Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Dagenhart, J. Ray

Publications and source records attributed to Dagenhart, J. Ray.

Crossflow Stability and Transition Experiments in Swept-Wing Flow

An experimental examination of crossflow instability and transition on a 45deg swept wing was conducted in the Arizona State University Unsteady Wind Tunnel. The stationary-vortex pattern and transition location are visualized by using both sublimating chemical and liquid-crystal coatings. Extensive hot-wire measurements were obtained at several measurement stations across a single vortex track. The mean and travelling wave disturbances were measured simultaneously. Stationary crossflow disturbance profiles were determined by subtracting either a reference or a span-averaged velocity profile from the mean velocity data. Mean, stationary crossflow, and traveling wave velocity data were presented as local boundary layer profiles and contour plots across a single stationary crossflow vortex track. Disturbance mode profiles and growth rates were determined. The experimental data are compared with predictions from linear stability theory.

Dagenhart, J. Ray↗

The development of crossflow vortices on a 45 degree swept wing

Three-dimensional boundary-layer experiments are currently being conducted on a 45 deg swept wing in the Arizona State University Unsteady Wind Tunnel. Crossflow-dominated transition is produced via a model with contoured end liners to simulate infinite swept-wing flow. Fixed-wavelength stationary and traveling crossflow vortex are observed. The stationary vortex wavelengths vary with Reynolds number as predicted by linear-stability theory, but with observed wavelengths which are about 25 percent smaller than theoretically predicted. The frequencies of the most-amplified moving waves are in agreement with linear-stability theory; traveling waves at higher frequencies than predicted are also observed. These higher-frequency waves may be harmonics of the primary crossflow waves generated by a parametric resonance phenomena. Boundary-layer profiles measured at several spanwise locations show streamwise disturbance profiles characteristic of the crossflow instability. Near the transition location, severe distortions of the laminar boundary-layer profiles are observed. Mean-profile measurements are compared to theoretical predictions.

Mousseux, Marc C.↗

Crossflow-vortex instability and transition on a 45 deg swept wing

A crossflow vortex experiment on a 45 deg swept wing is currently being conducted in the Arizona State University Unsteady Wind Tunnel. The experimental apparatus is designed to produce crossflow-dominated transition by simulating infinite swept wing flow using contoured end liners in a closed throat wind tunnel. Stationary fixed-wavelength crossflow vortices are observed at several chord Reynolds numbers. The vortex wavelength which is fixed for a given Reynolds number varies with Reynolds number approximately as predicted by linear stability theory, but with the predicted wavelengths about 30 percent larger than the observed wavelengths. Travelling waves are observed both in the frequency range predicted by linear stability theory and at higher frequencies. These higher frequency waves may be harmonics of the primary crossflow waves generated by a nonlinear parametric resonance phenomena.

Dagenhart, J. Ray↗

Goertler instability on an airfoil: Comparison of marching solution with experimental observations

Theoretical predictions based on the marching technique are compared with experimental observations on an airfoil with a concave region. Theoretical predictions of the wavelength of the most amplified Goertler vortex are in excellent agreement with the experimental observation for the range of chord Reynolds numbers from 1.0 to 3.67 million. In the convex zone, solutions from the marching technique showed that the initial counter-rotating vortex pairs lift off the surface and dissipate while another layer of vortex pairs of opposite rotation develops near the surface. This confirms the experimentally observed double peaked streamwise velocity perturbations. Furthermore, the streamwise velocity perturbations which dominate spanwise variation in the surface shear stress distribution shift by half a wavelength in the convex region. The experimental flow visualization photographs clearly confirm this phenomena.

Kalburgi, Vijay↗

Experiments in swept-wing transition

Stability and transition experiments are conducted on a 45 degree sweep airfoil in the ASU Unsteady Wind Tunnel. Combined flow-visualization techniques and hot-wire measurements are used in conjuction with stability-code calculations to map out transition behavior for this flow geometry. Both steady and unsteady crossflow vortices are observed and at this time there is no contradiction with the theoretical predictions.

Saric, William S.↗

A comparative study of theoretical methods on Goertler instability

Goertler vortices arise in boundary layers along concave surfaces due to centrifugal effects and these vortices in combination with Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) waves and crossflow vortices may play an important role in triggering early transition. There have been two distinct theoretical approaches to solve the problem. In the classical, normal-mode approach (NMA) the linear development of Goertler vortices is reduced to an eigenvalue problem. In the other method, initiated by Hall, the governing partial differential equations for the perturbations which are parabolic in the streamwise direction, are solved as an initial value problem. This method predicts multiple neutral curves depending on how and where the mean flow is perturbed, unlike the NMA where a unique but different neutral curve is predicted by each investigator. The present paper attempts to compare the two techniques and shows that mutually compatible results can be obtained when physically consistent assumptions are made.

Kalburgi, Vijay↗

Goertler instability on an airfoil

An effective computational scheme was developed to study the growth/damping of Goertler vortices along walls of variable curvature. Computational experiments indicate that when the amplification rates for the u-, v-, and w-perturbations are the same, the finite difference approach to solve the initial value problem and the normal mode approach give identical results for the Blasius boundary layer on constant curvature concave walls. The growth of Goertler vortices was rapid in the concave regions and was followed by sharp damping in the convex region. However, multiple sets of counter-rotating vortices were formed and remained far downstream in the convex region. The current computational scheme can be easily extended to more realistic problems including variable pressure gradients and suction effects.

Kalburgi, Vijay↗

Predicted and hot-film measured Tollmien-Schlichting wave characteristics

The Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) instability is a time-dependence instability which can lead to transition of laminar boundary layers on airfoils. A comparison of theoretical predictions and experimental observations of the TS instability on the NLF(1)-0414F airfoil designed by Viken and Pfenninger. The theoretical predictions were obtained using the SALLY stability code. Test results, from the same hot films that were used to detect transition, revealed that TS waves could be detected by the hot films if the hot-film signal was adequately modified.

Stack, John P.↗

Experimental studies on Goertler vortices

Goertler vortices arise in laminar boundary layers along concave walls due to an imbalance between pressure and centrifugal forces. In advanced laminar-flow control (LFC) supercritical airfoil designs, boundary-layer suction is primarily used to control Tollmien-Schlichting instability and cross-flow vortices in the concave region near the leading edge of the airfoil lower surface. The concave region itself is comprised of a number of linear segments positioned to limit the total growth of Goertler vortices. Such an approach is based on physical reasonings but rigorous theoretical justification or experimental evidence to support such an approach does not exist. An experimental project was initiated at NASA Langley to verify this concept. In the first phase of the project an experiment was conducted on an airfoil whose concave region has a continuous curvature distribution. Some results of this experiment were previously reported and significant features are summarized.

Mangalam, Siva M.↗

Boundary-layer stability analysis of Langley Research Center 8-foot LFC experimental data

An analytical study of linear-amplifying instabilities of a laminar boundary layer as found in the experimental data of the LaRC/8-foot laminar-flow control (LFC) experiment was completed and the results are presented. The LFC airfoil used for this experiment was a swept, supercritical design which removed suction air through spanwise slots. The amplification of small disturbances by linear processes on a swept surface such as this can be due to either Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) and/or crossflow (CF) mechanisms. This study consists of the examination of these two instabilities by both the commonly used incompressible (SALLY and MARIA) analysis and the more involved compressible (COSAL) analysis. A wide range of experimental test conditions with variations in Mach number, Reynolds number, and suction distributions were available for this study. Experimentally determined transition locations were found from thin-film techniques and were used to correlate the n-factors at transition for the range of test cases.

Berry, Scott↗

Boundary-layer stability analysis of NLF and LFC experimental data at subsonic and transonic speeds

NASA-Lewis has conducted wind tunnel experiments to ascertain the effectiveness of state-of-the-art in natural laminar flow (NLF) and LFC airfoils for subsonic and transonic speeds, such as the NLF(1)-0414F and the SCLFC(1)-0513F. Attention is given to the effects of Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) and/or crossflow linear mechanisms amplifying small disturbances to generate turbulence. It is found that the incompressible TS transitional n-factors were generally in the 9-12 range, in agreement with earlier correlation studies; the TS instability was the dominant instability mode on a swept-planform LFC airfoil over the entire range of test conditions.

Berry, Scott A.↗

Two experimental supercritical laminar-flow-control swept-wing airfoils

Two supercritical laminar-flow-control airfoils were designed for a large-chord swept-wing experiment in the Langley 8-Foot Transonic Pressure Tunnel where suction was provided through most of the model surface for boundary-layer control. The first airfoil was derived from an existing full-chord laminar airfoil by extending the trailing edge and making changes in the two lower-surface concave regions. The second airfoil differed from the first one in that it was designed for testing without suction in the forward concave region of the lower surface. Differences between the first airfoil and the one from which it was derived as well as between the first and second airfoils are discussed. Airfoil coordinates and predicted pressure distributions for the design normal Mach number of 0.755 and section lift coefficient of 0.55 are given for the three airfoils.

Allison, Dennis O.↗