Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Duty, Chad

Publications and source records attributed to Duty, Chad.

At least 19 records

Recycling of CF-ABS machining waste for large format additive manufacturing

Large format additive manufacturing (LFAM) necessitates the use of short fiber thermoplastic composites, such as carbon fiber filled acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, to enable printing. Currently, when LFAM parts are machined into their final shape, the machining scrap (i.e., small flake like particles and offcuts) is landfilled. Previous studies have demonstrated the viability of recycling end-of-life LFAM parts by shredding and optionally re-compounding the material back into pellets. However, there is little understanding of the value and performance of recycled material made from LFAM machining scrap, which if pursued could motivate more broad recycling of this waste stream. In this study, recycled in-process machining scrap is explored as an LFAM feedstock source. Herein, it is found that the primary degradation mechanism of the recycled material is significant fiber length attrition during surface machining. While this fiber attrition negatively impacts the mechanical performance of the material in the print direction, it seems that the changes in processing behaviors and print quality, namely the surface roughness of the printed structure associated with shorter fiber lengths, is beneficial to interlayer adhesion. The tensile strength and elastic modulus of the recycled material, in the print direction, decreased 11% and 31% respectively compared to the pristine material. However, in the layer-wise direction it was found that the recycled material exhibited no significant change in elastic modulus and a significant 21% increase in tensile strength – a surprising result. In conclusion, this work indicates that machining waste could be a viable material stream for recycled LFAM feedstock materials.

42 ENGINEERING↗

THE IMPACT OF VISCOSITY ON MATERIAL TRANSITIONS IN LARGE FORMAT ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING OF POLYMER COMPOSITES

The need to produce complex geometries incompatible with traditional manufacturing techniques has fueled rapid growth in Large-Format Additive Manufacturing (LFAM). Printing of polymer composite materials have generated significant interest, but the production of Multi-Material (MM) structures with location-based material properties continues to be a challenge. Extrusion-based techniques have utilized multiple deposition heads to successfully print MM structures with both stiff and flexible regions, but these techniques often result in discrete material boundaries that concentrate stress and act as failure points. To avoid discrete interfaces, a novel dual-hopper configuration was developed for the Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM) system that creates a blended material region within the structure. The ability to blend and freely switch between stiff polymer composites and flexible polymers enables printing of robust MM structures with site-specific properties. This study characterizes the influence of viscosity on a blended material transition between carbon fiber-filled acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (CF-ABS) and unfilled thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU), which have significantly different viscoelastic behaviors

Brackett, James↗

Enabling Recycling of Composites: Understanding the Impacts of Multiple Thermal Processing Cycles

When considering the utilization of recycled short carbon fiber feedstock materials for advanced manufacturing, understanding the material degradation behavior is essential in determining how many times a composite material can be effectively reprocessed and remanufactured. This study characterizes the degradation behavior of short carbon fiber acrylonitrile butadiene (CF-ABS) that has been reprocessed five times with twin screw extrusion. Parallel plate rheology was completed to observe the degradation in complex viscosity of the recycled feedstock materials. Gel permeation chromatography (GPC) was utilized to characterize the changes in molecular weight distribution of the recycled materials as a result of thermal and mechanical degradation during the re-processing steps. Rheological characterization, GPC, and twin-screw processing data help inform the process optimizations required to process the recycled feedstock material. Successful characterization of the degradation behavior of short fiber composite feedstock materials aids in increased understanding of the lifespan of high value carbon fiber composite materials and aids in process optimization of recycled composite materials.

Walker, Roo↗

MEASURING THERMALLY-INDUCED DISTORTION OF LARGE-SCALE COMPOSITE PRINTED STRUCTURES USING DIGITAL IMAGE CORRELATION

Additive manufacturing (AM) gives designers the ability to create complex part geometries without several of the limitations of traditional manufacturing. Large-Scale AM (LSAM) allows the creation of large composite structures and is a popular area of composite tooling research. Fiber-reinforced polymers are common feedstock for LSAM tooling but introduce anisotropic thermomechanical properties that can lead to the warpage of tools at autoclave conditions. Digital image correlation (DIC) has been used to measure the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of LSAM parts using a novel DIC Oven design. This method was utilized to measure the CTE of LSAM structures printed using different fiber-reinforced materials and multiple geometries. Specifically, glass fiber ABS (GF-ABS) and carbon fiber ABS (CF-ABS) samples were compared as well as cube and plate geometries for each material. The temperature profile over time was also evaluated to determine how rapidly the strain of the sample increased as temperature of the DIC Oven was increased. A thermal model was developed to predict temperature profiles for various samples and identify when the samples had reached thermal equilibrium.

Corum, Tyler↗

Modeling the interfacial failure and resulting mechanical properties of z-pinned additively manufactured composites

The mechanical properties of Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) parts are limited in the build direction, albeit advantages such as design flexibility and in-house customization. Here, in this paper, a novel z-pinning approach that enhances mechanical properties in the build direction by depositing material across multiple layers within the part was investigated through numerical simulations and validated experimentally. A finite element model for z-pinned composite structures was developed by assigning fiber-orientation dependent material properties obtained using a micromechanics approach to beads and pins. The bead-to-bead and pin-to-pin adhesions within the z-pinned structures were modeled using a cohesive traction separation law. The properties of cohesive elements for carbon fiber-reinforced polylactic acid (CF-PLA) z-pinned composites were calibrated using tensile experiments. The elastic modulus and tensile strength of CF-PLA z-pinned composites in the build direction were predicted with the developed numerical model. The numerical investigation on various geometrical parameters revealed that the largest pin volume increases the stiffness and tensile strength by 40% and thus, has the greatest influence on the mechanical properties of the z-pinned composites. The effect of z-pin geometrical parameters on the mechanical properties was summarized to aid in the design of z-pinned additively manufactured composite structures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The impact of infill percentage and layer height in small-scale material extrusion on porosity and tensile properties

We report material extrusion additive manufacturing is prone to introducing porosity within the structure due to the layer-by-layer construction using elliptical beads of material. This open porosity ultimately plays a role in determining the mechanical properties of printed parts. The shape, size, and amount of porosity within a printed part is influenced by a variety of factors, including nozzle diameter, infill percentage, layer height, raster orientation, and print speed. While several studies have investigated these and other parameters’ effects on mechanical performance and porosity, better understanding the interconnected relationships is crucial in balancing the various input parameters to achieve maximum strength. This work initially examined the influence of key print parameters (infill percentage and layer height) on the internal porosity of a printed Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) part. Then, the print parameters and internal porosity were statistically correlated to final mechanical properties. Porosity was further classified as either open or closed to differentiate between connected voids in the mesostructure from isolated voids within the material itself. Mechanical performance increased with an increasing density and infill percentage, displaying a 224 % increase in elastic modulus and a 150 % increase in ultimate tensile strength. The contribution of layer height was found to be conditional upon the infill percentage.

3D Printing↗

Characterizing the Thermal-Induced Distortion of Large-Scale Polymer Composite Printed Structures

The Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM) system has been used to print large-scale parts, such as automotive structures and molds for tooling, with fiber-reinforced polymer composites. Incorporating reinforcing fibers in printed parts is commonly used to increase stiffness and strength, but it also introduces significant anisotropy in the thermomechanical performance, which can lead to distortion and warping during thermal cycling. Characterizing and understanding how a printed tool distorts is crucial to maintaining tolerances and avoiding part failure. This study uses digital image correlation (DIC) to measure the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of a printed part from room temperature and to a known steady state temperature. The samples were printed with carbon fiber reinforced acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (CF-ABS). Various nozzle geometries were evaluated in this study with the intent of minimizing the thermal- induced distortion experienced by printed parts.

Corum, Tyler↗

Design and Use of a Penetrating Deposition Nozzle for Z-Pinning Additive Manufacturing

Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) involves depositing material layer-by-layer to create athree-dimensional object. This method often demonstrates high mechanical anisotropy in theprinted structure, leading to a drop in the material strength of the part when comparing structuresalong the deposition plane (X/Y-Axis) versus across layers in the build direction (Z-Axis). Initialefforts to improve anisotropy led to the development of the Z-Pinning process, where continuouspins are deposited across layers in the Z-Axis. Z-pinning has demonstrated significant gains intoughness and inter-layer strength, particularly in fiber-reinforced materials. However, thisprocess can also create flaws in the structure that increase in severity and frequency as the pinsgrow in length and diameter. To mitigate this, a penetrating nozzle has been developed thatextends a fine-tipped extrusion nozzle deep into the pin cavity and simultaneously extrudesmaterial as it retracts. This study investigates the printability of the penetrating nozzle for simplegeometries and evaluates the resulting Z-pinning mesostructure. As a result of this study, theprototype penetrating nozzle design was analyzed and built. Through a pressure driven flowanalysis it was determined that the penetrating nozzle extruder can not only flow extrudefilament. After a transient thermal simulation it was found that after a pause of 15 secondsresume printing with no drop in heat at nozzle exit.

Bales, Brenin↗

THE IMPACT OF A STATIC-MIXING NOZZLE ON UNIFORMITY IN MATERIAL EXTRUSION LARGE-SCALE ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING

There are many methods of incorporating more than one material in Additive Manufacturing (AM) processes. Oak Ridge National Laboratory has developed a unique solution that enables in-situ material switching by developing a dual-hopper feed system for Cincinnati’s Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM) system. Continuous extrusion during a step-change in material feedstock results in a unique blended material transition region that exhibits a heterogeneous internal morphology. To improve mixing of materials during extrusion, a customized static-mixing nozzle was created for use with the BAAM. Single-bead transitions from Material A to B and B to A were printed with the mixing nozzle at a specified screw speed. Compositional analysis tracked the progression of the material transition as a function of extrudate volume. The resulting transition curves were compared against a standard nozzle configuration. Optical microscopy of cross sections also demonstrated that the static-mixing nozzle promoted a more uniform bead geometry as well as a more homogeneous internal structure throughout the material transition.

Brackett, James↗

Anisotropic thermal behavior of extrusion-based large scale additively manufactured carbon-fiber reinforced thermoplastic structures

Large format additive manufacturing (AM) enables rapid manufacturing of large parts and structures with minimum waste in material and energy. Extrusion-based AM deposition processes provide parts with highly anisotropic thermal properties, which are not typically reflected in textbook values for these materials. In order to develop accurate models that describe the directionally dependent thermal behavior of these materials in processing and service, accurate measurements of specific heat capacity and thermal conductivity are required. Here, this work characterizes, documents, and analyzes the effect of the anisotropic nature of the extrusion-based deposition process on the specific heat capacity and thermal conductivity of the resulting AM products. All measurements were made over a temperature range of 20–180°C using the transient plane source technique, also referred to as the hot disk technique. Three of the most commonly used large format AM feedstock materials that utilize carbon fiber reinforcement were examined in this work: acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, polyphenylene sulfide and polyphenylsulfone. Finally, these findings can serve as a thermal design/process guideline for future large format AM applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development of Large Scale Extrusion Deposition for Structural Applications

Large Scale Extrusion Deposition (LSED) is an evolving additive manufacturing (AM) technology that research, such as that taking place at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and companies like Local Motors, are continuing to utilize and develop new applications. A major LSED application of interest has been molds and tooling as it allows for much shorter production time and lower cost. However, interest has been expanding into using LSED for more structural applications due to more frequent use of high performing polymer composites as feedstock. The use of LSED for structural applications is of particular interest to Local Motors as it is currently being used to create commercially viable, energy efficient electric vehicles. LSED offers a unique opportunity when compared to traditional manufacturing methods as it can significantly reduce the number of components necessary, while decreasing embodied energy and carbon emissions. Even with these benefits however, it is important that LSED is properly understood from a structural aspect as this field has not been as heavily researched as tooling. To ensure a high level of safety and repeatability is an essential responsibility of a manufacturer whose products are structural in nature. As such it is important to understand the materials and LSED process to make structural objects that the manufacturer can be confident in. The main goals of this project were to: develop and investigate materials that are of interest for structural LSED applications, further develop and understand the current machines used in LSED and develop simulations tools of LSED and the mechanical properties of the created structure. Material development focused on composite materials that have high mechanical properties and are stable in a variety of environments. The materials were tested to determine their as printed mechanical and thermal properties as these are necessary for simulations. Once the materials were investigated thoroughly, it allowed for simulations to be performed to compare to experimental data with simulations. Materials were also vetted to determine candidates for multi-material printing. The machine development focused around the areas of process monitoring, non-destructive evaluation, and quality control. Finally, the goal of the simulations was to develop a realistic model of printed structures, including in-process simulation and dynamic simulation. The routes to get to some of these goals and the depth in which they were investigated changed throughout the project due to personnel changes and the COVID-19 pandemic. This project resulted in many valuable results such as the development of an nondestructive evaluation (NDE) technique for interlayer defects, proof of simulation for warpage in simple parts, the development and utilization of a profilometer to monitor a print for defects or inconsistencies, thorough investigation of a material used commercially for structural LSED applications and valuable experimental data on the applicability and advantages of multi-material crush structures versus their neat counterparts by creation and testing of samples.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Characterizing The Internal Morphology of Transition Regions in Large-Scale Extrusion Deposition Additive Manufacturing

A dual-hopper feed system that was developed for the Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM) system allows for transitioning between different materials while maintaining continuous deposition. This technique creates a step-change in material feedstock by switching the pellet feeding system to alternate which hopper is currently supplying material, allowing for multi-material construction. The step-change in feedstock material produces a transition region that is characterized by a compositional gradient and blended internal morphology. Initial cross-sectional imaging of the transition region revealed a non-homogenous blend of materials with distinct domains of each material, likely due to incomplete mixing within the screw. This study used a carbon fiber reinforced acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (CF-ABS) and an unfilled ABS to characterize the internal structure and to correlate it to mechanical performance by tracking microhardness across cross-sections of the transition region.

Brackett, James↗