Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Gigax, Jonathan Gregory

Publications and source records attributed to Gigax, Jonathan Gregory.

At least 19 records

Overview of SAVY-4000 Lifetime Extension Activities in Fiscal Year 2024

This report provides an overview of activities engaged in during the 2024 fiscal year in support of the SAVY-4000 (hereafter “SAVY”) lifetime extension. As the final full year prior to the submittal of the technical basis, efforts were made to assess the current understanding regarding SAVY degradation in service as well as any knowledge that provided a more substantive view of the challenges that SAVYs face in storage. Close coordination with the stakeholders (i.e. LANL program office) ensured alignment with expectations regarding timelines for the remainder of the activities supporting the technical basis document for the lifetime extension request.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Alloying effects on deformation induced microstructure evolution in copper

In this work, we investigated the effects of alloying elements on plastic deformation and microstructure evolution in polycrystalline copper (Cu) and Cu alloyed with 1 wt. % lead (Cu-1 %Pb). These materials were selected due to the size mismatch between Cu and Pb, with the latter forming precipitates at grain boundaries. Multi-modal characterization techniques, including neutron diffraction, electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), along with finite element simulations were employed to study the deformation behavior across multiple length scales. While both Cu and Cu-1%Pb exhibited similar macroscale response and final deformation textures, both dislocation line profile analysis and TEM revealed increased dislocation density in deformed Cu-1%Pb specimens. The presence of lead precipitates also significantly affected local plastic deformation during compression, with their influence diminishing with increasing strain. These results demonstrate the complex relationships between alloying elements, plastic deformation, microstructural evolution, and material behavior under load. The insights gained from this multi-scale and multi-technique approach contribute to the fundamental understanding of microstructural evolution in immiscible alloys and are valuable for tailoring the properties of structural materials for specific engineering applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Corrosion Analysis of 121103072 (SAVY-4000)

A surveillance feedlist for fiscal year (FY) 2022 was developed with the intent to target containers with contents known to generate corrosive gasses. One SAVY-4000 (hereafter “SAVY”) container with a serial number 121103072 was selected due to the reasonable wattage and known molten salt extraction (MSE) material corrosive behavior. The material was measured at 3.08 W with approximately 200 g of material placed inside of the SAVY for 6.07 years. The inner packaging configuration included a ¼ Qt stainless steel slip top inner container and a sPVC bag-out bag enclosing the inner container. Visual observations of the container during retrieval revealed several concerning features on the exterior of the container, notably on the lid. Fig. 1 shows the container lid along with an inset image further magnifying the features of interest. The corroded tamper indicating device (TID) wire and the corroded radioactive material tag wire indicated that corrosive gas species for steel were produced during storage. Although the TID wire and rad tag wire are not the same composition as the SAVY body and lid, these are often used as an indicator of potential corrosion inside of the SAVY container. The oxide residing inside of the filter holes and significant buildup around one hole provided further evidence supporting the presence of corrosive species inside of the container.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Lifetime extension drop-test of real-world corroded 5 Quart Hagan nuclear material storage container

A 5Qt Hagan container with a 20-year history of nuclear material storage was challenged with three successive drop tests at a height of 3.7 meters. The total mass of the test package was 12.1 kg. The 1st and 2nd drop tests (center of gravity over the container bottom corner but 180 degrees apart on the container bottom face) passed the pre- and post- impact helium leak criterion at less than 1.00E-6 atm-cc/sec (ambient cubic centimeters per second). The 3rd and final test (center of gravity over top corner) failed with a post-impact gross leak of 1.1E-1 atmcc/sec. The RRFMC (Respirable Release Fraction Measurement Chamber) is a drop tower test system that is critical for the sustainability of the SAVY-4000™ series and Hagan-type (NFT Inc. Golden CO) nuclear material storage containers. These are the primary in-use nuclear material storage container types at the Los Alamos National Laboratory TA-55 facility. Results are presented to expand the technical knowledge basis for container lifetime, regarding actual exposure to corrosive gas species on the container inner surfaces. The primary source of general corrosion throughout the container is gaseous hydrogen chloride (HCl). This gas is generated by the degradation of the polyvinylchloride (PVC) bag-out bag. Additionally, in most cases, the nuclear material itself also releases HCl gas (due to residual chemical components associated with the material formation). The RRFMC drop tower gives the end-user the ability record and analyze high-speed video and photography and if needed aerosol mass release measurements. In this report the principal issue is the physical deformation of the 5Qt Hagan container. There were no mass release experiments of test aerosol mass in the present study.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Phase patterning of metallic glasses through superfast quenching of ion irradiation-induced thermal spikes

Amorphous metallic glasses (MGs) convert to crystalline solids upon annealing at a high temperature. Such a phase change, however, does not occur with the local melting caused by damage cascades introduced by ion irradiation, although the resulting thermal spikes can reach temperatures > 1000 K. This is because the quenching rate of the local melting zone is several orders of magnitude higher than the critical cooling rate for MG formation. Thus the amorphous structure is sustained. This mechanism increases the highest temperature at which irradiated MG sustains amorphous phase. More interestingly, if an irradiated MG is pre-annealed to form a polycrystalline structure, ion irradiation can locally convert this crystalline phase to an amorphous phase if the grains are nanometers in size and comparable to the damage cascade volume size. Combining pre-annealing and site selective ion irradiation, patterned crystalline-amorphous heterogeneous structures have been fabricated. This finding opens new doors for various applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

SAVY-4000 Lifetime Extension Overview for FY23

The SAVY-4000 (hereafter “SAVY) was granted a 15 year design life as of June 11, 2019. Since that time, a concerted effort to evaluate the SAVY lifetime beyond 15 years initiated. Several key gaps in knowledge were identified by subject matter expert reviewers across the complex, along with testing that should be included or addressed in the next technical basis. While surveillance has not fundamentally changed since the last life extension, many key techniques have since been identified as necessary to evaluate key container performance requirements not addressed previously (i.e. drop qualification release rate). FY23 provided an opportunity to establish the groundwork for the development of those key techniques that aid in addressing DOE Manual 441.1-1 (hereafter “Manual”) requirements for safe storage of nuclear material.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Transition in helium bubble strengthening of copper from quasi-static to dynamic deformation

Damage from low-temperature irradiation and the subsequent degradation of materials performance pose significant challenges for the storage of radioactive materials and for peripheral components in some nuclear reactor designs. Fully understanding the mechanical behavior of such materials requires test data for strain rates in both the quasi-static (< 10/s) and dynamic (>> 10/s) regimes. While dynamic testing has generally been avoided in the past for neutron irradiated (contamination concerns) and ion irradiated (insufficient volume) materials, surface-sensitive Richtmyer-Meshkov instability (RMI) tests were used in the present work to overcome these limitations. Here, nanopillar compression, nanoindentation, and RMI testing data from a helium implanted surface layer (~10 µm thick) were compiled to explore the effects of helium bubbles on the materials strength of high-purity copper at strain rates of 0.001/s – 10 8 /s. While nano-mechanical testing revealed increases in yield strength and hardness with increasing helium dose from 1000 to 4000 appm He, RMI indicated no significant changes in strength as compared to unimplanted copper. Here, this discrepancy in behavior was rationalized through a combination of recent literature and follow-on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, leading to the conclusion that the nanoscale helium bubbles acting as dispersed barriers to dislocation motion at quasi-static strain rates collapse under shock loading and cease to be effective barriers at high strain rates.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Micromechanical properties of spherical and facetted He bubble loaded copper

Exploring new irradiation resistant materials requires understanding their mechanical responses to irradiation. Resistance to helium bubble formation and understanding bubble effects on the mechanical response of candidate materials are crucial factors to qualify materials as irradiation resistant. Here, in this paper, we explore the effect of spherical and facetted helium bubbles on the mechanical response of copper via in-situ micromechanical tensile testing at room temperature. Bubble formation and shape effects on strength and ductility, and their behavior on grain boundaries are discussed and compared to literature. Loading Cu with helium bubbles is shown here to increase strength but decrease ductility.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Advancing Vision-based Feedback and Convolutional Neural Networks for Visual Outlier Detection

Machine learning has matured into a technology that has immediate applicability to the surveillance needs of nuclear material storage containers. These containers at LANL are the barrier preventing release of radioactive material to the workers, public, and environment during the storage period of the material. Annual surveillance activities can only provide coverage on a handful of containers. There is a significant need for surveillance tools to identify potential issues and precursors to containment failure that can be used during opportunistic inspections and, more generally, outside of annual surveillance activities. In this report we provide details on the advancement of our proposed embodiment that combines an automation system for taking pictures and a high-accuracy machine learning-driven object detection software. We further showcase the improvements on the software side with progress on extracting unique identification features and advances in detecting damage. The current state of the system captures subject matter expert training and a space-conscious design whose implementation is envisioned in the near future.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

Evaluating Corrosion Effects on the Stainless Steel Components of the SAVY-4000/Hagan Nuclear Material Storage Containers: FY2022 Update

This report summarizes the work completed and underway for the Corrosion Working Group (CWG) for FY2022 in support of evaluating a greater than a 15 year design life for the SAVY4000. The CWG meets on an as needed basis to review new work, results or information regarding the corrosion of SAVY-4000 and Hagan nuclear material storage containers. The goal when analyzing corrosion is to develop a design life appropriate for the containers and to identify when a container should be removed from service. There are many parallel efforts associated with identifying and extending the service life of nuclear material storage containers. This report includes information from research and development efforts to address the lifetime. The CWG is closely related to surveillance activities and continues to play a role in identification of issues and paths forward for analysis of surveillance containers. This work summarizes the completed tasks for FY22 of the CWG while keeping in mind that some efforts continue into future years. Brief summaries of identified new avenues of work have been identified for FY23.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Improving Non-Destructive Detection Technology Through SAVY Feature Detection

Surveillance of special nuclear material (SNM) storage containers is required by the DOE to assess their integrity across the Complex. This work aims to improve the task of container inspections by leveraging automation through machine learning (ML) tools to reduce the human-intensive effort and expert-level knowledge needed to assess container status. A field-deployable, non-destructive technology was designed using off-the-shelf components to collect multiple images from different perspectives of containers in storage to detect both spatial features of interest and anomalies of concern. Nine ML models were generated using unique training datasets and parameters. Learned features include SAVY surface regions including the body side wall, collar, lid, filter, and printed/etched information. Average Precision (AP) is used to calculate detection performance when both viewing previously seen environments and previously unseen environments. The application of image transformations and resolution scaling while training greatly improved the detection performance in unseen environments, and significantly increasing the number of computation iterations improved detection performance on previously seen environments. Additional capabilities were developed including the novel detection of procedural non-compliance and the ability to localize anomalies relative to SAVY surface features.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

A Demonstration of Intelligent Container Surveillance Using Stationary and Mobile Camera Platforms

Surveillance of nuclear material storage containers is required to ensure that the container safety boundary is maintained during the service life of the container. As many of these container types are the first and only containment barrier to release protecting the worker, public, and environment, it is imperative to develop robust surveillance tools to characterize container degradation. Machine learning (ML) techniques have matured quickly in the past decade and are slowly becoming a routine application in data analysis. While more popular architectures have been developed with different applications in mind, these can be easily translated to container surveillance requirements. In this study, we developed a ML model based on the Detectron2 framework to identify slip lid containers and common exterior container defects, primarily dents. Commercial-off-the-shelf cameras are combined into a stationary camera array or are mounted to a robotic arm to provide more mobility for positioning needs. Results from the model evaluations on the images indicate that the stationary camera arrays outperform the accuracy of the mobile camera systems for both individual camera and composite image detections. Overall, however, the detection accuracies of the systems fell short of 50% and were less than satisfactory. Future efforts to improve the system involve focusing on a single camera deployable solution that combines a controllable light source that eliminates one of the biggest environmental factors that influence ML model detection performance. Additional training set collection is planned to build a more robust model that enables accurate detection from a wider range of imaging conditions.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

Dynamic properties of FeCrMnNi, a high entropy alloy

The goal of this paper was to assess the dynamic properties of a new class of materials, High entropy alloys (HEAs). Specifically, gas gun experiments coupled with recovery were performed on a specific HEA, FeCrMnNi, to measure its equation of state (EOS) and its spall strength, which is a measure of the stress required to nucleate voids under shock loading conditions. While there has been a plethora of work performed to assess the mechanical properties of these HEAs under uniaxial stress conditions as a function of strain rate, investigation of its properties in dynamic extremes remains rare. The current work fills this gap in knowledge for this novel class of materials. Our results show that the measured EOS for this material at one velocity was in reasonable agreement with an estimated Hugoniot. Furthermore, while the spall strength for this material was found to be ~1.9 GPa, with some variation based on sample location, the main failure mode was brittle. This brittle failure leading to formation of cracks in the material is different than the ductile failure observed in pure iron and its alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effects of helium cavity size and morphology on the strength of pure titanium

In this study, high-purity α-titanium was implanted with helium to observe cavity morphology – size, number density, and form (i.e., bubbles vs. voids) – effects on materials strength. Increasing implantation temperatures lead to an Arrhenius-type (i.e., exponential) increase in cavity size, a transition from spherical bubbles to faceted voids, and a marked increase in strength (~20–50%). Implanted samples deformed uniformly in contrast to nano-compression of unimplanted or alloyed titanium, but pillars with the largest faceted voids developed a type of bulging localized deformation. Affected voids were repeatedly sheared, becoming rough and shrunken. Dislocation-cavity interactions and the role of helium content within cavities are considered.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Void swelling of conventional and composition engineered HT9 alloys after high-dose self-ion irradiation

Ferritic/martensitic (F/M) steels are being considered as potential structural materials for next generation nuclear reactors, and variants of the alloy HT9 are some of the most promising candidates. In this study, two conventional and two composition engineered HT9 alloys were irradiated using 3.5 MeV Fe 2+ up to 600 peak displacement-per-atom (dpa) at 450 °C. Void swelling and microstructure evolution were characterized for each alloy and compared. The two conventional HT9 alloys (INL and ACO3) showed similar void swelling behavior due to their similar elemental composition and processing conditions. The INL HT9 exhibited a maximum of 2.4% swelling and the ACO3 HT9 showed a maximum of 2.8% swelling at 342 and 393 average local dpa, respectively. On the other hand, the two-composition engineered HT9 alloys with varying N contents (10 ppm for low N and 440 ppm for high N) showed disparate swelling behavior. The low N HT9 exhibited a maximum of 4.6% swelling, while the high N HT9 showed a maximum of 0.7% swelling at 342 average local dpa. Changes in the N content also affected Ni/Si rich G-phase formation. The low N HT9 showed a larger size and lower density of G-phase precipitates compared with the high N HT9 after 600 peak dpa irradiation. This study compares the void swelling behavior of the ion irradiated four current HT9 alloys to extremely high doses, with the void swelling data from neutron irradiated HT9 alloys. Furthermore, the comparison lends critical insights into how well these current alloys can withstand high neutron fluxes in future reactors, especially since the low N and high N HT9 alloys have never been exposed to such high doses before.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Solid-State Welding of the Nanostructured Ferritic Alloy 14YWT Using a Capacitive Discharge Resistance Welding Technique

Joining nanostructured ferritic alloys (NFAs) has proved challenging, as the nano-oxides that provide superior strength, creep resistance, and radiation tolerance at high temperatures tend to agglomerate, redistribute, and coarsen during conventional fusion welding. In this study, capacitive discharge resistance welding (CDRW)—a solid-state variant of resistance welding—was used to join end caps and thin-walled cladding tubes of the NFA 14YWT. The resulting solid-state joints were found to be hermetically sealed and were characterized across the weld region using electron microscopy (macroscopic, microscopic, and nanometer scales) and nanoindentation. Microstructural evolution near the weld line was limited to narrow (~50–200 μm) thermo-mechanically affected zones (TMAZs) and to a reduction in pre-existing component textures. Dispersoid populations (i.e., nano-oxides and larger oxide particles) appeared unchanged by all but the highest energy and power CDRW condition, with this extreme producing only minor nano-oxide coarsening (~2 nm → ~5 nm Ø). Despite a minimal microstructural change, the TMAZs were found to be ~10% softer than the surrounding base material. These findings are considered in terms of past solid-state welding (SSW) efforts—cladding applications and NFA-like materials in particular—and in terms of strengthening mechanisms in NFAs and the potential impacts of localized temperature–strain conditions during SSW.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗