Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Brown, F. B.

Publications and source records attributed to Brown, F. B..

Investigations into validation of plutonium solutions for criticality safety analysis

Plutonium solution chemistry is among the most complex of all the elements in the periodic table. Under acidic conditions up to four different oxidation states can be present in significant amounts in a single solution. From the perspective of nuclear criticality safety, accurate information regarding the concentration of plutonium and other constituents in solution must be well-known in order to correctly model plutonium solution systems for analysis. This requires knowledge of the solution system along with the ability to make accurate assumptions and predictions of the chemical and physical properties of the solution system. If neutron transport methods are used to assess subcriticality in a nuclear criticality safety analysis, the models must be compared with benchmark experiments which are similar and the suitability of the computer code system must be quantified. This paper describes some investigations undertaken to support the validation of plutonium solution systems for nuclear criticality safety analysis and how the Whisper sensitivity/uncertainty (S/U) tool can provide information to support validation of such systems. Case study results for various solution systems such as aqueous plutonium nitrate, aqueous plutonium chloride and hypothetical metal-water mixture are presented. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Release of MCNP6.2 and WHISPER-1.1 - Guidance for NCS users

In 2017, a new version of the MCNP6 Monte Carlo code package was released: MCNP6.2. This is the first version of MCNP to include the WHISPER package to support sensitivity-uncertainty based nuclear criticality safety validation. The coding changes to MCNP6.2 physics are relatively insignificant. Corrections to the S(α,β) thermal scattering numerics are generally negligible relative to problem statistics (or, in rare cases, prevent aborts). Similarly, the changes to adjoint-weighting for computing kinetics parameters may result in small differences, generally negligible compared to problem statistics. The change to the MCNP6.2 geometry treatment to correctly handle coincident surfaces in problems with universe/fill features will produce different round-off in the geometry tracking. This will produce differences in results relative to previous versions, but those differences should be small relative to problem statistics, and are not a concern. An immediate benefit of using MCNP6.2 (rather than MCNP6.1) is that the new version is typically 1.5-2 times faster.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Using Whisper-1.1 to guide improvements to nuclear data evaluations

Along with the latest release of the general purpose Monte Carlo radiation transport code, MCNP6.2, came the first officially released version of Whisper, version 1.1, a statistical analysis code used for nuclear criticality safety (NCS) validation. The Whisper software package is primarily used to calculate the upper subcritical limit (USL) of a particular application case along with components of the margin of subcriticality (MOS). In the calculation of the MOS due to nuclear data uncertainties, Whisper uses the generalized linear-least-squares (GLLS) approach to obtain adjusted nuclear data uncertainties which are then propagated to estimate the nuclear data uncertainties in the k{sub eff} of the application. Due to the fact that Whisper contains the simulated and measured k{sub eff} values for over 1100 benchmarks, nuclear data sensitivity profiles for each benchmark along with the nuclear data covariance matrices, all of which are used in the GLLS method, it is possible to easily utilize these data available to help guide improvements to nuclear data evaluations. In the present work, the Whisper data and the GLLS method are used together to suggest an adjusted nuclear data cross section evaluation specifically for {sup 233}U such that the agreement between the calculated and experimental k{sub eff} measurements of the relevant benchmarks are improved. With this adjusted nuclear data available, feedback to the theoretical and experimental nuclear data community is provided. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

MCNP6 Status and plans for criticality safety applications - 14368

The first production version of MCNP6 was released in 2013, with an update in 2014. MCNP6 provides all of the standard methodology for criticality calculations available in previous versions and new capabilities for adjoint-based sensitivity profiles and perturbations. This paper reviews the current status of MCNP6, including new features, performance improvements, verification testing, and nuclear data libraries. For criticality safety support, a new statistical package called Whisper was developed and first applied in 2014 for validation and determining USLs. Whisper includes input files and sensitivity profiles for over 1000 ICSBEP benchmarks and will be distributed with MCNP6. For the long term, an initiative called MCNP 2020 is underway to improve performance, strengthen the code foundation, and prepare for future computer systems. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Implementation of on-the-fly doppler broadening in MCNP

A new method to obtain Doppler broadened cross sections has been implemented into MCNP, removing the need to generate cross sections for isotopes at problem temperatures. When a neutron of energy E enters a material region that is at some temperature T, the cross sections for that material at temperature T are immediately obtained 'on-the-fly' (OTF) by interpolation using a high order functional expansion for the temperature dependence of the Doppler-broadened cross section for that isotope at the neutron energy E. The OTF cross sections agree with the NJOY-based cross sections for all neutron energies and all temperatures in the range specified by the user, e.g., 250 K - 3200 K. The OTF methodology has been successfully implemented into the MCNP Monte Carlo code and has been tested on several test problems by comparing MCNP with conventional ACE cross sections versus MCNP with OTF cross sections. The test problems include the Doppler defect reactivity benchmark suite and two full-core VHTR configurations, including one with multiphysics coupling using RELAP5-3D/ATHENA for the thermal-hydraulic analysis. The comparison has been excellent, verifying that the OTF libraries can be used in place of the conventional ACE libraries generated at problem temperatures. In addition, it has been found that the OTF methodology greatly reduces the complexity of the input for MCNP, resulting in an order of magnitude decrease in the number of input lines for full-core configurations. Finally, for full-core problems with multiphysics feedback, the memory required to store the cross section data is considerably reduced with OTF cross sections and the additional computational effort with OTF is modest, on the order of 10-15%. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Methodology, verification, and performance of the continuous-energy nuclear data sensitivity capability in MCNP6

A continuous-energy sensitivity coefficient capability has been introduced into MCNP6. The methods for generating energy-resolved and energy-integrated sensitivity profiles are discussed. Results from the verification exercises that were performed are given, and these show that MCNP6 compares favorably with analytic solutions, direct density perturbations, and comparisons to TSUNAMI-3D and MONK. Run-time and memory requirements are assessed for typical applications, and these are shown to be reasonable with modern computing resources. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

K-Eigenvalue sensitivities of secondary distributions of continuous-energy data

MCNP6 has the capability to produce energy-resolved sensitivity profiles for secondary distributions (fission {Chi} and scattering laws). Computing both unconstrained and constrained profiles are possible. Verification is performed with analytic test problems and a comparison to TSUNAMI-3D, and the comparisons show MCNP6 calculates correct or consistent results. Continuous-energy calculations are performed for three fast critical experiments: Jezebel, Flattop, and copper-reflected Zeus. The sensitivities to the secondary distributions (integrated over chosen energy ranges) are of similar magnitude to those of many of the cross sections, demonstrating the possibility that integral experiments are useful for assessing the fidelity of these data as well. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Evaluation of vectorized Monte Carlo algorithms on GPUs for a neutron Eigenvalue problem

Conventional Monte Carlo (MC) methods for radiation transport computations are 'history-based', which means that one particle history at a time is tracked. Simulations based on such methods suffer from thread divergence on the graphics processing unit (GPU), which severely affects the performance of GPUs. To circumvent this limitation, event-based vectorized MC algorithms can be utilized. A versatile software test-bed, called ARCHER - Accelerated Radiation-transport Computations in Heterogeneous Environments - was used for this study. ARCHER facilitates the development and testing of a MC code based on the vectorized MC algorithm implemented on GPUs by using NVIDIA's Compute Unified Device Architecture (CUDA). The ARCHER{sub GPU} code was designed to solve a neutron eigenvalue problem and was tested on a NVIDIA Tesla M2090 Fermi card. We found that although the vectorized MC method significantly reduces the occurrence of divergent branching and enhances the warp execution efficiency, the overall simulation speed is ten times slower than the conventional history-based MC method on GPUs. By analyzing detailed GPU profiling information from ARCHER, we discovered that the main reason was the large amount of global memory transactions, causing severe memory access latency. Several possible solutions to alleviate the memory latency issue are discussed. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Calculating infinite-medium {alpha}-eigenvalue spectra with a transition rate matrix method

The time-dependent behavior of the energy spectrum in neutron transport was investigated with a formulation, based on continuous-time Markov processes, for computing {alpha}-eigenvalues and eigenvectors in an infinite medium. For this, a research Monte Carlo code called TORTE was created and used to estimate elements of a transition rate matrix. TORTE is capable of using both multigroup and continuous-energy nuclear data, and verification was performed. Eigenvalue spectra for infinite homogeneous mixtures were obtained and an eigenfunction expansion was used to investigate transient behavior of the neutron energy spectrum. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Fission matrix capability for MCNP, Part I - Theory

The theory underlying the fission matrix method is derived using a rigorous Green's function approach. The method is then used to investigate fundamental properties of the transport equation for a continuous-energy physics treatment. We provide evidence that an infinite set of discrete, real eigenvalues and eigenfunctions exist for the continuous-energy problem, and that the eigenvalue spectrum converges smoothly as the spatial mesh for the fission matrix is refined. We also derive equations for the adjoint solution. We show that if the mesh is sufficiently refined so that both forward and adjoint solutions are valid, then the adjoint fission matrix is identical to the transpose of the forward matrix. While the energy-dependent transport equation is strictly bi-orthogonal, we provide surprising results that the forward modes are very nearly self-adjoint for a variety of continuous-energy problems. A companion paper (Part II - Applications) describes the initial experience and results from implementing this fission matrix capability into the MCNP Monte Carlo code. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Fission matrix capability for MCNP, Part II - Applications

This paper describes the initial experience and results from implementing a fission matrix capability into the MCNP Monte Carlo code. The fission matrix is obtained at essentially no cost during the normal simulation for criticality calculations. It can be used to provide estimates of the fundamental mode power distribution, the reactor dominance ratio, the eigenvalue spectrum, and higher mode spatial eigenfunctions. It can also be used to accelerate the convergence of the power method iterations. Past difficulties and limitations of the fission matrix approach are overcome with a new sparse representation of the matrix, permitting much larger and more accurate fission matrix representations. Numerous examples are presented. A companion paper (Part I - Theory) describes the theoretical basis for the fission matrix method. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Comparison of discrete and continuous thermal neutron scattering treatments in MCNP5

The standard discrete thermal neutron S({alpha},{beta}) scattering treatment in MCNP5 is compared with a continuous S({alpha},{beta}) scattering treatment using a criticality suite of 119 benchmark cases and ENDF/B-VII.0 nuclear data. In the analysis, six bound isotopes are considered: beryllium metal, graphite, hydrogen in water, hydrogen in polyethylene, beryllium in beryllium oxide and oxygen in beryllium oxide. Overall, there are only small changes in the eigenvalue (k{sub eff}) between discrete and continuous treatments. In the comparison of 64 cases that utilize S({alpha},{beta}) scattering, 62 agreed at the 95% confidence level, and the 2 cases with differences larger than 3 {sigma} agreed within 1 {sigma} when more neutrons were run in the calculations. The results indicate that the changes in eigenvalue between continuous and discrete treatments are random, small, and well within the uncertainty of measured data for reactor criticality experiments. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Temperature effects of resonance scattering for epithermal neutrons in MCNP

Epithermal neutron elastic scattering can be significantly affected by the thermal motion of target nuclides. Since the 1950's continuous-energy Monte Carlo codes have generally accounted for the target motion using a free gas scattering model, with the assumption that the scattering cross-section is constant in energy. Recent work has shown the importance of resonance scattering, and several methods for an improved free-gas treatment have been developed. We have implemented a rejection-based sampling scheme in the MCNP free-gas treatment to account for cross-section variation. The modified MCNP code was used to investigate a number of practical concerns: results for an LWR Doppler defect benchmark; computational costs; and energy limits for the free-gas treatment. Additionally, the impact on a suite of ICSBEP criticality benchmark problems (at room temperature) was determined to be negligible, an important result since such problems are used extensively in testing and evaluating revisions to ENDF/B-VII nuclear data. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Chord length sampling method for analyzing VHTR unit cells in continuous energy simulations

The chord length sampling method (CLS) is studied in the continuous energy simulations by applying it to analyzing two types of Very High Temperature Gas-cooled Reactor (VHTR) unit cells: the fuel compact cell in the prismatic type VHTR and the fuel pebble cell in the pebble-bed type VHTR. Infinite multiplication factors of the unit cells are calculated by the CLS and compared to the benchmark simulations at different volume packing fractions from 5% to 30%. It is shown that the accuracy of the CLS is affected by the boundary effect, which is induced by the CLS procedure itself and results in a reduction in the total volume packing fraction of the fuel particles. To mitigate the boundary effect, three correction schemes based on the research of 1) Murata et al. 2) Ji and Martin 3) Griesheimer et al. are used to improve the accuracy by applying a corrected value of the volume packing fraction to the CLS. These corrected values are calculated based on 1) a simple linear relationship, 2) an iterative self-consistent simulation correction method, and 3) a theoretically derived non-linear relationship, respectively. The CLS simulation using the corrected volume packing fraction shows excellent improvements in the infinite multiplication factors for the VHTR unit cells. Ji and Martin's self-consistent correction method shows the best improvement. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

A Monte Carlo neutron transport code for eigenvalue calculations on a dual-GPU system and CUDA environment

Monte Carlo (MC) method is able to accurately calculate eigenvalues in reactor analysis. Its lengthy computation time can be reduced by general-purpose computing on Graphics Processing Units (GPU), one of the latest parallel computing techniques under development. The method of porting a regular transport code to GPU is usually very straightforward due to the 'embarrassingly parallel' nature of MC code. However, the situation becomes different for eigenvalue calculation in that it will be performed on a generation-by-generation basis and the thread coordination should be explicitly taken care of. This paper presents our effort to develop such a GPU-based MC code in Compute Unified Device Architecture (CUDA) environment. The code is able to perform eigenvalue calculation under simple geometries on a multi-GPU system. The specifics of algorithm design, including thread organization and memory management were described in detail. The original CPU version of the code was tested on an Intel Xeon X5660 2.8 GHz CPU, and the adapted GPU version was tested on NVIDIA Tesla M2090 GPUs. Double-precision floating point format was used throughout the calculation. The result showed that a speedup of 7.0 and 33.3 were obtained for a bare spherical core and a binary slab system respectively. The speedup factor was further increased by a factor of {approx}2 on a dual GPU system. The upper limit of device-level parallelism was analyzed, and a possible method to enhance the thread-level parallelism was proposed. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Inclusion of electron correlation for the target wave function in low- to intermediate-energy e-N2 scattering

In a recent calculation, an exact exchange method was developed for use in the partial-differential-equation approach to electron-molecule scattering and was applied to e-N2 scattering in the fixed-nuclei approximation with an adiabatic polarization potential at low energies (0-10 eV). Integrated elastic cross sections were calculated and found to be lower than experiment at energies both below and above the Pi(g) resonance. It was speculated at that time that improved experimental agreement could be obtained if a correlated target representation were used in place of the uncorrelated one. The present paper implements this suggestion and demonstrates the improved agreement. These calculations are also extended to higher energies (0-30 eV) so asd to include the Sigma(u) resonance. Some discrepancies among the experiments and between experiment and the various calculations at very low energy are noted.

Weatherford, C. A.↗

Vectorized Monte Carlo methods for reactor lattice analysis

Some of the new computational methods and equivalent mathematical representations of physics models used in the MCV code, a vectorized continuous-enery Monte Carlo code for use on the CYBER-205 computer are discussed. While the principal application of MCV is the neutronics analysis of repeating reactor lattices, the new methods used in MCV should be generally useful for vectorizing Monte Carlo for other applications. For background, a brief overview of the vector processing features of the CYBER-205 is included, followed by a discussion of the fundamentals of Monte Carlo vectorization. The physics models used in the MCV vectorized Monte Carlo code are then summarized. The new methods used in scattering analysis are presented along with details of several key, highly specialized computational routines. Finally, speedups relative to CDC-7600 scalar Monte Carlo are discussed.

Brown, F. B.↗