Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Dodd, E. S.

Publications and source records attributed to Dodd, E. S..

Milestone 7714 National Opacity Program: High-Fidelity Iron Data on NIF

Establish the level of reproducibility of NIF iron opacity shots, quantify to-date improvements in data quality through, e.g. background reduction, improved signal, and improved analysis methods, and formalize the approach that will be taken in the future to compare NIF data, Z data, and theory.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

Progress toward NIF opacity measurements

The opacities of iron and other mid-Z elements help to regulate the transport of energy in the sun. Recent experiments on the Sandia National Laboratories Z machine have shown large discrepancies between the measured and calculated opacities of iron at certain solar conditions. To replicate these opacity measurements a platform is being developed on the National Ignition Facility to measure the opacities of iron and other elements at the same conditions as in the Z experiments. The NIF platform consists of a hohlraum to heat the opacity sample to the desired conditions, a separate backlighter to radiograph the sample, and a spectrometer to give the spectrally resolved opacity. Not only must the opacity be measured but the temperature and density of the sample must also be accurately determined. This platform has now produced its first iron transmission measurements. Overall, these measurements will be presented along with plans for future measurements and details on how the measurements will be improved.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Design considerations for indirectly driven double shell capsules

Here, double shell capsules are predicted to ignite and burn at relatively low temperature (~3 keV) via volume ignition and are a potential low-convergence path to substantial α-heating and possibly ignition at the National Ignition Facility. Double shells consist of a dense, high-Z pusher, which first shock heats and then performs work due to changes in pressure and volume (PdV work) on deuterium-tritium gas, bringing the entire fuel volume to high pressure thermonuclear conditions near implosion stagnation. The high-Z pusher is accelerated via a shock and subsequent compression of an intervening foam cushion by an ablatively driven low-Z outer shell. A broad capsule design parameter space exists due to the inherent flexibility of potential materials for the outer and inner shells and foam cushion. This is narrowed down by design physics choices and the ability to fabricate and assemble the separate pieces forming a double shell capsule. We describe the key physics for good double shell performance, the trade-offs in various design choices, and the challenges for capsule fabrication. Finally, both 1D and 2D calculations from radiation-hydrodynamic simulations are presented.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Update on the Iron Opacity Experiments on the NIF

Recent iron opacity experiments on the Sandia National Laboratories Z machine have reported up to factors of two discrepancies between theoretical and experimental results. Much effort has been invested in identifying experimental errors as well as revisiting opacity theories, but a resolution of the discrepancies has not been forthcoming. Here, we emphasize the discrepancies present a fundamental theoretical challenge. To help resolve this question, an experimental platform for opacity experiments is being developed at the National Ignition Facility (NIF). This platform will be able to replicate the experimental conditions of the Z experiments and also extend the measurements to other temperatures and densities. Experiments to date have demonstrated a satisfactory X-ray backlighting source and have achieved the appropriate plasma conditions in the opacity sample. Some initial iron data have been taken, but problems remain with backgrounds and with the spectrometer used to make the measurements.The path forward for correcting these problems is presented.We expect that data for comparing with the Z experiments will be available within a year.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Replicating the Z iron opacity experiments on the NIF

Here, X-ray opacity is a crucial factor of all radiation-hydrodynamics calculations, yet it is one of the least validated of the material properties in the simulation codes. Recent opacity experiments at the Sandia Z-machine have shown up to factors of two discrepancies between theory and experiment, casting doubt on the validity of the opacity models. Therefore, a new experimental opacity platform is being developed on the National Ignition Facility (NIF) not only to verify the Z-machine experimental results but also to extend the experiments to other temperatures and densities. The first experiments will be directed towards measuring the opacity of iron at a temperature of ~160 eV and an electron density of ~7 x 10 21 cm -3 . Preliminary experiments on NIF have demonstrated the ability to create a sufficiently bright point backlighter using an imploding plastic capsule and also a hohlraum that can heat the opacity sample to the desired conditions. The first of these iron opacity experiments is expected to be performed in 2017.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Conceptual design of initial opacity experiments on the national ignition facility

Accurate models of X-ray absorption and re-emission in partly stripped ions are necessary to calculate the structure of stars, the performance of hohlraums for inertial confinement fusion and many other systems in high-energy-density plasma physics. Despite theoretical progress, a persistent discrepancy exists with recent experiments at the Sandia Z facility studying iron in conditions characteristic of the solar radiative–convective transition region. The increased iron opacity measured at Z could help resolve a longstanding issue with the standard solar model, but requires a radical departure for opacity theory. To replicate the Z measurements, an opacity experiment has been designed for the National Facility (NIF). The design uses established techniques scaled to NIF. A laser-heated hohlraum will produce X-ray-heated uniform iron plasmas in local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) at temperatures ${\geqslant}150$ eV and electron densities ${\geqslant}7\times 10^{21}~\text{cm}^{-3}$ . The iron will be probed using continuum X-rays emitted in a ${\sim}200$ ps, ${\sim}200~\unicode[STIX]{x03BC}\text{m}$ diameter source from a 2 mm diameter polystyrene (CH) capsule implosion. In this design, $2/3$ of the NIF beams deliver 500 kJ to the ${\sim}6$ mm diameter hohlraum, and the remaining $1/3$ directly drive the CH capsule with 200 kJ. Calculations indicate this capsule backlighter should outshine the iron sample, delivering a point-projection transmission opacity measurement to a time-integrated X-ray spectrometer viewing down the hohlraum axis. Preliminary experiments to develop the backlighter and hohlraum are underway, informing simulated measurements to guide the final design.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Revised Knudsen-layer reduction of fusion reactivity

Recent work by Molvig et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 095001 (2012)] examined how fusion reactivity may be reduced from losses of fast ions in finite assemblies of fuel. In this paper, this problem is revisited with the addition of an asymptotic boundary-layer treatment of ion kinetic losses. This boundary solution, reminiscent of the classical Milne problem from linear transport theory, obtains a free-streaming limit of fast ion losses near the boundary, where the diffusion approximation is invalid. Thermonuclear reaction rates have been obtained for the ion distribution functions predicted by this improved model. It is found that while Molvig's “Knudsen distribution function” bounds from above the magnitude of the reactivity reduction, this more accurate treatment leads to less dramatic losses of tail ions and associated reduction of thermonuclear reaction rates for finite fuel volumes.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

“Bloch wave” modification of stimulated Raman by stimulated Brillouin scattering

Using the reduced-description particle-in-cell (RPIC) method, we study the coupling of backward stimulated Raman scattering (BSRS) and backward stimulated Brillouin scattering (BSBS) in regimes where the reflectivity involves the nonlinear behavior of particles trapped in the daughter plasma waves. The temporal envelope of a Langmuir wave (LW) obeys a Schrödinger equation where the potential is the periodic electron density fluctuation resulting from an ion-acoustic wave (IAW). The BSRS-driven LWs in this case have a Bloch wave structure and a modified dispersion due to the BSBS-driven spatially periodic IAW, which includes frequency band gaps at kLW∼kIAW/2∼k0 (kLW, kIAW, and k0 are the wave number of the LW, IAW, and incident pump electromagnetic wave, respectively). This band structure and the associated Bloch wave harmonic components are distinctly observed in RPIC calculations of the electron density fluctuation spectra and this structure may be observable in Thomson scatter. Bloch wave components grow up in the LW spectrum, and are not the result of isolated BSRS. Self-Thomson scattered light from these Bloch wave components can have forward scattering components. The distortion of the LW dispersion curve implies that the usual relationship connecting the frequency shift of the BSRS-scattered light and the density of origin of this light may become inaccurate. The modified LW frequency results in a time-dependent frequency shift that increases as the IAW grows, detunes the BSRS frequency matching condition, and reduces BSRS growth. A dependence of the BSRS reflectivity on the IAW Landau damping results because this damping determines the levels of IAWs. The time-dependent reflectivity in our simulations is characterized by bursts of sub-picosecond pulses of BSRS alternating with multi-ps pulses of BSBS, and BSRS is observed to decline precipitously as soon as SBS begins to grow from low levels. In strong BSBS regimes, the Bloch wave effects in BSRS are strong and temporal anti-correlation with BSRS is due to pump depletion in addition to frequency detuning. In most cases studied, BSBS suppressed the time-averaged reflectivity of BSRS compared to the levels obtained with fixed ions (and therefore no BSBS). The strong spatial modulation of the Bloch Langmuir waves appears to weaken electron trapping and thereby lowers the inflated reflectivity levels of BSRS.

Dodd, E. S.↗