Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Burns, Joseph R.

Publications and source records attributed to Burns, Joseph R..

SCALE 6.2.4 Validation: Reactor Physics

This report is the third volume in a report series documenting the validation of SCALE 6.2.4, which is used herein with ENDF/B-VII.1 libraries, for nuclear criticality safety, reactor physics, and radiation shielding applications. This report focuses on validating SCALE capabilities that affect reactor physics applications. The experimental data used as basis for validation consists of measurement data for nuclide inventory, decay heat, and full-core experiments and include the following: 1. radiochemical assay measurements of 40 nuclides of importance to burnup credit, decay heat, and radiation shielding in 169 light-water reactor (LWR) spent nuclear fuel samples that cover burnups up to 70 GWd/MTU and initial enrichments up to 4.9% 235 U; 2. full-assembly decay heat measurements for 236 LWR assemblies with: a. initial fuel enrichments up to 4% 235 U, b. assembly burnups of 5–51 GWd/MTU, and c. cooling times after discharge in the 2- to 27-year range (of importance to spent nuclear fuel storage, transportation, and disposal); and 3. pulse fission irradiations for fissionable materials at cooling times of interest to severe accident analyses (<10 5 s). Validation examples for full-core analysis are based on startup experiments for the Watts Bar Nuclear Unit 1 (WBN1) pressurized water reactor (PWR) and two high-temperature gas-cooled reactor (HTGR) benchmarks for the HTR-10 pebble bed and the prismatic HTTR reactor.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

SCALE 6.2.4 Validation for Light Water Reactor Decay Heat Analysis

Energy release from the decay of radionuclides in nuclear fuel after its discharge from reactor is a critical parameter for design, safety, and licensing analyses of used nuclear fuel storage, transportation, and repository systems. Well-validated computational tools and nuclear data are essential for decay heat prediction. This paper summarizes the validation of the SCALE nuclear analysis code system version 6.2.4, used with ENDF/B-VII.1 libraries, for decay heat analysis of light water reactor used fuel. The experimental data used for validation include full-assembly decay heat measurements that cover assembly burnups of 5 to 51 GWd/tonne U, cooling times after discharge in the 2- to 27-year range, and initial fuel enrichments up to 4 wt% 235U. The comparison between calculated (C) and experimental (E) decay heat showed very good agreement, with an average C/E over all considered measurements of 1.006 (σ = 0.016) for pressurized water reactor and 0.984 (σ = 0.077) for boiling water reactor assembly measurements. The effect of using assembly-average versus axially varying modeling data on the calculated decay heat, important to thermal analyses for used fuel transportation and storage systems, is discussed.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

HFIR SiC Bowing Test Ready to Insert

This report describes the successful assembly of a High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) irradiation experiment designed to assess radiation-induced lateral bowing of silicon carbide fiber–reinforced, silicon carbide matrix composite (SiC/SiC) components under a radial fast neutron flux gradient. Excessive bowing of a SiC/SiC channel box in a boiling water reactor could potentially interfere with control blade movements. Similar concerns exist for SiC/SiC fuel cladding in light water reactors. The experiment described herein will provide experimental validation of the structural response of a miniature SiC/SiC channel box and tube specimens with pressurized water reactor diameters during irradiation. The significant radial fast neutron flux gradients that exist in the permanent reflector of HFIR were characterized using detailed three-dimensional neutronic calculations. The three-dimensional displacement damage dose rate profile and the resulting volumetric swelling in SiC were used as inputs to structural analyses that predicted the deformation and stresses in the channel box specimen. The specimens were thoroughly characterized prior to irradiation using traditional dimensional inspection and surface profilometry so that these measurements can later be compared with similar measurements that will be made post-irradiation to determine radiation-induced deformations. Furthermore, fine engraving markers were inscribed along all outer surfaces of the specimen and mapped using a digital microscope and a three-dimensional stage. This technique allowed for accurate measurements of the marker spacings, which can be compared with similar measurements that will be made post-irradiation to provide local radiation-induced strain mapping. The experiment was successfully assembled and is scheduled for insertion during HFIR cycle 492, which is currently scheduled to run from May 25, 2021 to June 18, 2021.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Postirradiation examination from separate effects irradiation testing of uranium nitride kernels and coated particles

An overview of postirradiation examination results for uranium nitride kernels and uranium nitride coated particles irradiated in the High Flux Isotope Reactor are presented. This is the first postirradiation examination of the MiniFuel irradiation vehicle that was recently developed to rapidly accumulate burnup during separate effects irradiation testing. In general, the burnup and fuel temperatures measured postirradiation were consistent with the design calculations. The burnup measured by mass spectrometry ranged from 5.9 to 10 MWd/kgU and was achieved after only 68 effective full-power days of irradiation. The dilatometric evaluation of passive silicon carbide thermometry indicated that the fuel was irradiated at temperatures ranging from 410 to 460 °C. Because the irradiation temperatures and burnup were low, the UN kernels showed minimal fission gas release that was within the range of the expected recoil (athermal) release. While it is possible to measure fuel swelling using x-ray computed tomography, the observed swelling was too small to quantify in this case. Extensive microstructural characterization of the irradiated fuel was performed in this study, and no significant irradiation induced changes were observed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Summary of the Postirradiation Examination of the First Samples from a MiniFuel Irradiation

An overview of postirradiation examination results for uranium nitride kernels and uranium nitride coated particles irradiated in the High Flux Isotope Reactor are presented. This is the first postirradiation examination of the MiniFuel irradiation vehicle that was recently developed to rapidly screen different nuclear fuel concepts. Observations on fission gas release, irradiation conditions and microstructure of the irradiated fuel show good fuel performance at the low burnup achieved in this initial irradiation. The burnup measured by mass spectrometry ranged from 5.9 to 10 MWd/kgU as was achieved after only 68 effective full power days of irradiation. Results from silicon carbide thermometry measurements further benchmarked the MiniFuel irradiation vehicle and indicated fuel was irradiated at temperatures ranging from 410-460°C. Extensive microstructural characterization on the irradiated fuel was performed and no significant irradiation induced changes were observed.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Assembly and Delivery of Capsules for Irradiation of Absorber Material Specimens in the High Flux Isotope Reactor

This report provides a summary of the thermal analysis, test matrix, and assembly of two capsules containing absorber material specimens. Four different absorber materials are inserted in the same capsule: hafnium carbide, hafnium carbide with a molybdenum silicide additive, samarium hafnate, and europium hafnate. The two capsules are planned for irradiation in the flux trap of the High Flux Isotope Reactor at two different neutron fluence levels and with a target specimen temperature of 300°C. In addition, this report shows the pre-characterization performed on the absorber material specimens. The goal of this experiment is to investigate the neutron irradiation effects on the absorber materials and characterize irradiation-induced swelling.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Separate effects irradiation testing of miniature fuel specimens

We report that qualification of new nuclear fuels is necessary for their deployment and requires a thorough understanding of fuel behavior under irradiation. Traditionally, nuclear fuels have been qualified by performing exhaustive integral tests under a limited range of prototypic conditions designed for their specific reactor application. While some integral fuel testing is essential, basic data on behavior and property evolution under irradiation can be obtained from separate effects tests. These irradiations could offer reduced cost, reduced complexity, and in the case of accelerated testing, reduced time to achieve a given burnup. Furthermore, it may be desirable to design test irradiations capable of deconvoluting the myriad effects of burnup, temperature gradients, and other factors inherent to integral irradiation tests. Oak Ridge National Laboratory has developed an experimental capability to perform separate effects irradiation testing of miniature fuel specimens in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR): the “MiniFuel” irradiation vehicle. The small size (<4 mm 3 ) of the fuel specimens simplifies the design, analysis, and post-irradiation examination. By reducing the fuel mass, the total heat generated inside the experiment vehicle can be dominated by gamma heating in the structural materials instead of fission heating in the fuel. This essentially decouples the fuel temperature from the fission rate, allowing for highly accelerated testing (3X-18X the burnup rate of a typical light water reactor for 235 U enrichments varying from 0.22 wt% to 8 wt%) and an extremely flexible experiment design that can accommodate a wide range of fuel temperatures (~100 °C to >1200 °C), compositions, enrichments, and even geometries without requiring detailed analyses for each fuel variant. In conclusion, this paper summarizes the experiment design concept, evaluates potential applications for specific fuel forms, and briefly describes the first set of experiments on uranium nitride kernels that have been assembled and are currently being irradiated in the HFIR.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Design and Thermal Analysis for Irradiation of Absorber Material Specimens in the High Flux Isotope Reactor

This report provides a summary of the irradiation vehicle design and thermal analysis of absorber material specimens planned for irradiation in the flux trap of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). Four different absorber materials will be inserted in the same capsule: hafnium carbide without additive (HfC), hafnium carbide with molybdenum silicide additive (HfC + MoSi 2 ), samarium hafnate (Sm 2 HfO 5 ), and europium hafnate (Eu 2 HfO 5 ). The capsule design,with target temperatures of 300°C,will accommodate twelve specimens. Two capsules are planned to be built and irradiated to two different neutron fluence levels.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Irradiation Testing of a SiC/SiC Channel Box in the High Flux Isotope Reactor

This report provides a summary of the experiment design and the neutronics and structural analyses of a miniature SiC/SiC channel box that will be irradiated in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). The goal of this experiment is to evaluate the lateral bowing in the channel box during irradiation under a radial neutron flux gradient. The concern is that lateral bowing could potentially block coolant flow or interfere with control blade movements in boiling water reactors (BWRs). The experiments described in this work will help validate thermomechanical models of channel box bowing. The experiment design allows for one channel box specimen to be irradiated in the HFIR while being directly cooled by the reactor coolant. Monte Carlo neutronics analyses are performed to determine the three-dimensional profile of the dose rate in the channel box. Dose is then converted to volumetric swelling, using literature data, and the resulting swelling profile is used as an input to structural finite element calculations that predict lateral bowing.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Irradiation of Miniature Fuel Specimens in the High Flux Isotope Reactor

The Advanced Fuels Campaign (AFC) within the US Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Nuclear Energy is considering several advanced ceramic fuels for use in light water reactors (LWRs) and/or advanced reactor concepts. Advanced fuels, such as uranium carbide (UC), uranium nitride (UN), and uranium silicide (U 3 Si 2 ) offer increased uranium density and enhanced thermophysical properties compared to conventional UO 2 fuel, while maintaining an acceptably high melting point. Enhancements to traditional UO 2 are also being considered that would increase the thermal conductivity of the fuel and fission product retention through various additives. However, some of these advanced fuels have very limited information available on their irradiation performance (microstructural evolution, swelling, fission gas release, etc.), particularly for the range of temperature and burnup that are relevant for LWR fuel pins. To address this issue, Oak Ridge National Laboratory has developed an experimental facility to irradiate miniature fuel specimens in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). The small size of the fuel specimens simplifies the design, analysis, and post-irradiation evaluations. Post-irradiation examination will provide basic data on the stability and behavior of advanced fuels as a function of temperature and burnup. This report briefly summarizes the experiment facility design concept and the assembly of the first set of experiments. The experiment contains six different types of UN-based fuel kernels UN TRISO particles with varying densities, impurity levels, and burnable absorber contents. The experiments were successfully assembled, welded, evaluated, and delivered to the HFIR along with a complete quality assurance fabrication package. Pictures of the assembly process are included in this report. The experiment is planned for insertion into the HFIR during cycle 480 (June 2018).

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Young's modulus evaluation of high burnup structure in UO 2 with nanometer resolution

The mechanical properties of a well-characterized irradiated light water reactor fuel pin with an average burnup of 72 MWd/kgU were investigated by utilizing nano-indentation technique. Young's modulus and hardness are reported as functions of radial positions covering from mid radial position in the urania pellet to high burnup structure, fuel-cladding chemical interaction zone and zirconium-based cladding. Here, by probing microstructure of the high burnup zone, the mechanical properties of sub-grains and the interaction between them were examined at the nanometer scale. Force-displacement curves from each of these individual sub-grains suggest they resemble single crystal UO 2 . However, these restructured grains are weakly bonded to their neighbors.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Reactor physics phenomena in additively manufactured control elements for the High Flux Isotope Reactor

Additive manufacturing is under investigation as a novel method of fabricating the control elements (CEs) of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory with greater simplicity, eliminating numerous highly complex fabrication steps and thereby offering potential for significant savings in cost, time, and effort. This process yields a unique CE design with lumped absorbers, a departure from traditionally manufactured CEs with uniformly distributed absorbing material. Here, this study undertakes a neutronics analysis of the impact of additively manufactured CEs on the HFIR core physics, seeking preliminary assessment of the feasibility of their practical use. The results of the MCNP transport simulations reveal changes in the HFIR reactor physics arising from geometric and nuclear effects. Absorber lumping in the discrete CEs yields a large volume of unpoisoned material that is not present in the homogeneous design, in turn yielding increases in free thermal flux in the CE absorbing regions and their immediate vicinity. The availability of additional free thermal neutrons in the core yields an increase in fission rate density in the fuel closest to the CEs and a corresponding increase in neutron multiplication on the order of 100 pcm. The absorption behavior exhibited by the discrete CEs is markedly different from the homogeneous CEs due to several competing effects. Self-shielding arising from absorber lumping acts to reduce the effective absorption cross section of the discrete CEs, but this effect is offset by geometric and spectral effects. The operational performance of the discrete CEs is found to be comparable to the homogeneous CEs, with only limited deficiencies in reactivity worth that are expected to be operationally recoverable via limited adjustment of the CE positions and withdrawal rate. On the whole, these results indicate that the discrete CEs perform reasonably similarly to the homogeneous CEs and appear feasible for application in HFIR. In conclusion, the physical phenomena identified in this study provide valuable background for follow-up design studies.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Evaluation of the First Generation Dual-purpose Coatings for SiC Cladding

The loss of coolant and station blackout at the Fukushima Daichi nuclear power station highlighted the need to improve the safety margins of current and future Light Water Reactors (LWRs). Accident Tolerant Fuel (ATF) development is designed to find solutions to mitigate or prevent such events through improvement of fuels and fuel cladding. One promising ATF concept is the replacement of zirconium-based alloy cladding with silicon carbide (SiC) fiber-reinforced SiC matrix (SiCf-SiC) composites, due to the inherent accident resistant features of SiC. However, during normal operations, SiC corrodes in reactor coolant potentially at an unacceptable rate. In addition, it is likely for the SiC-based cladding to undergo microcracking under an applied stress, which potentially degrades the hermeticity.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Examination of Hybrid Metal Coatings for Mitigation of Fission Product Release and Corrosion Protection of LWR SiC/SiC

There is a need to increase the safety margins of current and future light water reactors (LWRs) due to the unfortunate events at Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Plant. Safety is crucial to restore public confidence in nuclear energy, acknowledged as an economical, high-­density energy solution to climate change. The development of accident-­tolerant fuel (ATF) concepts is crucial to this endeavor. The objective of ATF is to delay the consequences of accident progression, being inset in high temperature steam and maintaining high thermomechanical strength for radionuclide retention. The use of advanced SiCf-­SiC composite as a substitute for zircaloy-­based cladding is being considered. However, at normal operations, SiC is vulnerable to the reactor coolant and may corrode at an unacceptable rate. As a ceramic-­matrix composite material, it is likely to undergo microcracking operation, which may compromise the ability to contain gaseous fission products. A proposed solution to both issues is the application of mitigation coatings for use in normal operations. At Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), three coating technologies have been investigated with industry collaborators and vendors. These are electrochemical deposition, cathodic arc physical vapor deposition (PVD hereafter) and vacuum plasma spray (VPS). The objective of this document is to summarize these processing technologies, the resultant as-­processed microstructures and properties of the coatings. In all processes, substrate constraint resulted in substantial tensile stresses within the coating layer. Each technology must mitigate this tensile stress. Electrochemical coatings use chromium as the coolant facing material, and are deposited on a nickel or carbon “bond coat”. This is economical but suffers microcracking in the chromium layer. PVD-­based coatings use chromium and titanium in both metallic form and nitrides, and can be deposited defense-­in-­depth as multilayers. This vapor method eliminated tensile stress during processing and coatings were up to ~30 μm thick without microcracking. VPS produced coatings based on Zircaloy-2, which has a proven reactor-­compatibility. The tensile stresses appearred to be partially mitigated by annealing. Analysis showed that VPS coatings required further optimizations to prevent adverse reactions with the substrate and need a minimum thickness of ~50 μm. In addition, development of coatings are constrained by neutronic depletion analysis, which clearly indicated enrichment as an issue if the coating is too thick. Based on the present work, the cathodic arc PVD technology was considered ready for the extensive testing and evaluation on cladding materials due to their ability to mitigate the excessive tensile stresses and the reasonable coating quality achieved. The VPS Zircaloy-­2 coating technology required additional development toward mitigation of issues related to the substrate reaction and porosity. In the future, PVD and VPS will have be scaled upon successful development and demonstration. Electrochemical coatings, which are proven scalability, currently require development to mitigate issues related to the tensile stress after deposition.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗