Search NASASearch

Engineering topics

Herbert, Thorwald

Publications and source records attributed to Herbert, Thorwald.

Simulations of Boundary-Layer Transition

For incompressible benchmark flows, we have demonstrated the capability of the parabolized stability equations (PSE) to simulate the transition process in excellent agreement with microscopic experiments and direct Navier-Stokes simulations at modest computational cost. Encouraged by these results, we have developed the PSE methodology of three-dimensional boundary-layers in general curvilinear coordinates for the range from low to hypersonic speeds, and for both linear and nonlinear problems. For given initial and boundary conditions, the approach permits simulations from receptivity through linear and secondary instabilities into the late stages of transition where significant changes in skin friction and heat transfer coefficients occur. We have performed transition simulations for a variety of two- and three-dimensional similarity solutions and for realistic flows over swept wings at subsonic and supersonic speeds, the pressure ans suction side of turbine blades at low and medium turbulence levels, and over a blunt cone at Mach number Ma = 8. We present selected results for different transition mechanisms with emphasis on the late stage of transition and the evolution of wall-shear stress and heat transfer.

Herbert, Thorwald

Transition in Turbine Flows

We have further developed our capabilities to analyze transition in turbine boundary layers from first principles by integrating the nonlinear parabolized stability equations (PSE) with improved initial and boundary conditions. With modified iteration schemes, we are able to proceed deeper into the transition region where skin friction coefficient and heat transfer coefficient significantly increase. Initial and boundary conditions at elevated turbulence levels can be derived by receptivity analysis. Test runs for ERCOFTAC test case T3A at 2.4\% turbulence level provide results in good agreement with the experimental data. The sharper minimum of the skin coefficient also shown by DNS results is likely due to the missing intermittency. The method has been applied to various experimentally studied turbine blades (UTRC, VKI, Zierke, Langston, Hippensteele, and others). The PSE results, though physically reasonable, do not agree as well as expected with the experimental findings. We have, therefore, performed an extensive search for the reasons of the seemingly systematic deviations. A first source of uncertainty has been found in the often insufficient documentation of the experiments (e.g. on blockage by end-wall boundary layers). However, variation of the relevant parameters does not lead to more satisfactory agreement. A second reason has been found in the "standard procedure" which considers a 2D flow at midspan and uses a panel code and subsequent boundary-layer code to obtain the laminar basic flow for the transition analysis. Comparison with the pressure distribution obtained with a 3D design code (RVC3D) shows significant three-dimensionality of the flow (e.g. in the UTRC experiments). The spanwise variation has been neglected in our original PSE code. To overcome this problem, we have developed the PSE/3D for fully 3D boundary layers to account for streamwise and spanwise variations. Since the design code does not provide the boundary-layer flow with sufficient resolution, we have generated the Euler solution and employed a 3D boundary-layer code to obtain the viscous basic flow. Although only the linear stability level of PSE/3D has been implemented so far, the discrepancies with the experiments change but do not disappear. We still find deviations between the computed and experimental variations of C(sub f), and St along the blade for laminar flow. The main reason can be seen by comparing the solution of the boundary-layer code with the viscous results of the design code. The conventional boundary-layer solution exhibits an asymptotic behavior appropriate in external aerodynamics but does not match the steep gradients of the inviscid flow through the passage and consequently provides biased results for C(sub f), and St. An attempt is currently being made to correct this deficiency. Before attempting to perform the transition analysis for the viscous flow provided by the design code, we have analyzed the implementation and "best possible" results. Code and results exhibit flaws that may negatively affect the design and are intolerable for transition analysis. Therefore, we have decided to develop a new code to obtain a reliable basis for stability and transition studies. We expect to report improved results by the time of the meeting.

Herbert, Thorwald

Linear Wave Motion from Concentrated Harmonic Sources in Blasius Flow

The motion of individual linear instability waves in shear flows is well described by existing theoretical and numerical methods. However, naturally occuring sources produce coherent wave motions with broadband spanwise wavenumber and frequency spectra, and the different spectral components interact both linearly and nonlinearily. This paper describes a series of calculations for the parameters of three different experiments using locally parallel linear stability theory (LST), the Parabolized Stability Equations (PSE), and Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS). The calculations illustrate the strengths and weaknesses of the different methods, the extent to which the methods agree or disagree, and, finally the extent to which agreement with the measurements can be attained, given that the experiments also have their own difficulties.

linear

Parabolized stability equations

The parabolized stability equations (PSE) are a new approach to analyze the streamwise evolution of single or interacting Fourier modes in weakly nonparallel flows such as boundary layers. The concept rests on the decomposition of every mode into a slowly varying amplitude function and a wave function with slowly varying wave number. The neglect of the small second derivatives of the slowly varying functions with respect to the streamwise variable leads to an initial boundary-value problem that can be solved by numerical marching procedures. The PSE approach is valid in convectively unstable flows. The equations for a single mode are closely related to those of the traditional eigenvalue problems for linear stability analysis. However, the PSE approach does not exploit the homogeneity of the problem and, therefore, can be utilized to analyze forced modes and the nonlinear growth and interaction of an initial disturbance field. In contrast to the traditional patching of local solutions, the PSE provide the spatial evolution of modes with proper account for their history. The PSE approach allows studies of secondary instabilities without the constraints of the Floquet analysis and reproduces the established experimental, theoretical, and computational benchmark results on transition up to the breakdown stage. The method matches or exceeds the demonstrated capabilities of current spatial Navier-Stokes solvers at a small fraction of their computational cost. Recent applications include studies on localized or distributed receptivity and prediction of transition in model environments for realistic engineering problems. This report describes the basis, intricacies, and some applications of the PSE methodology.

Herbert, Thorwald

Stability and transition on swept wings

This paper describes the extension and application of the Parabolized Stability Equations (PSE) to the stability and transition of the supersonic three-dimensional laminar boundary layer on a swept wing. The problem formulation uses a general coordinate transformation for arbitrary curvilinear body-fitted computational grids. Some testing using these coordinates is briefly described to help validate the software used for the investigation. The disturbance amplitude ratios as a function of chord position for supersonic (Mach 1.5) boundary layers on untapered, untwisted wings of different sweep angles are then presented and compared with those obtained from local parallel analyses.

Stuckert, Greg

Theory of instability and transition

The strongly nonlinear area of theory is discussed, as well as linear and weakly nonlinear (i.e., perturbation) theories, and it is noted that the weaknesses of the weakly nonlinear theory are essentially the inappropriate formulation in earlier works and the lack of guidance for the choice of the lowest-order basis. Attention is focused on the areas of theoretical/numerical development contributing to understanding the transition mechanism and new means for analyzing and predicting transition quantitatively. The nonlinear stability of nonparallel flows, linear secondary instability, and nonlinear wave interaction are analyzed. The incompressible flow over a flat plate with zero-pressure gradient is chosen as an example, while applications range to other shear flows including three-dimensional and compressible boundary layers.

Herbert, Thorwald

A code for linear stability analysis

A new spectral code, Linear.x, has been written in FORTRAN 77 for the analysis of the linear stability of some basic state. While being generic and unrelated to any particular physical problem, the code provides for various common tasks, including global (eigenvalue spectra), local (single eigenvalues and eigenfunctions), table (one-dimensional and multidimensional tables of eigenvalues), curve (curves in parameter space), and others. A specific problem can be defined as a set of files some of which are included at compile time, while definitions, tasks, and parameters are read during run time. The code is currently used for the stability analysis of compressible flows.

Herbert, Thorwald

Studies of transition in boundary layers

Some current studies on transition in boundary layers are briefly reviewed, including work based on the asymptotic transition theory. In particular, attention is given to the appearance of transition, primary instability, transition criterion, nonparallelism and nonlinearity, multistructural approach to transition, and two-dimensional nonlinear interactions. The discussion also covers secondary instability, three-dimensional interactions, Floquet theory of secondary instability, breakdown, and boundary-layer receptivity.

Herbert, Thorwald