Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Burchell, Timothy

Publications and source records attributed to Burchell, Timothy.

At least 19 records

Codes and standards for ceramic composite core materials for High Temperature Reactor applications

Fiber-reinforced ceramic matrix composites are attractive for high-temperature nuclear applications due to excellent thermal and mechanical properties as well as reasonable-to-outstanding radiation resistance. Over the past 20 years, the use of ceramic matrix composite applications expanded to many commercial non-nuclear industries as fabrication and application of the technologies mature. The ASME Boiler Pressure Vessel Code, under Section III Division 5, provides the design and construction rules for High Temperature Reactor components. It published the first rules for ceramic matrix composites to be used for reactor core components. The rules lay out the quality requirements together with the design and materials criteria for the use and application of silicon carbide- and carbon-based matrix material technologies. As with the established graphite rules, the ceramic composite material rules are structured in Subsection HH (from Section III), that addresses the criteria for class SN nonmetallic core components. The code rules rely heavily on the development and publication of standards for composite specification, classification, and testing of mechanical, thermal, and other properties. These test methods are developed in ASTM Committee C28 on Advanced Ceramics, with a current focus on ceramic composite tubes. This article describes the detail of the composites code, the design methodology and similarities to the graphite code, the guidance for the development of specifications for ceramic composites (for nuclear applications) including recent standard developments, and it mentions the next steps to support licensing aspects by validating the code with benchmarking data.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

The Fracture Toughness of Nuclear Graphite Grades, Revision 1

New measurements of graphite mode I critical stress intensity factor, K Ic (commonly referred to as the fracture toughness) and the mode II critical shear stress intensity, K IIc , are reported and compared with prior data for K Ic and K IIc . The new data are for graphite grades PCEA, IG-110 and 2114. Variations of K Ic and acoustic emission (AE) data with graphite texture are reported and discussed. The Codes and Standards applications of fracture toughness, K Ic , data are also discussed. A specified minimum value for nuclear graphite K Ic is recommended.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

ASME Code Rules and ASTM Standards Integration for Ceramic Composite Core Materials and Components 1

Fiber-reinforced ceramic matrix composites have many desirable properties for high-temperature nuclear applications, including excellent thermal and mechanical properties and reasonable to outstanding radiation resistance. Over the last 20 years, the use of ceramic composite materials has already expanded in many commercial nonnuclear industries as fabrication and application technologies mature. The new ASME design and construction rules under Section III, Subsection HH, Subpart B lay out the requirements and criteria for materials, design, machining and installation, inspection, examination, testing, and the marking procedure for ceramic composite core components, which is similar to the established graphite code under Section III, Subsection HH, Subpart A. Moreover, the general requirements listed in Section III, Subsection HA, Subpart B are also expanded to include ceramic composite materials. The code rules rely heavily on the development and publication of standards for composite specification, classification, and testing of mechanical, thermal, and other properties. These test methods are developed in the American Society for Testing and Materials Committee C28 on Advanced Ceramics with a current focus on ceramic composite tubes. Details of the composites code, design methodology, and similarities to the graphite code, as well as guidance for the development of specifications for ceramic composites for nuclear application and recent standard developments, are discussed. The next step is to "close the gap" to support licensing aspects by validating the code with benchmarking data.

Geringer, Josina↗

Radiation Effects in Graphite

Graphite has been a core structural material and neutron moderator since the first man-made chain reaction experiment in Chicago. This article will discuss the requirements of what makes graphite a good solid moderator. The manufacture and properties of some currently available near-isotropic and isotropic grades are described. The major features of a graphite moderated reactors are briefly outlined. Displacement damage and the induced structural and dimensional changes in graphite are described. Recent characterization work on nano-carbons and oriented pyrolytic graphites that have shed new light on graphite defect structures are reviewed, and the effect of irradiation temperature on the defect structures is highlighted. Changes in the physical properties of nuclear graphite caused by neutron irradiation are reported. Finally, the importance of irradiation induced creep is presented, along with current models and their deficiencies.

Campbell, Anne↗

Status Report on ASME Code Development for Nonmetallic Core Components in 2020

The purpose of this report is to provide a status update on the progress and ongoing activities of the current ASME Boiler Pressure Vessel (BPV) Code Section III, Division 5, on nonmetallic core components and assemblies which includes the design rules for graphite and ceramic composite materials. Section III is concerned with the design and construction of nuclear reactor components and Division 5 focuses on high temperature reactors (HTR). The ASME Section III Committee’s function for nuclear items other than pressure-retaining components, is to establish rules of safety related to structural integrity. The term “construction” refers to the all-inclusive effort comprising of materials, design, fabrication, examination, inspection, testing, certification, and pressure relief. The Department of Energy (DOE) supports industry codes and standards development through focused research providing the technical basis for new or modified codes and standards and the participation of subject matter experts in codes and standards committees. The activities for the nonmetallic core components and assemblies committees are the pursuit of two working groups that meet quarterly during ASME BPV Code Week meetings. The two working groups are General Requirements for Graphite and Ceramic Composite Core Components and Assemblies (GR GCCCCA) and Nonmetallic Design and Materials (NDM). The rules on general requirements for nonmetallic core components are discussed in the articles of Subsection HA subpart B. Ceramic composites were recently incorporated within the rules, and the GR GCCCCA working group is now in the process of aligning the requirements with the subsections and articles of ASME BPV Code Section III NCA, the general requirements for Division 1 and 2 of the code. The NDM working group is concerned with the design rules for graphite and composite materials for core components and assemblies discussed in Subsection HH (Class SN Nonmetallic Core Components) subpart A and subpart B which reference graphite and composite materials respectively. The bulk of the progress and work is done within this working group. A significant undertaking, with discussion that started in 2015, is to gain endorsement of ASME Section III, Division 5, by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). In June 2018, ASME formally recommended endorsement to the NRC. The NRC has since initiated the endorsement review process, which is to be concluded early in 2021. ASME task groups on metallic structures and components, as well as non-metallic core support structures, have been formed to define potential pathways and schedules for NRC endorsement of Division 5. NRC determined to perform a review on the 2017 edition of Section III Division 5 as a baseline. As a result, the use of graphite as nonmetallic core components formed part of the review, but it excluded composite materials (which were first introduced in the 2019 edition). This report documents progress in FY 2020 directed toward ASME’s efforts to develop design codes for graphite and composites. Progress includes a major code review by NRC, the first code enquiry, and its solution, an overhaul of the treatment of Weibull Statistics, and the addition of Nonmandatory Appendices to the composites code relating to carbon-carbon composite materials.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Protection of graphite from salt and gas permeation in molten salt reactors

The reactor core, moderator and reflectors of a thermal spectrum advanced molten salt reactor will constitute multi-tons of graphite. Porous reactor-grade graphite, if unprotected, can be permeated by molten salt depending on the infiltrating pressure differential and entrance diameters of accessible graphite pores. Salt and gas permeation of graphite can affect microstructural properties and radiation behavior but also facilitate diffusion, deposition and retention of fission products and tritium. Because of the significant void volume of nuclear graphite, fission products and tritium retention due to salt permeation necessitates seal coatings or pore impregnation to reduce open porosity. Alternatively, very fine-grained graphite grades with low Xe permeability are being developed. In this work, we survey the current technologies for mitigating salt and gas transport into graphite.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Characterization of the Irradiation Effects in Nuclear Graphite

Graphite serves as the neutron moderator of British Gas-Cooled Reactors and is a candidate material for the Generation IV of nuclear power stations. The neutron irradiation affects the crystalline structure of graphite; this damage results in volumetric changes of the bulk material and generation of porosity. Dimensional changes induced by irradiation in graphite bricks can make difficult the refueling operations and reduce the stability of the graphite core. Some of the neutron irradiation damage mechanisms in the crystal lattice of graphite are not well understood. Results of TEM, SEM, FIB-SEM tomography, gas adsorption and optical microscopy will be combined to help understand how the irradiation affects graphite at multiple length scales. Furthermore, some new evidence of porosity and microstructural changes generated by irradiation will be presented.

Arregui Mena, Jose'↗

AGC-1 Irradiation Induced Property Changes Analysis Report: Dynamic Elastic Modulus

Recent analyses of some of the test property data from the AGC-1 creep capsule are reported. Specifically the analyses of data for the effects of compressive creep strain on the Dynamic elastic modulus (by the fundamental frequency and ultrasonic velocity/tof methods) are reported. Statistical “t” testing was used to establish the statistical significance of any differences observed between the Dynamic elastic modulus of the creep (irradiated with compressive stress) and the control (irradiated without stress) specimens. Compressive creep strain does have a small effect on Dynamic elastic modulus, reducing it at the higher doses as volume turnaround is approached.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

AGC-1 Irradiation Induced Proprerty Changes Analysis Report: Electrical Resistivity and Coefficient of Thermal Expansion

Here we report the analysis of some of the test property data from the AGC-1 creep capsule. Specifically, we report analysis of the electrical resistivity (ER) and coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE). AGC-1 was operated at ~640°C and we measured the irradiated specimen CTE (α) over the temperature range 25°C to 550°C. Consequently, we have analyzed the mean CTE value for the temperature rage 25°C – 500°C. Both the ER and α(25-500°C) have been examined as a function of specimen dose (control specimens) and creep strain, %, (creep specimen). A direct comparison of the property changes has been made for the creep and control specimens by plotting their respective fractional changes as a function on neutron dose. Statistical “t” testing has been applied to any observed differences in property (ER or CTE) as a function of dose for the creep and control specimens of each graphite grade in the AGC-1 capsule. For electrical resistivity the irradiated value was shown to be greater than the unirradiated value for all graphite grades. However, the additional change due to creep strain was not found to be statistically significant. The coefficient of thermal expansion was seen to increase with dose for both the creep and control specimens. This increase was clearly seen in the fractional changes in CTE plot. The creep specimens were seen to increase their CTE above that noted for the control samples. The values of α(25-500°C) was statistically “t” tested and the differences between the creep and control CTE increases were shown to be statistically significant. Thus, creep strain is shown to have no additional effect upon ER but does increase the CTE over that observed from dose alone. The additional increase of CTE due to creep, is attributed to the closure of a larger fraction of the aligned porosity by compressive creep.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

The Analysis of Results from 3-Point Flexure Testing of Irradiated AGC-1 Graphite Creep Specimens

Here we report the analysis of test data from AGC-1 specimen 3-pt flexure testing. At this time all mechanical (flexural) testing of AGC-1 specimens has been completed. Individual force-extension curves are available as .txt files recorded electronically from the author (burchelltd@ornl.gov). This Technical Memorandum meets Idaho National Laboratories statement of Work No. 10752 Rev. 3 deliverable 4.4C “Issue a draft ORNL TM report summarizing the results and data analysis of all mechanical testing to INL no later than May 15, 2015.” The data and analysis was provided in a timely fashion as an excel s/s with data analysis plots. This TM follows on and formalizes transmission of the data. The major conclusion from this analysis is that there is no additional effect of creep strain on the flexure strength of graphite.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

PCEA Baseline Characterization: Billet XCP01S8 11 Compressive, Tensile, and Flexure Strengths

Grade PCEA graphite is one of several grades being considered for the core structures of the Next Generation Nuclear Plant (NGNP). An experimental program is underway to describe the statistical nature of the mechanical properties of PCEA graphite, information needed to support the design of graphite components and licensing of the NGNP. It will be necessary to characterize several billets from various lots or batches. The exact number of billets will depend on the observed variability in properties.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

The Results of 3-Point Flexure Testing of Irradiated AGC-1 Graphites Specimens

Here we report the test data from AGC-1 specimen 3-pt flexure testing. At this time all mechanical (flexural) testing of AGC-1 specimens has been completed. Individual force-extension curves are available as .txt files recorded electronically and are available from the author (burchelltd@ornl.gov). Typical curves are included for both the unirradiated and irradiated specimens. The flexure strength has been calculated for each specimen. This letter report meets Idaho National Laboratories statement on Work No. 10752 Rev. 3 deliverable 4.4B “Issue an electronic letter report communication indicating the status of AGC-1 mechanical testing to INL no later than March 27, 2015."

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

AGC-1 Irradiation Creep Strain Data Analysis

This Technical Memorandum (TM) fulfills milestone 4.2 of SOW-112178 “VHTR TDO GRAPHITE R&D – FY2014”, a level 2 deliverable due to the Department of Energy on September 30, 2014. Here we report the creep strain data and the analysis of the creep strain data from the irradiation creep capsule AGC-1 specimens that were supplied to ORNL. This is the first (prototype) of a series of five or six capsules planned as part of the Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment to fully characterize the neutron irradiation effects and radiation creep behavior of current nuclear graphites. The data reported include: specimen dimensions and hence the dimensional change upon irradiation. A comparison of these data for specimen matched pairs yields the creep strain; mass and volume, hence density. The creep strain analysis is by graphite grade. The AGC-1 capsule was irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at INL at approximately 700°C and to a peak dose of 7 dpa (displacements per atom). The specimens final dose, temperature and stress conditions have been reported by INL1,2 are also tabulated here and used in the analysis.

Graphite Creep↗

Progress of Codes and Standards Development for Nuclear Applications of Ceramic Composite Materials

Ceramic matrix composites, mainly continuous silicon carbide (SiC) fiber-reinforced SiC matrix composites (SiC-SiC composites) and continuous carbon fiber-reinforced carbon matrix composites (C-C or carbon-carbon composites), are currently being evaluated for use at high temperatures and high radiation fields in various advanced high temperature reactor concepts. These composites have a number of desirable properties for high temperature nuclear applications, including excellent thermal and mechanical properties and reasonable (C-C) to outstanding (SiC-SiC) radiation resistance. Moreover, these composites are finding expanding utilization as the fabrication and application technologies mature. However, designing nuclear reactor core components with these composite materials and qualification of certain composite materials for use in nuclear reactors requires the design rules. In order to establish such rules, a development task for rules for the construction of the ceramic composite materials for use in high temperature reactors has been undertaken in the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME), Boiler and Pressure Vessel (B&PV) Code, Section III (Nuclear), Division 5 (High Temperature Reactors), Working Group on Graphite and Composite Design (WG-GCD). The status of the ceramic composite design rules development in the WG-GCD during FY-201D is briefly summarized in this report.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Understanding Creep Mechanisms in Graphite with Experiments, Multiscale Simulations, and Modeling

Disordering mechanisms in graphite have a long history with conflicting viewpoints. Using Raman and x-ray photon spectroscopy, electron microscopy, x-ray diffraction experiments and atomistic modeling and simulations, the current project has developed a fundamental understanding of early-to-late state radiation damage mechanisms in nuclear reactor grade graphite (NBG-18 and PCEA). We show that the topological defects in graphite play an important role under neutron and ion irradiation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

AGC-1 Specimen Post Irradiation Data Report

Here we report the results of the Post Irradiation Examination (PIE) of the creep, control, and piggyback specimens from the irradiation creep capsule AGC-1. This is the first (prototype) of a series of six capsules planned as part of the Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment to fully characterize the neutron irradiation effects and radiation creep behavior of current nuclear graphites. The data reported include: specimen dimensions and hence the dimensional change upon irradiation (a comparison of these data for specimen matched pairs will yield the creep strain); mass and volume, hence density; elastic constants (Young’s modulus, shear modulus and Poisson’s ratio) from ultrasonic time of flight (TOF) and velocity measurements; Young’s modulus from the fundamental frequency of vibration; electrical resistivity; and thermal expansion from 100-550°C (hence coefficient of thermal expansion). Over 8500 individual physical measurement have been made and the data are reduced and reported here. The AGC-1 capsule was irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at INL at approximately 700°C and to a peak dose of 7 dpa (displacements per atom). The specimen’s final dose, temperature and stress conditions have been reported by INL and are also tabulated here. Additionally the analysis of the SiC temperature monitors is reported. These temperature monitors were located along the center of the AGC-1 capsule and provide an independent assessment of the capsules final irradiation temperature. While all the PIE testing is reported (with the exception of the glued-end tensile strength specimens) additional analysis of the AGC data will be required to allow: 1. Improved fits to the existing models of graphite irradiation induced creep strain. 2. With the eventual advent of temperature dependency data from the additional AGC series of capsules, and microstructural data from piggy back specimens in AGC capsules, the development of new and improved models for the development of irradiation induced creep strain in graphite are anticipated. 3. An Investigation into the effects of creep strain on the physical properties of irradiated graphite.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗