Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Breault, Ronald W.

Publications and source records attributed to Breault, Ronald W..

At least 19 records

Scaling CFB risers: Beyond the data using microstructure similarity

Scaling circulating fluidized bed risers has been a point of contention for nearly a century. There have been numerous attempts to define various methodologies. These have all fallen short of providing a robust approach, primarily due to a lack of maintaining microstructure dynamics – a key factor in maintaining interphase heat and mass transfer. Recent work by the author put forward an approach based upon preserving dynamic similarity at different scales by ensuring that the microstructure remained similar by maintaining statistical and chaotic parameters across the scale. That work relied on a dimensionless regime map in which the x-axis was defined by the ratio of the solids flux to the saturation carrying capacity. This latter property was only good within the range of the data, and it became evident that extrapolation beyond the limits of the data could induce unrealistic conditions. Therefore, literature was reviewed to develop a better correlation for the saturation carrying capacity. In doing so, a critical riser diameter concept was developed and applied to the correlations for both Geldart Group A and B materials. The critical diameter for Geldart Group A and B materials is 0.2 m and 0.3 m, respectively. Here the paper then gives three examples on how to use the scaling approach to maintain dynamic similarity across the scales.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Effects of additively manufactured surface roughness on small diameter plenums with multiple side discharges for high temperature gas turbine blade cooling applications

Combined heat and power (CHP) applications have significant environmental and economic benefits that are consistent with the goals of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). One area that is currently being studied includes the potential benefits of CHP turbine operation at higher turbine inlet temperatures. Internal cooling concepts enabled by additive manufacturing (AM) are of primary interest. Here, the effectiveness of internal cooling is hindered by many factors such as velocity distribution of the cooling air to the hot surface considering impingement cooling. To simulate cooling air exiting from a series of orifices for internal cooling in an airfoil, a straight smooth wall tubing with multiple side discharging orifices is used and compared to additively manufactured tubing (Ti6Al4V Grade 23) with orifice size and spacing as well as inner and outer diameters identical to the smooth wall tubing. Similar to flow discharging form perforated pipes, the flow discharged from individual orifices along the tubes in this study is found to be nonuniformly distributed, and the horizontal (axial direction) momentum can be observed from the experimental data. Discharge velocities have been measured with two-dimensional (2D) particle imaging velocimetry (PIV) and single element hot wire anemometry. Numerical analysis has also been conducted to predict the velocity distributions along the orifices in the smooth wall and additive manufacturing (AM) tubing, which are inherited with surface roughness. Numerical and measured results in this study are compared, presented, and discussed.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Scaling CFB risers: Maintaining microstructure dynamics

Over the years there have been numerous approaches to develop a scaleup methodology for circulating fluidized beds. Many of these past approaches have relied on macroscopic definitions of similitude to define dimensionless groups such as Reynolds number, Froude number, density ratios, and dimensional ratios involving different length scales. These approaches have demonstrated various levels of success, but often fail when used outside the bounds of experimental datasets. The issue with these methods is that they rely on macroscopic similitude with the hopes that those conditions would provide microscopic similitude as it does in single phase systems where the Buckingham Pi techniques have given reasonable success. Two of the main reasons for failure are 1) changing fluidization regimes and 2) changing material properties that result in the material falling into a different Geldart group. Both are certain to change the microstructure (local instantaneous volume solids fraction) and changes to the microstructure affect the interphase transport properties of the reactor system, namely the mass transfer and heat transfer. Here, this work presents a new approach towards scaling based upon maintaining similitude at the microscale. It reviews a novel dimensionless flow regime map developed from analysis of the deterministic chaos parameters and higher order moments to ensure microstructure similitude. The work then examines four cases from the literature to assess the scaling approach used: (1) same particle-different scale risers for Geldart Group B particles, (2) Glicksman scaling of atmospheric circulating fluidized bed combustor, (3) same particle-different scale risers for Geldart Group A particles and (4) Glicksman scaling for pressurized gasification. General findings are that none of the scaling approaches produced directly applicable microstructure similar behavior based upon the chaotic and higher moment analysis. The positive take away is that the approach can define scale conditions that will provide similar microstructure that can be us to predict transport behavior.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Saturation Carrying Capacity for Group A Particles in a Circulating Fluidized Bed

Empirical models continue to play a significant role in the design process of multiphase chemical reactors, particularly riser reactors in circulating fluidized bed (CFB) processes. It is imperative that accurate, industrial relevant correlations are developed to aid these design efforts. Using poor correlations could result in startup issues and significant redesign work. In this work, a new correlation is proposed to predict the saturation carrying capacity of Geldart Group A particles. This new correlation improves upon the currently available correlations for these materials and covers a broad range of Geldart Group A particles (particle diameters from 52 to 70 µm, and Archimedes numbers ranging from 5 to 20), superficial gas velocities (1 to 4 m/s), and riser diameters (0.066 to 0.3048 m). The new correlation has an Absolute Average Percent Deviation of only 17.6%, making it the most accurate correlation for Geldart Group A particles in the current literature.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Data analytics for leak detection in a subcritical boiler

For decades, boiler leaks have been the leading cause of forced outages in the coal-fired unit. The leak occurrences are currently escalating since the existing plants must satisfy faster-ramping rates to support grid operation. Data analytics including Principal Component Analysis, Canonical Variate, and Fisher Discriminant Analysis were combined for detecting and characterizing the leak in a commercial 650 MW subcritical coal-fired power plant. The combined approach was shown to be highly effective in the fault investigation that would not have been easily achieved by an individual technique. The variability in both training and validation datasets was first evaluated using PCA. Then, the CV-FDA was employed to discriminate among faults, and to categorize the processed data into two main groups: no-leak (0) and leak (1), providing the timeframe and location of the leak occurrence. Furthermore, about 8,014 observations from 81 process variables were initially included in the calculation, while the variable count was reduced to 4 with less than 1% misclassification rate in total observations. Finally, the leak was isolated in the waterwall section. Thus, the outcome of this research may provide early detection and isolation of faulty operations in the coal-fired power plant that involves a considerable number of process variables.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Development of Spouting Bed Reactor for Reduction of Hematite to Magnetite (Final Report)

This project was designed to leverage both past and current technology development efforts and utilize the expertise of the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) in a collaborative effort with SIOX for the development of a spouting bed reactor to produce magnetite from very fine hematite waste. More specifically, the effort involved the conversion of a steel manufacturing byproduct, iron oxide hematite (Fe 2 O 3 ), and reduces it chemically into a salable magnetite product applicable to a number of markets. SIOX previously operated a magnetite batch production facility based on a rotary kiln reactor process. Unfortunately, that process was both costly and inefficient, making it difficult to achieve desired economies, purity, and throughput levels. NETL’s technology, developed in this work, replaced the batch inefficient rotary kiln with a continuous spouting bed reactor capable of producing synthetic magnetite products. In the project, NETL was to develop the spouting bed for the SIOX application and SIOX was to construct and operate a fully integrated pilot scale demonstration plant. NETL successfully completed its tasks, but SIOX due to financial issues was not able to complete their tasks. They have chosen not to participate in this final report so for their tasks a short summary of NETL’s knowledge of their efforts is included.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Process Failure Detection via Recurrence Quantification Analysis in a Slot-Rectangular Spouted Bed

A study was conducted to explore the applicability of recurrence and recurrence quantification analysis (RQA) to the detection of process failures in spouted bed reactor systems. Here, three different potential failure modes were examined in a transparent, cold flow slot-rectangular spouted bed. These being, a simulated air leak from a side wall of the reactor, a simulated gas leak from the top wall of the reactor, and simulated agglomeration of solids via introduction of larger “klinker” particles. Bed pressure drop time history data were collected and analyzed via generation of recurrence plots (RPs) and RQA parameters. In general, the simulated agglomeration case was quite easily detected via ever RQA Parameter examined, whereas the simulated air leaks were detected by only a single RQA parameter.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

Effects of Riser Diameter on Solids Holdup and Particle Velocity Profiles in Circulating Fluidized Bed Riser Systems

Tests were performed in a 0.1-m diameter small circulating fluidized bed (SCFB) and 0.3 m diameter cold flow circulating fluidized bed (CFCFB) riser systems located at the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) to study the effects of riser diameter on the riser hydrodynamics. These tests were performed at solids circulation rates of G s = 20 and 75 kg/m 2 s and superficial gas velocities of U g = 5.8 and 6.5 m/s using high-density polyethylene (HDPE) pellets with a density of 0.863 g/cm 3 , particle size range of 600–1400 µm (with a Sauter mean diameter of 871 µm, placing them in the Geldart B classification). Comparisons of riser axial pressure and solids fraction profiles, radial particle velocity profiles, and radial profiles of higher statistical moments and select chaos analysis parameters were considered. The results showed that for a given U g and G s , the smaller diameter riser exhibited characteristics associated with more dilute solids flow than that observed in the larger diameter riser. Additionally, the larger diameter riser exhibited a downward flow of solids near the wall under all test conditions, whereas the smaller diameter riser data exhibited little or no indications of solids downflow near the wall. Overall, these findings suggest that, from an industrial standpoint, a direct scaleup of small-scale tests cannot readily be accomplished as the solids holdup and the solids velocity profiles in small units (those normally tested in the laboratory) are not similar to those of large units and the performance of large units can therefore not be predicted from small-scale tests.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Hydrodynamic Characterization of a Shallow Rectangular Spouted Bed Using Bed Pressure Signals and Image Processing Methods

To support the design of spouted bed reactors, experiments are performed in a rectangular spouted bed to measure the peak pressure drop (Δ P max ) and the internal and external spouting velocities ( U is and U es ). Four particle types spanning under Geldart D and B are used. U is and U es are measured from bed pressure drop and expansion ratio profiles, respectively, with the U es / U is ratio of each particle type obtained. Additionally, correlations predicting the Δ P max of Geldart D and B particles are developed by reviewing published correlations and investigating the nozzle effect. Good prediction is achieved with a slope of 0.997 and an adjusted R 2 of 0.998 in a 95% confidence interval. U es is predicted through correlations developed by adding effects of d p / D i and H 0 in the Mathur–Gishler equation. The calculated U es agrees well with the experimental data, achieving a slope of 0.998 and an adjusted R 2 of 0.998 in a 95% confidence interval.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Applying image processing methods to study hydrodynamic characteristics in a rectangular spouted bed

This paper presents systematic image processing methods for investigating hydrodynamic characteristics in a rectangular spouted bed (30.2 mm × 101.6 mm). The objective is to provide a non-intrusive technique to determine the bed expansion ratio, the jet height and the fountain height due to their significant influence on the hydrodynamics of the entire bed. A high-speed video camera is used in the experiment with Geldart D particles as the bed material. After the image acquisition, image denoising, thresholding, logical and mask operations are applied correspondingly for the boundary discrimination, based on which an algorithm has been developed to determine the bed height successfully. With the discriminated boundary, morphological operations viz. erosion and dilation have been used to accurately determine the jet height and the fountain height. The feasibility of the technique is proven through profiles of bed expansion ratio, jet height and fountain height under three initial bed heights (0.0762 m, 0.102 m, and 0.127 m) for two different nozzle sizes (0.0096 m and 0.0127 m). Depending on the determination of the hydrodynamic characteristics, different flow regimes can be distinguished comprehensively through profiles of the bed expansion ratio and bed pressure drop in combination with the standard deviation of jet/fountain height. The proposed flow regime discrimination verifies the feasibility and effectiveness of the image processing methods in assessing the solids behavior in the spouted beds. Results about the variation of the jet height and the fountain height under current operating conditions as determined by the new technique are also discussed.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Attrition of hematite particles for chemical looping combustion in a conical jet cup

The attrition of hematite particles for use in the chemical looping combustion process was investigated using a cold flow jet cup test. Jet cup attrition experiments are commonly used for bulk attrition testing of fluidized bed catalyst. The results indicate that the particle attrition in the jet cup cold flow experiments arises from surface abrasion due to particle-particle and particle-wall interactions. Experiments indicate that the measured cumulative mass loss increases with attrition time. However, the attrition rate decreases sharply at the early stage of attrition, and gradually, the rate decline slows and approaches a constant value with increasing attrition time. Furthermore, the influence of inlet gas velocity and solid inventory is discussed. As inlet gas velocities increase, the measured cumulative mass loss also increases. However, as the solid inventory increases, the cumulative mass loss decreases. The results also show that the jet cup experiments quantitatively compare with low magnitude tangential forces which is an indication of attrition through abrasion as the primary mechanism. It is determined through particle size distributions before and after which show a small shift of the main peaks with no peak broadening while producing a small number of fines. By using the mass of abraded fines and the widely-used Archard model for abrasive attrition, the specific wear rate coefficient can be predicted as a function of time. The wear coefficient calculation further identifies that the abrasion mechanism as the primary mechanism of attrition.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Analysis of Solids Flow Rate through Nonmechanical L-Valve in an Industrial-Scale Circulating Fluidized Bed Using Group B Particles

A series of statistically designed experiments were conducted using two different Geldart Group B particles in a 0.3 m diameter circulating fluidized bed (CFB) cold model to evaluate the nonmechanical L-valve for controlling the solids flow rate. The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of standpipe aeration, L-valve aeration, solids inventory, and superficial gas velocity through the riser on the solids flow rate. A stochastic correlation was developed for calculating the solid flow rate as a function of these variables. It was found that the solid flow rate increased directly proportional to each of these variables. Dimensional analysis was used to generate an expression for the solids turnover ratio. The model developed in the present study is intended to simulate flow in the present CFB loop. In conclusion, it is not intended for scale-up and will probably not apply for alternative CFB loops with different geometries/pressure balance conditions.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Estimation of Minimum Spouting Velocity in a Rectangular Spouted Bed

Here, a study was conducted to explore the effects of static bed height, nozzle diameter, cone angle, and particle properties on the minimum spouting velocity in a 4 in × 1 in rectangular spouted bed. Tests were conducted with various solids materials (including 871 μm HPDE pellets, 3.2 mm nylon beads, 707 μm glass beads, and 1.5 mm alumina spheres), two gas inlet nozzle diameters, and two cone angles. Experimentally obtained minimum spouting velocities were compared to existing published correlations developed for cylindrical spouted beds. In each case, it was determined that the existing correlations did not adequately predict the minimum spouting velocity for a rectangular spouted bed. A new correlation is proposed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Design, Development, and Operation of an Integrated Fluidized Carbon Capture Unit Using Polyethylenimine Sorbents

In this paper, we present the design, development, and operation of a reactor system for CO 2 capture. Modifications were implemented to address differences in sorbent from 180 μm Geldart group B to 115 μm Geldart group A material; operational issues were discovered during experimental trials. The major obstacle in system operation was the ability to maintain a constant circulation of a solid sorbent stemming from this change in sorbent material. The system consisted of four fluid beds, through which a polyamine impregnated sorbent was circulated and adsorption, preheat, regeneration, and cooling processes occurred. Pressure transducers, thermocouples, gas flow meters, and gas composition instrumentation were used to characterize thermal, hydrodynamic, and gas adsorption performance in this integrated unit. A series of shakedown tests were performed and the configuration altered to meet the needs of the sorbent performance and achieve desired target capture efficiencies. Methods were identified, tested, and applied to continuously monitor critical operating parameters including solids circulation rate, adsorbed and desorbed CO 2 , solids inventories, and pressures. The working capacity and CO 2 capture efficiency were used to assess sorbent performance while CO 2 closure was used to define data quality and approach to steady-state. Testing demonstrated >90% capture efficiencies and identified the regenerator to be the process step limiting throughput. Sorbent performance was found to be related to the reactant stoichiometry. Finally, a stochastic model with an exponential dependence on the relative CO 2 /amine concentration was used to describe 90% of the variance in the data.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Investigation of core-annular flow in an industrial scale circulating fluidized bed riser with electrical capacitance volume tomography (ECVT)

There is a paucity of riser data for industrial scale units, particularly with regard to the solids fraction. This is especially true for detailed spatially distributed values. To alleviate this problem, NETL installed a 0.445 m tall electrical capacitance volume tomography (ECVT) sensor 9.66 m from the gas distributor of its industrial size (15.45 m high and 0.3 m diameter) circulating fluidized bed (CFB) cold model. A series of tests were conducted to investigate the gas-solid flow behavior using high density polyethylene (PPE) solids. Static electricity was successfully minimized using Larostat and humidification. Time averaged radial solid fractions profiles are presented and discussed. The time and spatially averaged solid fractions measured by the ECVT agree well with estimates from the pressure drop. The annular thickness was measured and found to increase with increases in the solids flow rate and decrease with increases in the gas velocity. Comparisons of the annular thickness and solids fraction as determined from the ECVT unit were compared to existing correlations. In conclusion, the average error ranged from 13% to 275% which is not surprising since the literature correlations were developed from data on much smaller units and for significantly different particles.

42 ENGINEERING↗