Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Daniel Ingraham

Publications and source records attributed to Daniel Ingraham.

Blade and Trajectory Optimization of a Propeller-Driven Electric Aircraft with Acoustic Constraints

Urban Air Mobility vehicles are intended to operate near or within large cities, where a significant portion of the public will be exposed to the noise they create. If these vehicles are to become acceptable to the public, designers must be able to manage the amount of noise they generate, and understand the relationship between traditional performance metrics (thrust, efficiency, etc.) and noise. New design tools are needed to meet this challenge. As a first step toward providing these tools, a propeller design toolchain that includes aerodynamic performance, acoustics, and trajectory is developed in this work. This toolchain will be exercised on a hypothetical electric-powered general aviation aircraft, inspired by a previous study.

Acoustics↗

Application of Low & Mid Fidelity Tools to the Moog SureFly Vehicle

The results from a comprehensive acoustic analysis using low- and mid-fidelity tools to predict the acoustic signature of the Moog SureFly® UAM vehicle are presented and compared to experimental ground test data taken in 2019. The data presented is taken from a ground plate microphone at a distance of just under 100 feet from the propeller source. Simulations were performed for a single propeller and a coaxial pair. Results indicate that the first few blade passing frequency (BPF) harmonics match the experimental data reasonably well using both low- and mid-fidelity prediction toolchains.

Acoustics↗

Low-Noise Propeller Design with the Vortex Lattice Method: Preliminary Results

The unsteady vortex lattice method (VLM) is a popular approach to mid-fidelity aerodynamic prediction. In this work, an unsteady VLM code is coupled with a form of Farassat’s formulation 1A acoustic analogy and used to design low-noise propellers via gradient-based optimization. Solutions to a few unexpected problems with computing the gradients of the VLM code are discussed, as are preliminary results for an isolated propeller and a propeller-wing interaction case.

Acoustics↗

Low-Noise Propeller Design with the Vortex Lattice Method and Gradient-Based Optimization

This work aims to combine an aerodynamic model based on the unsteady vortex lattice method with an acoustic model provided by Farassat’s formulation 1A to perform gradient-based propeller optimizations with aerodynamic and acoustic constraints. Two optimization cases are attempted and successfully converged: an isolated propeller and a propeller-wing configuration, both operating in a 0.11 Mach freestream, representative of a cruise condition. The results show that simultaneously decreasing the RPM and increasing the collective angle of a propeller is an effective noise reduction technique, as expected, and little difference is observed between the two cases. A vortex dissipation model was found to be needed to stabilize the derivatives of the vortex lattice outputs, and a constraint on the propeller blade’s chord distribution concavity was needed to produce realistic-looking blade chord distributions.

Propellers↗

Towards Gradient-Based Proprotor Design with VSPAERO

Gradient-based optimization techniques are an attractive approach to solving multidisciplinary design problems. In this work, the status of gradient-based proprotor optimizations with the VSPAERO code are described.

Multidisciplinary optimization↗

Towards Low-Noise Design of a Proprotor with the Vortex Lattice Method and Gradient-Based Optimization

This work aims to combine an aerodynamic model based on the unsteady vortex lattice method with an acoustic model provided by Farassat's formulation 1A to perform gradient-based optimizations of a proprotor with aerodynamic and acoustic constraints. The resulting combination of tools is applied to the problem of designing a single proprotor operating at a cruise condition, with and without an acoustic constraint and wing placed downstream of the proprotor rotation plane. Results are compared to a baseline design studied previously, and to similar optimizations performed with a simpler blade element momentum theory aerodynamic model. Each optimization case achieved feasibility and made significant improvements in the objective function, but the optimality criterion was not satisfied. Overall the designs the optimizer found roughly comported with our previous experience with similar problems, with some discrepancies that are discussed.

Aerodynamics↗

Towards Low-Noise Design of a Proprotor with the Vortex Lattice Method and Gradient-Based Optimization

This work aims to combine an aerodynamic model based on the unsteady vortex lattice method with an acoustic model provided by Farassat's formulation 1A to perform gradient-based optimizations of a proprotor with aerodynamic and acoustic constraints. The resulting combination of tools is applied to the problem of designing a single proprotor operating at a cruise condition, with and without an acoustic constraint and wing placed downstream of the proprotor rotation plane. Results are compared to a baseline design studied previously, and to similar optimizations performed with a simpler blade element momentum theory aerodynamic model. Each optimization case achieved feasibility and made significant improvements in the objective function, but the optimality criterion was not satisfied. Overall the designs the optimizer found roughly comported with our previous experience with similar problems, with some discrepancies that are discussed.

Aerodynamics↗

Blade and Takeoff Trajectory Optimization of a Propeller-Driven Electric Aircraft with Acoustic Constraints

In this work, a multi-disciplinary toolchain is described and used to optimize the takeoff trajectory of a electrified general aviation aircraft, subjected to acoustic constraints. The Dymos multi-disciplinary optimal control library is used to optimize the trajectory, with propeller aerodynamic and acoustic models provided by blade element momentum theory (CCBlade.jl) and acoustic analogy (AcousticAnalogies.jl) codes, respectively. Each model is implemented in the OpenMDAO framework, with all derivatives calculated either analytically or via automatic differentiation tools. The toolchain is applied to a hypothetical electrified form of the Cirrus SR20 and compared to the conventional piston-driven form.

Aerodynamics↗

Blade and Takeoff Trajectory Optimization of a Propeller-Driven Electric Aircraft with Acoustic Constraints

In this work, a multi-disciplinary toolchain is described and used to optimize the takeoff trajectory of a electrified general aviation aircraft, subjected to acoustic constraints. The Dymos multi-disciplinary optimal control library is used to optimize the trajectory, with propeller aerodynamic and acoustic models provided by blade element momentum theory (CCBlade.jl) and acoustic analogy (AcousticAnalogies.jl) codes, respectively. Each model is implemented in the OpenMDAO framework, with all derivatives calculated either analytically or via automatic differentiation tools. The toolchain is applied to a hypothetical electrified form of the Cirrus SR20 and compared to the conventional piston-driven form.

gradient-based optimization↗