Engineering topics

J. W. Boyce

Publications and source records attributed to J. W. Boyce.

10 records

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Revisiting the Origin of Macromolecular Carbon (MMC) in Lunar Basalts 15556 & 10044

Volatile elements influence the geo-chemical evolution of planetary bodies and they are in magmas at every stage, from melting within planetary interiors to eruption at the surface. Analyses of lunar mare basalts supported the hypothesis that lunar mag-mas were depleted in volatiles (H-C-F-Cl-S), relative to their terrestrial analogs [1]. Nevertheless, several early studies of samples returned during the Apollo program proposed that the mare basalt eruptions, including the “fire fountain” eruptions, were propelled by the oxidation of magmatic graphite to CO (and/or CO2) gas [2, 3]. Seminal studies during the 1970’s measured the bulk concentration and isotopic compositions of C from Apollo 11 samples, and identified several carbonaceous compounds, including: (a) gaseous (CO, CO2, and traces of CH4), (b) metallic carbide, and (c) potentially elemental carbon [4-6]. These studies reported a relatively broad range of C contents (~100-400 μg/g) and isotopic values (δC13 = -30 to +20), and suggested that these heterogeneities can be explained by contribution from multiple factors, including: (a) indigenous carbon, (b) solar wind implantation, (c) bombardment and/or meteorite impact, and (d) terrestrial contamination [5,6]. However, unequivocal observations of magmatic graphite in lunar basalts have never been made. Macromolecular carbon (MMC)—graphitic carbon varying from nearly amorphous to highly crystalline varieties—was identified as inclusions hosted by igneous pyroxenes from Martian meteorites and were attributed to being indigenous to Mars [8]. The authors carefully considered the textural and mineralogical relationship of the MMC phases, and concluded that the subset of MMC located within and/or adjacent to cracks, or at a disrupted surface (e.g., cut) were most consistent with terrestrial contamination. The near absence of con-firmed instances of lunar magmatic MMC within the literature [9], combined with the wide range of isotopic values and bulk carbon contents measured in lunar bas-alts begs the question as to whether previously measured carbon is of an indigenous origin, or the result of terrestrial contamination. Using Raman spectroscopy, we have observed MMC in lunar basalts subjected to different forms of anthropogenic modification related to sample preparation including polished sections, sawn surfaces, and fractured surfaces adjacent to sawn sur-faces. We have observed MMC of unknown origin in all of these settings. Here we report the preliminary textural and spectroscopic characteristics of MMC hosted within the groundmass of Apollo 15 (15556) and Apollo 11 basalts (10044) as part of our ongoing investigation of the origin of these carbonaceous materials.

lunar↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

From Source to Surface: An Investigation of Magmatic Lunar Volatiles

Lunar missions led by NASA discovered water ice on the Moon’s surface [1-3], revolutionizing views of the abundance, distribution, and potential sources of H2O and other volatiles. Volatiles play an important role in affecting the rheological properties of minerals and melts and influencing magma eruption processes. In order to determine the indigenous volatile inventory of the Moon, it is vital to identify the magmatic and secondary processes that may have affected the volatile contents in lunar minerals [4]. As part of the Apollo Next Generation Sample Analysis (ANGSA) program we are investigating the petrogenesis of a set of four Apollo lunar basalts collected from the rim of Steno Crater 71035, 71037, 71055, and specially curated sample 71036. Our team is studying the petrology in 2D and 3D (this work), chronology (Pomeroy et al., LPSC 2022), oxidation state of sulfur in apatite (Brounce et al., LPSC 2022), and volatile inventory of the sample set in order to understand the age and genetic relationships among the basalts, their magma ascent conditions and eruptive signatures, and their degassing and surface histories. Here we present the first detailed study of the 2D and 3D mineralogy, textures, 3D vesiculation, and chemistry of these basalts to shed light on their magmatic, volcanic, and post-eruptive histories. Note: Extended abstract on document.

Z. E. Wilbur↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Chronology of Steno Crater Basalt

The Apollo Next Generation Sample Analysis (ANGSA) program was designed to investigate specially curated samples returned by the Apollo 15 and 17 missions [1]. As part of this effort, we are examining a suite of Apollo 17 basalts collected from the rim of Steno Crater, to investigate the magmatic and post-magmatic volatile histories of these samples. Here we report initial 207Pb-206Pb chronology of accessory phases for two steno crater basalts, which will ultimately be paired with (40)Ar*/(39)Ar chronology and (38)Ar exposure ages to constrain crystallization and surface histories. The chronology of these samples will help determine if the samples derive from the one lava sequence or represent multiple lava flows, and will allow us to place petrologic and volatile data into the wider context of the magmatic suite [1,2]. Note: Extended abstract on document.

S. J. Pomeroy↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

The Oxidation State of Sulfur in Martian Apatite- Implications for Redox of Surficial Processes

Meteorites from Mars record fO2 values of ∆IW = -1 to +6.5 [1, 2]. This relatively large range in fO2 has been attributed to igneous processes like differentiation and assimilation, or sometimes to alteration [2, 3], modifying the range inherited from the Martian mantle, which is thought to be closer to the values recorded by lunar basalts (~∆IW -1 [e.g., 1]). Trace element compositions reveal that those Martian meteorites that are light Rare Earth Elements (LREE) enriched record higher fO2 values than those that are LREE-depleted [2]. Sulfur (S) has been used to track redox and alteration processes on Mars because it can be present in multiple redox states varying from S2- in magmatic sulfides to S6+ in sedimentary sulfate deposits and alteration products like jarosite [4, 5]. Apatite (Ca5(PO4)3(F,Cl,OH)) is found in many of the Martian meteorites as a late stage crystallizing mineral. It can incorporate both S^(2-) [6] or S^(6+) [7] or mixtures of both [7, 8] in its crystal structure, and it has been hypothesized that the relative proportions of S^(2-) and S^(6+) in apatite will depend on the prevailing fO2 in which it formed (along with P, T, and major element composition). Note: Extended abstract on document.

P. Chowdhury↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Thermodynamic Modeling of the Vapor in Equilibrium With Apollo 17 Basalts.

Lunar mare basalts sampled during the Apollo 17 mission provide insight to the chemical evolution of mare basalt magmas and their associated vapor as these samples erupted and cooled rapidly at the lunar surface. We focus on minerals present on vesicle and vug surfaces in Apollo 17 basalts, such as 71036, which was opened as part of the Apollo Next Generation Sample Analysis (ANGSA) program. The mineral assemblage observed includes native Fe, SiO2, and a Mg-P mineral, possibly merrillite [1, 2]. The pet-rographic context of these phases suggests that they may have been deposited directly from the vapor phase after eruption. Here we use thermodynamic modeling to assess the plausibility of the vapor-phase deposition hypothesis.

D. L. Thompson↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Testing and Application of Commercial Thermodynamics Software for Solid-Gas Equilibria in Planetary Science Applications

The ability to calculate chemical equilibria from thermochemical constants (e.g., H, S, Cp) or other experimental data is a tool widely employed by scientists. However, phase equilibria for planetary science problems is limited by easy access to libraries of thermochemical data, as well as the software to invert that data. Many academic software packages are focused on specific types of problems (e.g., aqueous solutions or melting and crystallization of magmas). This focus makes them excellent tools for specific uses, but poorer tools for other scenarios, especially those involving elements or chemical species that are less well-studied in that specific scientific field (e.g. NaCl vapor). Amongst the more general thermodynamic software tools, there are closed academic software packages, open-source options, as well as commercial software. We have explored the extent to which commercial chemistry/chemical engineering software may be able to satisfy the need for thermochemical modeling packages that can accommodate the diverse species and conditions of planetary science problems. Here we compare the output of software package HSC Chemistry™ (Metso Outotec) to published vapor-solid phase diagrams for a variety of major and minor elements. HSC Chemistry™ has been used in several recent geochemical studies of terrestrial volcanic systems [2- 4]. However, it has not to our knowledge been benchmarked against peer-reviewed model results for the conditions and compositions relevant to planetary science. We present one such comparison here, the low- pressure environment of the solar nebula, using literature data. In short, we find excellent agreement between HSC Chemistry™ and the well-regarded academic software package CONDOR. These preliminary results suggest that at least some commercial software packages are capable of robust thermochemical calculations for planetary science.

planetary science↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Volatile Abundances of Apatite in CK and R Chondrites: Implications for Apatite Volatile Records in Oxidized and Thermally Altered Chondrite Parent Bodies

The mineral apatite [Ca5(PO4)3(F,Cl,OH)] is one of the primary mineralogical reservoirs for phosphorus on Earth, and it is a common phosphate mineral within a broad range of extraterrestrial samples. Naturally occurring apatite hosts F, Cl, and OH as essential structural constituents, and all three make up the apatite endmembers fluorapatite, chlorapatite, and hydroxylapatite, respectively. The presence of apatite in chondrite parent bodies indicates that apatite may hold a record of volatiles and their associated processes during the nascent stages of planetesimal formation and evolution.

F. M. McCubbin↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Chlorine Isotope Transect Across the Sudbury Impact Deposits Reveals Enigmatic Isotopic Fractionation

Volatile elements play an important role in a variety of cosmochemical and geochemical processes. As such, there has been significant interest in their abundance and isotopic composition. Chlorine is an important element for tracing these processes because it is incompatible in nearly all minerals, extremely volatile, and strongly hydrophilic [1]. The Cl isotope composition ( 37 Cl/ 35 Cl) of meteoritic components, therefore, can provide useful information regarding the isotopic reservoirs that were present in the early Solar System and any secondary processes that may have occurred on different parent bodies (e.g., [2-4]). There is a relatively narrow range in the Cl isotope compositions of terrestrial, Martian, and chondritic meteorites (δ 37 Cl ~ −6 to +4‰) (e.g., [2,3,5,6]), with exceptions to this being the Moon and Vesta (up to ~ +81‰ and ~ +40‰, respectively) [4, 5, 7-10]. One hypothesis for the extreme Cl isotope fractionation observed on the Moon is degassing following large-scale (possibly even crust-breaching) impact events [7-9]. The role of hypervelocity impacts and impact-generated magmatism in the isotopic evolution of planetary materials, however, has been until recently an area of limited published research with the majority of works focusing on the effects of impact shock (e.g., [10-13]). The ~ 1.85 Ga Sudbury impact crater [14] located in Ontario, Canada, is one of the three largest impact craters on Earth with good exposures of its impact melt sheet and overlying breccias [15,16]. The impact melt sheet, called the Sudbury Igneous Complex (SIC), is up to 5 km thick [17], with an estimated original volume of >10 4 km 3 [18], and differentiated. Recent work demonstrated evaporative loss and isotope fractionation of the moderately volatile element zinc and suggest melt sheets produced by impacts could have a significant effect on the Earth’s volatile inventory [19]. In this study we investigate the abundance and isotopic composition of Cl as well the water abundance of apatite from the SIC and the overlying crater-fill to test the hypothesis that large-scale impacts may have generated the extensive Cl isotopic fractionation observed on the Moon.

Sudbury↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Volatile Abundance of Paired Lunar Troctolites and the Early Lunar Crust

Nominally anhydrous minerals (NAMs) such as plagioclase, pyroxene, and olivine can contain small amounts of water and other volatile elements, typically within crystal lattice defects. Given the volumetric abundance of NAMs, these minerals can contain a significant volatile reservoir despite their low abundances. At least one NAM is present in nearly all lunar rocks, unlike the more commonly studied volatile-bearing mineral apatite, making NAM-based hygrometry more widely applicable. NAMs are also not subject to enrichment in H due to self-fractionation of F, as is the case for apatite. Recent developments in secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) techniques (e.g., the reduction of analytical background) have allowed the evaluation of volatiles in samples that were previously too low in abundance to measure. The ability to make volatile measurements in the sub-10 ppm range opens up a suite of samples where volatile-bearing phases, such as melt inclusions and apatite, are rare or entirely absent. In this study we measure the abundances of H, C, F, P, S, and Cl in plagioclase from two paired lunar troctolites to better understand the volatile inventory of the early lunar crust and its implications for the bulk Moon.

volatiles↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Petrologic Comparison of High- and Low-Titanium Basalt Clasts Derived From ANGSA Core 73001

Volatile elements and compounds significantly influence the properties and behavior of magma, including ascent and eruptive processes. Basalts record a complicated history of the volatile species inherent to their parental magma, and the processes, such as degassing, that change these volatile inventories. On the Moon, outstanding questions remain concerning the behavior of magmatic volatiles and their roles in the evolution of lunar magmas and the formation of mare basalts. As part of the Apollo Next Generation Sample Analysis (ANGSA) program, we are investigating the petrogenesis of two basalt clasts collected from the recently processed Apollo 17 drive tube, 73001. Our team is studying the petrology of the two basalt clasts in 2D and 3D. Recent work has highlighted the utility of coupling traditional 2D methods with 3D measurements to better understand the crystallization and degassing histories of lunar lava flows. We are also investigating the volatile inventory of the samples through in situ studies of volatile-bearing phases, like apatite, to understand the eruptive signatures and degassing histories of low-titanium and high-titanium lunar basalts. At the upcoming conference, we will present the first detailed study of the 2D and 3D mineralogy, textures, 3D vesiculation, and chemistry of these basalt clasts to shed light on their magmatic, volcanic, and post-eruptive histories.

Basalt↗