Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Diers, James R..
Two annulated bacteriochlorin isomers exhibit profoundly different spectral and photophysical features, which are attributed to the absence or presence of electronic (and vibronic) mixing of x - and y -polarized transitions/states.
Nine dyads composed of bacteriochlorins were prepared to investigate excited-state energy transfer (FRET) processes.
A new pentad array designed to exhibit panchromatic absorption and charge separation has been synthesized and characterized. The array is composed of a triad panchromatic absorber (a bis(perylene-monoimide)-porphyrin) to which are appended an electron acceptor (perylene-diimide) and an electron donor/hole acceptor (bacteriochlorin) in a crossbar arrangement. The motivation for incorporation of the bacteriochlorin versus a free-base or zinc chlorin utilized in prior constructs was to facilitate hole transfer to this terminal unit and thereby achieve a higher yield of charge separation across the array. The intense S 0 → S 1 (Q y ) band of the bacteriochlorin also enhances absorption in the near-infrared spectral region. Due to synthetic constraints, a phenylethyne linker was used to join the bacteriochlorin to the core porphyrin of the panchromatic triad rather than the diphenylethyne linker employed for the prior chlorin-containing pentads. Static and time-resolved photophysical studies reveal enhanced excited-state quenching for the pentad in benzonitrile and dimethyl sulfoxide compared to the prior chlorin-containing analogues. Success was only partial, however, as a long-lived charge separated state was not observed despite the improved energetics for the final ground-state hole/electron-shift reaction. The apparent reason is more facile competing charge-recombination due to the shorter bacteriochlorin – porphyrin linker that increases electronic coupling for this process. Furthermore, the studies highlight design criteria for balancing panchromatic absorption and long-lived charge separation in molecular architectures for solar-energy conversion.
A panchromatic triad and a charge-separation triad are joined in a crossbar architecture to capture solar energy. The panchromatic triad (T) is comprised of a central free-base porphyrin that is strongly coupled via direct ethyne linkages to two perylene-monoimides. Here, the charge-separation unit incorporates a free-base or zinc chlorin (C or ZnC) as a hole acceptor (or electron donor) and a perylene-diimide (PDI) as an electron acceptor, both attached to the porphyrin via diphenylethyne linkers. The free-base porphyrin is common to both light-harvesting and charge-separation motifs. The chlorin and PDI also function as ancillary light absorbers, complementing direct excitation of the panchromatic triad to produce the discrete lowest excited state of the array (T*). Attainment of full charge separation across the pentad entails two steps: (1) an initial excited-state hole/electron transfer process to oxidize the chlorin (and reduce the triad) or reduce the PDI (and oxidize the triad); and (2) subsequent ground-state electron/hole migration to produce oxidized chlorin and reduced PDI. Full charge separation for pentad ZnC-T-PDI to generate ZnC + -T-PDI¯ occurs with a quantum yield of ~30% and mean lifetime ~1 μs in dimethyl sulfoxide. For C-T-PDI, initial charge separation is followed by rapid charge recombination. The molecular designs and studies reported here reveal the challenges of balancing the demands for charge separation (linker length and composition, excited-state energies, redox potentials, and medium polarity) with the constraints for panchromatic absorption (strong electronic coupling of the porphyrin and two perylene-monoimide units) for integrated function in solar-energy conversion.
Here, the impact of vibrational–electronic resonances on the rate of excited-state energy transfer is examined in a set of bacteriochlorin dyads that employ the same phenylethyne linker. The donor/acceptor excited-state energy gap is tuned from ~200 to ~1100 cm –1 using peripheral substituents on the donor and acceptor bacteriochlorin macrocycles. Ultrafast energy transfer is observed with rate constants of (0.3 ps) –1 to (1.7 ps) –1 , which agree with those predicted by Förster theory to within a factor of 2. Furthermore, the measured rates follow a trend-line with only small deviations that do not correlate with the density of vibrations at the donor/acceptor excited-state energy gap. Thus, if vibrational–electronic resonances occur in any of these dyads, which seems likely, the impact on the rate of energy transfer is small.
Electronic interactions between tetrapyrroles are utilized in natural photosynthetic systems to tune the light-harvesting and energy/charge-transfer processes in these assemblies. Such interactions also can be employed to tailor the electronic properties of tetrapyrrolic dyads and larger arrays for use in materials science and biomedical research. Here we have utilized static and time-resolved optical spectroscopy to characterize the optical absorption and emission properties of a set of chlorin and bacteriochlorin dyads with varied degrees of through-bond (TB) and through-space (TS) interactions between the constituent macrocycles. The dyads consist of two chlorins or two bacteriochlorins joined by a linker that utilizes a triple-double-triple bond (enediyne) motif in which the double bond portion is a ester-substituted ethylene or o-phenylene unit. The photophysical studies are coupled with density functional theory (DFT) calculations to probe the ground-state molecular orbital (MO) characteristics of the dyads and time-dependent calculations (TDDFT) to elucidate excited-state properties. The latter include electronic characteristics of the singlet excited state manifold and the absorption transitions to these states from the electronic ground state. Comparison of the MO and calculated spectral properties of each dyad with the linker present versus disrupted (by eliminating the double-bond portion) gives insight into the relative contributions of TB versus TS interactions to the electronic properties of the dyads. The results show that the TB and TS contributions are additive (constructively interfere), which is not always the case for molecular dyads. Most of the dyads have shorter lifetimes of the lowest singlet excited state compared to the parent monomer, which derives from increased S 1 → S 0 internal conversion. The enhancement is greater for the dyads in benzonitrile than in toluene. Furthermore, the studies provide insights into the nature of the electronic interactions between the constituents in the tetrapyrrole arrays and how these interactions dictate the spectral properties and excited-state decay characteristics.
Tetrapyrrole macrocycles serve a multitude of roles in biological systems, including oxygen transport by heme and light harvesting and charge separation by chlorophylls and bacteriochlorophylls. Synthetic tetrapyrroles are utilized in diverse applications ranging from solar-energy conversion to photomedicine. Nevertheless, students beginning tetrapyrrole research, as well as established practitioners, are often puzzled when comparing properties of related tetrapyrroles. Questions arise as to why optical spectra of two tetrapyrroles often shift in wavelength/energy in a direction opposite to that predicted by common chemical intuition based on the size of a π-electron system. Gouterman's four-orbital model provides a framework for understanding these optical properties. Similarly, it can be puzzling as to why the oxidation potentials differ significantly when comparing two related tetrapyrroles, yet the reduction potentials change very little or shift in the opposite direction. In order to understand these redox properties, it must be recognized that structural/electronic alterations affect the four frontier molecular orbitals (HOMO, LUMO, HOMO-1 and LUMO+1) unequally and in many cases the LUMO+1, and not the LUMO, may track the HOMO in energy. This perspective presents a fundamental framework concerning tetrapyrrole electronic properties that should provide a foundation for rational molecular design in tetrapyrrole science.
Panchromatic absorbers have potential applications in molecular-based energy-conversion schemes. A prior porphyrin–perylene dyad (P-PMI, where “MI” denotes monoimide) coupled via an ethyne linker exhibits panchromatic absorption (350–700 nm) and a tetrapyrrole-like lowest singlet excited state with a relatively long singlet excited-state lifetime (τ S ) and increased fluorescence quantum yield (Φ f ) versus the parent porphyrin. To explore the extension of panchromaticity to longer wavelengths, three arrays have been synthesized: a chlorin–terrylene dyad (C-TMI), a bacteriochlorin–terrylene dyad (B-TMI), and a perylene–porphyrin–terrylene triad (PMI-P-TMI), where the terrylene, a π-extended homologue of perylene, is attached via an ethyne linker. Characterization of the spectra (absorption and fluorescence), excited-state properties (lifetime, yields, and rate constants of decay pathways), and molecular-orbital characteristics reveals unexpected subtleties. The wavelength of the red-region absorption band increases in the order C-TMI (705 nm) < PMI-P-TMI (749 nm) < B-TMI (774 nm), yet each array exhibits diminished Φ f and shortened τ S values. The PMI-P-TMI triad in toluene exhibits Φ f = 0.038 and τ S = 139 ps versus the all-perylene triad (PMI-P-PMI) for which Φ f = 0.26 and τ S = 2000 ps. The results highlight design constraints for auxiliary pigments with tetrapyrroles to achieve panchromatic absorption with retention of viable excited-state properties.
The synthesis, photophysical properties and electronic structure of seven new chlorin dyads and associated benchmark monomers are described. Each dyad contains two identical chlorins linked at the macrocycle β-pyrrole 13-position. The extent of electronic communication between chlorin constituents depends on the nature of the conjugated linker. The communication is assessed by modification of prominent ground-state absorption and redox properties, rate constants and yields of excited-state decay processes, and molecular-orbital characteristics. Relative to the benchmark monomers, the chlorin dyads in toluene exhibit a substantial bathochromic shift of the long-wavelength absorption band (30 nm average), two-fold increased radiative rate constant [average (10 ns) -1 vs. (22 ns) -1 ], reduced singlet excited-state lifetimes (average 5.0 ns vs. 8.2 ns), and increased fluorescence quantum yields (average 0.56 vs. 0.42). The excited-state lifetime and fluorescence yield for the chlorin dyad with a benzothiadiazole linker are reduced substantially in benzonitrile vs. toluene due largely to ~25-fold accelerated internal conversion. The results aid design strategies for molecular architectures that may find utility in solar-energy conversion and photomedicine.
Six zinc(II) porphyrins bearing 0–4 meso-phenyl substituents have been examined spectroscopically and theoretically. Comparisons with previously examined free base analogues afford a deep understanding of the electronic and photophysical effects of systematic addition of phenyl groups in porphyrins containing a central zinc(II) ion versus two hydrogen atoms. Trends in the wavelengths and relative intensities of the absorption bands are generally consistent with predictions from time-dependent density functional theory calculations and simulations from Gouterman’s four-orbital model. These trends derive from a preferential effect of the meso-phenyl groups to raise the energy of the highest occupied molecular orbital. The calculations reveal additional insights, such as a progressive increase in oscillator strength in the violet-red (B-Q) absorption manifold with increasing number of phenyls. Progressive addition of 0–4 phenyl substituents to the zinc porphyrins in O 2 -free toluene engenders a reduction in the measured lifetime of the lowest singlet excited state (2.5–2.1 ns), an increase in the S 1 → S o fluorescence yield (0.022–0.030), a decrease in the yield of S 1 → T 1 intersystem crossing (0.93–0.88), and an increase in the yield of S 1 → S o internal conversion (0.048–0.090). The derived rate constants for S 1 decay reveal significant differences in the photophysical properties of the zinc chelates versus free base forms. Here, the unexpected finding of a larger rate constant for internal conversion for zinc chelates versus free bases is particularly exemplary. Collectively, the findings afford fundamental insights into the photophysical properties and electronic structure of meso-phenylporphyrins, which are widely used as benchmarks for tetrapyrrole-based architectures in solar energy and life sciences research.