Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Kuhlman, Alison

Publications and source records attributed to Kuhlman, Alison.

Uranium Mill Tailings Radiation Control Act Title II DOE Due Diligence and Lessons Learned from a Previous Site Transfer - 20352

Title II of the Uranium Mill Tailings Radiation Control Act (UMTRCA) established that a government agency will provide perpetual care for closed uranium and thorium ore-processing sites that were operating under an NRC source material license in 1978 or were licensed thereafter. Commercial owners (licensees) operating under an NRC or agreement state specific license when UMTRCA was passed are responsible for conducting reclamation of any byproduct material remaining from uranium-ore processing operations in accordance with an NRC or agreement state approved reclamation plan. Reclamation includes both surface and groundwater remedies. Upon completion of reclamation and approval by NRC, the site is required to be transferred to either the host state or the DOE for long-term surveillance and maintenance. Since UMTRCA's enactment, six Title II sites have been transferred to DOE; an additional 24 Title II sites are anticipated to be transferred before 2050. DoE's role mandated under UMTRCA Title II as the long-term care custodian is to perform 'monitoring, maintenance, and emergency measures necessary to protect the public health and safety.' UMTRCA requires that the licensee pay a long-term surveillance charge 'sufficient to cover the annual costs of site surveillance.' However, at some sites such as the Bluewater, New Mexico, Disposal Site, this mandate has required additional effort and expense by DOE, beyond the originally anticipated and intended scope within UMTRCA, but within the authority of DOE under UMTRCA. In 1997, the Bluewater site became the second UMTRCA Title II site to be transferred to DOE. The site was the location of a uranium mill operated from 1953 until 1982. The specific licensee began site reclamation in 1991, and by 1995 all tailings and contaminated materials were encapsulated in two tailings disposal cells and other disposal areas. In addition to surface contamination, milling activities impacted groundwater in the two upper aquifers. In 1989, the specific licensee attempted active groundwater remediation; however, no significant reduction in contaminant concentrations was observed. As a result, the specific licensee applied to NRC for alternate concentration limits (ACLs) in 1990, which were approved in 1996 as being protective, after additional corrective actions were performed. Since transfer of the Bluewater site to DOE, unforeseen challenges have occurred, requiring additional actions. The first challenge is the occurrence of surface depressions located on the northern section of the main tailings disposal cell. The depressions were first observed during DoE's initial inspection in 1998; however, evidence of these can be observed on satellite images taken prior to transfer. Since being first observed, the depressions have continued to grow both in depth and areal extent. Due to the design of the main tailings disposal cell, the depressions impede storm water from being effectively shed off the 101- hectare (250-acre) top slope of the main tailings disposal cell. Instead, storm water accumulates in the depressions, forming a large ephemeral pond that has stored up to 16.3 x 10{sup 6} liters (4.3 million gallons) of stormwater. The ponding poses a potential risk to the integrity of the main tailings disposal cell in the case of a large storm event, with the potential to cause the pond to overtop and erode the cover material and underlying waste. DOE has taken a number of short-term actions to monitor, measure, and reduce the ponding and is currently working with the US Army Corps of Engineers to design and construct a repair. Additional challenges are associated with groundwater at the Bluewater site. Nine wells were present on the 1335-hectare (3300-acre) site upon transfer. Groundwater compliance was called into question after the State of New Mexico reduced its uranium groundwater standard from 5.0 to 0.03 milligrams per liter in 2004, and when an ACL for uranium was exceeded in a site monitoring well in 2010. Acquiring historical groundwater data and subsequent evaluations as well as additional DOE groundwater monitoring led to installing 10 new monitoring wells and performing additional site hydrogeology recharacterization. DOE continues to evaluate groundwater conditions at the site and works with the NRC to determine regulatory requirements and a path forward. As a result of lessons learned at the Bluewater site and other Title II sites, improved processes have been implemented at a programmatic level to increase due diligence before site transfer and prevent similar issues from occurring at other UMTRCA Title II sites under long-term management. DoE's due diligence process is documented in the Process for Transition of UMTRCA Title II Disposal Sites to DOE for Long-Term Surveillance and Maintenance and is designed to ensure that DOE has no technical or compliance concerns with regulatory decisions that might compromise protectiveness following site transfer to DOE. Implementation of the due diligence process has increased DoE's role prior to site transfer and has been effective in identifying potential issues. Actions by NRC and specific licensees, in response to enhanced due diligence efforts by DOE, are expected to minimize, if not totally prevent, the need for unanticipated actions by DOE pertaining to the surface and groundwater remedies after site transfer. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Stability of a Uranium-Contaminated Plume in a Karst Aquifer in Northwest New Mexico - 19574

The US Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Legacy Management monitors groundwater contamination resulting from ore processing operations conducted between 1953 and 1982 at a former uranium mill site on property that is now part of the Bluewater, New Mexico, Disposal Site. The site is located in the Grants Mineral Belt in northwest New Mexico at the base of the Zuni Mountains. It is estimated that prior to mill tailings encapsulation in 1995, approximately 21.6 billion liters (5.7 billion gallons) of tailings fluid seeped from the main tailings impoundment into the underlying aquifers. Today, there is remnant groundwater contamination from the mill in two aquifers: the San Andres-Glorieta (SAG) bedrock aquifer and the Ancestral Rio San Jose alluvial aquifer. Groundwater contamination in the SAG aquifer is of particular concern, as the aquifer is the primary water source in the region for municipal, agricultural, and industrial use. Municipal wells for the region are located as close as 6.4 kilometers (4 miles) southeast of the Main Tailings Disposal Cell. The SAG uranium plume extends east for more than 4.8 kilometers (3 miles) beyond the site's eastern boundary, along the direction of groundwater flow. The plume intersects the Homestake Mining Company site, another former uranium mill site undergoing active remediation. The SAG aquifer contains two formations, the Lower Permian San Andres Limestone and the Glorieta Sandstone. Most of the groundwater moving through the SAG aquifer is in ancient karst features consisting of open conduits where the limestone has dissolved, resulting in flow through solution cavities, solution channels, cavernous zones, and enlarged fracture openings. These features make the San Andres Limestone extremely permeable and capable of rapidly transporting groundwater. In addition, the karst characteristics make the aquifer difficult to evaluate and the uranium plume difficult to characterize. Numerous faults in the area, including two directly under the Main Tailings Disposal Cell, further complicate characterization by impacting groundwater flow both onsite and in the vicinity. A DOE study of the SAG aquifer uranium plume at the Bluewater site, conducted in 2014, indicated that the plume had moved offsite soon after the start of milling and effectively stabilized in its present location prior to the 1980's. An updated study completed in 2018 confirmed previous information regarding general plume stability and provided insight regarding potential localized trends east and south of the Main Tailings Disposal Cell. One such trend may be decreasing uranium concentrations east of the Main Tailings Disposal Cell, potentially attributable to regional groundwater elevation decreases. Both the 2013 and 2017 plumes suggest that the dissolved uranium contamination is derived from the leaching of a secondary mineralized zone derived from seeped tailings fluids in the geologic formations and fault zones below the Main Tailings Disposal Cell at the Bluewater site. In developing the 2013 and 2017 SAG aquifer uranium plume depictions, DOE had to address challenges associated with data quality and comparability. Analytical results used to determine the plume extent were compiled from multiple sources, including the state of New Mexico, Homestake Mining Company, and DOE. Each source used different well identifiers and coordinate systems, and well information between sources was inconsistent. Also, the integrity of some wells was questionable and necessitated review; casing integrity was found to be compromised in multiple wells. Given these uncertainties, some of these wells were excluded from the characterization. Another source of uncertainty is the paucity of wells, particularly monitoring wells, near or immediately downgradient of the leading edge of the plume. Therefore, the exact extent of the SAG aquifer uranium plume is not known at this time. There is, however, no evidence or indication of milling-related contamination in municipal wells. Furthermore, due to plume stability and direction of groundwater flow, the municipal wells are not expected to be impacted. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗