Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

James M Luckring

Publications and source records attributed to James M Luckring.

Prediction of Concentrated Vortex Aerodynamics: Current CFD Capability Survey

Concentrated vortex flows contribute to the aerodynamic performance of aircraft at elevated load conditions. For military interests, the vortex flows are exploited at maneuver conditions of combat aircraft and missiles. For transport interests, the vortex flows are exploited at takeoff and landing conditions as well as at select transonic conditions. Aircraft applications of these vortex flows are reviewed with a historical perspective followed by a discussion of the underlying physics of a concentrated vortex flow. A hierarchy of computational fluid dynamics simulation technology is then presented followed by findings from a capability survey for predicting concentrated vortex flows with computational fluid dynamics. Results are focused on military and civil aircraft; only limited results are included for missiles. Opportunities for predictive capability advancement are then reported with comments related to digital transformation interests. A hierarchical approach that merges a physics-based perspective of the concentrated vortex flows with a systems engineering viewpoint of the air vehicle is also used to frame much of the discussion.

vortex flow↗

Technical Evaluation Report, Part A - Vortex Flow and High Angle of Attack

A symposium entitled Vortex Flow and High Angle of Attack was held in Loen, Norway, from May 7 through May 11, 2001. The Applied Vehicle Technology (AVT) panel, under the auspices of the Research and Technology Organization (RTO), sponsored this symposium. Forty-eight papers, organized into nine sessions, addressed computational and experimental studies of vortex flows pertinent to both aircraft and maritime applications. The studies also ranged from fundamental fluids investigations to flight test results, and significant results were contributed from a broad range of countries. The principal emphasis of this symposium was on "the understanding and prediction of separation-induced vortex flows and their effects on military vehicle performance, stability, control, and structural design loads." It was further observed by the program committee that "separation- induced vortex flows are an important part of the design and off-design performance of conventional fighter aircraft and new conventional or unconventional manned or unmanned advanced vehicle designs (UAVs, manned aircraft, missiles, space planes, ground-based vehicles, and ships)." The nine sessions addressed the following topics: vortical flows on wings and bodies, experimental techniques for vortical flows, numerical simulations of vortical flows, vortex stability and breakdown, vortex flows in maritime applications, vortex interactions and control, vortex dynamics, flight testing, and vehicle design. The purpose of this paper is to provide brief reviews of these papers along with some synthesizing perspectives toward future vortex flow research opportunities. The paper includes the symposium program. (15 refs.)

VORTEX BREAKDOWN↗

Multiblock Navier-Stokes solutions about the F/A-18 wing-LEX-fuselage configuration

Three-dimensional thin-layer Navier-Stokes computations are presented for the F/A-18 configuration. The modeled configuration includes an accurate surface representation of the fuselage, leading-edge extension (LEX), and wing, both with and without leading-edge flap deflection. A multiblock structured grid strategy is employed to decompose the computational flowfield domain around the subject configuration. Steady-state solutions are obtained from an algorithm that solves the compressible Navier-Stokes equations with an upwind-biased, flux-difference splitting approach. The results presented are based on a fully turbulent flow assumption, simulating the high Reynolds number flow conditions that correspond to a recent FI A-18 flight experiment. Good agreements between the computations and the flight test results are obtained for both surface flow patterns as well as surface pressure distributions. Furthermore, a correlation between the computed LEX vortex-core and the flight test results, observed by way of smoke visualization, is also presented.

Aircraft configurations↗

Transonic Navier-Stokes solutions about a generic hypersonic configuration

Three-dimensional transonic viscous flow computations are presented for a generic high-speed accelerator model that includes wing, body, fillets, and a no-flow-through engine nacelle. Solutions are obtained from an algorithm for the compressible Navier-Stokes equations that incorporates an upwind-biased, flux-vector-splitting approach along with longitudinally patched grids. Results are presented for fully turbulent flow assumptions and include correlations with wind-tunnel data. A good quantitative agreement for the forebody surface pressure distribution is achieved between computations and the available wind-tunnel measurements at M∞ = 0.9. Furthermore, it is demonstrated that the flow is stagnating around the boattail region due to separation from the aft-engine cowl lip.

Hypersonic flows↗

Navier-Stokes solutions about the F/A-18 forebody-leading-edge extension configuration

Three-dimensional viscous flow computations are presented for the F/A-18 forebody including the leading-edge extension geometry. Solutions are obtained from an algorithm for the compressible Navier-Stokes equations that incorporates an upwind-biased, flux-difference-splitting approach along with longitudinally patched grids. Results are presented for both laminar and fully turbulent flow assumptions and include correlations with wind-tunnel as well as flight-test results. A good quantitative agreement for the forebody surface pressure distribution is achieved between the turbulent computations and wind-tunnel measurements at M ∞ = 0.6. The computed turbulent surface flow patterns on the forebody qualitatively agree well with in-flight surface flow patterns obtained on an F/A-18 aircraft at M ∞ = 0.34

Leading edge extension↗

Application of a patched-grid algorithm to the F/A-18 forebody-leading-edge extension configuration

A patched-grid algorithm for the analysis of complex configurations with an implicit, upwind-biased Navier-Stokes solver is presented. Results from both a spatial-flux and a time-flux conservation approach to patching across zonal boundaries are presented. A generalized coordinate transformation with a biquadratic geometric element is used at the zonal interface in order to treat highly stretched viscous grids and arbitrarily shaped zonal boundaries. Applications are made to the F/A-18 forebody-Ieading-edge extension configuration at subsonic, high-alpha conditions. Computed surface flow patterns compare well with ground-based and flight-test results; the large effect of Reynolds number on the forebody flowfield is shown.

Leading edge extension↗

Navier-Stokes solutions about the F/A-18 forebody-LEX configuration

Three-dimensional viscous How computations are presented for the F/A-18 fore body-LEX geometry. Solutions are obtained from an algorithm for the compressible Navier-Stokes equations which incorporates an upwind-biased, flux-difference-splitting approach along with longitudinally-patched grids. Results are presented for both laminar and fully turbulent flow assumptions and include correlations with wind tunnel as well as flight-test results. A good quantitative agreement for the forebody surface pressure distribution is achieved between the turbulent computations and wind tunnel measurements at M ∞ = 0.6. The computed turbulent surface flow patterns on the forebody qualitatively agree well with in-flight surface flow patterns obtained on an F/A-18 aircraft at M ∞ = 0.34.

Farhad Ghaffari↗

Navier-Stokes solutions about the F/A-18 forebody-LEX configuration

Three-dimensional viscous How computations are presented for the F/A-18 fore body-LEX geometry. Solutions are obtained from an algorithm for the compressible Navier-Stokes equations which incorporates an upwind-biased, flux-difference-splitting approach along with longitudinally-patched grids. Results are presented for both laminar and fully turbulent flow assumptions and include correlations with wind tunnel as well as flight-test results. A good quantitative agreement for the forebody surface pressure distribution is achieved between the turbulent computations and wind tunnel measurements at M ∞ = 0.6. The computed turbulent surface flow patterns on the forebody qualitatively agree well with in-flight surface flow patterns obtained on an F/A-18 aircraft at M ∞ = 0.34.

Transitional flow↗

A Patched-Grid Algorithm for Complex Configurations Directed Towards the F/A-18 Aircraft

A patched-grid algorithm for the analysis of complex configurations with an implicit, upwind-biased Navier-Stokes solver is presented. Results from both a spatial-flux and a time-flux conservation approach to patching across zonal boundaries are presented. A generalized coordinate transformation with a biquadratic geometric element is used at the zonal interface in order to treat highly stretched viscous grids and arbitrarily-shaped zonal boundaries. Applications are made to the F-18 forebody-strake configuration at subsonic, high-alpha conditions. Computed surface flow patterns compare well with ground-based and flight-test results; the large effect of Reynolds number on the forebody flow-field is shown.

High alpha research vehicle↗

Navier-Stokes Solutions about the F/A-18 Forebody-LEX Configuration

Three-dimensional viscous flow computations are presented for the F/A-18 forebody-LEX geometry. Solutions are obtained from an algorithm for the compressible Navier-Stokes equations which incorporates an upwind-biased, flux-difference-splitting approach along with longitudinally-patched grids. Results are presented for both laminar and fully turbulent flow assumptions and include correlations with wind tunnel as well as flight-test results. A good quantitative agreement for the forebody surface pressure distribution is achieved between the turbulent computations and wind tunnel measurements at Mach number of 0.6. The computed turbulent surface flow patterns on the forebody qualitatively agree well with in-flight surface flow patterns obtained on an F/A-fS aircraft at Mach number of 0.34.

Transitional flow↗

Program Overview: Vortex Interaction Aerodynamics Relevant to Military Air Vehicle Performance

A research program has been underway for five years to study vortex interaction aerodynamics that are relevant to military air vehicle performance. The program has been conducted under the auspices of the NATO Science and Technology Organization (STO), Applied Vehicle Technology (AVT) panel by a Task Group with the identification of AVT-316. Seven special sessions have been established to highlight accomplishments from the AVT-316 research. An overview of the AVT-316 program is presented in this paper.

Verification and Validation↗

Exploitation of a Validation Hierarchy for Modeling and Simulation

Across engineering there is an evolving need to increase reliance on physics-based simulation to develop, design and optimize engineering systems. This increased reliance on modeling and simulation has highlighted a growing need to transform the confidence that modeling and simulation analysts have in their results into credibility for systems engineers to design and field systems more quickly and with less physical testing. For isolated components of a complex system, where a single discipline may drive product design, this is less of a concern as the relationship is often straightforward and easy to explain. However, when these isolated components are integrated, and are expected to operate in a multi-disciplinary context in which safety critical systems are involved, new concepts and model assurance standards are required. In this paper we address this challenge by showing how a model validation hierarchy can be exploited to identify those model validation experiments that will contribute most to increasing confidence and credibility of modeling and simulation predictions. The approach that is adopted contains four main steps. The first step is the construction of a model validation hierarchy that links subsystems, assemblies, and components to a hierarchy of physical experiments that can be used support model validation. This hierarchy connects the concerns of systems engineers to those of the modeling and simulation analyst in a clear and logical way. The structure and content of this hierarchy is then used in a second step to establish which physical phenomena have the greatest impact on overall system performance metrics. A gap analysis technique, based upon modeling and simulation concerns, is then used to prioritize the important physical phenomenon. Unfortunately, a common outcome of such gap analyses is the identification of many important gaps and so, in the final step of our process, we advocate the use of a global sensitivity analysis as a means to complete the prioritization.

Verification and Validation↗

Exploitation of a Validation Hierarchy for Modeling and Simulation

Across engineering there is an evolving need to increase reliance on physics-based simulation to develop, design and optimize engineering systems. This increased reliance on modeling and simulation has highlighted a growing need to transform the confidence that modeling and simulation analysts have in their results into credibility for systems engineers to design and field systems more quickly and with less physical testing. For isolated components of a complex system, where a single discipline may drive product design, this is less of a concern as the relationship is often straightforward and easy to explain. However, when these isolated components are integrated, and are expected to operate in a multi-disciplinary context in which safety critical systems are involved, new concepts and model assurance standards are required. In this paper we address this challenge by showing how a model validation hierarchy can be exploited to identify those model validation experiments that will contribute most to increasing confidence and credibility of modeling and simulation predictions. The approach that is adopted contains four main steps. The first step is the construction of a model validation hierarchy that links subsystems, assemblies, and components to a hierarchy of physical experiments that can be used support model validation. This hierarchy connects the concerns of systems engineers to those of the modeling and simulation analyst in a clear and logical way. The structure and content of this hierarchy is then used in a second step to establish which physical phenomena have the greatest impact on overall system performance metrics. A gap analysis technique, based upon modeling and simulation concerns, is then used to prioritize the important physical phenomenon. Unfortunately, a common outcome of such gap analyses is the identification of many important gaps and so, in the final step of our process, we advocate the use of a global sensitivity analysis as a means to complete the prioritization.

Verification and Validation↗

An Application of CFD to Guide Forced Boundary-Layer Transition at Subsonic and Transonic Speeds for a Lambda-Wing Configuration

A hybrid transition trip-dot sizing and placement test technique was extended to support recent experimental research on a moderately-swept hybrid wing-body Uninhabited Combat Air Vehicle configuration under study in a North Atlantic Treaty Organization Applied Vehicle Technology task group. The approach combines traditional test techniques with Computational Fluid Dynamics. The application had three-dimensional boundary layers that were simulated with either fully turbulent or mixed laminar-turbulent flow models using established Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes methods. Forced transition effectiveness was verified experimentally using sublimating chemicals during low-speed and transonic wind tunnel tests. Assessments were performed between tripped low Reynolds number data and un-tripped high Reynolds number data. The hybrid test technique is based on fundamental flow physics and as such could be applicable to other configurations.

UCAV↗

An Application of CFD to Guide Forced Boundary-Layer Transition at Subsonic and Transonic Speeds for a Lambda-Wing Configuration

A hybrid transition trip-dot sizing and placement test technique was extended to support recent experimental research on a moderately-swept hybrid wing-body Uninhabited Combat Air Vehicle configuration under study in a North Atlantic Treaty Organization Applied Vehicle Technology task group. The approach combines traditional test techniques with Computational Fluid Dynamics. The application had three-dimensional boundary layers that were simulated with either fully turbulent or mixed laminar-turbulent flow models using established Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes methods. Forced transition effectiveness was verified experimentally using sublimating chemicals during low-speed and transonic wind tunnel tests. Assessments were performed between tripped low Reynolds number data and un-tripped high Reynolds number data. The hybrid test technique is based on fundamental flow physics and as such could be applicable to other configurations.

Wind tunnel test technique↗