085 filaments were found to have concentrations of around 9 and 5 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, while the printed complex spring clip part was found to have slightly elevated concentrations of 25 and 7 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively. All these results were obtained using a novel dry ashing method in crucibles constructed of ultralow background electroformed copper or, when applicable, microwave assisted wet ashing digestion. Samples and process blanks were spiked with 229 Th and 233 U as internal standards prior to dry/wet ashing and determinations were made by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). In order to maintain high radiopurity levels, pre-cleaning the filaments before printing and post-cleaning the parts is recommended, although the printing process itself has shown to contribute very minute amounts of radiocontaminants.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Identification of background limitations to ultra-sensitive $\mathrm{LSC}$ counting through $\mathrm{ICP}$-$\mathrm{MS}$ assay of $\mathrm{LSC}$ cocktails
We report the performance of LSC cocktails in ultra-sensitive applications was evaluated. Backgrounds from radioactive contaminations in commercially available and in-house developed liquid scintillation cocktails were measured and compared to the predicted background levels of the ultra-low background liquid scintillation counter. Through the ICP-MS assay of the cocktails and their constituents, potassium impurities in the surfactant component were identified as a significant source of background, potentially limiting the use of LSC counting in ultra-sensitive applications. This work lays the groundwork for future research towards ultrapure LSC cocktails for ultrasensitive LSC counting
73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
Radiological HEPA Filter 10-year Lifetime Evaluation in Research Facilities
High-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters are widely employed by nuclear facilities to remove radiological particulate matter from their effluent exhaust streams. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the relationships between the 10-year HEPA filter lifetime deployment and its other performance indicators. This 10-year-long endeavor to collect and analyze data regarding the service life of HEPA filters at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory began in 2010. A set of HEPA filters were selected and have been surveyed and analyzed at least annually to verify compliance with permit conditions. The study suggests the frequency of filter replacement should be based on the actual operational requirements, such as fume hood face velocity and/or efficiency test results, instead of on the prescribed filter “age limit” of 10 years from the date of manufacture (e.g., birth date) when operating under dry conditions. The study has now been completed, and over the past decade all the HEPA filters have been replaced, due to either technical issues as listed in this report or the previously recommended filter “age limit” of 10 years as prescribed by the oversight bodies. Experimentally determined failure rates are also determined from the data set and can be used to estimate the chances of HEPA filters surviving 15, 20, or even 30 years.
61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗
HEPA Filter Age Evaluation Report
In 2020, PNNL completed a literature search for high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filter age information. HEPA filters are used in many operations to remove particulate matter from effluent exhaust streams. They are thought to degrade over time both during proper storage and during normal operational service; however, the rate at which the filters degrade remains unknown. This brings into question if age is an adequate indicator of HEPA filter performance. Data from six previous reports were obtained from the literature search and combined to create a data set of 1600 operating filters. Filter usage was identified from multiple facilities. The various types of filters (e.g., axial flow, self-contained, and standard 24 x 24 x 11.5 inches; and both separator and separatorless) reported were constructed to the requirements Section FC (HEPA Filters) or Section FK (Special HEPA Filters) of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers AG-1 code. Filters were presumed to have continuously met the operational criteria and in particular passed both annual efficiency tests and annual DP measurements. The environmental conditions within the exhaust system were also assumed adequate for long-term filter operation. The data, by the nature of the reports, excludes rejected filters from quality assurance evaluations, intake, or installation testing. The collective data set shows over half of were operating past the current 10-year Department of Energy (DOE) limit. Data was evaluated for age lifetime using a linear trendline, survival function, probability functions, and failure rate; financial impacts were also addressed. This report supports the notion that HEPA filters can operate safely and efficiently under proper maintenance well past the 10-year lifetime established by DOE. Using the results of the four age evaluation approaches, they collectively point to the reasonableness of an operating HEPA filter lifetime of 20 years. The results are not necessarily definitive, but nevertheless, they are promising. The analysis provides reasonable assurance that when implemented using a graded approach with well-defined performance and operational requirements, extending the service life for HEPA filters beyond 10 years is low risk.
42 ENGINEERING↗
Mass spectrometric analyses of high performance polymers to assess their radiopurity as ultra low background materials for rare event physics detectors
Not Available
Grate, Jay W. (ORCID:0000000221638383)↗
Final Status of HEPA Filter 10-Year Lifetime Evaluation
High-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters are widely employed by nuclear facilities to remove radiological particulate matter from their effluent exhaust streams. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the relationships between the 10-year HEPA filter lifespan and its other performance indicators. The 10-year-long endeavor to collect and analyze data regarding the lifetime of HEPA filters at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory began in 2010. Forty-nine HEPA filters were selected and have been surveyed and analyzed at least annually to verify compliance with permit conditions. The study suggests the frequency of filter replacement should be based on the actual operational requirements, such as fume hood face velocity and/or efficiency test results, instead of on the prescribed filter “age limit” of 10 years from the date of manufacture (e.g., birth date) when operating under dry conditions. Over the past decade, the study has now been completed, and all forty-nine HEPA filters have been replaced, due to either technical issues listed in this report, or the previously recommended filter “age limit” of 10 years.
61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗
Radon Photoionization: Project Technical Report
In most low-background physics experiments, radon is a significant and problematic source of background radiation because it is inert and sufficiently long-lived to pervade laboratory spaces. It may be possible to manipulate (and thus mitigate) radon electromagnetically by taking advantage of its relatively low first ionization energy. When considering ambient-temperature gas phases, only iodine is comparable. The other noble gases, and the most important constituents of breathable air (nitrogen and oxygen), all have higher ionization energies; so it may be possible to selectively manipulate radon in a variety of gas streams by ionizing it with an appropriately low-energy source of photons. Radon’s first ionization energy is in the vacuum UV part of the electromagnetic spectrum, which can be produced using a deuterium lamp. In this report, we present our attempts to manipulate radon via UV photoionization in a laboratory setting. This approach has the potential to increase radon removal efficiency from gases and/or to improve the efficiency of radon detectors. Unfortunately, our experiments suggest that either the life-time of a photoionized radon ion (before it re-neutralizes) is too short to be of much practical use and/or that our low-cost UV-photon source was not sufficiently energetic for efficient photoionization of radon.
73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗