James R. Phillips III

NASA NTRS2022

Investigating Particle-Particle Electrostatic Effects on Charged Lunar Dust Transport via Discrete Element Modeling

NASA surface exploration missions have always seen negative effects of dust including the Apollo missions. The astronaut-witnessed unusual behavior of the dust particles that surround the vehicle after engine cutoff has the potential to have more of an influence on surface systems dust loading than the high velocity lunar rocket plume ejecta in the landing process. The levitation and transport of the fine components of regolith on lunar surface has been linked to electrostatic effects and electric field, but so far there is no accurate model considering the inter-particle electrostatic interactions, especially when the particles are charged by rocket plume or other mechanical interactions due to exploration activities. This study is proposed to investigate the dynamics of charged lunar regolith with a discrete element method (DEM) approach focusing on the inter-particle interactions and contact charge transfer. The grain dynamics is coupled with mechanical and electrical particle interactions, and both short- and long-range interactions between spherical particles are incorporated. A tribo-charging model based on instantaneous collisions between particles is adopted and validated by comparing the simulation results to existing experimental data. Sensitivity analysis is conducted to quantify the effects of initial charge, tribo-charging, and E-field on transport of lunar dust based on JSC-1 simulants with a radius of 50 lm. DEM simulations are also conducted in a near realistic lunar environment with the estimations of initial conditions that shows the difference in position and velocity distributions between charged particles and uncharged particles. The results indicate that the charged dust particles have higher dispersion of position and velocity by several orders of magnitude due to electrostatic effects. This provides a potential explanation for the phenomena of the approximately 30 s dust lofting following Apollo Lunar Module landing.

Lunar dust↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Implementation of Charged Particle Behavior in Discrete Element Method (DEM) Simulations

Lunar landers will agitate the surface of the Moon with an exhaust plume during descent which will, due to the particulate nature of the lunar regolith, loosen and eject grains from the surface. This ejection is not only coupled with the charged plume gas, but also results in significant particle-particle interactions. Settling of these grains after plume effects have subsided takes much longer than expected in a ballistic trajectory. The prevailing hypothesis attributes this behavior to the accumulated charge on the particles. We are thus developing a discrete element method (DEM) approach to explore these charged particle interactions on the lunar surface. The Large-scale Atomic/Molecular Massively Parallel Simulator (LAMMPS) Improved for General Granular and Granular Heat Transfer Simulations (LIGGGHTS) software package provides a DEM modeling framework for granular interactions. It includes many complexities such as non-spherical particle shapes, cohesion and frictional forces, and heat transfer, but has no provision for inter-particle electrostatic forces and charge transfer that are important to examine in the lunar environment. In this work, a standard Coulomb potential and a Yukawa potential are integrated into the LIGGGHTS framework to provide a basis for particle-particle electrostatic interactions, as well as a gravitational potential to enable inter-grain gravitational interactions. A preliminary approach to charge transfer between grains incorporating properties such as work function and electrical conductivity to the library of available material characteristics will be presented. Several scenarios have been simulated that include charged particle interactions within a diffuse granular gas, settling of charged grains into a regolith bed, sliding of granular material along an incline, and vibration of settled grains to produce a behavior similar to fluidization. There are numerous challenges to incorporate realistic interactions between complex lunar particles. Currently, grains are modeled to behave as if the entirety of the charge acts at the center of mass, such as conductors with spherical symmetry and insulators with homogeneously distributed charge. We are developing improvements that will include the use of non-spherical particle geometries, as well as reasonable approximations of insulating/dielectric materials that have non-uniform charge distributions. The cases simulated thus far will be examined in a relevant environment within a vacuum chamber to validate the simulations. These simulations will be bounded by experiments utilizing high-speed camera observations of the motion for validation. The grains in the experiment will exchange charge during their motion and this can be quantified by collection within a charge measurement device such as a Faraday cup. Such a device may be modeled within the software by defining an integration region and computing the contained charge as a function of simulation time, allowing for side-by-side comparison of simulated and measured bulk charging results. Any differences will be reconciled by updating the mathematical mechanisms described within the simulation suite. Successfully combining results from experiments within a relevant environment into the LIGGGHTS framework will improve modeling of the charged grain dynamics experienced on the Moon to provide insights into dust behavior for future lunar exploration missions.

Electrostatics↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Electrostatic charging of the lunar regolith

Lunar regolith dust particles accumulate charge and interact electrostatically with rover wheels, astronaut boots, and equipment. We have developed instrumentation for in situ measurements of the electrostatic charge developed by the interactions of lunar regolith dust with the space-rated materials on these devices. This instrument is also capable of measuring the distribution of electric fields on or near the lunar surface and the ion currents present near the lunar surface. We also report on our efforts to characterize the charging behavior of lunar dust in low gravity environments. This behavior is nonintuitive due to complex interactions between individual dust grains. We are developing an experiment to study this interaction in a microgravity vacuum environment. Better understanding of this interaction will allow for improved dust mitigation on the lunar surface.

electrostatics↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Electrostatic Regolith Interaction Experiment (ERIE) Electrometer Initial Flight Results

The Electrostatic Regolith Interaction Experiment (ERIE) is a suborbital flight payload studying electrostatically charged dust particle dynamics under microgravity, jointly developed by University of Central Florida (UCF) and NASA Kennedy Space Center (KSC). ERIE combines components from two systems, the COLLisions Into Dust Experiment (COLLIDE) from UCF and the Wheel Electrostatic Spectrometer (WES) from NASA KSC, to advance understanding of charged grain behavior on low gravity bodies such as the Moon and asteroids. ERIE slides a door containing an electrometer system monitoring various insulating disks across the surface of a regolith simulant bed. The experiment is activated when the payload enters the microgravity potion of the flight. The grains in the simulant bed tribocharge via agitation during launch as well as through frictional interactions with the door and its protruding insulators. As the retention door retracts, particles are allowed to loft into an open volume, achieving motion due to electrostatic repulsion. The electrometer system measures the charge transfer between the granular material and the insulators. As the charged grains exit the bed, they travel through an applied electric field and a camera observes the kinematics of the individual grains whose trajectories are determined by their net charges. The design of the ERIE electrometer instrument and initial results from the first flight was presented at the 2021 AGU Fall Meeting under P55E-2002. Shortly after microgravity was achieved and the retaining door began to open, the rate of charge acquisition measured by the electrometer increased, indicating the insulators were accumulating triboelectric charge. Charged grains were observed in the video data to traverse across the external electric field and become deflected from a linear path due to their charges. Pairs of grains were also observed to orbit one another as expected from two oppositely charged bodies in proximity to one another. Improvements to the design of the instrument and preliminary results obtained from the second flight scheduled for Q3 2022 will be presented at this meeting.

Electrostatics↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Evaluation of Coatings for the Electrodynamic Dust Shield Application on Thermal Radiators

Space dust acts as a blackbody, becoming hot if left in direct sunlight. This is a problem for thermal radiators used in space missions, where the main function is to radiate heat away from an object. If dust lands on the thermal radiator, the unit will less effectively reject heat, and it will overheat, leading to electrical or system failure. The current state-of-the-art in active dust mitigation is the Electrodynamic Dust Shield (EDS) which uses an electric field generated by alternating high positive and negative voltages (low current) to eject the charged dust off surfaces. An EDS made from copper coated Kapton is an ideal candidate to be bonded to a thermal radiator and coated with a low solar absorptance, high heat-emitter coating. This work compares the dust removal of copper-Kapton EDSs covered with different thermal radiator coatings in air and vacuum environments. The coatings include AZ-93 paint, Thermal Bright, and Solar White, a coating developed by the Applied Physics Lab (APL) at NASA Kennedy Space Center (KSC). The resistance and the thickness of the various coatings impact how well it works as an insulative layer for the EDS. Preliminary results indicate that Solar White may have better properties for dust removal and thermal rejection than the other coatings.

Krystal L. Acosta↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Electrostatic Regolith Interaction Experiment (ERIE) Electrometer Initial Flight Results

The Electrostatic Regolith Interaction Experiment (ERIE) is a suborbital flight payload studying electrostatically charged dust particle dynamics under microgravity, jointly developed by University of Central Florida (UCF) and NASA Kennedy Space Center (KSC). ERIE combines components from two systems, the COLLisions Into Dust Experiment (COLLIDE) from UCF and the Wheel Electrostatic Spectrometer (WES) from NASA KSC, to advance understanding of charged grain behavior on low gravity bodies such as the Moon and asteroids. ERIE slides a door containing an electrometer system monitoring various insulating disks across the surface of a regolith simulant bed. The experiment is activated when the payload enters the microgravity potion of the flight. The grains in the simulant bed tribocharge via agitation during launch as well as through frictional interactions with the door and its protruding insulators. As the retention door retracts, particles are allowed to loft into an open volume, achieving motion due to electrostatic repulsion. The electrometer system measures the charge transfer between the granular material and the insulators. As the charged grains exit the bed, they travel through an applied electric field and a camera observes the kinematics of the individual grains whose trajectories are determined by their net charges. The design of the ERIE electrometer instrument and initial results from the first flight was presented at the 2021 AGU Fall Meeting under P55E-2002. Shortly after microgravity was achieved and the retaining door began to open, the rate of charge acquisition measured by the electrometer increased, indicating the insulators were accumulating triboelectric charge. Charged grains were observed in the video data to traverse across the external electric field and become deflected from a linear path due to their charges. Pairs of grains were also observed to orbit one another as expected from two oppositely charged bodies in proximity to one another. Improvements to the design of the instrument and preliminary results obtained from the second flight scheduled for Q3 2022 will be presented at this meeting.

Electrostatics↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

NASA’s Handheld Ionizer Tool for Astronauts

NASA’s next human lunar mission will require handheld tools to eliminate dust accumulation as well as electrostatic charge for the upcoming manned missions to the moon in the Artemis Program. The Moon’s lack of substantial atmosphere means the lunar surface is directly exposed to the solar wind, solar UV radiation, and cosmic rays which can cause dielectric charging of the lunar regolith via the photoelectric effect. The result is a layer of highly charged dust that is levitated and transported about a meter off the surface called the “horizon glow” as seen by the Apollo astronauts. The complex lunar electrostatic environment coupled with the surface dust behavior poses a concern for the longevity of surface infrastructures. The Electrostatics and Surface Physics Laboratory at NASA’S Kennedy Space Center retrofitted a commercial ionizer and successfully demonstrated that air ionizers are effective at removing dust particles and the static charge in high vacuum. Additional work is planned to establish the optimal voltage and flow characteristic to develop a high-fidelity ground prototype for future flight certification.

Electrostatics↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Design of Electrostatic Dust Lofting Suborbital Flight Experiment Examining Photoionization under Lunar Gravity

Dust on the lunar surface electrostatically charges due to the plasma environment surrounding the Moon, causing grains to become lofted and adhere to nearby surfaces including landers and astronauts. Studying the behaviors of these charged particles in the lunar environment is essential to plan around the deleterious effects of dust to future Moon missions. Models attempt to predict the amount of dust loading that can be expected in many of these scenarios, but they require experimental validation to be predictive. This physics cannot be fully studied on Earth due to the six times larger gravitational force obscuring the electrostatic interactions, so it is necessary to run experiments in a more relevant environment, including vacuum and near-lunar gravitational effects. An experiment has been designed to fly on the Lunar Gravity Acceleration (LGA) mission aboard the Blue Origin New Shepard suborbital rocket. This experiment will perform photoionization charging of lunar regolith simulant grains under the illumination of an ultraviolet (UV) source. As a result, the charged grains will then electrostatically repel one another and loft in the reduced gravity environment; their trajectories will be imaged via a high-speed camera. Preliminary laboratory results influencing the design of this experiment will be presented, including characterization of several UV sources, measurements of photoionization currents under various vacuum conditions, and examination of lunar simulant dust lofting under terrestrial gravity. Results from this flight will be compared with ground-based testing and the laboratory results outlined above to examine the dependence on gravity and will be fed into the dust charging and lofting models currently under development.

electrostatics↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Charge Deposition/Neutralization and Dust Removal via Plasma Interactions

Electrically charged and chemically reactive lunar dust can cause serious problems to spacecraft, surface equipment, and astronaut health, so understanding its interaction with and transport through the lunar plasma environment is important to dust mitigation efforts. We explore the charging of granular material in the natural environment of the Moon, recreate those conditions in the laboratory under high vacuum, and examine dust transport and charge neutralization for application in future lunar missions. Phenomena such as charge deposition via electron and ion beams, photoionization through ultraviolet light exposure, neutralization of charge through impingement by an ionized compressed gas, and tribocharging during dust liberation from surfaces will be presented. Surface materials of interest such as floating/grounded conductors and orthofabric for spacesuits are the preliminary focus of this effort. An electrometer is used to characterize currents interacting with the surfaces in the case of the electron/ion/UV source exposure, an electrostatic voltmeter is used to measure the potential on the surfaces without inadvertently discharging them, and a charge plate monitor is used to verify the efficiency of discharging the surfaces via ionized gas impingement. After setup of the initial charge conditions on the surfaces, a quick burst of high-pressure gas is used to overcome adhesion forces and initially dislodge the dust from the surfaces, followed by a low flow of gas that is ionized via application of a strong electric field. The gas is released in a high vacuum environment so as the pressure drops from the initial compressed state through to the vacuum state, the mean free path reaches a point where ionization can occur before all the gas disperses into the vacuum. This ionized gas can then neutralize both the dust and the surface to ensure minimal resettling. Several parameters such as gas composition, electrode geometry, high voltage waveform shape/polarity, and pulse timing have been explored and will be presented here.

electrostatics↗