Engineering topics
Dagle, Robert A.
Publications and source records attributed to Dagle, Robert A..
Production of 1,3-Butadiene from Renewable Feedstocks Ethanol and 1,3-Butanediol - CRADA 560 (Final Report)
1,3-butadiene is a commodity chemical currently produced from petroleum sources. Producing 1,3-butadiene from renewable resources will contribute to decarbonization, provide new green jobs, and reduce our dependance on oil. Development of multifunctional catalysts that are active, selective, and stable for this reaction has been an area of research and development. This effort reported here builds on our prior work for the 1-step conversion of ethanol to butadiene. The goal of the additional scope performed here was to accelerate the commercial deployment of sustainable butadiene production. We demonstrated that the PNNL Ag-based catalyst is significantly more active than the WWII-era catalyst when operated under the same conditions. A butadiene selectivity of 68% was obtained at 64% conversion for the production of butadiene from ethanol. It was found that ethanol feedstock is preferred over 1,3-butanediol feedstock to produce butadiene due to higher yield resulting in lower butadiene selling price (i.e., $\$$0.4-1.7/ lb). Production of 3.0 Liter of butadiene solution in hexane containing 100 grams of butadiene was achieved and delivered to Bridgestone for producing a butadiene-derived test piece.
Reactive direct air capture of CO 2 to C–C coupled products using multifunctional materials
A single sorbent-catalytic (non-noble metal) material has been developed for the integrated direct air capture and catalytic conversion of captured CO 2 into C-C coupled products.
Microchannel reactive distillation for the conversion of aqueous ethanol to ethylene
Here we demonstrate the proof-of-concept for microchannel reactive distillation for alcohol-to-jet application: combining ethanol/water separation and ethanol dehydration in one unit operation. Ethanol is first distilled into the vapor phase, converted to ethylene and water, and then the water co-product is condensed to shift the reaction equilibrium. Process intensification is achieved through rapid mass transfer—ethanol stripping from thin wicks using novel microchannel architectures—leading to lower residence time and improved separation efficiency. Energy savings are realized with integration of unit operations. For example, heat of condensing water can offset vaporizing ethanol. Furthermore, the dehydration reaction equilibrium shifts towards completion by immediate removal of the water byproduct upon formation while maintaining aqueous feedstock in the condensed phase. For aqueous ethanol feedstock (40% w ), 71% ethanol conversion with 91% selectivity to ethylene was demonstrated at 220 °C, 600 psig, and 0.28 h -1 wt hour space velocity. 2.7 stages of separation were also demonstrated, under these conditions, using a device length of 8.3 cm. This provides a height equivalent of a theoretical plate (HETP), a measure of separation efficiency, of ~3.3 cm. By comparison, conventional distillation packing provides an HETP of ~30 cm. Thus, 9.1× reduction in HETP was demonstrated over conventional technology, providing a means for significant energy savings and an example of process intensification. Finally, preliminary process economic analysis indicates that by using microchannel reactive distillation technology, the operating and capital costs for the ethanol separation and dehydration portion of an envisioned alcohol-to-jet process could be reduced by at least 35% and 55%, respectively, relative to the incumbent technology, provided future improvements to microchannel reactive distillation design and operability are made.
Solar thermochemical processing system and method
A solar thermochemical processing system is disclosed. The system includes a first unit operation for receiving concentrated solar energy. Heat from the solar energy is used to drive the first unit operation. The first unit operation also receives a first set of reactants and produces a first set of products. A second unit operation receives the first set of products from the first unit operation and produces a second set of products. A third unit operation receives heat from the second unit operation to produce a portion of the first set of reactants.
Methane Pyrolysis for CO2-free H2 and Carbon Nanomaterials - CRADA 576 (Final Report)
In this CRADA project we continued to develop the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) patent-pending Regenerable Catalytic Pyrolysis (ReCaP) process technology for producing CO 2 -free hydrogen (H 2 ) from inexpensive and domestically-abundant natural gas (NG), while simultaneously reducing H 2 ’s net production cost to $\$$1.0/kg through the sale of valuable crystalline solid carbon co-product. Producing clean hydrogen at this price is a DOE Hydrogen Energy Earthshot goal. This effort builds on our prior catalyst and processing advances made thermocatalytic decomposition of methane (TCD). The additional scope performed here accelerated the commercial deployment of TCD for CO 2 -free H 2 and valuable solid carbon nanotubes (CNT) co-product, by i) scaling up the production of CNT co-product using a fluidized bed reactor (25 g catalyst scale versus the 1 g catalyst scale demonstrated prior), ii) producing approximately 1 kg of CNT byproduct, produced via multiple cycles of TCD, carbon-catalyst separation, and catalyst re-synthesis, to enable the production of sufficient quantities of solid carbon so as to explore its market potential, iii) understanding the quality of the co-product CNTs, produced at larger scale, using advanced characterization, and iv) beginning to explore multiple promising high volume carbon product applications (e.g., aluminum and polymer composites, steel additive, and cement reinforcement applications). We are in discussions with Department of Energy and potential commercial partners to continue funding of this effort with the goal to facilitate eventual commercial deployment.
Toward Rational Design of Nickel Catalysts for Thermocatalytic Decomposition of Methane for Carbon Dioxide-Free Hydrogen and Value-Added Carbon Co-Product: A Review
Thermocatalytic decomposition of methane provides opportunities for hydrogen (H2) production with no emission of carbon dioxide. However, high-value carbon products need to be produced for economic deployment of thermocatalytic decomposition and to achieve a minimum H 2 selling price below the U.S, Department of Energy target of $ 1/kg H 2 . In this review, we re-evaluate data on catalyst development reported in the literature and propose correlations between catalyst characteristics, catalytic stability, and properties of carbon co-products. In the first part of the review, growth mechanisms for carbon nanotubes using state-of-the-art chemical vapor deposition are reviewed to catalog the effects of catalyst characteristics, the influence of carbon sources, interactions between metal particles and supports, and metal particle sizes on carbon growth. In the second part, representative developments in mono-, bi-, and tri-metallic nickel catalysts are highlighted. We present kinetic analysis of reactions catalyzed by mono-metallic nickel catalysts, which generates a correlation between metal particle size and catalyst stability. Rational design of Ni-based catalysts for TCD of methane requires attention to the size of the metal particle and effective normalization of the reaction rates. Further attention to the distribution of the metal particle sizes may help identify catalyst properties that contribute longevity and selectivity to processes that use them. While it is tempting to focus on the highest valued carbon products (e.g., CNTs and CFs), analysis of the markets for other carbon products suggests that a more flexible approach may generate comparable returns without the risk associated with specialization.
Influence of blending cycloalkanes on the energy content, density, and viscosity of Jet-A
Not Available
Systems and methods for preparing butenes
Systems for preparing butenes are provided. The systems can include a reactor inlet coupled to both a reactor and at least one reactant reservoir; at least one of the reactant reservoirs containing one or both of an aldehyde and/or ethanol; a catalyst within the reactor, the catalyst comprising a metal component and an acidic support material; and a reactor outlet operationally configured to convey a butene-rich reaction product to a product reservoir. Methods for preparing butenes are also provided. The methods can include exposing one or both of ethanol and/or an aldehyde to a catalyst comprising a metal component and an acidic support to form a butene-rich product that comprises one or both of 1-butene and/or 2-butene.
Customization for Current Market Applications of the Carbon Nanotubes Produced by PNNL’s Regenerable Catalytic Pyrolysis (ReCaP) for Scaled Hydrogen Production
Here, we demonstrated the Regenerative Catalytic Pyrolysis (ReCaP) process that generates carbon dioxide-free hydrogen (CO 2 -free H 2 ) from inexpensive and domestically abundant natural gas (NG), while simultaneously producing H 2 at net production cost of $1.0/kg through the sale of valuable carbon nanotube (CNT) co-product. The specific goal of this project is to 1) scale up the production of CNT, 2) correlate the properties of the CNT with the reaction conditions, 3) perform a techno-economic analysis to obtain minimum selling price of H 2 and CNT, and 4) identify industrial partners interested in the CNT co-product.
Mechanistic insights to drive catalytic hydrogenation of formamide intermediates to methanol via deaminative hydrogenation
Amine-promoted hydrogenation of CO 2 to methanol typically proceeds via a formamide intermediate when amines are used as additives or if the hydrogenation is performed in carbon capture solvents. The catalysts used for the hydrogenation of the formamide intermediate dictate the selectivity of the products formed: 1) Deoxygenative hydrogenation (C–O bond cleavage) resulting in N-methylation of amine and deactivation of the solvent, 2) Deaminative hydrogenation (C–N bond cleavage) resulting in formation of methanol and regeneration of the solvent. To date, catalytic reductions of CO 2 with amine promoters suffer from poor selectively for methanol which we attribute to the limiting formamide intermediate, though to date, the conditions that favor C–N cleavage have yet to be fully understood. To better understand the reactivity of the formamide intermediates, a range of heterogenous catalysts were used to study the hydrogenation of formamide. Well-known gas phase CO 2 hydrogenation catalysts catalyze the hydrogenation of formamide to N-methyl product via C–O bond cleavage. However, the selectivity can be readily shifted to selective C–N bond cleavage by addition of an additive with sufficient basicity for both homogenous and heterogeneous catalytic systems. The base additive shifts the selectivity by deprotonating a hemiaminal intermediate formed in situ during the formamide hydrogenation. This prevents dehydration process leading to N-methylated product, which is a key capture solvent deactivation pathway that hinders amine use in carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS). The findings from this study provide a roadmap on how to improve the selectivity of known heterogenous catalysts, enabling catalytic reduction of captured CO 2 to methanol.
Direct conversion of syngas to lower olefins precursors of jet fuel and chemicals
This study investigates the direct conversion of syngas to olefins as a pathway to produce sustainable aviation fuels. This approach combines methanol/ dimethyl ether synthesis with methanol-to-olefins into one unit operation to avoid the equilibrium limitation of methanol synthesis and the Anderson–Schulz–Flory distribution limitations from the Fischer Tropsch process. The ability to combine reactor functionalities into a single step are also projected to significantly lower capital costs over current synthesis approaches for the syngas to olefins process.
Promotional role of NiCu alloy in catalytic performance and carbon properties for CO 2 -free H 2 production from thermocatalytic decomposition of methane
The addition of Cu to Ni inhibits catalyst deactivation and changes carbon co-product morphology during the thermocatalytic decomposition of methan.
Solar thermochemical processing system and method
A solar thermochemical processing system is disclosed. The system includes a first unit operation for receiving concentrated solar energy. Heat from the solar energy is used to drive the first unit operation. The first unit operation also receives a first set of reactants and produces a first set of products. A second unit operation receives the first set of products from the first unit operation and produces a second set of products. A third unit operation receives heat from the second unit operation to produce a portion of the first set of reactants.
Production of 1,3-Butadiene from Renewable Oxygenated Feedstocks (Abstract)
Reproduce and ascertain additional experimental catalyst performance data for 1-step conversion of oxygenated feedstocks to butadiene. Experimental data will also be obtained for a 2-step processing configuration where we will tailor the PNNL catalyst originally developed for 1-step processing by tailoring the Lewis acidity and metal properties, with a limited number of experiments. We will measure preliminary catalyst performance results for producing Butadiene from the two oxygenated feedstocks. Additionally, we will produce 30 g of butadiene that will be sent to the client for use in producing polybutadiene. Finally, experimental results will inform techno-economic analysis (TEA) modeling. TEA will focus on identifying the most economically favorable processing route to BD from either oxygenated feedstock. We will also project GHG emissions associated with each of the process models being considered for BD production, and compare such results to GHG emissions when produced from conventional methods (e.g., cracking of naphtha) using values from the literature.
Effect of alkali metal addition on catalytic performance of Ag/ZrO 2 /SBA-16 catalyst for single-step conversion of ethanol to butadiene
Here, we describe how adding Na and K to a 4Ag/4ZrO 2 /SBA-16 catalyst enhances catalytic performance for single-bed conversion of ethanol to butadiene. While adding Na and K leads to a slight decrease in conversion (i.e., ~10% loss), the production of desired butadiene is significantly increased with up to 50% improvement in productivity for the 4Ag/4ZrO 2 /SBA-16 catalyst promoted with 0.5% Na. The reasons for this improvement are a beneficial decrease in Lewis acid site concentration and higher Ag dispersion when Na or K are added, which results in decreased activity involving ethanol dehydration to ethylene and diethyl ether. A remarkable butadiene selectivity of 75% was achieved while maintaining high conversion (i.e., 90%) with 0.5Na/4Ag/4ZrO 2 /SBA-16 catalyst. A 72-hour catalyst lifetime study shows that because of higher coke formation from polymerization of desired butadiene, catalyst deactivation occurs more rapidly with the 0.5Na/4Ag/4ZrO 2 /SBA-16 (55% loss in conversion) than with 4Ag/4ZrO 2 /SBA-16 (45% loss in conversion). However, this does not alter the advantageous effect of Na addition because the butadiene yield remained higher throughout the study period for 0.5Na/4Ag/4ZrO 2 /SBA-16. A key finding is that during the reaction, Na limits sintering of Ag particles and promotes selective coking of the acid sites responsible for ethylene and diethyl ether formation.
Methane Pyrolysis for CO2-free H2 and Carbon Nanomaterials (Abstract)
We propose to continue to develop a new process for producing CO2-free hydrogen (H2) from inexpensive and domestically-abundant natural gas (NG), while simultaneously reducing H2’s net production cost to $1.0/kg through the sale of valuable crystalline solid carbon co-product. Producing clean hydrogen at this price is a DOE Hydrogen Energy Earthshot goal. Cost effective production of clean H2 is also of commercial relevance to project partners Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) and startup company C4-MCP, who aim to further develop, demonstrate at scale, and ultimately deploy the new process technology developed on this project in order to meet regulatory demands in the State of California. In the current project we have focused on i) understanding the catalyst science for thermocatalytic decomposition of methane (TCD), which resulted in the development of a patent pending bimetallic catalyst offering favorable activity, stability, and selectivity under industrially relevant process conditions, ii) developing a novel, patent pending process to enable the separation of produced carbon and catalyst, and re-synthesis of the catalyst using recycled materials, iii) performing limited characterization of the produced carbon materials, and iv) performing detailed process modeling in order to perform techno economic assessment. The additional scope proposed here will accelerate the commercial deployment of TCD for CO2-free H2 and valuable solid carbon nanotubes (CNT) co-product, by i) scaling up the production of CNT co-product using a scalable, fluidized bed reactor (25 g catalyst scale versus the 1 g catalyst scale demonstrated to-date), ii) producing at least 40 g of CNT product, produced via multiple cycles of TCD, carbon-catalyst separation, and catalyst re-synthesis, to enable the production of sufficient quantities of solid carbon so as to explore its market potential, iii) understanding the quality of the co-product CNTs, produced at larger scale, through advanced characterization, and iv) beginning to explore multiple promising high volume carbon product applications (thermoplastics, automotive composites, battery, and cement reinforcement applications).
Integrated Capture and Conversion of CO 2 to Methanol (ICCCM) Process Technology - CRADA 449 (Final Report)
The goal of this project is to develop a prototype system that integrates the capture and catalytic hydrogenation of CO 2 into methanol in the same solvent. Ultimately, this integrated approach could provide a technology with projected reductions to capital and operating costs by at least 20% relative to a benchmark methanol synthesis via gas-phase CO 2 hydrogenation. There were five primary objectives for the project: 1. Optimize the selections of both the catalysts and the CO 2 capture solvents to achieve high conversion (>80%) and high selectivity (>90%) toward methanol in the targeted processing ranges (100-180°C, 1-60 bar). 2. Design a reactor system that provides a fixed catalyst surface area and high-efficiency heat exchange to assure compact modular processing. 3. Build and test a reactor system and demonstrate in a bench scale continuous flow system, and use the operating data to refine the comparison to existing conversion technologies. 4. Refine techno economic (TEA) and Tech-to-Market (TTM) analyses using the experimental data obtained from the bench-scale system. 5. Use the experimental data and TEA/TTM projections to develop a conceptual design for a pre-commercial system that targets a specific market opportunity.