Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Deshlahra, Prashant

Publications and source records attributed to Deshlahra, Prashant.

Single-Atom Alloy Formation via Reaction-Driven Catalyst Restructuring

We demonstrate that single-atom alloy catalysts can be made by exposing physical mixtures of monometallic supported Cu and Pd catalysts to vinyl acetate (VA) synthesis reaction conditions. This reaction induces the formation of mobile clusters of metal diacetate species that drive extensive metal nanoparticle restructuring, leading to atomic dispersion of the precious metal, smaller nanoparticle sizes than the parent catalysts, and high activity and selectivity for both VA synthesis and ethanol dehydrogenation reactions. As a result, this approach is scalable and appears to be generalizable to other alloy catalysts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Investigating Spillover Energy as a Descriptor for Single-Atom Alloy Catalyst Design

The identification of thermodynamic descriptors of catalytic performance is essential for the rational design of heterogeneous catalysts. Here, we investigate how spillover energy, a descriptor quantifying whether intermediates are more stable at the dopant or host metal sites, can be used to design single-atom alloys (SAAs) for formic acid dehydrogenation. Further, using theoretical calculations, we identify NiCu as a SAA with favorable spillover energy and demonstrate that formate intermediates produced after the initial O–H activation are more stable at Ni sites where rate-determining C–H activation occurs. Surface science experiments demonstrated that NiCu(111) SAAs are more reactive than Cu(111) while they still follow the formate reaction pathway. However, reactor studies of silica-supported NiCu SAA nanoparticles showed only a modest improvement over Cu resulting from surface coverage effects. Overall, this study demonstrates the potential of engineering SAAs using spillover energy as a design parameter and highlights the importance of adsorbate–adsorbate interactions under steady-state operation.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mechanistic Insights into Nonoxidative Ethanol Dehydrogenation on NiCu Single-Atom Alloys

Ethanol dehydrogenation presents a promising pathway towards the production of acetaldehyde, a valuable building block in chemicals production. Under non-oxidative conditions, the reaction is facilitated by supported Cu nanoparticles which afford reasonable activity and high selectivity. The stability issues associated with Cu nanoparticle sintering can be addressed by the addition of small amounts of Ni, which further boost reactivity while retaining selectivity. Despite the promise of NiCu single-atom alloys for non-oxidative ethanol dehydrogenation, little is known about the role of each component and the pathway of this mechanistically complex process. Herein, kinetic investigations from reactor tests identify C-H bond scission as the rate limiting step, while 1-hydroxyethyl is detected as the intermediate via IR spectroscopy. Temperature program desorption studies are employed to examine the effect of Ni coverage and to demonstrate that Ni atoms activate ethanol selectively at lower temperatures, resulting in higher acetaldehyde yield than pure Cu. Temperature program desorption experiments also reveal the spillover of intermediates from the Ni atom to neighboring Cu sites as a relevant step in the reaction pathway. Density functional theory calculations are used to investigate the 2 reaction energetics and to confirm that C-H bond scission is the initial reaction step, while a clear effect of H 2 partial pressure on the reaction pathway is realized. Further, counter to the expected behavior that all reaction steps take place on the Ni atoms, our degree of rate control analysis reveals that a mechanism involving spillover of the 1-hydroxyethyl intermediate from the Ni atom to the Cu surface, where it will dehydrogenate further, is more likely. Furthermore, our combined kinetic, spectroscopic, and theoretical approach sheds light on this complex reaction mechanism and represents a promising method for the understanding and designing of highly active, selective, and stable single-atom alloys for other multistep catalytic processes.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Effects of surface species and homogeneous reactions on rates and selectivity in ethane oxidation on oxide catalysts

Selective alkane oxidations on metal oxide catalysts involve complex mechanisms with multiple reactions in series and parallel, different types of reduced and oxidized surface species, and potential contributions from gas-phase reactions. We report kinetics and thermodynamics of elementary steps involved in C 2 H 6 -O 2 reactions on SiO 2 -supported small vanadium oxide domains are determined using density functional theory. These surface reactions together with gas-phase mechanisms are incorporated in kinetic simulations to determine how surface and gaseous reactions interact and contribute to rates and selectivity. The results show that gas-phase reactions within pore volumes in contact with the catalyst contribute significantly to C 2 H 6 activation rates, even at conditions where gas-phase reactions in empty volumes without catalyst are negligible. The majority of C 2 H 6 activations occur on the surface, via H abstraction by vanadium oxo species present at terminal lattice oxygens. The gas-phase activations via H-abstraction by OH radicals also exhibit significant contributions. The reduced centers formed by reactions at vanadium oxo species are re-oxidized rapidly and, therefore, are present in very small concentrations at reaction conditions. The re-oxidation steps lead to the formation of HO 2 radicals and surface peroxo species that are also rapidly consumed and are present in small concentrations. The peroxo species preferentially convert C 2 H 4 to its epoxide product and influence selectivity even at low concentrations. The gas-phase reactions decrease the concentrations of peroxo species and improve selectivity slightly. The effects of reaction conditions and catalyst site density provide further insights into how factors beyond conversions at lattice oxygens influence rates and selectivity in alkane oxidation reactions of significant industrial importance.

42 ENGINEERING↗

First-principles design of a single-atom–alloy propane dehydrogenation catalyst

The complexity of heterogeneous catalysts means that a priori design of new catalytic materials is difficult, but the well-defined nature of single-atom–alloy catalysts has made it feasible to perform unambiguous theoretical modeling and precise surface science experiments. Herein we report the theory-led discovery of a rhodium-copper (RhCu) single-atom–alloy catalyst for propane dehydrogenation to propene. Although Rh is not generally considered for alkane dehydrogenation, first-principles calculations revealed that Rh atoms disperse in Cu and exhibit low carbon-hydrogen bond activation barriers. Surface science experiments confirmed these predictions, and together these results informed the design of a highly active, selective, and coke-resistant RhCu nanoparticle catalyst that enables low-temperature nonoxidative propane dehydrogenation.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Reactivity descriptors in acid catalysis: acid strength, proton affinity and host–guest interactions

Brønsted acids mediate chemical transformations via proton transfer to bound species and interactions between the conjugate anion and bound cationic intermediates and transition states that are also stabilized by van der Waals forces within voids of molecular dimensions in inorganic hosts. This Feature Article describes the relevant descriptors of reactivity in terms of the properties of acids and molecules that determine their ability to donate and accept protons and to reorganize their respective charges to optimize their interactions at bound states. The deprotonation energy (DPE) of the acids and the protonation energy (Eprot) of the gaseous analogs of bound intermediates and transition states reflect their respective properties as species present at non-interacting distances. These properties accurately describe the reactivity of acids of a given type, such as polyoxometalates (POM) with a given type of addenda atom but different central atoms and heterosilicates, for different families of reactions. They do not fully capture, however, differences among acid types (e.g., Mo and W POM, heterosilicates, mineral acids) for diverse types of chemical transformations (e.g., elimination, isomerization, dimerization, condensation). The incompleteness of such descriptors reflects their inability to describe how protonated molecular species and conjugate anions restructure their respective charges when present as a binding pair at interacting distances. Such interaction energies represent electrostatic forces that depend on charge distributions in the cations and anions and the ability to reorganize the distributions to maximize the interactions. In the case of deprotonation, the electrostatic and charge reorganization components of DPE for various acids solely reflect the ability of the conjugate anion to accept and distribute the negative charge, a characteristic unique of each type of solid acid and specifically of the composition of its extended conjugate anion framework. The energy required to accept and rearrange the positive charge in bound intermediates and transition states reflects, in turn, their respective ability to recover the ionic and covalent components of DPE, the energy required to detach proton from conjugate anions. The DPE components and the recovery fractions together lead to a modified DPE, which captures only the part of DPE that remains unrecovered by the ion-pair interactions at bound intermediates and transition states, as the unifying descriptor for broad families of acids and reactions. The electrostatic and charge reorganization energies involved in these general descriptors are placed in historical context by assessing their connections to the heuristics of hard–soft acid–base displacements. Further development of these concepts requires benchmarking and extension of electrostatic and reorganization components of energies for a more diverse set of reaction types and acid families and advancement of methods for more efficient calculations of electrostatic interactions. Reactivity descriptors must also account for dispersive interactions between host cavities and guest molecules, requiring a framework analogous to the one described here for ion-pair interactions; these dispersive interactions depend on the fit between their shapes and sizes as well as their ‘‘structural stiffness’’ that determines the ability to modify the shapes of molecules and voids to minimize free energy. Entropy considerations and estimates of their dependence on properties of catalysts and molecules are also required for accurately determining Gibbs free energies that ultimately determine reaction rates.

Deshlahra, Prashant↗

Dynamic Restructuring Induced Oxygen Activation on AgCu Near Surface Alloys

Recent studies have shown that the addition of Cu to Ag catalysts improves their epoxidation performance by increasing the overall selectivity of the bimetallic catalyst. We have prepared AgCu near-surface alloys and used scanning tunneling microscopy to gain an atomistic picture of O 2 dissociation on the bimetallic system. These data reveal a higher dissociative sticking probability for O 2 on AgCu than Ag(111), and density functional theory (DFT) confirms that the O 2 dissociation barrier is 0.17 eV lower on the alloy. Surprisingly, we find that after a slow initial uptake of O 2 , the sticking probability increases exponentially. Further DFT calculations indicate that surface oxygen reverses the segregation energy for AgCu, stabilizing Cu atoms in the Ag layer. These single Cu atoms in the Ag surface are found to significantly lower the O 2 dissociation barrier. Altogether, these results explain nonlinear effects in the activation of O 2 on this catalytically relevant surface alloy.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Reactivity and selectivity descriptors of dioxygen activation routes on metal oxides

The activation of dioxygen at typically isolated two-electron reduced centers can lead to the formation of electrophilic superoxo or peroxo species, providing an essential route to form reactive O 2 -derived species in biological, organometallic, and heterogeneous catalysts. Alternatively, O 2 activation can proceed via outer sphere routes, circumventing the formation of bound peroxo (OO*) species during oxidation catalysis by forming H 2 O 2 (g), which can react with another reduced center to form H 2 O. The electronic and binding properties of metal oxides that determine the relative rates of these activation routes are assessed here by systematic theoretical treatments using density functional theory (DFT). These methods are combined with conceptual frameworks based on thermochemical cycles and crossing potential models to assess the most appropriate descriptors for the activation barriers for each route using Keggin polyoxometalates as illustrative examples. In doing so, we show that inner sphere routes, which form OO* species via O 2 activation on the O-vacancies (*) formed in the reduction part of redox cycles, are mediated by early transition states that only weakly sense the oxide binding properties. Outer sphere routes form H 2 O 2 (g) via O 2 activation on OH pairs (H/OH*) formed by dissociation of H 2 O on O-vacancies; their rates and activation barriers reflect the rates of the first H-atom transfer from H/OH* to O 2 . The activation barriers for this H-transfer step depend on the binding energy of more weakly-bound H-atom in H/OH* pairs (HAE 2 ) and on the ˙OOH-surface interaction energy at its product state ($E_{int}$ 0 ). The $E_{int}$ 0 values are similar among oxides unless a large charge-balancing cation is present and interacts with radical ˙OOH; consequently, HAE 2 acts as an appropriate descriptor of the outer sphere dynamics. HAE 2 also determines the thermodynamics of H 2 O dissociation on O-vacancies, which influence the inner and outer sphere rates by setting the relative coverage of * and H/OH*. So these results, in turn, show that HAE 2 is a complete descriptor of the reactivity and selectivity of oxides for O 2 activation; the O-atoms in more reducible oxides (more negative HAE 2 ) exhibit a greater preference for the inner sphere routes and for the formation of electrophilic OO* intermediates that mediate epoxidation and O-insertion reactions during catalytic redox cycles. Large charge-balancing cations locally modify $E_{int}$ 0 values that determine the outer sphere rates and thus can be used to alter the preference of O-atoms to either inner or outer sphere routes.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mechanistic Details and Reactivity Descriptors in Oxidation and Acid Catalysis of Methanol

Acid and redox reaction rates of CH₃OH-O₂ mixtures on polyoxometalate (POM) clusters, together with isotopic, spectroscopic, and theoretical assessments of catalyst properties and reaction pathways, were used to define rigorous descriptors of reactivity and to probe the compositional effects for oxidative dehydrogenation (ODH) and dehydration reactions. ³¹P-MAS NMR, transmission electron microscopy and titrations of protons with di-tert-butylpyridine during catalysis showed that POM clusters retained their Keggin structure upon dispersion on SiO₂ and after use in CH₃OH reactions. The effects of CH₃OH and O₂ pressures and of D-substitution on ODH rates show that C-H activation in molecularly adsorbed CH₃OH is the sole kinetically relevant step and leads to reduced centers as intermediates present at low coverages; their concentrations, measured from UV-vis spectra obtained during catalysis, are consistent with the effects of CH₃OH/O₂ ratios predicted from the elementary steps proposed. First-order ODH rate constants depend strongly on the addenda atoms (Mo vs W) but weakly on the central atom (P vs Si) in POM clusters, because C-H activation steps inject electrons into the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO) of the clusters, which are the d-orbitals at Mo⁶⁺ and W⁶⁺ centers. H-atom addition energies (HAE) at O-atoms in POM clusters represent the relevant theoretical probe of the LUMO energies and of ODH reactivity. The calculated energies of ODH transition states at each O-atom depend linearly on their HAE values with slopes near unity, as predicted for late transition states in which electron transfer and C-H cleavage are essentially complete. HAE values averaged over all accessible O-atoms in POM clusters provide the appropriate reactivity descriptor for oxides whose known structures allow accurate HAE calculations. CH₃OH dehydration proceeds via parallel pathways mediated by late carbenium-ion transition states; effects of composition on dehydration reactivity reflect changes in charge reorganizations and electrostatic forces that stabilize protons at Brønsted acid sites.

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗

Methanol Oxidative Dehydrogenation on Oxide Catalysts: Molecular and Dissociative Routes and Hydrogen Addition Energies as Descriptors of Reactivity

The oxidative dehydrogenation (ODH) of alkanols on oxide catalysts is generally described as involving H-abstraction from alkoxy species formed via O–H dissociation. Kinetic and isotopic data cannot discern between such routes and those involving kinetically-relevant H-abstraction from undissociated alkanols. Here, we combine such experiments with theoretical estimates of activation energies and entropies to show that the latter molecular routes prevail over dissociative routes for methanol reactions on polyoxometalate (POM) clusters at all practical reaction temperatures. The stability of the late transition states that mediate H-abstraction depend predominantly on the stability of the O–H bond formed, making H-addition energies (HAE) accurate and single-valued descriptors of reactivity. Density functional theory-derived activation energies depend linearly on HAE values at each O-atom location on clusters with a range of composition (H3PMo12, H4SiMo12, H3PW12, H4PV1Mo11, and H4PV1W11); both barriers and HAE values reflect the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital energy of metal centers that accept the electron and the protonation energy of O-atoms that accept the proton involved in the H-atom transfer. Bridging O-atoms form O–H bonds that are stronger than those of terminal atoms and therefore exhibit more negative HAE values and higher ODH reactivity on all POM clusters. For each cluster composition, ODH turnover rates reflect the reactivity-averaged HAE of all accessible O-atoms, which can be evaluated for each cluster composition to provide a rigorous and accurate predictor of ODH reactivity for catalysts with known structure. These relations together with oxidation reactivity measurements can then be used to estimate HAE values and to infer plausible structures for catalysts with uncertain active site structures.

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗

Ionic and Covalent Stabilization of Intermediates and Transition States in Catalysis by Solid Acids

Reactivity descriptors describe catalyst properties that determine the stability of kinetically relevant transition states and adsorbed intermediates. Theoretical descriptors, such as deprotonation energies (DPE), rigorously account for Brønsted acid strength for catalytic solids with known structure. Here, mechanistic interpretations of methanol dehydration turnover rates are used to assess how charge reorganization (covalency) and electrostatic interactions determine DPE and how such interactions are recovered when intermediates and transition states interact with the conjugate anion in W and Mo polyoxometalate (POM) clusters and gaseous mineral acids. Turnover rates are lower and kinetically relevant species are less stable on Mo than W POM clusters with similar acid strength, and such species are more stable on mineral acids than that predicted from W-POM DPE–reactivity trends, indicating that DPE and acid strength are essential but incomplete reactivity descriptors. Born–Haber thermochemical cycles indicate that these differences reflect more effective charge reorganization upon deprotonation of Mo than W POM clusters and the much weaker reorganization in mineral acids. Such covalency is disrupted upon deprotonation but cannot be recovered fully upon formation of ion pairs at transition states. Predictive descriptors of reactivity for general classes of acids thus require separate assessments of the covalent and ionic DPE components. Here, we describe methods to estimate electrostatic interactions, which, taken together with energies derived from density functional theory, give the covalent and ionic energy components of protons, intermediates, and transition states. In doing so, we provide a framework to predict the reactive properties of protons for chemical reactions mediated by ion-pair transition states.

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗