Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Harouaka, Khadouja

Publications and source records attributed to Harouaka, Khadouja.

Abatement of ionizing radiation for superconducting quantum devices

Ionizing radiation has been shown to reduce the performance of superconducting quantum circuits. In this report, we evaluate the expected contributions of different sources of ambient radioactivity for typical superconducting qubit experiment platforms. Our assessment of radioactivity inside a typical cryostat highlights the importance of selecting appropriate materials for the experiment components nearest to qubit devices, such as packaging and electrical interconnects. We present a shallow underground facility (30-meter water equivalent) to reduce the flux of cosmic rays and a lead shielded cryostat to abate the naturally occurring radiogenic gamma-ray flux in the laboratory environment. We predict that superconducting qubit devices operated in this facility could experience a reduced rate of correlated multi-qubit errors by a factor of approximately 20 relative to the rate in a typical above-ground, unshielded facility. Finally, we outline overall design improvements that would be required to further reduce the residual ionizing radiation rate, down to the limit of current generation direct detection dark matter experiments.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Assessing Gas-Phase Ion Reactivity of 50 Elements with NO and the Direct Application for 239 Pu in Complex Matrices Using ICP-MS/MS

Understanding the reactivity of metal cations with various reaction gases in ICP-MS/MS is important to determine the best gas to use for a given analyte/interference pair. In this study, nitric oxide (NO) was investigated as the reaction gas following previous experimental designs. The reactions with 50 elements were investigated to examine periodic trends in reactivity, validate theoretical modeling of reaction enthalpies as a method to screen reactant gases, and provide a baseline for potential in-line gas separation methods. ICP-MS/MS studies involving actinides are typically limited to Th, U and Pu, with analyses of Np and Am rarely reported in the literature. To date, only two previous methods have investigated the use of NO in ICP-MS/MS analyses. To showcase the utility of NO, a method was developed to measure 239 Pu in the presence of environmental matrix constituent and other actinides, like what could be expected from post-detonation debris, with no chemical separation prior to analysis. 239 Pu + was reacted to form 239 Pu 16 O + , eliminating interferences derived from the sample matrix by measuring 239 Pu + intensity at m/z = 255 ( 239 Pu 16 O + ). To validate NO for 238 U 1 H + interference removal in environmental matrices, standard reference materials were diluted to 1 mg per gram of solution and spiked to 0.05 pg/g of 239 Pu and 1 µg/g 238 U (Pu/U = 5 x 10 -8 ). Measured 239 Pu concentrations were within 6% of the spiked value. In conclusion, these results demonstrate that reliable 239 Pu measurements can be made at levels relevant to nuclear forensics without the need for extensive chemical matrix separation prior to analysis.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

The importance of ion kinetic energy for interference removal in ICP-MS/MS

Here, the effect of ion kinetic energy on gas phase ion reactivity with ICP-MS/MS was investigated in order to explore tuning strategies for interference removal. The collision/reaction gases CO 2 , N 2 O and O 2 were used to observe the ion product distribution for 48 elements using an Agilent tandem ICP-MS (ICP-MS/MS) as a function of reaction gas flow rate (pressure) and ion kinetic energy. The kinetic energy of the incident ion was varied by adjusting the octopole bias (V oct ). The three gases all form oxides (MO + ) as the primary product with differing reaction enthalpies that result in distinct differences in the ion energies required for reaction with product ion distributions that vary with Voct. Consequently, by varying the ion kinetic energy (i.e., V oct ), differences in interference reactivity can be used to achieve maximum separation. Three practical application examples were reported to demonstrate how the ion kinetic energy can be varied to achieve the ideal ion product distribution for interference resolution: CO 2 for the removal of 238 U in Pu analyses, CO 2 for the removal of 40 Ar 16 O vs. 56 Fe, and O 2 for the removal of Sm in Eu analyses, analogous to Pu/Am. The results demonstrate how the starting ion energy defined by V oct is an important factor to fully leverage the utility of any given reaction gas to remove interferences in the mass spectrum using ICP-MS/MS.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Development of a hybrid neural network and transfer learning model for optimized ICP-MS/MS operation

Correct function and calibration of instrumentation is a crucial assumption for any scientific experiment. One such instrument, tandem inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS/MS), has in-depth calibration settings that range across 30+ different parameters, making it difficult to determine optimal conditions without expertise and some degree of trial and error. Often, these settings are hand-tuned, a time-intensive process prone to local maxima and human error. While some automation is available, the automation also may favor local optimizations over a global optimum. In addition to these difficulties, day to day instrument variability can further complicate the calibration process. We propose a solution to this problem as a machine learning (ML) algorithm that learns how each parameter helps determine the calibration sensitivity across several elements, and re-weights parameters over time as instrument variability changes (e.g., a global neural network (NN) with a time-dependent transfer learning (TL) component). This model would be able to generate a surface of predicted calibration sensitivities and their respective parameters, and a simple multivariate algorithm would be able to pull out the optimum results with the settings associated with them. Here-in, we describe our initial findings in working towards this goal, including data extraction from historical files, exploratory data analysis, and some initial model building to better describe the data and the feasibility of our goal.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Fayda

The Fayda application developed as a part of the Reaction Roulette m/q LDRD project (76006) primarily exists as a data visualization, analysis and predictive platform for data collected using atomic tandem inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS/MS)

Harouaka, Khadouja↗

Utilizing metal cation reactions with carbonyl sulfide to remove isobaric interferences in tandem inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry analyses

Carbonyl sulfide (OCS) was used as a reaction gas to investigate gas phase metal (M + ) ion-molecule reactions using the Agilent 8900 inductively coupled plasma tandem mass spectrometer (ICP-MS/MS) to yield insight on how this gas may be used to remove isobaric interferences in analytical measurements. The experimental work was paired with density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the reaction enthalpy to predict whether M + will react with OCS. A multi-element standard containing 46 elements ranging from 9 to 208 u was analyzed in the presence and absence of OCS. When a reaction was observed, the dominant product was the sulfide (MS + ). Oxide products were also observed for many M + but formation was less efficient with OCS than previously observed with other reaction gases. This is likely due to the weaker OC-S bond that makes MS + formation more favorable. Increasing the flow rate from 0.1 to 0.2 mL/min (corresponding to a change in reaction gas pressure from 0.35 to 0.53 Pa (2.6 to 4.0 mTorr)) generally resulted in greater MS + production, including the secondary product MS 2 + for a few cations. The early lanthanide series ions (La + , Ce + , Pr + and Nd + ) produced greater quantities of MO + at the higher pressure, although MS + products were still the dominant product. The DFT-predicted reaction enthalpies were consistent with the observed sulfide formation, with an accuracy >90%; however, model predictions were less accurate for the minor and higher order products (< 77% for MO + ). Finally, the work presented here continues a systematic study of ion-molecule reactions in ICP-MS/MS to understand and develop new and novel ways to analyze complex mixtures with minimal pre-analysis treatment.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mass spectrometric investigations into 3D printed parts to assess radiopurity as ultralow background materials for rare event physics detectors

The mass concentrations of 232 Th and 238 U in several 3D printing filaments and printed polymer parts are reported as measures of their radiopurity. In order to minimize background signals in rare event physics detectors, radiopure polymers are necessary as dielectric and structural materials in their construction. New data are reported for polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), polyphenylene sulfide (PPS), and two forms of polyetherimide (PEI, branded ULTEM 1010 and 9085). Data for starting filaments and both simple and complex printed parts are reported. PVDF filaments and simple printed beads, were found to have values of approximately 30 and 50 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, while a more complex spring clip part had slightly elevated 232 Th levels of 65 pg g -1 , with 238 U remaining at 50 pg g -1 . PPS filament was found to have concentrations of 270 and 710 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, and were not chosen to be printed as those levels were already higher than other material options. ULTEM 1010 filaments and printed complex spring clip parts were found to have concentrations of around 5 and 7 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, illustrating no significant contamination from the printing process. ULTEM 9085 filaments were found to have concentrations of around 9 and 5 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively, while the printed complex spring clip part was found to have slightly elevated concentrations of 25 and 7 pg g -1 for 232 Th and 238 U, respectively. All these results were obtained using a novel dry ashing method in crucibles constructed of ultralow background electroformed copper or, when applicable, microwave assisted wet ashing digestion. Samples and process blanks were spiked with 229 Th and 233 U as internal standards prior to dry/wet ashing and determinations were made by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). In order to maintain high radiopurity levels, pre-cleaning the filaments before printing and post-cleaning the parts is recommended, although the printing process itself has shown to contribute very minute amounts of radiocontaminants.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Gas‐Phase Ion‐Molecule Interactions in a Collision Reaction Cell with ICP‐MS / MS : Investigations with CO 2 as the Reaction Gas

Carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) was used as a reaction gas to investigate the gas‐phase ion‐molecule interactions using the Agilent 8900 ICP‐MS/MS. A solution containing forty‐five elements representative of the periodic table was used to supply the ions to react with CO 2 in the collision/reaction cell (CRC). The only significant product ions formed were monoxides. The general reactivity was shown to be consistent with density functional theory (DFT)‐predicted reaction enthalpies, such that all predicted exothermic reactions produced product ions at levels of at least 1% of the unreacted ion. Most endothermic reactions observed had sufficient kinetic energy in excess of the reaction enthalpies. Our results suggest that reaction enthalpy is a reasonable predictor of reactivity with CO 2 on the timescales of the interactions in non‐thermal ICP‐MS/MS systems. The ease and rapidity of data collection with the ICP‐MS/MS and DFT calculations using the NWChem suite has value given the scarcity of thermochemical data of CO 2 reactions in the literature. These studies are especially useful for the identification of targeted reaction chemistries to be leveraged for analytical method development, such as for the inline separation of isobaric interferences from analytes of interest.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Activation of CO 2 by Actinide Cations (Th + , U + , Pu + , and Am + ) as Studied by Guided Ion Beam and Triple Quadrupole Mass Spectrometry

Reactions of CO 2 with Th+ have been studied using guided ion beam tandem mass spectrometry (GIBMS) and with An + (An + = Th + , U + , Pu + , and Am + ) using triple quadrupole inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (QQQ-ICP-MS). Additionally, the reactions ThO + + CO and ThO + + CO 2 were examined using GIBMS. Modeling the kinetic energy dependent GIBMS data allowed determination of bond dissociation energies (BDEs) for D o (Th + -O) and D o (OTh + -O) that are in reasonable agreement with previous GIBMS measurements. The QQQ-ICP-MS reactions were studied at higher pressures where multiple collisions between An + and the neutral CO 2 occur. As a consequence, both AnO + and AnO 2 + products were observed for all An + except Am + , where only AmO + was observed. Here, the relative abundances of the observed monoxides compared to the dioxides are consistent with previous reports of the AnO n + (n = 1, 2) BDEs. Comparison of the periodic trends of the group 4 transition metal, lanthanide (Ln), and actinide atomic cations in reactions with CO 2 (a formally spin-forbidden reaction for most M + ground states), and O 2 (a spin unrestricted reaction) indicate that spin conservation plays a minor role, if any, for the heavier An + metals. Further correlation of Ln + and An + + CO 2 reaction efficiencies with the promotion energy (E p ) to the first electronic state with two valence d-electrons (E p (5d 2 ) for Ln + and E p (6d 2 ) for An + ) indicates that the primary limitation in the activation of CO 2 is the energetic cost to promote from the electronic ground state of the atomic metal ion to a reactive state.

bond activation↗

Gas-phase ion-molecule interactions in a collision reaction cell with triple quadrupole-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry: Investigations with N 2 O as the reaction gas

Nitrous oxide (N 2 O) was used as a reaction gas to investigate the gas phase ion-molecule interactions using the Agilent 8900 QQQ-ICP-MS. A multi-element standard containing 45 elements with masses ranging from 9 to 208 u was measured in the presence and absence of N 2 O. The main product ion species observed were oxides and nitrides. Comparison of the N 2 O reaction results with similar measurements conducted with O 2 revealed that N 2 O was more effective at forming oxides in general: the elements Cd and Pb were shown to produce oxides with N 2 O where the reaction did not occur with O 2 . Nitrous oxide was also shown to produce a significant amount of nitride species in a few cases. The general reactivity was shown to be consistent with density functional theory (DFT)-predicted reaction enthalpies, such that all predicted exothermic reactions produced product ions at levels at least 1% of the unreacted ion. Our results show that reaction enthalpy is a reasonable predictor of reactivity with N2O on the timescales of the interactions in non-thermal ICP-MS/MS systems. Our work demonstrates the utility of two relatively new platforms (commercial elemental ICP-MS/MS and EMSL Arrows interface to the NWChem program suite), which allows for the study of a large number of elements within a short period. While DFT with the basis sets utilized here is not the most accurate computational method, it is also not computationally expensive and is shown to be suitable for predicting gas phase reactivity in the QQQ-ICP-MS for the majority of ions studied. Here, the ease and rapidity of data collection and DFT calculations has the potential to be very impactful for the identification of targeted reaction chemistries to be leveraged for analytical method development, such as for the inline separation of isobaric interferences from analytes of interest.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

A preliminary investigation into the electrodeposition and synthesis of radiopure Copper–Chromium alloys for rare-event physics detector systems

Current investigations into neutrinoless double beta decay and the direct detection of dark matter require increasingly sensitive detector systems that demand ultra-low background materials. These requirements have previously been attained using ultra-radiopure electroformed (EF) copper. However, pure copper possesses high ductility and relatively low strength, which necessitates the need for large amounts of material and extra care during fabrication to help minimize galling and mechanical failure. Furthermore, we investigate an alloying alternative to pure EF copper by examining low wt% copper chrome (Cu–Cr) solid solution alloys, with inquiries into alloy hardness, strength, and radiopurity. Alloyed Cu–Cr layered samples are shown to exhibit significantly increased hardness compared to EF copper, for example showing a 50% increase in exhibited hardness using less than 1% Cr by weight, with limited negative impact to the material’s radiopurity.

Background↗

Ultra-low radioactivity Kapton and copper-Kapton laminates

Polyimide-based materials, like Kapton, are widely used in flexible cables and circuitry due to their unique electrical and mechanical characteristics. This study is aimed at investigating the radiopurity of Kapton for use in ultralow background, rare-event physics applications by measuring the 238U, 232Th, and natK levels using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Commercial-off-the-shelf Kapton varieties, mea- sured at approximately 950 and 120 pg/g 238U and 232Th (1.2×104 and 490 µBq/kg), respectively, can be a significant background source for many current and next-generation ultralow background detectors. This study has found that the dominant contamination is due to the use of dicalcium phosphate (DCP), a nonessential slip additive added during manufacturing. Alternative Kapton materials were obtained that did not contain DCP and were determined to be significantly more radiopure than the commercially- available options with 12 and 19 pg/g 238U and 232Th (150 and 77 µBq/kg), respectively. The lowest radioactivity version produced (Kapton ELJ, which contains an adhesive) was found to contain single digit pg/g levels of 238U and 232Th, two-to-three orders of magnitude cleaner than commercial-off-the- shelf options. Moreover, copper-clad polyimide laminates employing Kapton ELJ as the insulator were obtained and measured and showed to be very radiopure at 8.6 and 22 pg/g 238U and 232Th (110 and 89 µBq/kg), respectively.

Arnquist, Isaac J.↗