Engineering topics

Delaye, Jean-Marc

Publications and source records attributed to Delaye, Jean-Marc.

9 records

DOE OSTI2023

On the effect of Al on alumino-borosilicate glass chemical durability

The chemical durability of borosilicate glass used to confine nuclear wastes is known to vary nonlinearly with their composition, making glass dissolution rate predictions difficult. Here, we focus on the effect of Al, an important oxide of these materials. The initial and residual glass dissolution rates were investigated through experiments conducted at 90 °C and pH 9. Our results show that low Al content glasses dissolve initially faster than glasses with higher Al content, but quickly achieve a lower residual rate due to the rapid formation of a more passivating gel. Nevertheless, the high Al content gel will eventually achieve passivation with a slower reorganization. The strengthening effect of Al on the Si-O bond hydrolysis will result in more stable gels, suggesting that slightly higher Al content in the gel will improve nuclear high-level waste glass durability in geological disposal conditions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2022

Behavior of B in passivating gels formed on International Simple Glass in acid and basic pH

International Simple Glass altered for years in silica saturated conditions develops a passivating gel, which retains some mobile elements such as B and Ca in its inner region. It has been suggested that the retention of these elements impacts the dissolution rate of the glass. However, the elements' retention mechanism, speciation, and diffusion properties are still unknown. This study finds that simultaneous presence of B and Ca in the solution can dramatically slow down glass alteration. However, splitting the B and Ca into two different solutions with other glass elements did not give similar protection against glass alteration. These experiments along with other experiments conducted in basic or acid pH, in which isotopically tagged B can diffuse in gels revealed that (i) water diffusion is not dramatically affected by the retention of B and Ca in passivating gels, and (ii) slow diffusion and high retention of B is observed only in gels developed in basic pH during the tracing experiments. Finally, this last mechanism therefore appears as one of the many mechanisms controlling the glass dissolution rate in the residual regime.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2021

Deciphering the non-linear impact of Al on chemical durability of silicate glass

The role of Al in aluminosilicate glasses remains somewhat a mystery: at low concentrations, it increases the resistance to hydrolysis of the glass, whereas at high concentrations an opposite effect is observed. To understand the origin of the phenomenon on a fundamental atomistic scale, we performed 577 MD simulations and applied potential mean force (PMF) calculations to estimate the activation barriers for hydrolysis and to statistically correlate them with local structural features of the glass. Models of pure silicate and aluminosilicate glasses are constructed and investigated. PMF simulation results are further validated by the experimental measurements and revealed that Al is very easy to dissociate, but it also increases the glass chemical durability through significantly increasing both the strength of Si and network connectivity of the glass. In contrast, at high Al concentration, preferential dissolution of Al weakens the silicate network, which it supposes to strengthen, and so the glass resistance becomes poor. Through PMF calculations, we evaluated the activation barriers for dissociating bonds around Al as 0.49 eV, which is less than a half of the energy to dissociate bonds around Si in pure silicate (1.22 eV) and around Si in aluminosilicate glass (1.34 eV), all these energy differences being statistically significant. Molecular structural level investigation revealed that Si with Al as a second neighbor in the glass network has a significantly higher activation energy for dissociation than Si in pure silicate glass. Furthermore, the proposed approach opens the way to the development of quantitative predictive models of glass durability.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2021

Predicting the Dissolution Rate of Borosilicate Glasses using QSPR analysis based on molecular dynamics simulations

Quantitative Structure Property Relationship (QSPR) analysis based on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations is a promising approach for establishing the composition-property relationships of glass and other materials with complex structures. A series of 20 borosilicate and boroaluminosilicate glasses have been modeled by using MD simulations with recently developed effective potentials. Short- and medium-range structures of these glasses were analyzed and, based on these structural information, QSPR analysis of the initial dissolution rate (r0) was made and compared with measured r0 at 90°C and pH 9 using various structural descriptors such as percentage of bridging oxygen species, network connectivity and average ring size. The structural descriptors, Fnet, containing energetic information such as single bond strength and other structural information were also used. It was found that overall network connectivity, average ring size and Fnet give reasonable predictions of the r0 of studied glasses, given the conditions that the glasses are homogeneous and dissolve congruently. Modifying glass compositions to account preferential release of modifiers gives a better prediction for incongruently dissolving glasses. The results were compared with our recent work of predicting glass dissolution behavior from compositions using the topological-constraints-based models.

Du, Jincheng↗

DOE OSTI2020

Insights into the mechanisms controlling the residual corrosion rate of borosilicate glasses

Borosilicate glasses are widely used to confine high-level radioactive wastes. The lifetime of these materials could reach hundreds of thousands of years if leaching of the glass into groundwater enables the formation of a passivating gel layer. Even in this regime, the glass will never stop corroding as thermodynamic equilibrium between glass and solution cannot be achieved. Therefore, accurate predictions of glass durability including passivation, require a deep understanding of the mechanisms controlling the so-called residual rate. However, despite tremendous efforts, these mechanisms remain poorly understood. Here, focusing on the behavior of the soluble elements of the International Simple Glass (B, Na, and Ca), we show that the residual rate is controlled by the behavior of B, a glass former supposed to dissolve instantaneously when in contact with water and thus widely considered as an ideal tracer. We then demonstrate that B release is controlled by multiple processes highly dependent on the pH. At the beginning of the passivating layer formation, the hydrolysis of B-O-Si linkages is rate-limiting and has an activation energy of ~60 kJ mol –1 , a value slightly lower than that for breaking Si-O-Si linkages. Once the fraction of closed pores resulting from gel restructuring is high enough, then diffusion of both reactants (water molecules) and some products (mainly B aq , Ca aq ) through the growing gel layer becomes rate-limiting. Consequently, B and Ca accumulate in an inner layer referred to as the active zone, with potential feedback on the B-O-Si hydrolysis. A new paradigm, including B as a key element of the system, is proposed to develop a comprehensive model for the corrosion of borosilicate glass.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

A classical molecular dynamics simulation method for the formation of “dry” gels from boro-aluminosilicate glass structures

In contact with water, glass transforms into amorphous and porous structures called gels. A simulation method based on classical molecular dynamics is proposed here to mimic “dry” gels forming from initial oxide glass structures. Six glass compositions were investigated. Two behaviours were evidenced depending on the initial glass composition, and in particular on the quantity of elements removed. If a large quantity of soluble elements (B, Na) was removed, it induced an increase in the average pore size within the gels, and the time needed to stabilise the gel structure increased because more local atomic rearrangements occurred. The gel network displayed a higher proportion of Si-Q4 at the expense of Si-Q3 and a lower average ring size compared to the glass network, irrespective of the glass composition. Surface effects were also highlighted in the dry gels, such as the presence of 3-coordinated Al and a decrease in the average angle Si-O-Si and Al-O-Al. Our findings will be compared to both wet gels and experimental data in further studies, to help find the best procedure to simulate such structures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

Effect of decades of corrosion on the microstructure of altered glasses and their radiation stability

Understanding the microstructural evolution of glasses during their interaction with water and radiation is of fundamental importance in addressing the corrosion of nuclear waste forms under geological disposal conditions. Here we report the results of more than 21 years of corrosion of two borosilicate glasses showing the formation of mesoporous C–S–H gels in Ca-bearing glasses and a mainly microporous microstructure in Al-bearing glasses. These porous corroded glasses were then irradiated with heavy ions to simulate the effects of recoil nucleus damage and monitored in real time using transmission electron microscopy with in situ ion irradiation. The ballistic collisions remarkably healed the porous corroded glasses to a pore-free homogeneous microstructure. Besides providing new insights and predictions about how doped glasses and actual waste forms may evolve under corrosion and irradiation, the results highlight the non-universal nature of the existing corrosion models and the important role that the glass composition and radiation damage play in the evolution of the microstructure during corrosion.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

Can a simple topological-constraints-based model predict the initial dissolution rate of borosilicate and aluminosilicate glasses?

Tuning glass composition to obtain targeted properties generally relies on empirical approaches. However, a deep understanding of the physical and chemical mechanisms linking glass composition to its structure and properties would enable developing reliable predictive models. Indeed, although empirical models are usually able to interpolate composition–property relationships within a given compositional envelope, they often fail at extrapolating predictions far from their training domain. Here, as an alternative route to empirical models, we show that a structural descriptor based on the number of topological constraints per atom can be used to predict the initial dissolution rate of aluminosilicate and borosilicate glasses after being parameterized on different families of glasses (specific series of borosilicate glasses). Sixteen glasses belonging to these families were studied and their initial dissolution rates were determined at 90 °C and pH 90 °C = 9, covering rates spanning over 5 orders of magnitude. The model based on topological constraints was trained based on seven select borosilicate glasses (R 2 = 0.997) and used to predict the dissolution rate of nine additional borosilicate and aluminosilicate glasses. We show that, provided that corrections are made for high alkali content glasses that dissolve incongruently (preferential release of Na), the model gives reasonable predictions, even far from its training domain.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

A general mechanism for gel layer formation on borosilicate glass under aqueous corrosion

Mineral and glass dissolution is a scientific topic deeply investigated but incompletely understood and of a great interest for the geochemical and materials science communities. If the interfacial dissolution/reprecipitation mechanism seems to be applicable to most of silicate minerals, the debate remains open concerning glass. Here we studied two model glasses, a ternary borosilicate (CJ1) and the same glass doped with 4.1 mol% of Al2O3 (CJ2). The two glasses were altered at 90°C, pH 9, and in conditions far and close to saturation with respect to amorphous silica, to determine the initial and residual rates. Moreover, a specific experiment was conducted for a short duration with a solution highly enriched with 18O and 29Si isotopes to understand how passivating gels form. SEM, TEM and ToF-SIMS characterization, along with Monte Carlo simulations were used to understand the rate limiting reactions at play and infer the role of Al. We show that Al yields a slower matrix dissolution in dilute conditions. However, it slows down he formation and the maturation of the passivating gel and favors alteration by partial hydrolysis of Si and Al entities followed by in-situ reorganization/relaxation into a porous network. Unexpectedly, CJ1 experienced both interfacial dissolution/reprecipitation and partial hydrolysis followed by in situ reorganization of the silicate network during the course of a single experiment. This study offers a unified concept that can pave the way for the future development of a predictive kinetic model based on a detailed description of bond breaking and bond forming as a function of glass composition and alteration conditions.

Gin, Stephane↗