Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Kunz, M. Ross

Publications and source records attributed to Kunz, M. Ross.

Internal calibration of transient kinetic data via machine learning

The temporal analysis of products (TAP) reactor provides a vast amount of transient kinetic information that may be used to describe a variety of chemical features including residence time distributions, kinetic coefficients, number of active sites, reaction mechanism, etc. However, as with any measurement device, the TAP reactor signal is convoluted with noise and drift is common. In order to reduce the uncertainty of the kinetic measurement and any derived parameters or mechanisms, proper preprocessing must be performed prior to any advanced type of analysis. This preprocessing includes baseline correction, i.e., a shift in the voltage response, and calibration, i.e., a scaling of the flux response based on prior experiments. The traditional methodology of preprocessing requires significant user discretion and reliance on separate calibration experiments that may drift over time. Herein we use machine learning techniques combined with physical constraints to understand the noise and drift that is being generated within and between experiments for enhancement of the chemical kinetic signal. As such, the proposed methodology demonstrates clear benefits over the traditional preprocessing approach by eliminating the need for separate calibration experiments or heuristic input from the user.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Quantifying the impact of temporal analysis of products reactor initial state uncertainties on kinetic parameters

The temporal analysis of products (TAP) reactor, a transient kinetic tool, provides users with information as the catalyst state evolves. However, the state of the art for TAP uncertainty quantification only considers the experimental noise present in the outlet flow signal. Additional sources of uncertainty, including, but not limited to, initial surface coverages, the catalyst zone location, the inert void fraction, and the gas pulse intensity and pulse delay, are not included. For this reason, a framework for quantifying all uncertainty sources present in TAP experiments is presented and applied to a carbon monoxide oxidation case study. Herein, two methods for quantifying these sources of uncertainty are introduced. The first utilizes initial state sensitivities to approximate the parameter variances, as well as to provide insights into the structural certainty of the model. The second generates parameter confidence distributions through an ensemble-based sampling algorithm. This initial state covariance matrix can ultimately be merged with the experimental noise covariance matrix, providing a unified description of the parameter uncertainties for a single TAP experiment.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Mechanistic pathways and role of oxygen in oxidative coupling of methane derived from transient kinetic studies

Oxidative coupling of methane (OCM) is a promising industrial process to upgrade natural gas to high value chemicals. In this study, Temporal Analysis of Products (TAP) and steady-state experiments were conducted to distinguish how the composition of surface and gas phase oxygen influence mechanistic details of the selective conversion of CH 4 to C 2 H 4 over the Mn-Na 2 WO 4 /SiO 2 catalyst. The results from TAP studies indicate that methane activation on this catalyst proceeds predominantly via a short-lived, transient surface oxygen species and there is a competition for this species to form either CO or methyl radicals on the surface. This active species has a total lifetime of 3 s and is identified to have a dioxygen (e.g. O 2 2- or O 2 -) form. We show that the concentration of the transient surface oxygen species significantly impacts the OCM performance. Oxygen attributed to the catalyst lattice (in a singular form e.g., O - ), is found to activate methane to a lesser degree, but exclusively forms CO 2 . Evidence for these surface pathways for methyl radical, CO and CO 2 formation identified by TAP are also validated through steady-state experiments. Finally, by distinguishing different catalyst oxygen species and their role in selective/nonselective pathways, important screening criteria have been identified for the advancement of superior catalyst formulations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Understanding Reaction Networks through Controlled Approach to Equilibrium Experiments Using Transient Methods

We report a combined experimental/theoretical approach to studying heterogeneous gas/solid catalytic processes using low-pressure pulse response experiments achieving a controlled approach to equilibrium that combined with quantum mechanics (QM)-based computational analysis provides information needed to reconstruct the role of the different surface reaction steps. We demonstrate this approach using model catalysts for ammonia synthesis/decomposition. Polycrystalline iron and cobalt are studied via low-pressure TAP (temporal analysis of products) pulse response, with the results interpreted through reaction free energies calculated using QM on Fe-BCC(110), Fe-BCC(111), and Co-FCC(111) facets. In TAP experiments, simultaneous pulsing of ammonia and deuterium creates a condition where the participation of reactants and products can be distinguished in both forward and reverse reaction steps. This establishes a balance between competitive reactions for D* surface species that is used to observe the influence of steps leading to nitrogen formation as the nitrogen product remains far from equilibrium. Here, the approach to equilibrium is further controlled by introducing delay timing between NH 3 and D 2 which allows time for surface reactions to evolve before being driven in the reverse direction from the gas phase. The resulting isotopic product distributions for NH 2 D, NHD 2 , and HD at different temperatures and delay times and NH 3 /D 2 pulsing order reveal the role of the N 2 formation barrier in controlling the surface concentration of NH x * species, as well as providing information on the surface lifetimes of key reaction intermediates. Conclusions derived for monometallic materials are used to interpret experimental results on a more complex and active CoFe bimetallic catalyst.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Formation of Surface Impurities on Lithium–Nickel–Manganese–Cobalt Oxides in the Presence of CO 2 and H 2 O

Surface impurities involving parasitic reactions and gas evolution contribute to the degradation of high Ni content LiNi x Mn y Co z O 2 (NMC) cathode materials. The transient kinetic technique of Temporal Analysis of Products (TAP), density functional theory, and infrared spectroscopy have been used to study the formation of surface impurities on varying nickel content NMC materials (NMC811, NMC622, NMC532, NMC433, NMC111) in the presence of CO 2 and H 2 O. CO 2 reactivity on a clean surface as characterized by CO 2 conversion rate in the TAP reactor follows the order: NMC811 > NMC622 > NMC532 > NMC433 > NMC111. The capacity of CO 2 uptake follows a different order: NMC532 > NMC433 > NMC622 > NMC811 > NMC111. Moisture pretreatment slows down the direct CO 2 adsorption process and creates additional active sites for CO 2 adsorption. Electronic structure calculations predict that the (012) surface is more reactive than the ($10\bar{1}4$) surface for CO 2 and H 2 O adsorption. CO 2 adsorption leading to carbonate formation is exothermic with formation of ion pairs. The average CO 2 binding energies on the different materials follow the CO 2 reactivity order. Water hydroxylates the (012) surface and surface OH groups favor bicarbonate formation. Water creates more active sites for CO 2 adsorption on the ($10\bar{1}4$) surface due to hydrogen bonding. The composition of surface impurities formed in ambient air exposure is dependent on water concentration and the percentage of different crystal planes. Different surface reactivities suggest that battery performance degradation due to surface impurities can be mitigated by precise control of the dominant surfaces in NMC materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Early Battery Performance Prediction for Mixed Use Charging Profiles Using Hierarchal Machine Learning

A key step limiting how fast batteries can be deployed is the time necessary to provide evaluation and validation of performance. Using data analysis approaches, such as machine learning, the validation process can be accelerated. However, questions on the validity of projecting models trained on limited data or simple cycling profiles, such as constant current cycling, to real-world scenarios with complex loads remains. Here, we present the ability to predict performance with less than 1.2% mean absolute percent error when trained on cells aged using complex electric vehicle discharge profiles, and either AC Level 2 charge or DC Fast charge profiles, using only the first 45 cycles, namely 5% of the total testing time. While error is low across the projections, this study also highlights that battery lifetime analysis using only cycling data may not extrapolate safely to certain real-world conditions due to the impact of calendar degradation.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Rate/Concentration Kinetic Petals: A Transient Method to Examine the Interplay of Surface Reaction Processes

Transient pulse response experiments are used to construct rate/concentration (RC) kinetic dependencies—RC petals—and provide a new method to distinguish the timing and interplay of adsorption, surface reaction, and product formation on complex (industrial) materials. A petal shape arises as the dynamic “reaction-diffusion” experiment forces the concentration and reaction rate to return to zero. In contrast to the typical steady-state “Langmuir-type” RC dependence, RC petals have two branches, which arise as a result of decoupled gas and surface concentrations in the non-steady-state regime. To demonstrate this approach, the characteristics of petal shapes using ammonia decomposition as a probe reaction are presented. Ammonia, hydrogen, and nitrogen transformation rates are compared on three simple materials: Fe, Co, and a bimetallic CoFe preparation when ammonia is pulsed at 550°C in a low-pressure diffusion reactor. All materials demonstrate a two-branch kinetic RC dependence for ammonia adsorption, and rate constants are quantified in the low-coverage regime. We found that H 2 and N 2 product formation was dependent on the concentration of surface intermediates for all materials with one exception: for Co, an additional fast hydrogen generation process was observed; the rate of which coincided with ammonia adsorption. Nitrogen generation was only significant for CoFe and Co and on the CoFe catalyst, a self-inhibition property was observed. A method for estimating the number of active sites based on the RC petals is presented and was applied to the Fe and CoFe samples. The surface coverage and rate of formation/conversion of surface intermediates are interpreted from the examination of shape characteristics of the RC petals for each material.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Transient Kinetic Experiments within the High Conversion Domain: The Case of Ammonia Decomposition

In the development of catalytic materials, a set of standard conditions is needed where the kinetic performance of many samples can be compared. This can be challenging when a sample set covers a broad range of activity. Precise kinetic characterization requires uniformity in the gas and catalyst bed composition. This limits the range of convecting devices to low conversion (generally <20%). While steady-state kinetics offer a snapshot of conversion, yield and apparent rates of the slow reaction steps, transient techniques offer much greater detail of rate processes and hence more information as to why certain catalyst compositions offer better performance. In this work, transient experiments in two transport regimes are compared: an advecting differential plug flow reactor (PFR) and a pure-diffusion temporal analysis of products (TAP) reactor. The decomposition of ammonia was used as a model reaction to test three simple materials: polycrystalline iron, cobalt and a bimetallic preparation of the two. These materials presented a wide range of activity and it was not possible to capture transient information in the advecting device for all samples at the same conditions while ensuring uniformity. We push the boundary for the theoretical estimates of uniformity in the TAP device and find reliable kinetic measurement up to 90% conversion. However, what is more advantageous from this technique is the ability to observe the time-dependence of the reaction rate rather than just singular points of conversion and yield. For example, on the iron sample we observed reversible adsorption of ammonia and on cobalt materials we identify two routes for hydrogen production. From the time-dependence of reactants and product, the dynamic accumulation was calculated. This was used to understand the atomic distribution of H and N species regulated by the surface of different materials. When ammonia was pulsed at 550 °C, the surface hydrogen/nitrogen, (H/N), ratios that evolved for Fe, CoFe and Co were 2.4, 0.25 and 0.3 respectively. This indicates that iron will store a mixture of hydrogenated species while materials with cobalt will predominantly store NH and N. While much is already known about iron, cobalt and ammonia decomposition, the goal of this work was to demonstrate new tools for comparing materials over a wider window of conversion and with much greater kinetic detail. As a result, this provides an approach for detailed kinetic discrimination of more complex industrial samples beyond conversion and yield.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Pulse response analysis using the Y-procedure: A data science approach

We report that pulse response experiments can provide a wealth of data for transient kinetic studies of gas phase heterogeneous reactions, with the ability to paint a detailed picture of intrinsic reaction kinetics pertaining to complex catalytic mechanisms. A novel framework called the Y-Procedure was developed by Yablonsky et al. to extract information from non-steady-state kinetic data (Yablonsky et al., 2007). The Y-Procedure reconstructs the chemical transformation rate and gas composition in the catalytic zone with no a priori assumptions on the kinetic model and is used to relate changes in catalytic reaction rates and kinetic parameters to changes in a catalyst’s surface composition. This paper provides a detailed description of the data science work flow implemented in the Y-procedure through an experimental example of oxygen adsorption on platinum. Lastly, this powerful method, along with a robust list of pre-processing methodology, will enable deeper understanding of kinetic processes and mechanism to be derived from the TAP pulse response technique.

03 NATURAL GAS↗

Extracting Knowledge from Data through Catalysis Informatics

Catalysis informatics is a distinct sub-field that lies at the intersection of cheminformatics and materials informatics, but with unique challenges arising from the dynamic, surface-sensitive, multi-scale nature of heterogeneous catalysis. The ideas behind catalysis informatics can be traced back decades, but the field is only recently emerging due to advances in data infrastructure, statistics, machine learning, and computational methods. In this work we review the field from early works on expert systems and knowledge engines to more recent approaches utilizing machine-learning and uncertainty quantification. The data-information-knowledge hierarchy is introduced and used to classify various developments. The chemical master equation and micro-kinetic models are proposed as a quantitative representation of catalysis knowledge, which can be used to generate explanative and predictive hypotheses for the understanding and discovery of catalytic materials. We discuss future prospects for the field, including improved quantitative coupling of experiment/theory, advanced micro-kinetic models, and the development of open-source software tools. As a result, integration of existing chemical and physical models with emerging statistical and computational tools presents a promising route toward the automated design, discovery, and optimization of heterogeneous catalytic processes.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Investigating the Efficacy of Integrating Energy Crops into Non-Profitable Subfields in Iowa

We present that within-field spatial variability reduces growers’ return on investment and overall productivity while potentially increasing negative environmental impacts through increased soil erosion, nutrient runoff, and leaching. The hypothesis that integrating energy crops into non-profitable segments of agricultural fields could potentially increase grain yield and biomass feedstock production was tested in this study using a statewide analysis of predominantly corn- and soy-producing counties in Iowa. Basic and rigorous controls on permissible soil and soil-carbon losses were imposed on harvest of crop residues to enhance year-to-year sustainability of crop and residue production. Additional criteria limiting harvesting costs and focus on large-area subfields for biomass production were imposed to reduce the impacts of energy crop integration on grain production. Model simulations were conducted using 4 years (2013–2016) of soil, weather, crop yield, and management practice data on all counties in Iowa. Miscanthus (Miscanthus x giganteus), switchgrass (Panicum virgatum), and crop-residue-based bioenergy feedstock systems were evaluated as biomass. Average energy crop and plant residue harvesting efficiencies were estimated at 50 and 60%, respectively. Because of higher potential yields, average logistics costs for miscanthus-based biomass production were 15 and 23% lower than switchgrass-based and crop residue-based biomass productions, respectively, under basic sustainability controls, and 17 and 26% lower under rigorous sustainability controls. Lastly, subfield shape, size, area, and harvest equipment size were the dominant factors influencing harvesting cost and efficiency suggesting that in areas where subfields are predominantly profitable or harvesting efficiencies low, other options such as prairie strips, buffer zones around fields, and riparian areas should be investigated for more profitable biomass production and sustainable farming systems.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗