Engineering topics

Colby, Sean M.

Publications and source records attributed to Colby, Sean M..

5 records

DOE OSTI2024

Reviews and syntheses: Opportunities for robust use of peak intensities from high-resolution mass spectrometry in organic matter studies

Abstract. Earth's biogeochemical cycles are intimately tied to the biotic and abiotic processing of organic matter (OM). Spatial and temporal variations in OM chemistry are often studied using direct infusion, high-resolution Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS). An increasingly common approach is to use ecological metrics (e.g., within-sample diversity) to summarize high-dimensional FTMS data, notably Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS). However, problems can arise when FTMS peak-intensity data are used in a way that is analogous to abundances in ecological analyses (e.g., species abundance distributions). Using peak-intensity data in this way requires the assumption that intensities act as direct proxies for concentrations. Here, we show that comparisons of the same peak across samples (within-peak) may carry information regarding variations in relative concentration, but comparing different peaks (between-peak) within or between samples does not. We further developed a simulation model to study the quantitative implications of using peak intensities to compute ecological metrics (e.g., intensity-weighted mean properties and diversity) that rely on information about both within-peak and between-peak shifts in relative abundance. We found that, despite analytical limitations in linking concentration to intensity, ecological metrics often perform well in terms of providing robust qualitative inferences and sometimes quantitatively accurate estimates of diversity and mean molecular characteristics. We conclude with recommendations for the robust use of peak intensities for natural organic matter studies. A primary recommendation is the use and extension of the simulation model to provide objective guidance on the degree to which conceptual and quantitative inferences can be made for a given analysis of a given dataset. Broad use of this approach can help ensure rigorous scientific outcomes from the use of FTMS peak intensities in environmental applications.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

DOE OSTI2024

Introducing Molecular Hypernetworks for Discovery in Multidimensional Metabolomics Data

Orthogonal separations of data from high-resolution mass spectrometry can provide insight into sample composition and address challenges of complete annotation of molecules in untargeted metabolomics. “Molecular networks” (MNs), as used in the Global Natural Products Social Molecular Networking platform, are a prominent strategy for exploring and visualizing molecular relationships and improving annotation. MNs are mathematical graphs showing the relationships between measured multidimensional data features. MNs also show promise for using network science algorithms to automatically identify targets for annotation candidates and to dereplicate features associated with a single molecular identity. Here, this paper introduces “molecular hypernetworks” (MHNs) as more complex MN models able to natively represent multiway relationships among observations. Compared to MNs, MHNs can more parsimoniously represent the inherent complexity present among groups of observations, initially supporting improved exploratory data analysis and visualization. MHNs also promise to increase confidence in annotation propagation, for both human and analytical processing. We first illustrate MHNs with simple examples, and build them from liquid chromatography- and ion mobility spectrometry-separated MS data. We then describe a method to construct MHNs directly from existing MNs as their “clique reconstructions”, demonstrating their utility by comparing examples of previously published graph-based MNs to their respective MHNs.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2024

Statistically-driven Experimental Design to Improve Reference-free Quantification of Small Molecules by Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry

Non-targeted analysis of small molecules and metabolites in unknown, complex samples using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry remains challenging. One of the main bottlenecks is the extensive unannotated regions of metabolomics mass spectrometry data, resulting in knowledge gaps. Small molecule annotation in mass spectrometry data has conventionally relied on reference standards and libraries for compound identification and confirmation, which can constrain compound identification to those molecules already known, thus limiting the ability to discover new knowledge and new markers. Retention time prediction can facilitate and expedite unknown compound identification in non-targeted analysis of complex metabolomics samples. Additionally, accurate retention time predictions can also inform sample mixture design for LC-MS/MS analyses. However, current machine learning-based methods for retention time prediction are typically developed for specific chromatographic platforms and are not generalizable across scales. And while technologies and methods to improve reference-free metabolite identification for more comprehensive annotation of unknowns has received much attention, development of the same for quantitation without reference standards has been much more limited, despite its importance in toxicological, environmental, food safety, forensics, and clinical applications. We believe that a reference-free quantitation strategy that exploits mass spectrometry data already collected for reference-free identification can provide much more insight on unknowns, and move the metabolomics field for more complete unknowns characterization. As such, we pursue two efforts to improve upon current state-of-the-art methods in non-targeted analysis: (1) machine learning-based retention time prediction and (2) statistical design of experiments framework for reference-free quantitation. In this work, we develop and demonstrate (1) a generalizable retention time prediction capability across chromatographic conditions and scales, and (2) a statistical design-based framework for response factor contribution elucidation and reference-free quantitation. Evaluation of our retention time prediction model, PrediToR, showed approximately 24% improvement over current models, and we observed approximately 10X improvement in concentration estimation accuracy from our statistical design-based response factor model over a primarily ionization efficiency-based model. We expect that future efforts to improve upon these new capabilities will further advance non-targeted analysis of small molecules towards truly reference-free metabolomics.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2024

Molecular Vision - Multimodal, multitask retrieval of molecular structure from measured signatures for reference-free compound identification

We are currently at risk of generating false conclusions based on limited methods to identify small molecules in biological systems and in chemical forensics. By definition, the chemical structures of novel small molecules have not been determined, let alone measured or synthesized. Currently, unambiguous structure determination of small molecules is constrained by the time and effort needed to isolate compounds and perform de novo structure elucidation using laboratory-based methods, significantly extending the time to inform mitigation strategies. To address this gap, we have developed a deep learning approach to directly map molecular structure to experimental signatures. We aim to unify measurement technologies employed in untargeted small molecule identification studies—such as infrared (IR) spectrometry, tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS), ion mobility spectrometry-derived collision cross section (CCS)—through use of a multimodal, multitask deep learning architecture. Where existing methods require direct generation of information-rich spectra and/or properties, an inherently difficult task, we will simplify molecular signature-based identification by posing the problem as a recognition or retrieval task. The model is thus presented with relevant endpoints – structure and one or more molecular signatures – and need only determine whether they are semantically related. Thus, our approach offers the following advantages over existing techniques: (i) circumvents difficulties associated with direct generation of molecular signatures from structure and structure from signatures; (ii) incorporates multiple molecular signatures simultaneously, as available, to support identification; and (iii) enables rapid computation of structural embeddings toward broad coverage of known chemical space. Taken together, the approach removes the need to explicitly obtain or compute reference spectra, representing a powerful method for compound identification that requires only experimentally observed signatures.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2024

Aryl hydrocarbon receptor-dependent toxicity by retene requires metabolic competence

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are a class of organic compounds frequently detected in the environment with widely varying toxicities. Many PAHs activate the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR), inducing the expression of a battery of genes, including xenobiotic metabolizing enzymes like cytochrome P450s (CYPs); however, not all PAHs act via this mechanism. We screened several parent and substituted PAHs in in vitro AHR activation assays to classify their unique activity. Retene (1-methyl-7-isopropylphenanthrene) displays Ahr2-dependent teratogenicity in zebrafish, but did not activate human AHR or zebrafish Ahr2, suggesting a retene metabolite activates Ahr2 in zebrafish to induce developmental toxicity. To investigate the role of metabolism in retene toxicity, studies were performed to determine the functional role of cyp1a, cyp1b1, and the microbiome in retene toxicity, identify the zebrafish window of susceptibility, and measure retene uptake, loss, and metabolite formation in vivo. Cyp1a-null fish were generated using CRISPR-Cas9. Cyp1a-null fish showed increased sensitivity to retene toxicity, whereas Cyp1b1-null fish were less susceptible, and microbiome elimination had no significant effect. Zebrafish required exposure to retene between 24 and 48 hours post fertilization (hpf) to exhibit toxicity. After static exposure, retene concentrations in zebrafish embryos increased until 24 hpf, peaked between 24 and 36 hpf, and decreased rapidly thereafter. We detected retene metabolites at 36 and 48 hpf, indicating metabolic onset preceding toxicity. This study highlights the value of combining molecular and systems biology approaches with mechanistic and predictive toxicology to interrogate the role of biotransformation in AHR-dependent toxicity.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗