Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Dubin, Daniel H. E.

Publications and source records attributed to Dubin, Daniel H. E..

At least 19 records

Equilibration of the planar modes of ultracold two-dimensional ion crystals in a Penning trap

In this work, planar thermal equilibration is studied using direct numerical simulations of ultracold two-dimensional ion crystals in a Penning trap with a rotating wall. The large magnetic field of the trap splits the modes that describe in-plane motion of the ions into two branches: high-frequency cyclotron modes dominated by kinetic energy and low-frequency E × B modes dominated by potential energy associated with thermal position displacements. Using an eigenmode analysis we extract the equilibration rate between these two branches as a function of the ratio of the frequencies that characterize the two branches and observe this equilibration rate to be exponentially suppressed as the ratio increases. Under experimental conditions relevant for current work at NIST, the predicted equilibration time is orders of magnitude longer than any relevant experimental timescales. We also study the coupling rate dependence on the initial energy of the planar modes and the number of ions. In addition, we show how increasing the rotating wall strength improves crystal stability. These details of in-plane mode dynamics help set the stage for developing strategies to efficiently cool the in-plane modes and improve the performance of single plane ion crystals for quantum information processing.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Broadening of the drumhead-mode spectrum due to in-plane thermal fluctuations of two-dimensional trapped ion crystals in a Penning trap

Two-dimensional crystals of ions stored in Penning traps are a leading platform for quantum simulation and sensing experiments. For small amplitudes, the out-of-plane motion of such crystals can be described by a discrete set of normal modes called the drumhead modes, which can be used to implement a range of quantum information protocols. However, experimental observations of crystals with Doppler-cooled and even nearground- state-cooled drumhead modes reveal an unresolved drumhead-mode spectrum. In this work, we establish in-plane thermal fluctuations in ion positions as a major contributor to the broadening of the drumhead-mode spectrum. In the process, we demonstrate how the confining magnetic field leads to unconventional in-plane normal modes, whose average potential and kinetic energies are not equal. This property, in turn, has implications for the sampling procedure required to choose the in-plane initial conditions for molecular-dynamics simulations. Further, for current operating conditions of the NIST Penning trap, our study suggests that the two-dimensional crystals produced in this trap undergo in-plane potential-energy fluctuations of the order of 10mK. Our study therefore motivates the need for designing improved techniques to cool the in-plane degrees of freedom.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Normal modes, rotational inertia, and thermal fluctuations of trapped ion crystals

The normal modes of a trapped ion crystal are derived using an approach based on the Hermitian properties of the system’s dynamical matrix. This method is equivalent to the standard Bogoliubov method, but for classical systems it is arguably simpler and more general in that canonical coordinates are not necessary. The theory is developed for stable, unstable, and neutrally-stable systems. The method is then applied to ion crystals in a Penning trap. Reduced eigenvalue problems for the case of large applied magnetic field are developed, for which the spectrum breaks into E x B drift modes, axial modes, and cyclotron modes. Thermal fluctuation levels in these modes are analyzed and shown to be consistent with the Bohr-van-Leeuwen theorem, provided that neutrally-stable modes associated with crystal rotations are included in the analysis. An expression for the rotational inertia of the crystal is derived, and a magnetic contribution to this inertia, which dominates in large magnetic fields, is described. An unusual limit is discovered for the special case of spherically-symmetric confinement, in which the rotational inertia does not exist and changes in angular momentum leave the rotation frequency unaffected.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Instability of nonlinear Trivelpiece-Gould waves I: Wave degeneracies

Arguments based on energy conservation are used to evaluate the fluid theory of stability of nonlinear traveling waves (pump waves) in an ideal plasma system. Instabilities growing on the pump wave are associated with wave degeneracies. The relative signs of the energies of degenerate waves, as seen in the frame of the pump wave, determine whether their amplitudes grow exponentially or merely oscillate through resonant energy exchange. This energy analysis is carried out in detail for Trivelpiece-Gould (TG) waves and is compared to numerical calculations. It is verified that nonlinear TG waves are stable with respect to 3 wave processes, but weaker 4 wave, 5 wave, and higher order wave processes cause instability over narrow wavenumber bands. A modulational instability is also identified.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Instability of nonlinear Trivelpiece-Gould waves. II. Weakly trapped particles

This paper discusses a novel parametric instability mechanism caused by particles that are weakly trapped in the potential wells of a nonlinear “pump” wave. The pump wave is unstable to the growth of daughter waves with longer wavelength and nearly the same phase velocity as the pump. This induces adjacent potential peaks in the wave to slowly approach one-another, receding from other pairs of peaks. Particles that are weakly trapped between approaching peaks, with kinetic energies just below the potential maxima, are heated by compression and escape the well, and then become retrapped on the other side of the approaching peaks, where they amplify the compression by pushing the peaks together. The mechanism applies to low-collisionality plasmas supporting waves with near-acoustic dispersion relations such as ion sound waves, magnetized Langmuir waves, or Alfven waves. The theory is compared to particle in cell simulations of TrivelpieceGould (TG) traveling waves, as well as to experiments on pure ion plasmas that observe parametric instability in TG standing waves.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Bernstein modes in a non-neutral plasma column

Our report presents theory and numerical calculations of electrostatic Bernstein modes in an inhomogeneous cylindrical plasma column. These modes rely on finite Larmor radius effects to propagate radially across the column until they are reflected when their frequency matches the upper hybrid frequency. This reflection sets up an internal normal mode on the column and also mode-couples to the electrostatic surface cyclotron wave (which allows the normal mode to be excited and observed using external electrodes). Numerical results predicting the mode spectra, using a novel linear Vlasov code on a cylindrical grid, are presented and compared to an analytical Wentzel Kramers Brillouin (WKB) theory. A prior version of the theory [D. H. E. Dubin, Phys. Plasmas 20(4), 042120 (2013)] expanded the plasma response in powers of 1/B, approximating the local upper hybrid frequency, and consequently, its frequency predictions are spuriously shifted with respect to the numerical results presented here. A new version of the WKB theory avoids this approximation using the exact cold fluid plasma response and does a better job of reproducing the numerical frequency spectrum. The effect of multiple ion species on the mode spectrum is also reported on, to make contact with experiments that observe cyclotron modes in a multi-species pure ion plasma [M. Affolter et al., Phys. Plasmas 22(5), 055701 (2015)].

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Superbanana transport in the collisional heating of a plasma column forced across a squeeze potential

When weakly collisional plasmas have locally trapped particle populations, perturbations to the plasma equilibrium (such as waves or static field-errors) can induce phase-space discontinuities in the particle distribution function that strongly enhance entropy production, plasma loss, and wave damping via superbanana transport. Here, this paper presents a simple version of this superbanana transport process, wherein a plasma is heated as it is slowly forced back and forth across a squeeze potential (at a frequency ω that is small compared with the particle bounce frequency). The squeeze potential traps low-energy particles on either side of the squeeze, but particles with higher energy can pass through it. Trapped and passing particles have different responses to the forcing, causing a collisionless discontinuity in the distribution function at the separatrix between the trapped and passing particles. Expressions for both the adiabatic and non-adiabatic distribution functions are presented, and the heating rate caused by collisional broadening of the separatrix discontinuity is derived. The heating rate is proportional to √νω , provided that ν<<ω, where ν is the collision rate (i.e., the √ν regime of superbanana theory).

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Parallel velocity diffusion and slowing-down rate from long-range collisions in a magnetized plasma

This paper derives an expression for the rate of collisional slowing of charges in a magnetized plasma for which r{sub c} < λ{sub D}, where r{sub c} is the mean thermal cyclotron radius and λ{sub D} is the Debye length. The rate depends on a new fundamental length scale d that separates collisions into two impact parameter ranges that yield different slowing rates: a Boltzmann rate due to isolated binary collisions for impact parameters ρ < d and a Fokker-Planck rate due to multiple small scatterings for ρ > d. Slowing due to Boltzmann collisions is also shown to depend on the sign of the Coulomb interaction: for repulsive interactions, the slowing is enhanced by “collisional caging,” while for attractive interactions the Boltzmann slowing rate is zero.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Effect of squeeze on electrostatic Trivelpiece-Gould wave damping

We present a theory for increased damping of Trivelpiece-Gouid plasma modes on a nonneutral plasma column, due to application of a Debye shielded cylindrically symmetric squeeze potential φ{sub 1}. We present two models of the effect this has on the plasma modes: a 1D model with only axial dependence, and a 2D model that also keeps radial dependence in the squeezed equilibrium and the mode. We study the models using both analytical and numerical methods. For our analytical studies, we assume that φ{sub 1}/T≪1, and we treat the Debye shielded squeeze potential as a perturbation in the equilibrium Hamiltonian. Our numerical simulations solve the 1D Vlasov-Poisson system and obtain the frequency and damping rate for a self-consistent plasma mode, making no assumptions as to the size of the squeeze. In both the 1D and 2D models, damping of the mode is caused by Landau resonances at energies E{sub n} for which the particle bounce frequency ω{sub b}(E{sub n}) and the wave frequency ω satisfy ω=nω{sub b}(E{sub n}). Particles experience a non-sinusoidal wave potential along their bounce orbits due to the squeeze potential. As a result, the squeeze induces bounce harmonics with n > 1 in the perturbed distribution. The harmonics allow resonances at energies E{sub n}≤T that cause substantial damping, even when wave phase velocities are much larger than the thermal velocity. In the regime ω/k≫√(T/m) (k is the wave number) and T≫φ{sub 1}, the resonance damping rate has a |φ{sub 1}|{sup 2} dependence. This dependence agrees with the simulations and experimental results.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Cyclotron waves in a non-neutral plasma column

A kinetic theory of linear electrostatic plasma waves with frequencies near the cyclotron frequency {Omega}{sub c{sub s}} of a given plasma species s is developed for a multispecies non-neutral plasma column with general radial density and electric field profiles. Terms in the perturbed distribution function up to O(1/{Omega}{sub c{sub s}{sup 2}}) are kept, as are the effects of finite cyclotron radius r{sub c} up to O(r{sub c}{sup 2}). At this order, the equilibrium distribution is not Maxwellian if the plasma temperature or rotation frequency is not uniform. For r{sub c}{yields}0, the theory reproduces cold-fluid theory and predicts surface cyclotron waves propagating azimuthally. For finite r{sub c}, the wave equation predicts that the surface wave couples to radially and azimuthally propagating Bernstein waves, at locations where the wave frequency equals the local upper hybrid frequency. The equation also predicts a second set of Bernstein waves that do not couple to the surface wave, and therefore have no effect on the external potential. The wave equation is solved both numerically and analytically in the WKB approximation, and analytic dispersion relations for the waves are obtained. The theory predicts that both types of Bernstein wave are damped at resonances, which are locations where the Doppler-shifted wave frequency matches the local cyclotron frequency as seen in the rotating frame.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Enhanced superbanana transport caused by chaotic scattering across an asymmetric separatrix

This paper discusses a novel 'chaotic' form of superbanana transport and compares the theory to experiments on non-neutral plasmas. Superbanana transport is caused by particles that cross local trapping separatrices (magnetic or electric ripples) in the presence of field 'errors' such as toroidal magnetic curvature. Traditionally, collisions (at rate {nu}) cause separatrix crossings, with resulting transport that scales as {nu}{sup 1/2}B{sup -1/2}. The 'chaotic' transport of interest here occurs when the separatrix is 'ruffled' in the direction of plasma drift; then, collisionless particle orbits give random trapping and detrapping. Prior theory assumed a 'stellarator symmetry' and suggested that these orbits give reduced transport scaling as {nu}{sup p} with p{approx}1. Here, we fully characterize chaotic transport and show that the transport is enhanced rather than reduced, scaling as {nu}{sup 0}B{sup -1}. Experiments on pure electron plasmas provide quantitative transport measurements, with precise control of the overall field error, and of the trapping separatrix with and without ruffles. The experiments show close agreement with theory over a decade in B, for both collisional neoclassical transport, and for the distinctive chaotic transport. At low magnetic fields, transport scaling as B{sup -p} with p>rsim2 becomes dominant, showing preliminary agreement with bounce-resonant theory.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Neoclassical transport and plasma mode damping caused by collisionless scattering across an asymmetric separatrix

Plasma loss due to apparatus asymmetries is a ubiquitous phenomenon in magnetic plasma confinement. When the plasma equilibrium has locally-trapped particle populations partitioned by a separatrix from one another and from passing particles, the asymmetry transport is enhanced. The trapped and passing particle populations react differently to the asymmetries, leading to the standard 1/{nu} and {radical}({nu}) transport regimes of superbanana orbit theory as particles collisionally scatter from one orbit type to another. However, when the separatrix is itself asymmetric, particles can collisionlessly transit from trapped to passing and back, leading to the enhanced diffusion and mobility that is calculated here. The effect of this collisionless scattering across an asymmetric separatrix on the damping rate of trapped particle diocotron modes is also considered.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Electrostatic waves and instabilities in multispecies nonneutral plasmas

This paper briefly describes waves and instabilities in a multispecies nonneutral plasma that have previously been studied only in neutral plasmas: ion sound waves, drift waves, and ion temperature gradient waves. The theory of their dispersion relations and growth rates is similar to that for neutral plasmas, but results differ in several important respects. For instance, drift waves are not necessarily unstable, the instabilities generally do not cause plasma loss, and they can be controlled (e.g., turned on or off) by manipulation of density and temperature profiles using standard experimental techniques such as centrifugal separation and laser cooling/heating. This should allow precise experimental studies of instability growth and saturation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Chaotic Transport and Damping from {theta}-Ruffled Separatrices

Variations in magnetic or electrostatic confinement fields give rise to trapping separatrices, and neoclassical transport theory analyzes effects from collision-induced separatrix crossings. Experiments on pure electron plasmas now quantitatively characterize a broad range of transport and wave damping effects due to ''chaotic'' separatrix crossings, which occur due to equilibrium plasma rotation across {theta}-ruffled separatrices, and due to wave-induced separatrix fluctuations.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Neoclassical Transport Caused by Collisionless Scattering across an Asymmetric Separatrix

Plasma loss due to apparatus asymmetries is a ubiquitous phenomenon in magnetic plasma confinement. When the plasma equilibrium has locally trapped particle populations partitioned by a separatrix from one another and from passing particles, the asymmetry transport is enhanced. The trapped and passing particle populations react differently to the asymmetries, leading to the standard 1/{nu} and {radical}({nu}) transport regimes of superbanana orbit theory as particles collisionally scatter from one orbit type to another. However, when the separatrix is itself asymmetric, particles can collisionlessly transit from trapped to passing and back, leading to enhanced transport.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Theory and Simulation of Neoclassical Transport Processes, with Local Trapping

Neoclassical transport is studied using idealized simulations that follow guiding centers in given fields, neglecting collective effects on the plasma evolution, but including collisions at rate {nu}. For simplicity the magnetic field is assumed to be uniform; transport is due to asymmetries in applied electrostatic fields. Also, the Fokker-Planck equation describing the particle distribution is solved, and the predicted transport is found to agree with the simulations. Banana, plateau, and fluid regimes are identified and observed in the simulations. When separate trapped particle populations are created by application of an axisymmetric squeeze potential, enhanced transport regimes are observed, scaling as {radical}({nu}) when {nu}<{omega}{sub 0}<{omega}{sub b} and as 1/{nu} when {omega}{sub 0}<{nu}<{omega}{sub b} where {omega}{sub 0} and {omega}{sub b} are the rotation and axial bounce frequencies, respectively. These regimes are similar to those predicted for neoclassical transport in stellarators.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Antihydrogen formation from antiprotons in a pure positron plasma

This paper investigates the evolution in binding energy of antihydrogen atoms formed from stationary antiprotons located within a strongly magnetized positron plasma. Three-body recombination and a collisional cascade to deeper binding, limited by a kinetic bottleneck at a binding energy of 4T, dominate the initial antihydrogen formation process. A classical Monte-Carlo simulation is used to determine the collisional transition rate between atomic binding energies, using the drift approximation for initial conditions that allow it, and full dynamics for initial conditions resulting in chaotic motion. These transition rates are employed in determining mean energy-loss rates for an ensemble of atoms, as well as in a numerical solution of the master equation to find the rate at which atoms are formed over a range of binding energies. The highly excited atoms formed by this process separate into guiding-center drift atoms and chaotic atoms. The phase-space distributions of the atoms are investigated, along with their implications for magnetic confinement and radiative energy loss. Estimates of radiative energy loss indicate that radiation is unimportant for guiding-center atoms, but increases rapidly near the chaotic regime, taking over as the dominant energy-loss process for parameters typical of recent experiments. Furthermore, the fraction of low-magnetic field seekers is considerably larger than suggested by estimates of the magnetic moment based on guiding-center dynamics, due to effects associated with chaos.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗