Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Clark, Aurora E

Publications and source records attributed to Clark, Aurora E.

Sensitivity of the Properties of Ruthenium “Blue Dimer” to Method, Basis Set, and Continuum Model

The ruthenium “blue dimer” [(bpy)2RuIIIOH2]2O4+ is best known as the first well-defined molecular catalyst for water oxidation. It has been subject to numerous computational studies primarily employing density functional theory. However, those studies have been limited in the functionals, basis sets, and continuum models employed. The controversy in the calculated electronic structure and the reaction energetics of this catalyst highlights the necessity of benchmark calculations that explore the role of density functionals, basis sets, and continuum models upon the essential features of blue-dimer reactivity. In this paper, we report Kohn-Sham complete basis set (KS-CBS) limit extrapolations of the electronic structure of “blue dimer” using GGA (BPW91 and BP86), hybrid-GGA (B3LYP), and meta-GGA (M06-L) density functionals. The dependence of solvation free energy corrections on the different cavity types (UFF, UA0, UAHF, UAKS, Bondi, and Pauling) within polarizable and conductor-like polarizable continuum model has also been investigated. The most common basis sets of double-zeta quality are shown to yield results close to the KS-CBS limit; however, large variations are observed in the reaction energetics as a function of density functional and continuum cavity model employed.

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗

Coupled-cluster, Möller Plesset (MP2), Density Fitted Local MP2, and Density Functional Theory Examination of the Energetic and Structural Features of Hydrophobic Solvation: Water and Pentane

The interaction potentials between immiscible polar and non-polar solvents are a major driving force behind the formation of liquid:liquid interfaces. In this work, the interaction energy of water–pentane dimer has been determined using coupled-cluster theory with single double (triple) excitations [CCSD(T)], 2nd order Möller Plesset perturbation theory (MP2), density fitted local MP2 (DF-LMP2), as well as density functional theory using a wide variety of density functionals and several different basis sets. The M05-2X exchange correlation functionals exhibit excellent agreement with CCSD(T) and DF-LMP2 after taking into account basis set superposition error. The gas phase water–pentane interaction energy is found to be quite sensitive to the specific pentane isomer (2,2- dimethylpropane vs. n-pentane) and relative orientation of the monomeric constituents. Subsequent solution phase cluster calculations of 2,2-dimethylpropane and n-pentane solvated by water indicate a positive free energy of solvation that is in good agreement with available experimental data. Structural parameters are quite sensitive to the density functional employed and reflect differences in the two-body interaction energy calculated by each method. In contrast, cluster calculations of pentane solvation of H2O solute are found to be inadequate for describing the organic solvent, likely due to limitations associated with the functionals employed (B3LYP, BHandH, and M05-2X).

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗

“Covalent Hydration” Reactions in Model Monomeric Ru 2,2'-Bipyridine Complexes: Thermodynamic Favorability as a Function of Metal Oxidation and Overall Spin States

Density functional theory (DFT) has been used to investigate the plausibility of water addition to the simple mononuclear ruthenium complexes, [(NH{sub 3}){sub 3}(bpy)Ru=O]{sup 2+}/{sup 3+} and [(NH{sub 3}){sub 3}(bpy)RuOH]{sup 3+}, in which the OH fragment adds to the 2,2{prime}-bipyridine (bpy) ligand. Activation of bpy toward water addition has frequently been postulated within the literature, although there exists little definitive experimental evidence for this type of 'covalent hydration'. In this study, we examine the energetic dependence of the reaction upon metal oxidation state, overall spin state of the complex, as well as selectivity for various positions on the bipyridine ring. The thermodynamic favorability is found to be highly dependent upon all three parameters, with free energies of reaction that span favorable and unfavorable regimes. Aqueous addition to [(NH{sub 3}){sub 3}(bpy)Ru=O]{sup 3+} was found to be highly favorable for the S = 1/2 state, while reduction of the formal oxidation state on the metal center makes the reaction highly unfavorable. Examination of both facial and meridional isomers reveals that when bipyridine occupies the position trans to the ruthenyl oxo atom, reactivity toward OH addition decreases and the site preferences are altered. The electronic structure and spectroscopic signatures (EPR parameters and simulated spectra) have been determined to aid in recognition of 'covalent hydration' in experimental systems. EPR parameters are found to uniquely characterize the position of the OH addition to the bpy as well as the overall spin state of the system.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

ForceFit: a code to fit classical force fields to ab-initio potential energy surfaces

The ForceFit program package has been developed for fitting classical force field parameters based upon a force matching algorithm to quantum mechanical gradients of configurations that span the potential energy surface of the system. The program, which runs under Unix and is written in C++, is an easy to use, nonproprietary platform that enables gradient fitting of a wide variety of functional force field forms to quantum mechanical information obtained from an array of common electronic structure codes. All aspects of the fitting process are run from a graphical user interface, from the parsing of quantum mechanical data, assembling of a potential energy surface database, setting the force field and variables to be optimized, choosing a molecular mechanics code for comparison to the reference data, and finally, the initiation of a least squares minimization algorithm. Furthermore, the code is based on a modular templated code design that enables the facile addition of new functionality to the program.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

Structural and Dielectric Properties of Quartz-Water Interfaces

The structure, orientation, and dielectric of water at the quartz|water interface has been examined under different hydration levels using classical molecular dynamics. The properties of 1H₂O/10 Ų, 2H₂O/10 Ų, 4H₂O/10 Ų, and bulk water on quartz have been benchmarked against experimental data. Structurally, the simulations match existing sum-frequency spectroscopy data, which indicate the existence and orientation of both frozen and loosely bound water on the quartz surface. Good agreement has also been found with existing experimental dielectric data for the 1H₂O/10 Ų level of hydration, and a clear difference has been found in the values of εs = 48, ε| = 48, and ε⊥ = 40 for the first slice of a bulk-water-solid interface and εs= 30, ε| = 30, and ε⊥ = 10 for that of 1H₂O/10 Ų water coverage. Overall there is a fundamental difference in shielding between a single interface and the 1H₂O/10 Å2 level of hydration.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermodynamic and Structural Features of Aqueous Ce(III)

With a single f-electron, Ce(III) is the simplest test case for benchmarking the thermodynamic and structural properties of hydrated Ln(III) against varying density functionals and reaction field models, in addition to determining the importance of multiconfigurational character in their wave functions. Here, the electronic structure of Ce(H₂O)x(H₂O)y 3+ (x =8, 9; y= 0, 12-14) has been examined using DFT and CASSCF calculations. The latter confirmed that the wave function of octa- and nona-aqua Ce(III) is well-described by a single configuration. Benchmarking was performed for density functionals, reaction field cavity types, and solvation reactions against the experimental free energy of hydration, ΔGhyd(Ce3+). The UA0, UAKS, Pauling, and UFF polarized continuum model cavities displayed different performance, depending on whether one or two hydration shells were examined, and as a function of the size of the metal basis set. These results were essentially independent of the density functional employed. Using these benchmarks, the free energy for water exchange between CN = 8 and CN = 9, for which no experimental data are available, was estimated to be approximately -4 kcal/mol.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Density Functional and Basis Set Dependence of Hydrated Ln(III) Properties

Benchmark studies of Ln(H₂O)₁‚₈₋₉³⁺ (Ln ) La, Lu) have been performed to assess the calculated properties obtained with local density approximation, generalized gradient approximation (GGA), meta-GGA, and hybrid functionals, when used with small- and largecore relativistic effective core potentials and their associated bases. Basis set dependence and the importance of specific functions to adequately describe the Ln atomic orbitals have been determined. The lanthanide contraction has been found to be an insufficient metric for characterizing the quality of a method/basis set combination due to cancellation of the errors. The electrostatic description obtained by natural population analysis has been examined, and an alternative partitioning of the valence space, which includes the 6s6p5d4f natural atomic orbitals, has been proposed.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗