Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Cole, James I.

Publications and source records attributed to Cole, James I..

Design of Mini-Plate-1 Irradiation Test for Qualification of High-Density, Low-Enriched U-10Mo Monolithic Fuel

The United States High Performance Research Reactor project is tasked with fuel development and qualification leading to conversion of higher power research and test reactors in the US from high-enriched uranium (HEU) to low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuels. Here, this manuscript identifies the functional and operational design requirements of the first miniature test plate (mini-plate [MP]) irradiation campaign (MP-1) of commercially fabricated LEU U-10Mo monolithic plate-type fuel and is the precursor to a large parametric mini-plate test (MP-2) aimed at producing the data to support regulatory qualification of the LEU U-10Mo monolithic fuel. The manuscript (1) provides a general description of the selected U-10Mo LEU fuel and (2) defines the overall experiment design and functional requirements to accomplish the specific test objective of MP-1, which is to confirm that the commercially manufactured LEU U-10Mo monolithic fuel meets the established requirements of geometric stability, mechanical integrity and stable and predictable behavior. The fuel testing parameters are established by the need to bound performance behavior within the operational envelope of the reactors being converted.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Mechanical Properties of Irradiated U-10 wt. %Mo Alloy Degraded by Porosity Development

In this study, a plate-type nuclear fuel consisting of a solid monolithic foil of U-10 wt. %Mo is under development for use in the United States' high-performance research reactors. In support of developing this fuel, the fuel has been fabricated for the first time by a commercial fuel vendor and subsequently irradiated in a test reactor. This provides an opportunity to evaluate postirradiation mechanical properties of the commercially fabricated fuel. Four-point bend testing was conducted on the irradiated U-10Mo samples to generate the fuel material properties, including the modulus of elasticity and the bending strength. Although the material behaves in a brittle manner due to the accumulated porosity, a general trend of strength and modulus reduction was found as fission density increases. The data produced was evaluated using both Weibull statistics and a modulus degradation model with recommendations provided.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Effect of heat treatment on the microstructure of medium burn-up U-Mo monolithic fuel foils

Using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), this study evaluates the microstructure evolution of U-Mo fuel foils made with and without heat treatment at medium burn-up (of approximately 5 x 10 21 f/cm 3 ). The impact of annealing treatments on critical microstructural properties of the U-Mo fuel foils, including porosity, grain structure, Mo homogeneity, and fuel interaction with the Zr interlayer, was examined using large area lift outs (LALOs). The heat-treated specimens presented less grain refining at these burnups when compared to the un-heated specimens. Grain refinement was associated with porosities and fission products precipitation. Heat treatment can reduce fuel swelling during irradiation. Chemical inhomogeneity (Mo banding) was found to persist in the un-heated samples but was not present in the heat-treated samples. Thus, heat-treated U-Mo foils allows for more predictable fuel behavior under irradiation with respect to un-heated foils. The U-Mo and Zr interaction layer appears to be thicker and more continuous in the heat-treated sample which has been associated with stronger interface integrity during irradiation, as also observed in previous studies. These observations may indicate an overall improved performance of heat-treated fuel foil in a reactor. Further, the effect of local burn-up on grain size/refinement and porosities in each LALO specimen, sampled from different positions in the fuel foil, was difficult to analyze due to the large standard deviation of these parameters. Finally, evidence of grain refinement by polygonization may be present in these specimens.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Micro X-ray computed tomography examination of mini plate fuel with hot isostatic pressed aluminum cladding

In order to minimize proliferation risks and improve security of nuclear material, the United States high performance research and test reactors (USHPRR) program is tasked with converting nuclear reactors that are fueled with highly enriched uranium (HEU) fuels to operate with low-enriched uranium (LEU) nuclear fuels. One favorable LEU fuel configuration is plate fuel with a metallic uranium-molybdenum foil clad within an aluminum alloy (AA 6061). In this fuel, the aluminum cladding is bonded with a hot isostatic pressing (HIP) method to seal the cladding around the fuel meat. However, the HIP process parameters influence the cladding performance, as a defective or incomplete bond can cause a pathway for corrosion. Micro X-ray computed tomography (XCT), a nondestructive technique that provides volumetric imaging, can be applied to inspect fuel plate cladding at the engineering scale. In this work, XCT methodology was developed and successfully utilized to not only observe the bond line of unirradiated mini fuel plates, but to also identify subsurface abnormalities in the plates’ cladding. Importantly, in future work, this technique could be applied to fuel plates, pre- and post-irradiation, to quantify irradiation effects on cladding defects and bond line integrity.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Tensile behavior of diffusion bonded AA6061 - AA6061 with variation in cooling method

Hot isostatically pressed AA6061 cladding is an important structural component of the high performance, Zr-laminated U-10Mo monolithic fuel system for the application in research and test reactors. In this study, the mechanical behavior of two diffusion bonded aluminum alloy, AA6061, was examined using tensile testing. Solid-to-solid diffusion bonding between two pieces of AA6061 was performed by isothermal annealing at 560 °C for 1.5 h, and diffusion couples were subsequently cooled via three different cooling methods: furnace cooling, air cooling, and water quenching. Dog-bone shaped tensile specimens, with 10 mm in gauge length (with diffusion bonded interface in the middle), and 1.5 × 1.5 mm 2 gauge cross-sections, were fabricated from the diffusion bonded AA6061 by electro-discharge machining. Yield strength (% EL at failure) of furnace cooled, air cooled and water quenched tensile specimens determined was 82 ~ 89 MPa (10 ~ 30%), 112 ~ 116 MPa (10 ~ 14%), and 149 ~ 164 MPa (10 ~ 17%), respectively. This variation in mechanical behavior was examined with cooling-rate dependent, concentrated precipitation of Mg 2 Si at the diffusion bonded interface, with due respect for mechanical properties of the AA6061 alloy that inherently vary as a function of cooling rate from 560 °C. Finite element analysis using ABAQUS was employed to augment experimental findings with the appropriate microstructural constituents and alloy properties. Results suggest that the strength is dominated by matrix/bulk properties of AA6061, while ductility is strongly influenced by the cooling method dependent presence of Mg 2 Si precipitates at the interface.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Annealing influence on the microstructure of irradiated U-Mo monolithic fuel foils

In this study we compared the microstructure evolution of U-Mo fuel foils produced with and without heat treatment at low burn-up via advanced post-irradiation examination. The aim of this study is to observe after irradiation the ways in which the fabrication processes have influenced fuel behavior at early-stage irradiation, as for very low burn up microstructural studies are lacking. In this work it was observed that the larger grain size detected in the heat-treated samples before irradiation led to decreased grain refinement after irradiation. Grain refinement was associated with the presence of small nano-size bubbles and precipitates. This phenomenon is hypothesized to influence early fuel swelling during reactor irradiation. Grain refinement was also observed to increase in regions where γ-U decomposition was present. Thus, it was enhanced in the samples fabricated without heat treatment. The heat treatment also increased the thickness of the U-Mo/Zr interface, namely of the UZr 2 layer. However, the influence of this layer on fuel performance needs further investigation. On one side, it may contribute to better mechanical bonding; on the other, it may influence swelling and blistering in the interaction layer as porosity increases when this layer is increased. This was observed especially in the presence of increased area containing low Mo concentration, and thus containing a higher fraction of the α-U phase, which is highly susceptible to irradiation induced swelling. Strong evidence of reverse transformation under irradiation (α-U + γ'-U2Mo → bcc γ-U) was observed in these samples. While the precipitates (carbides and oxide) seem to be unaffected by the irradiation at these low burnups. However, further analyses are necessary at higher burn-up to assess the exact impact different heat treatments have on fuel performance.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

A Plan to Qualify New Fuel for the High Flux Isotope Reactor for Material Minimization

The High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) is one of five high power research reactors the Office of Material Management and Minimization (M3) Program, Office of Conversion is working to convert from using highly enriched uranium (HEU) fuel to using low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel. This effort stems from the primary objective within the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) to achieve permanent threat reduction by minimizing, and when possible, eliminating weapon-usable nuclear material around the world. Under M3’s Office of Conversion, the U.S. High Performance Research Reactor (USHPRR) Project is pursuing fuel qualification and licensing of the high-performance reactors to operate with LEU fuels. All high-performance reactors except HFIR will be converted to LEU monolithic uranium-molybdenum alloy fuel. HFIR will be evaluated for conversion to LEU using a uranium silicide fuel, namely, U3Si2-Al dispersion fuel.The mission of the USHPRR Project is to develop the technology needed to reduce, and eventually eliminate, worldwide use of HEU in civilian applications. The goal is to develop the technical means needed to use low enriched uranium (LEU) instead of HEU fuel in research and test reactors without significant penalties in performance, economics, or safety of the reactors. The USHPRR Project has four major elements, called Pillars: Fuel Qualification (FQ) managed at Idaho National Laboratory (INL), Fuel Fabrication (FF) managed at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), Reactor Conversion (RC) managed at Argonne National Laboratory (Argonne), and Cross-Cutting (CC) managed at Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL). FQ is responsible for the qualification of the fuel type. RC is responsible for supporting reactor conversion analysis and overseeing licensing submittals leading to conversions of domestic reactors to LEU fuel. For the FQ effort, FQ (INL) worked in collaboration with RC (Argonne) and ORNL to develop the plan for the uranium silicide fuel qualification for HFIR.The resulting HFIR Fuel Qualification Plan provides the general approach for the USHPRR team to move the selected uranium silicide fuel design for HFIR conversion through qualification. Authorization and use in HFIR will be approved through the DOE’s Office of Science. Uranium silicide fuel was previously qualified in NUREG-1313 at an approximate maximum heat flux of 1.4 MW/m2 and a maximum fuel section temperature of about 130°C. In addition to the different regulator process utilized by DOE, these upper limits will be exceeded in HFIR; therefore, further testing will be necessary to ensure the fuel can meet HFIR qualification requirements. The HFIR fuel loading may exceed 4.8 gU/cm3 which was determined in the NUREG-1313 safety evaluation to be acceptable for use in non-power NRC-regulated reactors provided there exist no other safety considerations. In addition, the uranium silicide fuel will need to be qualified in a HFIR-specific design. This plan includes the currently available information from the USHPRR Project Functions and Requirements document and expands these requirements to ensure that planned tests have traceable results providing evidence that the requirements have been met. Data collection methods are discussed as well as the process to show that the requirements have been met. This document is designed to provide a pathway for researchers to obtain data necessary and at the appropriate quality level for HFIR fuel qualification.

Shokes, Tamara↗

Impacts of annealing treatment on the microstructure of U-Mo monolithic fuel plates

The objective of this paper is to analyze the effect of different heat treatments on the fuel microstructure and texture in laboratory scale monolithic U-Mo fuel plates. Such analyses are relevant as they could possibly inform future fabrication methods for the optimization of microstructure and of material properties to ultimately improve fuel performance during irradiation. For this reason, detail characterization including Energy x-ray dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) and electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) techniques were applied on U-Mo plates fabricated with different heat treatments to understand the influence of fabrication on fuel microstructure. Here, U-Mo fresh fuel specimens with or without annealing treatments (homogenization and stress release annealing) after rolling were analyzed in this work. In this study for the first time EBSD was systematically used to analyze the heat treatments influence on texture present in fresh fuel monolithic U-Mo fuel plates. Such changes were connected to other known microstructural and chemical changes. In this work minimization of molybdenum concentration variation and gamma phase decomposition of the U-Mo fuel core after homogenization was observed. Also, an increase in the interaction layer of the U-Mo fuel core with the Zr interlayer diffusion barrier was observed with the UZr 2 growing up to 1 µm in thickness. Such microstructural changes were aligned to the changes in texture and grain structure. Indeed, common texture observed in body-centered cubic (BCC) metal after cold rolling (e.g., α, ξ, γ fibers) were minimized by the annealing/homogenization process. Moreover, grain structure was influenced by the fabrication route with elongated grains formed in the rolled sample and equiaxed grains found after annealing. Such features are relevant since the formation of microstructural features formed during fuel fabrication can impact fuel performance in reactor.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Mechanical and Thermophysical properties of low enriched uranium-10wt% molybdenum rolled foils

In this study, low-enriched (~19.75% 235 U) U-10Mo(wt%) foils were evaluated for both mechanical and thermophysical properties to establish baseline characteristics prior to irradiation testing. Cast U-10Mo ingots were sequentially hot and cold rolled to two different final foil thicknesses, resulting in different levels of cold work being present in the finished foils. The mechanical response of the U-10Mo foils was evaluated in the temperature range of 293–623 K. Increasing test temperatures resulted in decreases of both yield and ultimate tensile strength. Comparison of results to earlier work performed on depleted U-10Mo rolled foils indicates that the material in this study has lower strength and increased ductility. However, a comparison of the two different foil thicknesses in this study found that they were nearly identical in yield and ultimate tensile strength, differing by only 10–20 MPa (<2%). Thermal conductivity was calculated from the measurements of specific heat, linear thermal expansion, and thermal diffusivity from 323 to 1273 K on both thicknesses of the foils. These data were approximately 5–10% lower than previously published data above 573 K and were similar to data for temperature ranges below 573 K. Differences are likely related to differences in grain size and/or impurity content and variation in fabrication history.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Micro-tensile testing of the bond line in hot isostatic pressed aluminum

Considerable effort is being devoted to development and regulatory qualification of low enriched fuels for research and test reactors by many agencies worldwide. One promising fuel configuration being examined for United States higher power research and test reactors (USHPRRs) are plate-type fuels composed of a metallic uranium-molybdenum foil clad in an aluminum alloy. The two pieces of aluminum alloy cladding are bonded using a hot isostatic pressing method. The mechanical properties of the resulting bond line in the aluminum alloy cladding will vary by the HIP'ing parameters, requiring a need to characterize the bond line. Small scale mechanical testing can provide a path for evaluating the mechanical properties and deformation behavior of the bond line both prior to and following irradiation. Here, in this research, room temperature micro-tensile specimens of non-irradiated and irradiated samples containing an Al alloy (AA 6061) bond line were tested to evaluate its strength and deformation behavior. Observations indicated that the strain rate did not affect the deformation behavior or strength and most of the micro-tensile specimens failed in a ductile mode in grains around the bond line. There was no indication that the microstructural features from the bond line affected the mechanical properties of the micro-tensile specimens. An initial examination was performed on irradiated material but further systematic studies of the effects of irradiation can be performed in the future.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Microstructural-Level Fuel Performance Modeling of U-Mo Monolithic Fuel

As the physics that governs the microstructural evolution of nuclear fuel span various time and spatial scales, to fully understand the fuel behavior inevitably involves atomic to mesoscale resolution that can be difficult to determine experimentally. Microstructural-level modeling and simulations can be used to develop physics-based materials models that can provide physical understanding to inform fabrication process control, as well as a valuable feedback mechanism between post-irradiation examination (PIE) results and fabrication parameters. In accordance with the program schedule, the primary goals of the microstructure modeling effort are to: 1. Address critical microstructural questions and provide practical guidance to the fabricator via the fuel product specification; 2. Provide mechanistic inputs for the existing fuel performance code to improve its descriptive and predictive capability at the macroscopic scale. In fiscal year (FY)-21, the work scope consisted of six main facets: (1) the effect of carbides on fuel performance; (2) gas diffusivity in different phases; (3) integration of microstructural fuel performance modeling; (4) property degradation; (5) irradiation creep; and (6) historical analysis of microstructure data. Brief summaries of each are included below.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗