Arecibo Observatory Auxiliary M4N Socket Termination Failure Analysis
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Azita Valinia↗
Engineering topics
Gregory Harrigan
Publications and source records attributed to Gregory Harrigan.
Arecibo Observatory Auxiliary M4N Socket Termination Failure Investigation
The NASA Engineering and Safety Center (NESC) was requested to support the Arecibo Observatory failure investigation in determining the root cause of the Auxiliary M4N cable failure. The NESC and Kennedy Space Center led an integrated NASA investigation with support from Marshall Space Flight Center and The Aerospace Corporation that included forensic investigation of failed hardware, finite element modeling, materials characterization, and root cause analysis. This document contains the outcome of the NESC Assessment.
Zinc Spelter Sockets↗
Structural Analysis Findings of Open Spelter Socket Cable Terminations
A three-dimensional nonlinear finite element model of a representative open spelter socket termination was developed to examine the underlying mechanics of load transfer from a structural cable through the termination, the sensitivity of the joint design to wire brooming, zinc material nonlinearity, contact friction between the zinc and socket, voids within the zinc, and, finally, the effects of repeated loading on the joint. Primary factors affecting open spelter socket design are cast zinc plastic flow, depth of zinc slug seating, and quality of wire brooming. Zinc plasticity and proper brooming allows for efficient load transfer by developing confining pressure on the broomed wires in the narrow part of the socket, which keep the wires from pulling out of the zinc and shift failure to occur outside the socket. Highest wire stresses in the cable occur in the outer ring adjacent to the termination. While industry use of stay cables are typically designed to carry less than half the rated breaking force in aggregate, the constituent stresses within the zinc and the wires have the potential to exceed their respective allowable in operation and should be evaluated for fatigue- and creep-critical applications.
Pavel Babuska↗
Lessons Learned from the Arecibo Observatory Auxiliary M4N Socket Analysis and Implications for Future Observatory Designs
The Arecibo Observatory collapsed after a progressive structural failure stemming from the failure of a single socket joint cable termination. A failure investigation was conducted to identify the cause of the first failed cable termination socket. Due to the nature of the suspended observatory receiver, the dominant source of loading in the suspension cables was due to deadload, with secondary contributions coming from environmental effects and observatory operation. The high ratio of deadload vs. live load applied to the cable over many years resulted in a creep failure mode of the cast zinc within the socket which further induced stress into the highly stress wires at the entrance of the socket. The design of the socket joint did not explicitly consider socket constituent stress margins and time-dependent damage mechanisms such as creep. Lessons learned from this investigation led to recommendations for revising civil engineering cable standards, and recommendations for manufacturers and designers. The design of cables employing socket terminations should consider the cumulative damage effects from creep and cyclic loading identify their corresponding worst-case inspectable defects or establish a sufficiently high factor of safety so that the design is sufficiently robust to defects and time-dependent failure modes. The design should specify end-of-life capability and set service life inspection intervals with pass/fail inspection criteria. Finally, trial studies on design iterations were conducted to increase the reliability of cables with socket joints.
Pavel Babuska↗