DOE OSTI2014
This summary describes the results of applying the ADVANTG variance reduction parameter generator to accelerate continuous-energy Monte Carlo simulations of the {sup 252}Cf Interrogation with Prompt Neutron (CIPN) detection system proposed by Hu et al. for detecting the diversion of fuel elements from spent nuclear fuel (SNF) assemblies. In previous work, ADVANTG was applied to a suite of nine radiation detection, special nuclear material (SNM) movement detection, and safeguards test cases. That effort demonstrated that ADVANTG was able to provide large increases in tally figures of merit (FOMs) in nearly all of the cases without introducing bias into the Monte Carlo results. The objective of the work described here is to further evaluate ADVANTG, and also to identify gaps in capability with regard to nuclear safeguards applications, by applying the code to a challenging problem that is of a different nature from the ones previously studied. The CIPN nondestructive assay (NDA) system consists of three fission chambers embedded in a C-shaped block of polyethylene and a polyethylene-moderated {sup 252}Cf source that are placed on opposite sides of a subject SNF assembly. The idea of the detection system is to measure the difference between the background neutron count rate, due to spontaneous fission in the fuel material, and the count rate observed once the source is introduced, which is dominated by multiplication within the assembly. Based on the difference between these count rates, the fissile content of the assembly can be inferred, and this information can be used to determine if some fraction of the original fuel pins have been replaced with depleted uranium substitutes. The authors report that the system can detect the replacement of at least eight pins (3% of total mass). The ADVANTG code generates space- and energy-dependent weight-window bounds and biased source distributions based on approximate transport solutions that are efficiently generated by the Denovo 3-D discrete ordinates package. ADVANTG implements the Consistent Adjoint Driven Importance Sampling (CADIS) method for accelerating individual tallies and the Forward-Weighted CADIS (FW-CADIS) method for obtaining relatively uniform uncertainties across tallies over multiple regions and/or energy bins. The variance reduction parameters are generated in a format directly usable by standard versions of MCNP5 and MCNPX. In this work, the ADVANTG variance reduction parameter generator was applied to accelerate continuous energy MCNPX simulations of the {sup 252}Cf Interrogation with Prompt Neutron detection system for detecting the diversion of fuel elements from SNF assemblies. Variance reduction parameters generated with the existing version of ADVANTG actually slowed down tally convergence in all cases. The cause of the poor performance was found to be the lack of an induced fission source treatment in the fixed-source discrete ordinates calculations employed by ADVANTG. Because fission was treated as capture and not as a source, the importance maps generated by ADVANTG significantly underestimated the importance of thermal neutrons in and around the fuel elements. In order to obtain improved results, we developed an experimental implementation of a fission source outer iteration for the adjoint calculations. We used this prototype capability to generate new variance reduction parameters and found that the mean fission rates agreed well with those predicted by the conventional MCNPX simulations, as was expected. With these new parameters, speedup factors of 59 to 80 were obtained for the case with the background source, and factors of 17 to 24 were obtained for the cases with the interrogating source. These results demonstrate that a fission source treatment is needed to improve the effectiveness of ADVANTG in problems where the effects of induced fission are important. This includes many types of NDA problems that are relevant to safeguards applications. (authors)
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗