Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Holmes, Matthew David

Publications and source records attributed to Holmes, Matthew David.

At least 19 records

Crush Gun Impact of Unconfined Explosive with Flat-Faced Projectiles at Nominal Velocity of 60 m/s

A pneumatic gun apparatus was designed and built to deliver crushing impacts at velocities of 0-70 m/s. The apparatus is designed to halt the projectile (if desired) approximately 1 mm before impacting the sapphire imaging surface, preventing a complete “pinch” condition from attaining. The primary diagnostics include high-speed visible videography and infrared imaging to determine spatial temperature rise of the sample during impact.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Crush Gun Impact of Lightly Confined Explosive with Rounded Projectiles at Nominal Velocity 35 m/s

Blunt, crushing impact of high explosives can cause internal shear heating sufficient to ignite a deflagration. Low-velocity impact of this sort is plausible in handling accident scenarios, e.g. if a charge is dropped or an object is dropped onto a charge. This mechanism can also be activated during sub-shock fragment impact. Efforts to model this viscous shear heating mechanism are currently being developed and refined. The Crush Gun apparatus was created to provide a controlled low-velocity impact stimuli to explosive samples. Infrared thermography captures temporal- and spatially-resolved heating that occurs during the impact event.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

VIPIR: A High-Throughput Drop-Weight Impact Instrument for Imaging the Initiation and Propagation of Reactions in Energetic Materials

Characterizing the handling safety and sensitivity of explosives has been a challenging area of study for over 60 years. Historically one of the most accessible and widely utilized experiments has been the drop-weight impact test, which involves dropping a weight on a small sample sandwiched between two anvils. Because this experiment generally only utilizes sound thresholds to determine whether or not a sample reacted, the physical and chemical properties governing sensitivity remain convolved. Better understanding of chemical and material characteristics is needed to give the chemistry and engineering communities a predictive tool to determine the handling sensitivity of explosives prior to pursuing expensive and potentially hazardous synthesis and formulation operations. Here, we are developing a high throughput drop tower instrument capable of imaging the deformation and flow of energetic materials during impact and the resulting thermal ignition and propagation events. This instrument is based on previous designs but has been modified for higher throughput and tailorable modifications in the future. Herein, we present key design features that enable high-speed visible and thermal imaging of explosive initiation by sub-shock impacts, as well as preliminary results in which ignition sites were observed in an erythritol tetranitrate sample.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Standardizing an Intermediate-Scale High Explosive Safety Test Suite

Small-scale safety testing, while successful in screening out extremely dangerous explosive compositions, does not fully characterize the explosive hazards associated with handling larger, consolidated or bare charges. It is proposed that intermediate-scale tests using consolidated charges in the range 25 mg – 1 kg are warranted to satisfactorily address the hazards. A standard for this intermediate-scale testing should be developed, proofed, peer-reviewed and adopted to assist in the development of safe new high explosive compositions across the complex. This whitepaper explains why current small-scale safety testing is insufficient to characterize the handling hazard, identifies the guiding aspects of explosive response that drive the handling hazards associated with larger consolidated charges, and proposes a suite of tests/experiments that can serve as a starting point for an intermediate-scale safety standard.

42 ENGINEERING↗

IHE DDT Qualification Tests (FY2020-FY2021)

A DDT tube test was designed to meet all requirements established in the new DOE IHE qualification standard. Ten tests were successfully executed with PBX 9502 as a demonstration of the design, assembly, heating system, and methods, and to establish a baseline set of test results with an existing IHE. The explosive response in all tests was low violence (as anticipated). This report contains detailed design drawings, assembly instructions and procedures for future execution of the qualification test series, and makes recommendations for minor improvements.

42 ENGINEERING↗

CISME report on experiments with HMX powder, PBX 9501 prills, and heated PBX 9501

The ability to predict post-ignition explosive response is relevant to explosives safety, particularly weapons assembly/disassembly operations that must operate under a sufficiently conservative safety basis to meet risk mitigation criteria for inadvertent nuclear detonation (IND). In particular, hazard determinations hinge on whether the PBX 9501 main charge can ultimately attain detonation from an initial, non-shock, ignition stimulus. The CISME experiment uses a spherical explosive charge, which is thermally ignited in the center using a fiber-delivered infrared laser pulse. This ignition mechanism - i.e. a localized thermal hotspot - is representative of the ignition-causing insults typical in accident scenarios, including low-velocity impact, drop, skid, and punch events. In fiscal year 2018 CISME experiments were conducted with pristine PBX 9501 spheres, confined and unconfined. Sub-detonative, low-violence reactions were observed. Here we report experiments conducted since 2018. The explosive charge was varied: experiments were conducted with room temperature pour-density HMX powder and prills of PBX 9501, and heated, thermally damaged PBX 9501. Experiments were conducted in a confined configuration, with two 4 mm-thick stainless-steel hemispherical shells bolted around the sphere. Detonation, via DDT (deflagration-to-detonation transition) was observed in the 3-inch diameter powdered HMX and the 6-inch diameter heated and thermally-damaged PBX 9501 tests. No transition to DDT was observed in smaller diameters for those configurations, and no DDT was observed for pour-density prills of PBX 9501 of any diameter. The original test series demonstrated that the response of pristine, undamaged PBX 9501 to a central ignition is relatively benign. This new test series shows that increased porosity, lack of polymer binders and thermal damage can greatly increase the violence of the post-ignition response, up to and including detonation. These results bridge the explosive response of PBX 9501 from sub-detonative through detonation as a function of diameter and provide valuable test cases for modeling efforts that strive to capture the DDT threshold. By exploring explosive response in a more representative 3D geometry, we can also benchmark these new results to more plentiful DDT datasets generated from testing in 1D tube confinement (the historical test configuration)–the configuration upon which almost all DDT models were developed.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Heavily Confined PBX 9501 Experiment Report FY2020

Most accidental insults to explosives are invariably thermal in nature—either direct thermal via application of heat or indirect thermal when mechanical energy is converted to heat. The key question is whether the initial thermal insult transitions into a violent explosive response. If the ultimate violence attained is moderate, nearby personnel may be harmed or killed, but Inadvertent Nuclear Detonation (IND) will not occur. However, if the explosive ultimately transitions from deflagration to detonation (DDT) then IND becomes a concern. PBX 9501 is not an insensitive high explosive (IHE). It has been conclusively demonstrated that mechanically and thermally damaged PBX 9501 can readily DDT in heavy confinement. However, it is currently unknown whether pristine explosive—i.e. thermally and mechanically undamaged— is capable of DDT. Three experiments were conducted in order to determine whether very heavily confined pristine PBX 9501 is capable of DDT. All experiments used identical 6-inch diameter spherical charges of PBX 9501 confined in a 350 lb. hardened steel vessel with >2.5-inch thick walls. The first, primary experiment tested pristine PBX 9501 and was thermally ignited at the center of using a laser over optical fiber. Two additional baseline experiments were performed for comparison: the second test was initiated at the center using a detonator; the third test was bulk heated until self-ignition (cookoff). Velocimetry data in combination with hydrocode simulations suggest that a classical detonation wave did not develop in the pristine, thermally ignited PBX 9501. Reaction violence was approximately equivalent—in terms of ultimate energy output—as a full detonation, but the acceleration of metal fragments occurred more slowly than in a detonation-driven scenario.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Slide Test FY 2019 Report

At Los Alamos, the Slide Test was developed in 2019 to investigate whether the mass of a main charge of explosive sliding on a gritty surface, in the absence of impact, is sufficient to heat grit to ignition temperatures in PBX 9501. This is a practical test to address frictional ignition during assembly/disassembly operations at the Pantex Plant. Twenty-seven Slide Tests were performed in total, testing PBX 9501 at various slide velocities, grit diameters, grit patterns, and charge masses. Time-resolved velocimetry of the slide event (from PDV) and spot area of the explosive charge (obtained from image analysis) is reported. High-speed videography is used to diagnose explosive reaction. Eighteen of these tests were performed with a charge mass of 30 lbs at velocities ≤ 4 m s-1 and grit diameters between 75 and 1000 µm. Nine Slide Tests were performed with a 15 lb charge mass at similar parameters. No ignition was observed in any of the tests. These data provide evidence that the mass of a main charge, caused to slide on a surface at the low velocities achievable during routine handling, is insufficient stimulus to heat grit to ignition temperatures. These findings are relevant to risk assessment for explosive handling operations and provide evidence that PBX 9501 is safe within the constraints that were tested. However, because ignitions were not observed in any of the tests, we cannot determine which variables (mass or velocity) dominate the explosive response and to what extent. The absence of observed ignition also precludes the determination of a safety margin. To identify this safety margin, further research would be necessary to define the velocity and/or mass threshold at which ignition occurs.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Skid Testing Report (FY 2019)

The Skid Test is an experiment that impacts an explosive charge obliquely upon a gritty target in order to deliver a frictional ignition stimulus. At Los Alamos, the Skid Test has been used since 2011 to test myriad explosives, drop heights, impact angles, target materials, target coatings, and other variables. In FY19, forty-four tests were performed. The focus was twofold: 1) investigate the possibility that grit pre-embedded into PBX 9501 can create ignitions when impacting a gritty soft-rubber surface, via grit-grit interactions; 2) test the HMX-based UK explosive EDC37 in typical Skid Test conditions. Thirty-one tests were performed with grit pre-embedded in PBX 9501, dropped onto gritty soft rubber targets. No ignitions were observed in any of the tests. Previously, nominally identical tests were performed, except lacking the pre-embedded grit, and no ignitions were observed in those tests. Post-mortem analysis suggests that grit-grit collisions are common, yet still fail to produce ignitions. We hypothesize that the softness of the rubber target fails to provide sufficient normal force for frictional heating, regardless the grit-grit collisions. Eleven tests with EDC37 were conducted in total, at drop heights of 9 in, 6 ft, and 9 ft and with grit diameters of 75-150 µm, 150-250 µm, 250-500 µm, and 500-1000 µm. Ignition of hotspots followed by quench was observed in a single test at an incident angle of 14° and effective drop height of 9 ft. These results demonstrate that EDC37 is safer—i.e. less prone to ignition—than other conventional high explosives tested to date, including PBX 9501.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Case Penetration and Detonator Crush FY2019 Report

The Punch Gun apparatus delivers a low-velocity, high-momentum impact that is representative of potential human accident insults, including drops, trips, and falls. This apparatus has been used since 2016 to explore various accident scenarios of interest to weapons handling operations. In previous years, ignition and violent deflagration of heavily confined cased charges of PBX 9501 was observed at very low velocities (~1.5 m s-1) with pointed tips. Ignition followed by violent deflagration was also observed with blunt impacts of un-cased bare charges of LX-07 and LX-07 with an embedded detonator. Previously, no ignition was observed with blunt impacts of bare charges of PBX 9501.

42 ENGINEERING↗

PBX 9502 Gas-Generation Throughout Long-Duration Thermal Exposure and Cookoff

When energetic materials are subjected to thermal insult, an event may follow in which the explosive exothermically reacts in an undesirable fashion. This event is known as cookoff, or self-ignition, and understanding how different explosives behave during this event is critical for explosives safety. To further our understanding of how PBX 9502 (95% TATB, 5% Kel-F 800) behaves at cookoff, small scale laboratory experiments were conducted to study the pressure rise created by unconfined samples as they were heated to self-ignition. Collected data included high speed video of deflagration, sample temperature, a time-lapse of thermal damage and expansion, quasi-static pressure during heating, and the dynamic pressure during cookoff. These data provide evidence that this composition remains impermeable through thermal evolution, until internal void pressure overcomes the mechanical strength of the material and drives macro-scale cracking. Previous work reported that PBX 9502 exhibits a pressure-dependent cookoff behavior [1], the cause of which is not entirely understood. The results reported here contribute to an understanding of the underlying behavior which gives rise to the observed pressure dependence.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Shear Heating of Explosives using the Crush Gun; FY2018 Report

Explosives subject to rapid mechanical deformation can experience large internal velocity gradients; this is a dissipative process, causing internal temperature rise. If this internal frictional heating is sufficiently large and sufficiently localized it can cause ignition of the explosive. Modeling the heat deposition that arises from mechanical insult is an ongoing effort, and additional experimental data is required to develop the model [1]. Apneumatic gun apparatus was designed and built to deliver crushing impacts at velocities of 0-70 m/s. The apparatus is designed to halt the projectile approximately 1 mm before impacting the sapphire imaging surface, preventing a complete “pinch” condition from attaining. The primary diagnostics include high-speed visible videography and infrared imaging to determine spatial temperature rise of the sample during impact. Forty-seven tests were performed with the apparatus during FY18, on four different explosives: Comp-B, PBX 9501, LX-07, and LX-14.No measurable heating was observed with Comp-B at a nominal velocity of 58 m/s. A maximum temperature rise of 17 °C was recorded with PBX 9501 at an impact velocity of 59 m/s. A maximum temperature rise of 32 °C was observed with LX-07 at an impact velocity of 57 m/s. A maximum temperature rise of 15 °C was observed with LX-14 at an impact velocity of 59 m/s. In contrast to drop-weight tower sensitivity testing [2,3], no ignitions were observed in any of the impacts. The lack of appreciable heating is attributed to the arrest mechanism which prevents the projectile from completing the final ~2 mm of crush. Differences between the explosive compositions are attributed primarily to binder effects.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Center-Ignited Spherical-Mass Explosion (CISME); FY 2018 Report

It is not known whether pristine (i.e. mechanically and thermally undamaged) PBX 9501 can transition from a deflagration to a detonation in realistic scenarios, with relevant charge masses and inertial and mechanical confinement. In order to place bounds on the behavior, a series of experiments was conducted in which a spherical PBX 9501 charge is center-ignited using a fiber-delivered infrared laser pulse. Charge diameter was varied from 1.5 in ch to 10 inch. Experiments were conducted in a “bare” (unconfined) configuration, and a confined configuration with 4 mm-thick stainless-steel hemispherical shells bolted together. In all eight experiments, the reaction exhibited a relatively benign pressure burst; no transition to detonation (DDT) was observed. Most of the explosive was unconsumed and recovered post-test. Confined tests demonstrated slightly greater violence than unconfined tests, as anticipated.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Fracture Effects on Explosive Response (FEER); FY2018 Report

It is known that the violence of explosive response is affected by inertial and mechanical confinement. In a mechanical insult, the impact location creates a contact pressure that can act as confinement surrounding the ignition location, as has been observed in the Skid Test experiment. Under certain conditions — the details of which have not been well characterized — the ignition can produce cracking in the explosive, down which flames are observed to propagate. Cracks serve to simultaneously provide additional surface area for accelerating the reaction, as well as vent paths for quenching the reaction. These are competing behaviors, and the factors which govern the outcome are poorly described. A new experiment was devised to examine the effect of a controlled pre-load pressure on the explosive response. Sixteen experiments were performed on 1-inch thick discs of PBX 9501, with diameters of 1 in ch, 4.25 in ch, and 5 in ch. The explosive was compressed to a known pre-load between two clear windows and ignited at the center of the bottom surface with a focused laser impinging on a graphite inclusion. The ensuing reaction was imaged through the windows used to compress the sample, and from the side. A speckle pattern was applied to some samples for performing DIC (digital image correlation) for the purpose of quantifying the strain field and tracking crack growth. A threshold behavior was observed, in which higher-pressure pre-load resulted in cracks forming, while lower-pressure pre-load vented across the face of the explosive. This report presents the preliminary results, discusses the observations, enumerates hypotheses regarding the observed behavior, identifies lessons learned, and outlines a path forward for the next round of testing. Proof testing was only recently concluded and considerable additional analysis is required. These data will be valuable for the ongoing development of a constitutive mechanical and cracking failure model that will aid in predicting explosive response in mechanical impact scenarios.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Simulations of Two Heavily Confined PBX 9502 Cook-off Experiments.

Finite element models of two cook-off experiments were constructed using the Aria code.These experiments provided thermocouple measurements that were used as boundary conditions to carry out finite element (FE) simulations and comparisons of the FE thermal response with internal temperature measurements in the PBX 9502. These FE models contain a pressure dependent PBX 9502 thermal decomposition model developed by Hobbs’ et al.. Comparisons of the FE results and the experiments are presented. These comparisons assess the predictive capabilities of Hobbs’ model under the experimental conditions. Limiting cases of the PBX 9502 decomposition model are considered. Two parameterizations associated with the pressure dependency of the PBX 9502 decomposition model were carried out to fit the experiments using internal temperature measurements. Two inverse heat conduction problems were implemented to estimate temperatures as functions of time at locations on the outer surface of the PBX 9502. Thermocouple conduction error studies were carried out to assess the comparisons of the FE model thermal response with the experiments.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

PBX 9502 Gas Generation Progress Report FY17

The self-ignition (“cookoff”) behavior of PBX 9502 depends on the dynamic evolution of gas permeability and physical damage in the material. The time-resolved measurement of product gas generation yields insight regarding the crucial properties that dominate cookoff behavior. We report on small-scale laboratory testing performed in FY17, in which small unconfined samples of PBX 9502 were heated in a small custom-built sealed pressure vessel to self-ignition. We recorded time-lapse video of the evolving physical changes in the sample, quasi-static long-duration pressure rise, then high-speed video and dynamic pressure rise of the cookoff event. We report the full pressure attained during the cookoff of a 1.02g sample in a free volume of 62.5 cm 3 .

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗