Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Blum, Suzanne A.

Publications and source records attributed to Blum, Suzanne A..

At least 19 records

A General Autofluorescence Method to Characterize Polymerization Progress

Abstract An autofluorescence technique to characterize polymerization progress in real time/in line was developed, which functioned in the absence of typical fluorogenic groups on the monomer or polymer. The monomer dicyclopentadiene and polymer polydicyclopentadiene are hydrocarbons that lack traditional functional groups for fluorescence spectroscopy. Here, the autofluorescence of formulations containing this monomer and polymer during ruthenium‐catalyzed ring‐opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) was harnessed for reaction monitoring. The methods fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and here‐developed fluorescence lifetime recovery after photobleaching (FLRAP) characterized polymerization progress in these native systems—without requiring exogenous fluorophore. (Auto)fluorescence lifetime recovery changes during polymerization correlated linearly to degree of cure, providing a quantitative link with reaction progress. These changing signals also provided relative rates of background polymerization, enabling comparison of 10 different catalyst‐inhibitor‐stabilized formulations. Multiple‐well analysis demonstrated suitability for future high‐throughput evaluation of formulations for thermosets. The central concept of the combined autofluorescence and FLRAP/FRAP method may be extendable to monitoring other polymerization reactions previously overlooked for lack of an obvious fluorescence handle.

López, Pía A.↗

A General Autofluorescence Method to Characterize Polymerization Progress

An autofluorescence technique to characterize polymerization progress in real time/in line was developed, which functioned in the absence of typical fluorogenic groups on the monomer or polymer. The monomer dicyclopentadiene and polymer polydicyclopentadiene are hydrocarbons that lack traditional functional groups for fluorescence spectroscopy. Here, the autofluorescence of formulations containing this monomer and polymer during ruthenium-catalyzed ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) was harnessed for reaction monitoring. The methods fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and here-developed fluorescence lifetime recovery after photobleaching (FLRAP) characterized polymerization progress in these native systems—without requiring exogenous fluorophore. (Auto)fluorescence lifetime recovery changes during polymerization correlated linearly to degree of cure, providing a quantitative link with reaction progress. These changing signals also provided relative rates of background polymerization, enabling comparison of 10 different catalyst–inhibitor-stabilized formulations. Multiple-well analysis demonstrated suitability for future high-throughput evaluation of formulations for thermosets. Furthermore, the central concept of the combined autofluorescence and FLRAP/FRAP method may be extendable to monitoring other polymerization reactions previously overlooked for lack of an obvious fluorescence handle.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Superresolved Motions of Single Molecular Catalysts during Polymerization Show Wide Distributions

The motion of single molecular ruthenium catalysts during and after single turnover events of ring-opening metathesis polymerization is imaged through single-molecule superresolution tracking with a positional accuracy of ±32 nm. This tracking is achieved through the real-time incorporation of spectrally tagged monomer units into active polymer chain ends during living polymerization; thus, by design, only active-catalyst motion is detected and imaged, without convolution by inactive catalysts. The catalysts show diverse individualistic diffusive behaviors with respect to time that persist for up to 20 s. Catalysts occupy three mobility populations: quasi-stationary (23%), intermediate (53%, 65 nm), and large (24%, 145 nm) step sizes. Differences in catalyst mobility populations also exist between individual aggregates (p < 0.001). Such differential motion indicates widely different local catalyst microenvironments during the catalytic turnover. These mobility differences are uniquely observable through single-catalyst microscopy and are not measurable through traditional ensemble analytical techniques for characterizing the behavior of molecular catalysts, such as nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The measured distributions of active molecular catalyst motions would not be readily predictable through modeling or first-principles, and the range likely impacts individual catalyst turnover rate and selectivity. This range plausibly contributes to property distributions observable in bulk polymers, such as molecular weight polydispersity (e.g., 1.9 in this system), leading to a revised understanding of the mechanistic, microscale origins of macroscale polymer properties.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Exploring chemistry with single-molecule and -particle fluorescence microscopy

The evolution of single-molecule and -particle fluorescence microscopy imaging techniques for the investigation of chemical reactions yielded achievements at all fronts, from synthetic organic chemistry to materials science. The removal of ensemble averaging effects uncovers unique, otherwise hidden reaction intermediates, reactivity, and kinetics. Thus, new insights can be obtained even for well-explored chemical reactions and processes. The aim of this article is to serve as a guide and a source of inspiration for scientists who wish to develop single-molecule and -particle fluorescence microscopy to answer questions in chemistry. Here, we describe the current status of technical accomplishments in the field and point out technical and conceptual obstacles for overcoming in the near future, with focus on improvement of bench-scale synthetic reactions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Does Selectivity of Molecular Catalysts Change with Time? Polymerization Imaged by Single‐Molecule Spectroscopy

Abstract The chemoselectivity of molecular catalysts underpins much of modern synthetic organic chemistry. However, little is known about the selectivity of individual catalysts because this single‐catalyst‐level behavior is hidden by the bulk catalytic behavior. Here, for the first time, the selectivity of individual molecular catalysts for two different reactions is imaged in real time at the single‐catalyst level. This imaging is achieved through fluorescence microscopy paired with spectral probes that produce a snapshot of the instantaneous chemoselectivity of a single catalyst for either a single‐chain‐elongation or a single‐chain‐termination event during ruthenium‐catalyzed polymerization. Superresolution imaging of multiple selectivity events, each at a different single‐molecular ruthenium catalyst, indicates that catalyst selectivity may be unexpectedly spatially and time‐variable.

Garcia, IV, Antonio↗

Does Selectivity of Molecular Catalysts Change with Time? Polymerization Imaged by Single-Molecule Spectroscopy

The chemoselectivity of molecular catalysts underpins much of modern synthetic organic chemistry. However, little is known about the selectivity of individual catalysts because this single-catalyst-level behavior is hidden by the bulk catalytic behavior. In this work, for the first time, the selectivity of individual molecular catalysts for two different reactions is imaged in real time at the single-catalyst level. This imaging is achieved through fluorescence microscopy paired with spectral probes that produce a snapshot of the instantaneous chemoselectivity of a single catalyst for either a single-chain-elongation or a single-chain-termination event during ruthenium-catalyzed polymerization. Superresolution imaging of multiple selectivity events, each at a different single-molecular ruthenium catalyst, indicates that catalyst selectivity may be unexpectedly spatially and time-variable.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Organic and Organometallic Chemistry at the Single-Molecule, -Particle, and -Molecular-Catalyst-Turnover Level by Fluorescence Microscopy

Mechanistic studies have historically played a key role in the discovery and optimization of reactions in organic and organometallic chemistry. However, even apparently simple organic and organometallic transformations may have surprisingly complicated multistep mechanisms, increasing the difficulty of extracting this mechanistic information. The resulting reaction intermediates often constitute a small fraction of the total reaction mixture, for example, creating a long-term analytical challenge of detection. This challenge is particularly pronounced in cases where the positions of intermediates on the reaction energy surface mean that they do not “build up” to the quantities needed for observation by traditional ensemble analytical tools. Thus, their existence and single-step elementary reactivity cannot be studied directly. New approaches for obtaining this otherwise-missing mechanistic information are therefore needed. Single-turnover, single-molecule, single-particle, and other subensemble fluorescence microscopy techniques are ideally suited for this role because of their sensitivity and spatiotemporal resolution. Inspired by the robust development of single-molecule fluorescence microscopy tools for studying enzyme catalysis, our laboratory has developed analogous fluorescence microscopy techniques to overcome mechanistic challenges in synthetic chemistry, with sensitivity as high as the single-complex, single-turnover, and single-molecule level. These techniques free the experimenter from the previous restriction that intermediates must “build up” to quantities needed for detection by ensemble analytical tools and are suited to systems where synchronization through flash photolysis or stopped flow would be inconvenient or inaccessible. In this process, the techniques transform certain previously “unobservable” intermediates and their elementary single-step reactivities into “observable” ones through sensitive and selective spectral handles. Our program has focused on imaging reactions in small-molecule, organic, and polymer synthetic chemistry with an accent on the reactivity of molecular transition metal complexes and catalysts. Our laboratory initiated studies in this area in 2008 with the imaging of individual palladium complexes that were tagged with spectator fluorophores. To enable imaging, we started with fluorophore selection and development, overcame challenges with imaging in organic solvents, and developed strategies compatible with air-sensitive chemistry and concentrations of reagents generally used in small-molecule synthesis. These studies grew to include characterization of previously unknown organometallic intermediates in the synthesis of organozinc reagents and the direct study of their elementary-step reactivity. The ability to directly observe this behavior generated predictive power for selecting salts that accelerated organozinc reagent formation in synthesis, including salts that had not yet been reported synthetically. In 2017 we also developed the first single-turnover imaging of molecular (chemo)catalysts, which through the technique’s spatiotemporal resolution revealed abruptly time-variable polymerization kinetics wherein molecular ruthenium ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) catalysts changed rates independently from other catalysts less than 1 μm away. Individual catalytic turnovers, each corresponding to one single-chain-elongation reaction arising from insertion of single ROMP or enyne monomers at individual Grubbs II molecular ruthenium catalysts, were spatiotemporally resolved as green flashes in growing polymers. In this work, we discuss the development of this technique from idea to application, including challenges overcome and strategies created to image synthetic organic and organometallic molecular chemistry at the highest levels of detection sensitivity. We also describe challenges not yet solved and provide an outlook for this growing field at the intersection of microscopy and synthetic/molecular chemistry.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Single-Polymer–Particle Growth Kinetics with Molecular Catalyst Speciation and Single-Turnover Imaging

The dynamics of the local environments surrounding molecular polymerization catalysts plausibly impact turnover kinetics, but the impact of and nature of such dynamics have previously been obscured by ensemble averaging. With Grubbs’ second generation ruthenium metathesis catalyst and a precipitation polymerization system, studies at the single-particle and -turnover level establish that (1) an inverse correlation exists between rate and duration of single-polymer–particle growth of aggregates, consistent with a local environment density model for the time-variable kinetics; (2) cross-linking additives produced a small, but detectible, reduction in overall monomer incorporation; (3) total ruthenium quantity within the polymer particles (as characterized by energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy) is differentiable from the quantity that is catalytically active (as characterized by in situ fluorescence microscopy), providing catalyst speciation information; and (4) time-resolved enyne metathesis reactions can be imaged, corresponding to single turnovers at individual molecular catalysts during polymer growth under synthetically relevant conditions. Here, these findings identify and characterize reactivity distributions likely arising from the dynamics of local environments. As such, these data provide reactivity information that is unavailable through traditional ensemble analytical methods that obscure this type of information through averaging.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Kinetics of the Same Reaction Monitored over Nine Orders of Magnitude in Concentration: When Are Unique Subensemble and Single‐Turnover Reactivity Displayed?

Abstract Essentially no information is known about the behavior of individual molecular catalysts under reaction conditions. This is a result of the averaging inherent to traditional analytical techniques. Herein, a combined fluorescence microscopy and 1 H NMR spectroscopy study reveals that unique (that is, non‐ensemble averaged) distributions and time‐variable kinetics from molecular ruthenium catalysts within growing polynorbornene occur and are detectable between 10 −9 m and 10 −6 m of substrate, surprisingly just 1000‐fold less concentrated than a typical laboratory bench‐scale reaction. The kinetic states governing single‐turnover events are determinable by overlay of the signal arising from individual monomer insertion reactions with that from polymer growth from neighboring catalysts.

Easter, Quinn T.↗

Evidence for Dynamic Chemical Kinetics at Individual Molecular Ruthenium Catalysts

Abstract Catalytic cycles are typically depicted as possessing time‐invariant steps with fixed rates. Yet the true behavior of individual catalysts with respect to time is unknown, hidden by the ensemble averaging inherent to bulk measurements. Evidence is presented for variable chemical kinetics at individual catalysts, with a focus on ring‐opening metathesis polymerization catalyzed by the second‐generation Grubbs’ ruthenium catalyst. Fluorescence microscopy is used to probe the chemical kinetics of the reaction because the technique possesses sufficient sensitivity for the detection of single chemical reactions. Insertion reactions in submicron regions likely occur at groups of many (not single) catalysts, yet not so many that their unique kinetic behavior is ensemble averaged.

Easter, Quinn T.↗

Single Turnover at Molecular Polymerization Catalysts Reveals Spatiotemporally Resolved Reactions

Abstract Multiple active individual molecular ruthenium catalysts have been pinpointed within growing polynorbornene, thereby revealing information on the reaction dynamics and location that is unavailable through traditional ensemble experiments. This is the first single‐turnover imaging of a molecular catalyst by fluorescence microscopy and allows detection of individual monomer reactions at an industrially important molecular ruthenium ring‐opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) catalyst under synthetically relevant conditions (e.g. unmodified industrial catalyst, ambient pressure, condensed phase, ca. 0.03 m monomer). These results further establish the key fundamentals of this imaging technique for characterizing the reactivity and location of active molecular catalysts even when they are the minor components.

Easter, Quinn T.↗