Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Hummel, Andrew

Publications and source records attributed to Hummel, Andrew.

Decay Heat Surrogate Modeling for High Temperature Reactors

The accuracy of the safety analysis of Nuclear Power Plants, in general, and the High Temperature Reactors, in particular, is driven by several factors, among which the accuracy of decay heat curves or calculation. This paper is aimed to present a methodology based on the usage of the RAVEN code for the construction of a multi-dimensional decay heat curve for High Temperature Reactors, via calculations performed by ORIGEN. The main goal of this activity has been the identification of a model able to surrogate the phenomenology of the decay heat after shutdown, satisfying the following requirements: 1) Reasonable prediction accuracy till 1 month after the shutdown, 2) Ability to capture the main deviation effects determined by field conditions (e.g. burn-up, fuel temperature, fissile enrichment, etc.), 3) As easy as possible formalism in order to possibly allow the implementation of the curve into system codes (e.g. RELAP5-3D) inputs exploiting, for example, control variable capabilities. Three surrogate models (also known as decay heat curves in the safety analysis nomenclature) have been identified: 1) Spline Exponential surrogate model, 2) A Support Vector Regression model and, 3) A Dynamic Mode Decomposition model. The aim of this paper is to present the mathematical background of the identified surrogate models and their performance in the prediction of decay heat evolution for High Temperature Reactors. A preliminary comparison of the surrogate model performances is finally reported.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

HTTR 3 D Cross Section Generation with Serpent and MAMMOTH

The High Temperature Test Reactor (HTTR) is a graphite moderated thermal reactor with a nominal power output of 30 MWth. The purpose of this work is to prepare a set of neutron cross sections for use in the transient analyses of three Loss of Forced Cooling (LOFC) events planned for this reactor. The cross sections are generated with the Serpent 2 3 D Monte Carlo code to include the axial heterogeneity and the strong axial coupling of this core. The approach yields good agreement of results when compared to previously used 2 D lattice models, which require a fine spatial discretization and, surprisingly, comes at a higher computational cost. In addition, the temperature distribution must be considered to obtain reasonable cross sections and the axial leakage component dominates the spectral effects in the core. Consequently, a temperature model as a function of the fuel and moderator temperatures is adopted, and the core is depleted to 390 effective full-power days (EFPDs). A full tabulation of cross sections is prepared at this burnup point for a variety of fuel and moderator temperatures. Next, the multiphysics reactor application MAMMOTH is used to evaluate the quality of these cross sections using a diffusion solver. As expected, the homogenization error in the cross sections is significant and the Super Homogenization (SPH) correction from MAMMOTH is necessary to preserve key reaction rates. The SPH corrected MAMMOTH results are in excellent agreement with the Serpent results and reproduce both the reference power profile and temperature coefficients at each tabulation point. This fact confirms the accuracy of the SPH corrected cross sections and demonstrates the maturity of using Serpent 2 and MAMMOTH for 3 D cross section generation, even for reactors as complex as the HTTR. Finally, the authors recommend that the cross sections should be parametrized with the local burnup and that a full core burnup calculation with coupled thermal fluids would provide a better estimate of the initial condition for any subsequent transient analysis. Unfortunately, this was not within the scope of this work, and direct analysis with these tabulations should be considered as a first order approximation, at best.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Decay Heat Quantification in the High Temperature Test Reactor

The proper calculation of decay heat is necessary for both postulated accidents as well as normal spent fuel repository safety analysis. Since the 1970s, the nuclear industry has primarily relied on the use of the ANSI/ANS-5.1 standard or one of it’s predecessors as the tool for calculating such heat. However, different reactor systems can have substantially different materials, neutron spectrums, operating characteristics, etc.…that lead to vastly different isotopic compositions in the fuel over time. The ANSI/ANS-5.1 standard is specific to Light Water Reactors, and thus may not be well suited for other systems such as high temperature gas reactors. Recent developments in the SCALE 6 code developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory have allowed for a more accurate treatment of the complexity associated with high temperature reactor TRISO fuel. Also, the standalone isotopic depletion and generation code ORIGEN-S, a module of SCALE, has been validated against experimental data for LWRs for properly characterizing decay heat. And most recently, Japan Atomic Energy Agency has used the ORIGEN code to generate HTGR cross section libraries to be used to quantify the decay heat generated in the High Temperature Engineering Test Reactor at the Oarai Research and Development Center. Given the Idaho National Laboratory’s continued research into the viability of HTGRs as a next generation power reactor, an independent decay heat quantification analysis has been performed for a variety of fuel enrichments, TRISO particle packing fractions, and fuel temperatures using a similar approach. Furthermore, these data are then used as input into the RAVEN code developed at INL. A Reduced Order Model mathematical model in RAVEN is ‘trained’ to create a response mechanism to the various input parameters. Preliminary results demonstrate the potential for using this methodology to accurately predict decay heat generation.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

New approaches to provide feedback from nuclear and covariance data adjustment for effective improvement of evaluated nuclear data files

A critical examination of the role of uncertainty assessment, target accuracies, role of integral experiment for validation and, consequently, of data adjustments methods is underway since several years at OECD-NEA, the objective being to provide criteria and practical approaches to use effectively the results of sensitivity analyses and cross section adjustments for feedback to evaluators and experimentalists in order to improve without ambiguities the knowledge of neutron cross sections, uncertainties, and correlations to be used in a wide range of applications and to meet new requirements and constraints for innovative reactor and fuel cycle system design. An approach will be described that expands as much as possible the use in the adjustment procedure of selected integral experiments that provide information on “elementary” phenomena, on separated individual physics effects related to specific isotopes or on specific energy ranges. An application to a large experimental data base has been performed and the results are discussed in the perspective of new evaluation projects like the CIELO initiative.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Small Sample Reactivity Measurements in the RRR/SEG Facility: Reanalysis using TRIPOLI-4

This work involved reanalyzing the RRR/SEG integral experiments performed at the Rossendorf facility in Germany throughout the 1970s and 80s. These small sample reactivity worth measurements were carried out using the pile oscillator technique for many different fission products, structural materials, and standards. The coupled fast-thermal system was designed such that the measurements would provide insight into elemental data, specifically the competing effects between neutron capture and scatter. Comparing the measured to calculated reactivity values can then provide adjustment criteria to ultimately improve nuclear data for fast reactor designs. Due to the extremely small reactivity effects measured (typically less than 1 pcm) and the specific heterogeneity of the core, the tool chosen for this analysis was TRIPOLI-4. This code allows for high fidelity 3-dimensional geometric modeling, and the most recent, unreleased version, is capable of exact perturbation theory.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗