Nanopores: synergy from DNA sequencing to industrial filtration – small holes with big impact
Nanopores in thin membranes play important roles in science and industry.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Bruening, Merlin L..
Nanopores in thin membranes play important roles in science and industry.
Ion separations are critical for producing materials such as Li and rare-earth element salts that are essential for applications including energy storage and production. This research aimed to develop and understand separations of singly and multiply charged ions as well as separations among different singly charged ions such as Li + and Na + . Thin layers of polyelectrolytes on membranes allow passage of singly charged ions at rates 1000 times faster than those for multiply charged ions. This allows purification of mixtures with equal concentrations of Li + and Mg 2+ to create a permeate solution with >99% Li + . Such membranes may also effectively isolate rare earth elements. To separate Li + and K + , this work developed opposing flow and current in membranes. The current overcomes the flow of K + to allow Li + to selectively pass through the membrane, leading to Li + /K + selectivities around 70. All of the research employs modelling to better understand the mechanism of these separations, which includes transport driven by gradients in electrical potential, concentration, and pressure. The interplay of these driving forces can create highly selective separations.
Separation of monovalent and multivalent ions is important in processes ranging from water softening to recycling of Li. Previous studies show that cation-exchange membranes coated with multilayer polyelectrolyte films exhibit monovalent/divalent ion selectivities as high as 1000 in electrodialysis (ED) under ideal conditions with low ion recoveries. This work shows that even at 60-80% monovalent-ion recoveries, ED through Nafion membranes coated with protonated poly(allylamine)/poly(4-styrenesulfonate) multilayers can separate equimolar K + and Mg 2+ or Li + and Mg 2+ to give 99.5% pure monovalent ion. Moreover, the use of a low-volume receiving phase allows ED to concentrate the monovalent ion. Typical current efficiencies are around 70% for these separations. Selectivities appear to increase when the membrane-coating procedure uses a higher polyelectrolyte concentration in the deposition solution. Because the limiting current declines with ED time due to depletion of the monovalent ion in the source phase, use of a gradually decreasing applied current enhances current efficiency compared to ED at a constant high current. Further, the membranes also show Li + /Mg 2+ selectivities around 100 when Mg 2+ is in a 20-fold excess in the source phase at an ionic strength of 0.6 M, but selectivity decreases at even higher ionic strengths.
Highly selective ion separations are vital for recovering important salts, and membrane-based techniques may enable environmentally friendly ion separations that operate continuously. This study demonstrates that simply opposing convective flow with electromigration in track-etched membranes leads to remarkable selectivities among monovalent ions. Because the membrane-pore diameters are orders of magnitude larger than the ion diameters, advection moves all ions at the same velocity, whereas electrophoretic velocities are proportional to ion mobilities. Thus during counter-flow cation electromigration, less mobile cations have lower electromigration velocity components and pass through porous membranes more rapidly than more mobile cations. Using membranes with 400 nm pores, counter-flow electromigration gives Li + /K + selectivities of 100 and Li + /Na + selectivities around 30 in mixed-salt studies. In this work, numerical simulations based on the extended Nernst-Planck equation agree with trends in experimental data and highlight the importance of high Péclet numbers, high current-to-flow ratios, and uniform current distributions for achieving high selectivities. Importantly, experimental separations give high selectivities at 0.3 M ionic strength and low Li + /K + ratios, which suggest these methods may also work in brine solutions. Nevertheless, energy costs for such separations are high.
Nanochannel-based fluidic diodes display ion selectivity and ion-current rectification (ICR), which may prove important in energy harvesting and biosensors. This paper reports asymmetric functionalization of the outer surface of a flexible nanochannel polymer membrane to create fluidic diodes that give ICR. Layer-by-layer (LbL) adsorption with cross-linking of only the underlying part of the polyelectrolyte nanofilm leads to a porosity step across the film. The combination of a high effective surface-charge density and the porosity step in the film leads to a remarkable maximum ICR factor of ~200 with a pH gradient across the film. Incorporation of pH-sensitive polyelectrolyte components enables the ICR factor to increase an order of magnitude on going from pH 8 to pH 3. Furthermore, the coated membrane shows excellent anion-selectivity. Thus, LbL adsorption with partial cross-linking provides a simple method for creating coated nanochannel membranes that serve as pH-responsive ionic diodes for potential chemical/biosensors.
This study explores theoretically and numerically the phenomenon of counter-flow accumulation of trace coions during electro-osmo-dialysis through composite membranes containing nanoporous and perforated ion-exchange layers. The combination of charged nanopores and perforations allows electroosmosis, and ion concentration polarization appears near the ion-exchange layer. Accumulation of trace coions occurs because their advective and electromigration flow velocity components have opposite signs and are locally compensating in depletion regions where electric fields are high. This local compensation of flow components can give rise to high accumulation factors (>1000 in some cases) for trace coions at some distance from the interface between the nanoporous and ion-exchange layers. Moreover, the extent of this accumulation depends on the trace-coion diffusion coefficient. The resulting selectivity between different coions might serve as a basis for environmentally friendly separation of ionic species such as synthetic peptides or rare-earth elements. For example, a periodic process might include accumulation followed by species release into smaller volumes of solution. For both rare-earth ions and peptide-like species, the accumulation selectivity between ions with small differences in mobilities depends on system parameters such as nanoporous-layer thickness, distance between the perforations, and the zeta potential of the nanopore surface. Here, the use of optimal values of these membrane parameters may enable tuning of the electro-osmo-dialysis system for separation of specific ions. Modelling reveals that despite inhomogeneous patterns of fluid and ion flows close to the nanoporous/perforated ion-exchange interface, at relatively short distances from this interface (less than half the distance between the perforations) all the flows become practically one-dimensional (1D). Similarly, the concentration profiles of trace coions also become 1D. The flow one-dimensionality at short distances from the current-polarized interface enables a simple 1D approximation that is useful for an approximate analysis of trends in this multi-parameter system.
Ion separations are important for resource recovery, water treatment, and energy production and storage. Techniques such as chemical precipitation, selective adsorption, and solvent extraction are effective, but membranes may separate ions continuously with less waste and lower energy costs. Separation of monovalent and multivalent ions with nanofiltration or electrodialysis membranes already enables water softening and edible salt purification. Similar membranes are attractive as separators in vanadium redox flow batteries. Selective partitioning of divalent counter-ions into ion-exchange membranes even allows transport of these ions against their concentration gradients in salt mixtures. However, separations of ions with the same charge is more challenging. Recent research demonstrated highly selective ion “sieving” at small scales. Here, separations using electrical potentials and differences in ion electrophoretic mobilities are promising, but relatively unexplored. Carrier-mediated transport affords high selectivity in liquid membranes, but these systems are not very stable, and selective transport via hopping between anchored carriers has proven elusive. Finally, this paper discusses how concentration polarization decreases selectivities in many membrane processes. Although development of selective, inexpensive ion-separation membranes is a work in progress, successes in water softening and edible salt purification suggests that future selective membranes will serve as complementary methods to traditional purification techniques.
Layer-by-layer (LBL) polyelectrolyte coatings on membranes are attractive for their high selectivities between monovalent and divalent ions. However, deposition of poly(4-styrenesulfonate) (PSS)/protonated poly(allylamine) (PAH) films on ion-exchange membranes leads to low ion fluxes that restrict productivity or current efficiency. This study shows that increasing the solution pH from 6.5 to 8.3 enhances cation fluxes and limiting currents through (PAH/PSS) 5 PAH-coated cation-exchange membranes while still achieving order of magnitude selectivity increases compared to bare membranes. In Donnan dialysis through (PAH/PSS) 5 PAH-coated Nafion, at pH 8.3 the K + /Mg 2+ selectivity is 100, and the K + flux is 22 times that at pH 6.5. Moreover, at the higher pH the electrodialysis limiting current through these membranes increases ~5-fold. This enables electrodialysis separation of K + and Mg 2+ with a current efficiency around 0.75, a selectivity of 18, and 50% K + recovery from the source phase. Transmembrane potential measurements and increases in Cl - /SO 4 2- selectivities (from 9.5 at pH 6.5 to ~70 at pH 8.3) for porous alumina membranes coated with (PSS/PAH) 5 PSS films suggest that the coating becomes cation-permselective at higher pH. Increased cation transference numbers in polyelectrolyte coatings likely lead to the enhanced limiting currents for coated Nafion at higher pH. Lastly, (PAH/PSS) 5 PAH-coated Nafion shows a Li + /Mg 2+ Donnan dialysis selectivity >700 at neutral pH and a selectivity of 10 at pH 8.3. However, the Li + flux is 6 times greater at pH 8.3, which might make operation at the higher pH desirable.
Flow through negatively charged nanopores separates Li + and K + with selectivities of up to 70 and Li + passages from 20% to above 100%. Remarkably, both the Li + /K + selectivity and Li + passage initially increase with flow rate, breaking the permeability/selectivity trade-off. Modelling demonstrates that flow through the membranes creates electric fields that retard transport of cations. Selectivity increases with flow rate because the K + electromigration velocity exceeds its convective velocity, but for Li + electromigration is weaker than convection. Here, modelling also shows the importance of controlling concentration polarization. With further work, related separations might provide highly pure Li salts for battery manufacturing.
This research examines theoretically the ion concentration polarization, ion fluxes, and electrostatic fields near an ion exchange patch in the wall of an electrified fluidic channel. These phenomena are important in related microfluidic ion-preconcentration systems. Under an electric field, counterions enter the ion-exchange patch at one side and leave at the other, with salt depletion occurring near the entrance and accumulation near the exit. Furthermore, the high patch conductivity and the concentration profiles lead to local electric field perturbations that may facilitate preconcentration. This study includes analytical expressions of ion concentrations and electrochemical potentials at small to moderate electric fields, as well as numerical simulations. Additionally, a simple matrix of polynomial coefficients (obtained via fitting of numerical data) enables analytical calculation of the 2-dimensional concentration profiles at all electric fields within the range investigated in the numerical simulations. This is possible because a single dimensionless parameter controls this problem.
We present that ion passage through ion-exchange membranes is vital in electrodialysis desalination, batteries and fuel cells, and water splitting. Simplified models of ion transport through such membranes frequently assume complete exclusion of coions (ions with the same sign of charge as the fixed charge in the membrane) from the membrane. However, a second assumption of constant counterion electrochemical potentials across the membrane leads to simple analytical expressions for ion fluxes and transmembrane potentials. Moreover, linear corrections to account for a small membrane electrical resistance yield analytical expressions with a wider applicability. For bi-ionic potential measurements and current-induced concentration polarization at low salt concentrations, these analytical solutions match the fluxes and potentials obtained numerically without the limiting assumptions. This gives confidence in both the limiting assumptions (under appropriate conditions) and the numerical solutions. At low ion concentrations, the analytical solutions may enable rapid characterization of membrane coatings or boundary layers in solution, and such boundary layers are important in many applications of ion-exchange membranes. In fact, the assumption of complete coion exclusion is sometimes more limiting than the constraint of constant electrochemical potentials of counterions across the membrane. Remarkably, this limiting case readily yields the ion accumulation and depletion regions above “ion-exchange patches” that reside beneath a solution with an applied electric field. Finally, such regions are important for sample pre-concentration in microfluidic devices.
During application of an electrical current through a composite micro-/nano-porous membrane, trace-ion accumulation in the microporous layer should vary greatly with the ion diffusion coefficient to allow selective accumulation of specific ions. In this study, we examine the theoretical enrichment factors in the microporous region as a function of current density and trace-ion diffusion coefficient to demonstrate the promise of such micro-/nano-porous interfaces for ion separations. Trace-ion accumulation relies on charged nanopores that exclude coions (ions with the same charge as the nanopore walls)and give rise (under current) to depletion of the dominant (high-concentration) salt in the region next to the nanopores. This depletion gives rise to high local electric fields. Trace ions accumulate in this region because convection carries them toward the nanoporous interface, whereas electromigration in the opposite direction is strongest next to the interface. For ions whose diffusion coefficients are half of the corresponding value for the dominant salt, calculated enrichment factors reach 150. In contrast depletion occurs for ions with the same diffusion coefficient as the dominant salt. Even higher enrichment factors appear for divalent ions due to their relatively low diffusion coefficients. Lastly, with monovalent coions whose diffusion coefficients differ by only 2%, calculated selectivity factors reach values >1.2 (>1.8 for divalent coions), depending on the magnitudes of the diffusion coefficients. Such selectivities may prove useful in separating very similar species such as isotopes or equally charged peptides.
This review critically examines current models for nanofiltration (NF) of electrolyte solutions. We start from linear irreversible thermodynamics, we derive a basic equation set for ion transfer in terms of gradients of ion electrochemical potentials and transmembrane volume flux. These equations are extended to the case of significant differences of thermodynamic forces across the membrane (continuous version of irreversible thermodynamics) and solved in quadratures for single salts and trace ions added to single salts in the case of macroscopically-homogeneous membranes. These solutions reduce to (quasi)analytical expressions in the popular Spiegler-Kedem approximation (composition independent phenomenological coefficients), which we extend to the case of trace ions. This enables us to identify membrane properties (e.g. ion permeances, ion reflection coefficients, electrokinetic charge density) that control its performance in NF of multi-ion solutions. Further, we specify the phenomenological coefficients of irreversible thermodynamics in terms of ion partitioning, hindrance and diffusion coefficients for the model of straight cylindrical capillaries. The corresponding expressions enable assessment of the applicability of the popular nanopore model of NF. This model (based on the use of macroscopic approaches at nanoscale) leads to a number of trends that have never been observed experimentally. We also show that the use of the Born formula (frequently employed for the description of dielectric exclusion) hardly leads to meaningful values of solvent dielectric constant in membrane pores because this formula disregards the very solvent structure whose changes are supposed to bring about the reduction of dielectric permittivity in nanopores. We conclude that the effect should better be quantified in terms of ion excess solvation energies in the membrane phase. As an alternative to the nanopore description of NF, we review recent work on the development of an advanced engineering model for NF of multi ion solutions in terms of a solution-diffusionelectromigration mechanism. This model (taking into account spontaneously arising transmembrane electric fields) captures several trends observed experimentally, and the use of trace ions can provide model parameters (ion permeances in the membrane) from experiment. We also consider a recent model (ultrathin barrier layers with deviations from local electroneutrality) that may reproduce observed feed-salt concentration dependences of membrane performance in terms of concentration independent properties like excess ion solvation energies.
Development of anion-exchange membranes (AEMs) with selectivities among anions may expand the applications of these membranes in salt separations. This work shows that layer-by-layer coating of aliphatic polyamide AEMs with poly(4-styrenesulfonate) (PSS)/protonated poly(allylamine) (PAH) films enhances Cl - /SO 4 2- dialysis selectivities, and the extent of this enhancement depends on the source-phase salt concentrations. For a source phase containing 0.01 M NaCl and 0.01 M Na 2 SO 4 and a receiving phase of 0.01 M Na 2 CO 3 , a (PSS/PAH) 5 PSS coating (5 PSS/PAH “bilayers” capped with a layer of PSS) increases the Cl - /SO 4 2- selectivity from 1.7 to 5.3 in diffusion dialysis and from 1.3 to 7.4 in electrodialysis. Remarkably, the diffusion dialysis selectivity of a coated membrane increases to 140 when the salt concentrations in the source phase are 0.1 M. Even with bare membranes, selectivity increases to 13 with 0.1 M source-phase salt concentrations. Moreover, AEMs coated only on the receiving side show much higher selectivities but lower fluxes than those coated only on the source side. In conclusion, partitioning experiments and modelling suggest that the increased Cl - /SO 4 2- selectivities at high source-phase salt concentrations stem from enhanced Cl - partitioning and electromigration that disproportionately decreases SO 4 2- flux in the AEM.
Cation-exchange membranes allow preferential passage of cations over anions, but they show minimal selectivity among cations, which limits their use in ion separations. Recent studies show that modification of cation-exchange membranes with polyelectrolyte multilayers leads to exceptional monovalent/divalent cation electrodialysis selectivities, but no studies report high selectivity among monovalent ions. Here, this work demonstrates that adsorption of protonated poly(allylamine) (PAH)/poly(4-styrenesulfonate) (PSS) multilayers on Nafion membranes leads to high K + /Li + selectivities in Donnan dialysis, where K + and Li + ions in a source phase pass through the membrane and exchange with Na + ions in a receiving phase. Addition of 0.01 M HNO 3 to a source phase containing 0.01 M KNO 3 and 0.01 M LiNO 3 increases the K + /Li + selectivity from 8 to ~60 through (PAH/PSS) 5 PAH-coated Nafion membranes, primarily because of a ≥fivefold increase in K + flux. These selectivities are much larger than the ratio of 1.9 for the aqueous diffusion coefficients of K + and Li + , and uncoated Nafion membranes give a K + /Li + selectivity <3. Bi-ionic transmembrane potential measurements at neutral pH confirm that the membrane is more permeable to K + than Li + , but this selectivity is less than in Donnan dialysis with acidic solutions. In situ ellipsometry data indicate that PAH/PSS multilayers (assembled at pH 2.3, 7.5, or 9.3) swell at pH 2.0, and this swelling may open cation-exchange sites that preferentially bind K + to enable highly selective transport. The coated membranes also exhibit modest selectivity for K + over H + , suggesting selective transport based on preferential partitioning of K + into the coatings. Selectivity declines when increasing the source-phase KNO 3 concentration to 0.1 M, perhaps because the discriminating transport pathway saturates. Finally, selectivities are lower in electrodialysis than in Donnan dialysis, presumably because electrodialysis engages other transport mechanisms, such as electroosmosis and strong electromigration.
Nafion membranes coated with polyelectrolyte multilayers (PEMs) exhibit outstanding monovalent/divalent cation electrodialysis selectivity in a single-membrane cell. Nevertheless, the high cost of Nafion and the extensive pretreatments required for polyelectrolyte adsorption on this surface may preclude the use of these membranes in many applications. Here this work reports that native aliphatic polyamide Fujifilm type 1 cation-exchange membranes modified with protonated poly(allylamine) (PAH)/poly (4-styrenesulfonate) (PSS) films also show extremely high K + /Mg 2+ cation selectivities in ED with a single-membrane cell. Even with 0.1 M salt in the source phase, the K + /Mg 2+ selectivity is >1000. The very low transfer of divalent cations implies that the PEM forms a complete, continuous coating on the smooth Fujifilm surface. Moreover, for a membrane coated on both sides, the PEM on the anode side is responsible for most of the selectivity. However, the current efficiency is only ~0.6 for PAH/PSS-modified Fujifilm or Nafion membranes. Adsorption of highly water-swollen (PDADMAC/PSS) n films on Nafion membranes leads to high K + /Mg 2+ and Li + /Co 2+ selectivities in ED, and the monovalent cation current efficiency reaches 0.8.
Here, this paper develops an analytical solution to the equations governing the solution-diffusion-electromigration transport of the ions from two salts that contain a common ion. The analytical expressions, which rely on constant ion permeances, readily enable simple spreadsheet computations of the permeate ion concentrations in nanofiltration (NF). Despite the model simplicity, calculations of ion rejections as a function of transmembrane volume fluxes, feed-solution compositions, and permeance values reproduce experimental trends, with ion permeances as the only adjustable parameters. For example, with solutions containing dissolved MA and M 2 B, when the membrane permeance to B 2– is much lower than the permeances to A – and M + , plots of A – rejection versus transmembrane volume flux show the negative minimum that is often characteristic of NF. Moreover, B 2– rejection increases with increasing MA in the feed solution, reflecting a decreasing electric field in the membrane. The analytical solution also enables spreadsheet computations of electric fields in membrane separation layers and effectively models experimental data for intrinsic rejections as a function of transmembrane volume flow. Interestingly, the model suggests that with sufficiently high permeances of A – (relative to M + ), at certain feed compositions the A – /B 2– selectivity may increase without bound as a function of volume flow. Otherwise, this selectivity does not vary greatly with feed composition and quickly reaches a limit as the volume flow increases. Despite the simplifying approximation of constant ion permeances, using only a few adjustable parameters this model readily reveals trends in NF ion rejections and may help to identify the desired ion permeances or solution compositions for specific separations.