DOE OSTI2023
Apatite can incorporate sulfur in its reduced form (S 2− ) when apatite equilibrates with a silicate melt under reducing conditions. Incorporation of sulfate (S 6+ ) has been observed in terrestrial apatite under oxidizing conditions. Thus, it has been suggested that the proportions of S 6+ /S 2− in apatite may record the oxygen fugacity ( f O 2 ) during the formation and/or equilibration of apatite grains with a silicate melt in a wide variety of igneous and metamorphic rocks, including from Earth, Mars, the Moon, and in materials from the asteroid belt. Martian rocks, which record f O 2 values intermediate between those recorded by rocks from the Moon and Earth, may have apatite that contains only S 2− or mixtures of S 6+ and S 2− . Here, we present new measurements of the oxidation state of sulfur in apatite grains in the basaltic shergottite, Shergotty, which exhibits spectral features consistent with the presence of sulfide (S 2− ) structurally bound in apatite, and no evidence for the presence of sulfite (S 4+ ) or sulfate (S 6+ ). Further, the presence of sulfide-only apatite in Shergotty is consistent with other mineralogical records of f O 2 in this meteorite, which are calculated from other late-stage crystallizing phases like Fe-Ti oxides as well as from early crystallizing phases like clinopyroxene ( D Eu Cpx/melt ) of ΔIW + 1.9 to ΔIW + 3.5. At these f O 2 values, S is present in silicate melts as only S 2− , and this suggests that the oxidation state of sulfur records and preserves the f O 2 during the igneous crystallization of apatite reinforcing the idea that sulfur in apatite can be used as an igneous oxybarometer.