Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

La Haye, R J

Publications and source records attributed to La Haye, R J.

Aspect ratio effects on neoclassical tearing modes from comparison between DIII-D and National Spherical Torus Experiment

Neoclassical tearing mode islands are sustained by helically perturbed bootstrap currents arising at finite beta from toroidal effects that trap a fraction of the particles in non-circulating orbits. DIII-D and NSTX are here operated with similar shape and cross-sectional area but almost a factor of two difference in inverse aspect ratio a/R. In these experiments, destabilized n=1 tearing modes were self-stabilized (reached the 'marginal point') by reducing neutral-beam power and thus beta. The measure of the marginal island gives information on the small-island stabilizing physics that in part (with seeding) governs onset. The marginal island width on NSTX is found to be about three times the ion banana width and agrees with that measured in DIII-D, except for DIII-D modes closer to the magnetic axis, which are about two times the ion banana width. There is a balance of the helically perturbed bootstrap term with small island effects with the sum of the classical and curvature terms in the modified Rutherford equation for tearing-mode stability at the experimental marginal point. Empirical evaluation of this sum indicates that while the stabilizing effect of the curvature term is negligible in DIII-D, it is important in NSTX. The mode temporal behavior from the start of neutral-beam injection reduction also suggests that NSTX operates closer to marginal classical tearing stability; this explains why there is little hysteresis in beta between mode onset, saturation, and self-stabilization (while DIII-D has large hysteresis in beta). NIMROD code module component calculations based on DIII-D and NSTX reconstructed experimental equilibria are used to diagnose and confirm the relative importance of the stabilizing curvature effect, an advantage for low aspect ratio; the relatively greater curvature effect makes for less susceptibility to NTM onset even if the classical tearing stability index is near marginal.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

The limits and challenges of error field correction for ITER

Significant progress has been made in interpreting the effects of non-axisymmetric 'error' fields on a plasma through ideal MHD stability and a dominant 'least stable' ideal mode through which the fields couple to the tearing resonant surface. However, in contrast to expectations from such theories, experiments have found limited success in correcting error fields, with single correction coil arrays giving benefits of between 0% and {approx}50% correction (in terms of improvement to a low density locked mode limit), dependent on the structure of the error and correcting fields. With additional coils up to {approx}70% is possible. It was unclear whether this represented an intrinsic stability or control limit, or higher order toroidal or poloidal harmonic effects. Thus, studies on the DIII-D tokamak explored correction of a proxy error field, using two differently structured coil arrays. This enabled the principles of error correction to be tested at high amplitudes and operational densities, with known pure n=1 fields. Results showed substantial residual effects from the corrected n=1 field, with improvements of only {approx}50% in the low density locked mode limit. This suggests that n=1 error fields must couple to more than one surface in the plasma, and this is conjectured to be through more than one ideal mode, thereby requiring precise correction. For ITER, updated predictions of field error have been obtained and compared with revised scalings for tearing mode thresholds, indicating 50% or better error field correction will be needed. This will likely require more than one well coupled correction coil array and sets a challenge for theory to model the behavior, in order to clarify the plasma response and braking mechanisms, and so the effectiveness of ITER's correction coils and the possible need for support from its edge localized mode control coils.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Off-axis fishbone-like instability and excitation of resistive wall modes in JT-60U and DIII-D

An energetic-particle (EP)-driven ''off-axis-fishbone-like mode (OFM)'' often triggers a resistive wall mode (RWM) in JT-60U and DIII-D devices, preventing long-duration high-{beta}{sub N} discharges. In these experiments, the EPs are energetic ions (70-85 keV) injected by neutral beams to produce high-pressure plasmas. EP-driven bursting events reduce the EP density and the plasma rotation simultaneously. These changes are significant in high-{beta}{sub N} low-rotation plasmas, where the RWM stability is predicted to be strongly influenced by the EP precession drift resonance and by the plasma rotation near the q=2 surface (kinetic effects). Analysis of these effects on stability with a self-consistent perturbation to the mode structure using the MARS-K code showed that the impact of EP losses and rotation drop is sufficient to destabilize the RWM in low-rotation plasmas, when the plasma rotation normalized by Alfven frequency is only a few tenths of a percent near the q=2 surface. The OFM characteristics are very similar in JT-60U and DIII-D, including nonlinear mode evolution. The modes grow initially like a classical fishbone, and then the mode structure becomes strongly distorted. The dynamic response of the OFM to an applied n=1 external field indicates that the mode retains its external kink character. These comparative studies suggest that an energetic particle-driven 'off-axis-fishbone-like mode' is a new EP-driven branch of the external kink mode in wall-stabilized plasmas, analogous to the relationship of the classical fishbone branch to the internal kink mode.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Measurement and modeling of three-dimensional equilibria in DIII-D

A detailed experiment-theory comparison reveals that linear ideal MHD theory is in quantitative agreement with external magnetic and internal soft x-ray measurements of the plasma response to externally applied non-axisymmetric fields over a broad range of beta and rotation. This result represents a significant step toward the goal of advancing the understanding of three-dimensional tokamak equilibria. Both the magnetic and soft x-ray measurements show the driven plasma perturbation increases linearly with the applied perturbation, suggesting the relevance of linear plasma response models. The magnetic and soft x-ray measurements are made at multiple toroidal and poloidal locations, allowing well resolved measurements of the global structure. The comparison also highlights the need to include kinetic effects in the MHD model once beta exceeds 80% of the kink mode limit without a conducting wall. Two distinct types of response fields are identified by the linear ideal MHD model: one that consists of localized currents at the rational surfaces that cancel the applied resonant field and another that is excited by the components of the external field that couple to the kink mode. Numerical simulations show these two fields have similar amplitudes in ITER-shaped DIII-D discharges where n = 3 fields are used to suppress edge localized modes.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Magnetohydrodynamic interference with the edge pedestal motional Stark effect diagnostic on DIII-D

Accurate measurement of internal magnetic field direction using motional Stark effect (MSE) polarimetry in the edge pedestal is desired for nearly all tokamak scenario work. A newly installed 500 kHz 32-channel digitizer on the MSE diagnostic of DIII-D allows full spectral information of the polarimeter signal to be recovered for the first time. Fourier analysis of this data has revealed magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) fluctuations in the plasma edge pedestal at {rho}{>=} 0.92. By correlating edge localized mode fluctuations seen on lock-in amplifier outputs with MSE spectrograms, it has been shown that edge pedestal tearing mode fluctuations cause interference with MSE second harmonic instrument frequencies. This interference results in unrecoverable errors in the real-time polarization angle measurement that are more than an order of magnitude larger than typical polarimeter uncertainties. These errors can cause as much as a 38% difference in local q. By using a redundant measure of the linear polarization found at the fourth harmonic photo-elastic modulator (PEM) frequency, MHD interference can be avoided. However, because of poorer signal-to-noise the fourth harmonic signal computed polarization angle shows no improvement over the MHD polluted second harmonics. MHD interference could be avoided in future edge pedestal tokamak polarimeters by utilizing PEMs with higher fundamental frequencies and a greater separation between their frequencies.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Islands in the stream: The effect of plasma flow on tearing stability

Reducing plasma flow clearly decreases the stability of tearing modes in multiple regimes (sawtooth, hybrid) in both high- and low-aspect-ratio tokamaks (DIII-D [J. L. Luxon, Nucl. Fusion 42, 614 (2002)], Joint European Torus [M. Keilhacker and the JET Team, Plasma Phys. Controlled Fusion 41, 301 (1999)], National Spherical Torus Experiment [M. Ono, S. M. Kaye, Y.-K. M. Peng, Nucl. Fusion 40, 557 (2000)], each with distinct means of lessening rotation). Further, reducing flow makes pre-existing 'saturated' islands larger at the same beta (beta). Thus lower plasma flow impairs high-beta operation owing both to the destabilization and to the impact of tearing-mode islands. Experimental results suggest that flow shear (not flow) at the tearing rational surface is classically stabilizing, making the effective tearing stability index DELTA{sup '} of the total current density profile more negative (more stable). In this picture, with profiles and all else the same, the minimum metastable beta at which neoclassical tearing modes (NTMs) can destabilize is proportional to -DELTA{sup '} and hence lower flow and flow shear lead to possible destabilization (depending on seeding) at lower beta. Similarly, if destabilized, the saturated NTM island width is proportional to -beta/DELTA{sup '} and thus increases as flow and flow shear are reduced. A working model gives a significant level of stabilizing shear if the plasma toroidal angular flow shear -dOMEGA{sub p}hi/dr at a given rational surface is of order of the inverse of the product of the local values of the parallel magnetic shear length L{sub s} and the Alfven time tau{sub A}. Experimental data are fitted for the effect of this normalization of flow shear in a simple empirical model for both onset and saturation of tearing modes. Most theoretical literature is on the consequence of flow shear on tearing stability at zero beta; tokamaks at high beta have large magnetic Prandtl number (an issue for the sign of the flow effect) and very large Lundquist number. It is in this regime that theory will be compared with experimentally based empirical models. The consequence for future tokamaks with low rotation may be lower tearing stability than now expected.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Validation of the linear ideal magnetohydrodynamic model of three-dimensional tokamak equilibria

The first quantitative comparison of linear ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) theory with external magnetic measurements of the nonaxisymmetric plasma perturbation driven by external long-wavelength magnetic fields in high-temperature tokamak plasmas is presented. The comparison yields good (within 20%) agreement for plasma pressures up to approx75% of the ideal stability limit calculated without a conducting wall. For higher plasma pressures, the ideal MHD model tends to overestimate the perturbed field indicating the increasing importance of stabilizing nonideal effects.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Advanced techniques for neoclassical tearing mode control in DIII-D

Two techniques were developed at DIII-D [J. L. Luxon, Nucl. Fusion 42, 64 (2002)] to tackle ITER-specific aspects of neoclassical tearing mode (NTM) control, namely, (1) the relatively small size of the rotating islands, smaller than the electron cyclotron current drive (ECCD) deposition region, and (2) the increased tendency of the islands, compared to present devices, to lock to the wall or to the residual error field, in a position not necessarily accessible to ECCD. Modulated ECCD is known to suppress small islands more efficiently, when ''broad,'' than continuous ECCD. At DIII-D, a NTM of poloidal/toroidal mode numbers m/n=3/2 was completely stabilized by a new technique where oblique electron cyclotron emission acted at the same time as an indicator of good alignment between ECCD and the island, and as a waveform generator, for modulation in synch and in phase with the island O-point. In another experiment, after locking in an unfavorable position, a 2/1 island was steered by externally generated magnetic perturbations, brought in the view of the gyrotrons and partly stabilized by ECCD in the island O-point. Magnetic perturbations were also used to sustain and control the mode rotation, which has the potential for an easier ECCD modulation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Low-Z Shell Pellet Experiments on DIII-D

Small (o.d. = 1.8 mm, t = 0.37 mm) polystyrene shells filled with either pressurized argon gas or boron powder have been fired into DIII-D plasmas for disruption mitigation experiments. The pellet shells were observed to burn up at rhoapprox =0.5, roughly consistent with ablation rate calculations. Pellet slowing from 350 m/s down to 100 m/s was observed, which is not well-understood at present. Negligible plasma current contraction or MHD onset were seen as a result of the shell burn-up in the plasma edge, consistent with calculations. The pellet payloads were observed to ionize rapidly in the pellet vicinity (<1 cm radius) and rapid (<15 ms) mixing through the plasma core was observed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Plasma Shape Optimization for Steady-State Tokamak Development in DIII-D

For a more detailed account of the results summarized here and for references, see C.T. Holcomb et al., Phys. Plasmas 16, 056116 (2009). Advanced tokamak research on DIII-D is focused on developing a high fusion gain, steady-state scenario that would eliminate or greatly reduce the demands on an inductive transformer in future machines. Steady-state operation requires the inductively driven current density (j{sub Ind}) be zero everywhere. Most of the total current I{sub p} is typically from self-driven bootstrap current, with the remainder driven by external noninductive sources, such as neutral beam and radiofrequency current drive. This paper describes an extension of the fully noninductive condition (f{sub NI} {approx} 100%) to {approx}0.7 current relaxation times that was achieved by a combination of more available ECCD and new scientific insights. The insights are an optimization of performance through variation of the plasma shape parameter known as squareness ({zeta}) and an optimization of divertor magnetic balance. These optimizations simultaneously improve stability, confinement, and density control. These are each essential for achieving fully noninductive operation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗