Assessment of Thermal Hydraulic Feedback Models
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Graham, Aaron.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This theory manual describes the three-dimensional (3-D) whole-core, pin-resolved transport calculation methodology employed in the MPACT code. To provide sub-pin level power distributions with sufficient accuracy, MPACT employs the method of characteristics (MOC) solutions in the framework of a 3-D coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) formulation. MPACT provides a 3D MOC solution, but also a 2D/1D solution in which the 2D planar solution is provided by MOC and the axial coupling is resolved by one-dimensional (1-D) lower order (diffusion or P3) solutions.
The MPACT (Michigan PArallel Charactistics based Transport) code is designed to perform high-fidelity light water reactor (LWR) analysis using whole-core pin-resolved neutron transport calculations on modern parallel-computing hardware. The code consists of several libraries which provide the functionality necessary to solve steady-state eigenvalue problems. Several transport capabilities are available within MPACT including both 2-D and 3-D Method of Characteristics (MOC). A three-dimensional whole core solution based on the 2D-1D solution method provides the capability for full core depletion calculations.
This paper describes the methodology developed and implemented in MPACT for performing high-fidelity pressurized water reactor (PWR) multi-cycle core physics calculations. MPACT is being developed primarily for application within the Consortium for the Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) as one of the main components of the VERA Core Simulator, the others being COBRA-TF and ORIGEN. The methods summarized in this paper include a methodology for performing resonance self-shielding and computing macroscopic cross sections, 2-D/1-D transport, nuclide depletion, thermal-hydraulic feedback, and other supporting methods. These methods represent a minimal set needed to simulate high-fidelity models of a realistic nuclear reactor. Results demonstrating this are presented from the simulation of a realistic model of the first cycle of Watts Bar Unit 1. The simulation, which approximates the cycle operation, is observed to be within 50 ppm boron (ppmB) reactivity for all simulated points in the cycle and approximately 15 ppmB for a consistent statepoint. The verification and validation of the PWR cycle depletion capability in MPACT is the focus of two companion papers.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The milestone for the operational reactor depletion demonstrates a cycle depletion simulation of Watt's Bar Unit 1 Cycle 1. The simulation was performed using the VERA-CS components MPACT and COBRA-TF. The simulation was performed on the Titan and Eos machines at the Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility. The simulation results include the critical boron concentration, the pin resolved power, temperature, and fluid density distributions, and detector responses as a function of time. These results are presented and the critical boron concentration is compared with measured data. The comparison is reasonable given the modeling approximation used at this point. Several suggestions, both near and longer term, are given for areas of future work which include improving the methods, data, models, and computational performance. For those solution results which are not compared to measurement, e.g. power and temperature distributions, their behavior coincides with analysts' expectations. An important next step in the validation of VERA-CS will be the comparison of the computational results to the measured flux data. To satisfy this L1 milestone, numerous capabilities were successfully added as a part of supporting L2 and L3 milestones. These include: full core depletion, generation of a new cross section library, coupling of neutronics and thermal hydraulic feedback, and detector response modeling. In addition to the operational reactor depletion, several 2-D core parametric studies were performed to assess the new simulation capability and to develop guidelines on model approximations and discretizations. Some of the conclusions from these studies are: • The simulation of B-10 depletion in the coolant is necessary to accurately predict critical boron concentrations, • If the end of cycle state is of primary interest in the simulation, then significant approximations may be made in the cycle history. The ability to make use of this approximation without a notable loss in accuracy will considerably accelerate multi-cycle analysis, • The new 47-group cross section library with a transport correction of the P 0 scattering can provide solutions very efficiently and which are nearly as accurate as solutions generated with explicit P 2 scattering, and • Simplified modeling of the equilibrium xenon concentration is well predicted by the existing depletion solver, and only in certain circumstances (e.g. large and "instantaneous" changes to rod position or T/H conditions) would an explicit physical model need to be included. Overall the milestone is considered a success as the objectives were met and several new and important results were produced from this work. The results and conclusions of this milestone will continue to guide future work and become the basis for addressing the CASL Challenge Problems.
MPACT is a three-dimensional (3-D) whole core transport code capable of generating sub-pin level power distributions. This feature is accomplished by obtaining the integral transport solutions to the heterogeneous reactor problem in which the actual detailed geometrical configuration of fuel components such as the pellet and cladding is modelled explicitly.. The cross section data needed for the neutron transport calculation are obtained directly from a multigroup microscopic cross section library similar to those used in lattice physics codes. Hence MPACT involves neither a priori homogenization nor group condensation for the core spatial solution. The integral transport solution is obtained by means of the method of characteristics (MOC) that employs discrete ray tracing. Since the direct application of the 3-D MOC capability in MPACT to 3-D core configuration requires considerable amounts of memory and computing time for practical reactor applications, an alternative approximate 3-D solution method was implemented in MPACT based on a 2D-1D approach which employs planar MOC solutions in the framework of the 3-D coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) formulation. The axial coupling is resolved by one-dimensional (1-D) diffusion solutions and the planar and axial problems are coupled through the transverse leakage. The use of a lower order 1-D solution in the axial direction is justified by the fact that most heterogeneity in the core occurs in the radial direction rather than the axial. However, it is possible to use one of the higher order methods in MPACT such as the 1-D SN kernel if improved solution accuracy is desired. The CMFD formulation which originally served as an efficient nodal formulation is used in MPACT to accelerate the whole core transport calculation. The basic mesh in the CMFD formulation is a pin cell which is much coarser than the flat source regions defined for MOC calculations. The concept of dynamic homogenization of group constants for the pin cells provides the basis of the CMFD formulation in whole core transport calculation. The intra-cell flux distribution determined from the MOC calculation is used to generate the homogenized cell constants while the MOC cell surface averaged currents are used to determine the radial nodal coupling coefficients. This dynamic implementation of the equivalence theory formulation ensures the same transport solution is obtained with CMFD as the one obtained using unaccelerated MOC calculations alone. The ability of MPACT to predict the Hot, Zero Power (HZP) condition of a reactor was reported in CASL-U-2014-0045-000. The purpose of this report is to demonstrate the capability of MPACT to simulate the operation of a reactor at Hot, Full Power (HFP) conditions during normal operation throughout a full operating cycle. The time scale for a reactor burnup cycle is typically one to two years and therefore short time phenomena such as the effect of delayed neutrons can be neglected. Instead the time dependence can be treated quasi-statically using the depletion algorithm presented in CASL-U-2013-0276-001. The full power operation requires thermal hydraulic feedback to be present during the entire simulation which will utilize the work in CASL-U-2014-0051-000. However, due to the significant computational burden of the coupled physics simulation, a simplified thermal hydraulic model is used for the analysis reported here which is principally intended to demonstrate the full core neutronics depletion. In addition to the thermal hydraulic feedback, the effect of Boron 10 depletion should be modeled in cases where major boron additions are not performed for extended periods of time. Each of these capabilities will be described in the following sections.