Engineering topics
Larbalestier, David C.
Publications and source records attributed to Larbalestier, David C..
Influence of Nb alloying on Nb recrystallization and the upper critical field of Nb 3 Sn
Nb 3 Sn conductors are important candidates for high-field magnets for particle accelerators, and they continue to be widely used for many laboratory and NMR magnets. However, the critical current density, J c , of present Nb 3 Sn conductors declines swiftly above 12-15 T. State-of-the-art Ta- and Ti-doped strands exhibit upper critical field, H c2 , values of ~ 24-26.5 T (4.2 K) and do not reach the FCC target J c , which serves as the present stretch target for Nb 3 Sn development. As recently demonstrated, to meet this goal requires enhanced vortex pinning but an independent and supplementary approach is to significantly enhance H c2 . In this study, we have arc-melted multiple Nb alloys with added Hf, Zr, Ta and Ti and drawn them successfully into monofilament wires to investigate the possibilities of H c2 enhancement through alloying. H c2 (T) was measured for all samples in fields up to 16 T and some up to 31 T. We have found that all alloys show good agreement with the standard Werthamer, Helfand, and Hohenberg (WHH) fitting procedure without the need to adjust the paramagnetic limitation parameter (α) and spin-orbit scattering parameter (λ so ). The evaluation of dH c2 /dT near T c , which is proportional to the electronic specific heat coefficient γ and the normal state resistivity ρn, allows a better understanding of the induced disorder introduced by alloying in the A15 phase. So far, we have observed that Hf alloying of pure Nb can enhance H c2 (0) by 3-4 T to ~28 T, while adding just 1 at. %Hf or Zr into a Nb4Ta base alloy can raise H c2 (0) to ~31 T. Very importantly we find that Hf and Zr raise the alloy recrystallization temperature above the usual A15 reaction temperature range of 650°C – 750°C, thus ensuring denser A15 phase nucleation in the Nb alloy grain boundaries, possibly leading to a more homogeneous A15 phase Sn content and refined A15 grain size. Furthermore, the potential for further advancements in Nb 3 Sn properties is explored in relation to the recrystallization of the Nb alloy and the factors controlling the upper critical field.
Nuclear magnetic resonance investigation of superconducting and normal state Nb 3 Sn
The superconductor Nb3Sn has important applications for construction of very high-field superconducting magnets. In this work we investigate its microscopic electronic structure with 93 Nb nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The high-quality Nb 3 Sn powder sample was studied in both 3.2 T and 7 T magnetic fields in the temperature range from 4 K to 300 K. From measurement of the spectrum and its theoretical analysis, we find evidence for anisotropy despite its cubic crystal structure. Magnetic alignment of the powder grains in the superconducting state was also observed. The Knight shift and spin-lattice relaxation rate, T 1 -1 , were measured and the latter compared with BCS theory for the energy gap Δ(0) = 2.7 ± 0.3k B T c at 3.2 T and Δ(0) = 2.33 ± 0.07 k B T c at 7 T, indicating suppression of the order parameter by magnetic field.
ac susceptibility studies of intra- and intergrain properties of high-$J_c$ Bi-2212 wires
Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O x (Bi-2212) is the only high-$T_c$ superconductor (HTS) available as a multifilamentary round wire with multiple architectures and it is a very promising conductor for the realization of high-field applications. Despite their relatively simple wire fabrication by the powder-in-tube technique, Bi-2212 wires require a tightly controlled overpressure heat treatment (HT) with a multi-parameter time-temperature schedule to achieve high critical current density, $J_c$. Further, the variation of these HT parameters, changes in the wire design, wire diameter and powder quality can lead to variations in both the microstructure and the superconducting performance. Particularly noticeable are variations in $J_c$ performance and degree of filament bridging. In this work, we focus on the use of different magnetic characterization techniques to estimate the bridging level and assess the balance of INTER-grain and intra-grain superconducting properties including the irreversibility field ($H_{\text{irr}}$) and the pinning energy ($U_0$) in differently processed wires. Regardless of the actual bridging level, we find that the supercurrent flows at the filament bundle level, not just at the individual filament level. Moreover, using AC susceptibility we identify two distinct supercurrent contributions, one related to the intra-grain and one to the INTER-grain properties, whose irreversibility fields are different but without large sample-to-sample variation. Moreover, an additional component of intra-grain pinning mechanism becomes effective at low temperatures with positive effects also on the INTER-grain performance. The work clearly shows that detailed magnetic characterizations can become valuable tools to investigate the performance of differently processed Bi-2212 wires, correlating their microstructure and overall transport $J_c$, to obtain a deeper understanding of the causes of performance variation and paths to achieve further improvement.
Origin of the enhanced Nb3Sn performance by combined Hf and Ta doping
Abstract In recent years there has been an increasing effort in improving the performance of Nb 3 Sn for high-field applications, in particular for the fabrication of conductors suitable for the realization of the Future Circular Collider (FCC) at CERN. This challenging task has led to the investigation of new routes to advance the high-field pinning properties, the irreversibility and the upper critical fields ( H Irr and H c2 , respectively). The effect of hafnium addition to the standard Nb-4Ta alloy has been recently demonstrated to be particularly promising and, in this paper, we investigate the origins of the observed improvements of the superconducting properties. Electron microscopy, Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure Spectroscopy (EXAFS) and Atom Probe Tomography (APT) characterization clearly show that, in presence of oxygen, both fine Nb 3 Sn grains and HfO 2 nanoparticles form. Although EXAFS is unable to detect significant amounts of Hf in the A15 structure, APT does indeed reveal some residual intragrain metallic Hf. To investigate the layer properties in more detail, we created a microbridge from a thin lamella extracted by Focused Ion Beam (FIB) and measured the transport properties of Ta-Hf-doped Nb 3 Sn. H c2 (0) is enhanced to 30.8 T by the introduction of Hf, ~ 1 T higher than those of only Ta-doped Nb 3 Sn, and, even more importantly the position of the pinning force maximum exceeds 6 T, against the typical ~ 4.5–4.7 T of the only Ta-doped material. These results show that the improvements generated by Hf addition can significantly enhance the high-field performance, bringing Nb 3 Sn closer to the requirements necessary for FCC realization.
Effect of heat treatments on superconducting properties and connectivity in K-doped BaFe2As2
Abstract Fe-based superconductors and in particular K-doped BaFe 2 As 2 (K-Ba122) are materials of interest for possible future high-field applications. However the critical current density ( J c ) in polycrystalline Ba122 is still quite low and connectivity issues are suspected to be responsible. In this work we investigated the properties of high-purity, carefully processed, K-Ba122 samples synthesized with two separate heat treatments at various temperatures between 600 and 825 °C. We performed specific heat characterization and T c -distribution analysis up to 16 T and we compared them with magnetic T c and J c characterizations, and transmission-electron-microscopy (TEM) microstructures. We found no direct correlation between the magnetic T c and J c , whereas the specific heat T c -distributions did provide valuable insights. In fact the best J c -performing sample, heat treated first at 750 °C and then at 600 °C, has the peak of the T c -distributions at the highest temperatures and the least field sensitivity, thus maximizing H c2 . We also observed that the magnetic T c onset was always significantly lower than the specific heat T c : although we partially ascribe the lower magnetization T c to the small grain size (< λ , the penetration depth) of the K-Ba122 phase, this behaviour also implies the presence of some grain-boundary barriers to current flow. Comparing the T c -distribution with J c , our systematic synthesis study reveals that increasing the first heat treatment above 750 °C or the second one above 600 °C significantly compromises the connectivity and suppresses the vortex pinning properties. We conclude that high-purity precursors and clean processing are not yet enough to overcome all J c limitations. However, our study suggests that a higher temperature T c -distribution, a larger H c2 and a better connectivity could be achieved by lowering the second heat treatment temperature below 600 °C thus enhancing, as a consequence, J c .
Effects of Wire Diameter and Filament Size on the Processing Window of Bi-2212 Round Wire
High engineering critical current density (J E of 1300 A/mm 2 at 4.2 K and 15 T) in Bi-2212 round wire has been achieved through a partial melt, overpressure heat treatment process. J E varies strongly with processing conditions, particularly the maximum heat treatment temperature (T max ). Increasing T max results in longer time in the melt (defined as the time between when Bi-2212 melts on heating and when Bi-2212 begins to form on cooling), more bridging between the filaments, lower J E , and higher ac losses. A wide processing window with a large range of T max that has a nearly constant J E is desired for processing large coils with large thermal mass and significant thermal time constants that may make precise control over the desired temperature – time profiles uncertain. Accordingly, we wanted to explore broadening the T max window by controlling the Bi-2212 powder melting or wire architecture design. In this work, we report on studies of the performance variation with T max for two production wires with a filling factor of about 20% and 85 × 18 filaments where filament size was varied by changing the wire diameter, a process which also shortens the distance between filaments. We found that wires with smaller filament diameter (9 to 11 μm) showed a peak J E at the low end of T max and also a J E that was more sensitive to T max . A J E – T max plot showed a plateau J E (4.2 K, 5 T) of ~1100 A/mm 2 between T max of 886 and 894 °C for 1.0 and 1.2 mm wires, where J E is less sensitive to the wire diameter and T max . This J E plateau range is a preferred processing window for achieving high J E in coils.
Critical Current Distributions of Recent Bi-2212 Round Wires
Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O 8+x (Bi-2212) is the only high-field, high-temperature superconductor (HTS) capable of reaching a critical current density J c (16 T, 4.2 K) of 6500 A·mm –2 in the highly desirable round wire (RW) form. However, state-of-the-art Bi-2212 conductors still have a critical current density (J c ) to depairing current density (J d ) ratio around 20 to 30 times lower than that of state-of-the-art Nb–Ti or REBCO. Previously, we have shown that recent improvements in Bi-2212 RW J c are due to improved connectivity associated with optimization of the heat treatment process, and most recently due to a transition to a finer and more uniform powder manufactured by Engi-Mat. One quantitative measure of connectivity may be the critical current (I c ) distribution, since the local I c in a wire can vary along the length due to variable vortex-microstructure interactions and to factors such as filament shape variations, grain-to-grain connectivity variations and blocking secondary phase distributions. Modeling the experimental V-I transition measured on a low resistance shunt as a complex sum of voltage contributions of individual filament and wire sub-sections allows a numerical extraction of the I c distribution from the d 2 V/dI 2 treatment of the V-I curves. Here we compare ~0.1 m length I c distributions of Bi-2212 RWs with recent state-of-the-art very high-J c Engi-Mat powder and lower J c and older Nexans granulate powder. We do find that the I c spread for Bi-2212 wires is about twice the relative standard of high-J c Nb–Ti well below H irr . We do not yet see any obvious contribution of the Bi-2212 anisotropy to the I c distribution and are rather encouraged that these Bi-2212 round wires show relative I c distributions not too far from high-J c Nb–Ti wires.
Evidence of Kramer extrapolation inaccuracy for predicting high field Nb 3 Sn properties
Future applications requiring high magnetic fields, such as the proposed Future Circular Collider, demand a substantially higher critical current density, J c , at fields ≥16 T than is presently available in any commercial strand, so there is a strong effort to develop new routes to higher J c Nb 3 Sn. As a consequence, evaluating the irreversibility field (H irr ) of any new conductor to ensure reliable performance at these higher magnetic fields becomes essential. To predict the irreversibility field for Nb 3 Sn wires, critical current measurements, I c , are commonly performed in the 12-15 T range and the Kramer extrapolation is used to predict higher field properties. Here, the Kramer extrapolation typically models the contribution only for sparse grain boundary pinning, yet Nb 3 Sn wires rely on a high density of grain boundaries to provide the flux pinning that enables their high critical current density. However, whole-field range VSM measurements up to 30 T recently showed for Nb 3 Sn RRP® wires that the field dependence of the pinning force curve significantly deviates from the typical grain boundary shape, leading to a 1-2 T overestimation of Hirr when extrapolated from the typical mid-field data taken only up to about 15 T. In this work we characterized a variety of both RRP® and PIT Nb 3 Sn wires by transport measurements up to 29 T at the Laboratoire National des Champs Magnétiques Intenses (LNCMI), part of the European Magnetic Field Laboratory in Grenoble, to verify whether or not such overestimation is related to the measurement technique and whether or not it is a common feature across different designs. Indeed we also found that when measured in transport the 12-15 T Kramer extrapolation overestimates the actual H irr in both types of conductor with an inaccuracy of up to 1.6 T, confirming that high field characterization is a necessary tool to evaluate the actual high field performance of each Nb 3 Sn wire.
Ta, Ti and Hf effects on Nb 3 Sn high-field performance: temperature-dependent dopant occupancy and failure of Kramer extrapolation
The increasing demand for improving the high-field (16-22 T) performance of Nb 3 Sn conductors requires a better understanding of the properties of modern wires much closer to irreversibility field, H Irr . In this study we investigated the impact of Ta, Ti and Hf doping on the high-field pinning properties, the upper critical field, H c2 , and H Irr . We found that the pinning force curves of commercial Ti and Ta doped wires at different temperatures do not scale and that the Kramer extrapolation, typically used by magnet designers to estimate high-field critical current density and magnet operational margins from lower field data, is not reliable and significantly overestimates the actual H Irr . In contrast, new laboratory scale conductors made with Nb-Ta-Hf alloy have improved high-field J c performance and, despite contributions by both grain boundary and point defect pinning mechanisms, have more predictable high-field behavior. Using Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure spectroscopy, EXAFS, we found that for the commercial Ta and Ti doped conductors, the Ta site occupancy in the A15 structure gradually changes with the heat treatment temperature whereas Ti is always located on the Nb site with clear consequences for H c2 . Finally, this work reveals the still limited understanding of what determines H c2 , H Irr and the high-field J c performance of Nb 3 Sn and the complexity of optimizing these conductors so that they can reach their full potential for high-field applications.
Investigation of Precipitation and Segregation of Secondary Phase Byproducts in Intermetallic Superconducting Materials
For broader acceptance, the next generation of superconductors for high magnetic field appli-cations will need to be both higher performance and lower cost. In this work, we contrast two super-conductors that are candidates for high field magnets; Nb 3 Sn, which has a long history yet has seen renewed interest in recent years because of remarkable advances in its properties, and Fe-based superconductors that offer potentially low-costs and very high fields. TEM techniques are essential to understand how to engineer the desired micro-/nanostructure that ultimately defines the properties for these superconductors.
Beneficial influence of Hf and Zr additions to Nb4at%Ta on the vortex pinning of Nb 3 Sn with and without an O source
In this paper we show that addition of Hf to Nb4Ta can significantly improve the high field performance of Nb 3 Sn, making it suitable for dipole magnets for a machine like the 100 TeV Future Circular Collider (FCC). A big challenge of the FCC is that the desired non-Cu critical current density (J c ) target of 1500 A mm –2 (16 T, 4.2 K) is substantially above the best present Nb 3 Sn conductors doped with Ti or Ta (~1300 A mm –2 in the very best sample of the very best commercial wire). Recent success with internal oxidation of Nb–Zr precursor has shown significant improvement in the layer J c of Nb 3 Sn wires, albeit with the complication of providing an internal oxygen diffusion pathway and avoiding degradation of the irreversibility field H Irr . We here extend the Nb1Zr oxidation approach by comparing Zr and Hf additions to the standard Nb4Ta alloy of maximum H c2 and H Irr . Nb4Ta rods with 1Zr or 1Hf were made into monofilament wires with and without SnO 2 and their properties measured over the entire superconducting range at fields up to 31 T. We found that Group IV alloying of Nb4Ta does raise H Irr , though O 2 addition still slightly degrades it. As noted in earlier Nb1Zr work with an O source, the pinning force density F p is strongly enhanced and its peak value shifted to higher field by internal oxidation. A surprising result of this work is that we found better properties in Nb4Ta1Hf without SnO 2 , F pMax achieving 2.35 times that of the standard Nb4Ta alloy, while the oxidized Nb4Ta1Zr alloy achieved 1.54 times that of the Nb4Ta alloy. The highest layer J c (16 T, 4.2 K) of 3700 A mm –2 was found in the SnO 2 -free wire made with Nb4Ta1Hf alloy. Using a standard A15 cross-section fraction of 60% for modern powder-in-tube and rod restack process wires, we estimated that a non-Cu J c of 2200 A mm –2 is obtainable in modern conductors, well above the 1500 A mm –2 FCC specification. Moreover, since the best properties were obtained without SnO 2 , the Nb4Ta1Hf alloy appears to open a straightforward route to enhanced properties in Nb 3 Sn wires manufactured by virtually all the presently used commercial routes employed today.
Investigation of the melt-growth process of YbBa 2 Cu 3 O 7−δ powder in Ag-sheathed tapes
We investigate the reaction mechanism of the melting and regrowth of Yb123 in Ag tape, which provides a starting point to fabricate Ag-sheathed Yb123 wires by PIT.
Prediction of the J C (B) Behavior of Bi-2212 Wires at High Field
Bi-2212 wires have been produced for much of the last decade with varying architectures, powder sources and great variability of final J c (B) properties. As Bi-2212 transitions from an R&D materials development to a magnet technology, means to predictably forecast J c (B) become increasingly valuable. Here we report on characterizations of short samples having J c (15T, 4.2 K) varying from 1210 to 6560 A/mm 2 , measured in fields up to 31 T, and drawn from 10 billets. Using both 4 K transport and variable temperature VSM measurements capable of probing the 20 K irreversibility field, B irr = μ 0 H k , we discovered that the vortex pinning properties are very stable across these wires, which all used the same standard powder composition (Bi 2.17 Sr 1.94 Ca 0.89 Cu 2.00 O 8+x ), even though it has been made by three different manufacturers over nine years. We conclude that a power-law fit J c ∝ B -α , where α = 0.280 (σ = 0.015), works well at 4.2 K over the field range of at least 3-30 T and that μ 0 H k (20 K) remains stable at 8.6 ± 0.4 T. We conclude that the dominant current limiting mechanism predicting J c (B) in Bi-2212 is the effective filament connectivity. J c (B) at high fields may thus be predicted by simple I c measurements at easily accessible fields in the 3-15 T range.
High-Performance Bi-2212 Round Wires Made With Recent Powders
Multifilamentary Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O x (Bi-2212) wire made by the powder-in-tube technique is the only high-temperature superconductor made in the round shape preferred by magnet builders. The critical current density (J C ) of Bi-2212 round wire was improved significantly by the development of overpressure heat treatment in the past few years. Bi-2212 wire is commercially available in multiple architectures and kilometer-long pieces and is a very promising conductor for very high-field NMR and accelerator magnets. Here, we studied the effects of precursor powder and heat treatment conditions on the superconducting properties and microstructure of recent Bi-2212 wires. Short samples of recent wire with optimized overpressure processing showed J C (4.2 K, 15 T) = 6640 A/mm 2 and J C (4.2 K, 30 T) = 4670 A/mm 2 , which correspond to engineering critical current densities J E (4.2 K, 15 T) = 1320 A/mm 2 and J E (4.2 K, 30 T) = 930 A/mm 2 .
Controlling Cu–Sn mixing so as to enable higher critical current densities in RRP ® Nb 3 Sn wires
Dipole magnets for the proposed Future Circular Collider (FCC) demand specifications significantly beyond the limits of all existing Nb 3 Sn wires, in particular a critical current density (J c ) of more than 1500 A mm -2 at 16 T and 4.2 K with an effective filament diameter (D eff ) of less than 20 μm. The restacked-rod-process (RRP ® ) is the technology closest to meeting these demands, with a J c (16 T) of up to 1400 A mm -2 , residual resistivity ratio > 100, for a sub-element size D s of 58 μm (which in RRP ® wires is essentially the same as D eff ). An important present limitation of RRP ® is that reducing the sub-element size degrades J c to as low as 900 A mm -2 at 16 T for D s = 35 μm. To gain an understanding of the sources of this J c degradation, we have made a detailed study of the phase evolution during the Cu–Sn 'mixing' stages of the wire heat treatment that occur prior to Nb 3 Sn formation. Using extensive microstructural quantification, we have identified in this paper the critical role that the Sn–Nb–Cu ternary phase (Nausite) can play. The Nausite forms as a well-defined ring between the Sn source and the Cu/Nb filament pack, and acts as an osmotic membrane in the 300 °C–400 °C range—greatly inhibiting Sn diffusion into the Cu/Nb filament pack while supporting a strong Cu counter-diffusion from the filament pack into the Sn core. This converts the Sn core into a mixture of the low melting point (408 °C) η phase (Cu 6 Sn 5 ) and the more desirable ε phase (Cu 3 Sn), which decomposes at 676 °C. After the mixing stages, when heated above 408 °C towards the Nb 3 Sn reaction, any residual η liquefies to form additional irregular Nausite on the inside of the membrane. All Nausite decomposes into NbSn 2 on further heating, and ultimately transforms into coarse-grain (and often disconnected) Nb 3 Sn which has little contribution to current transport. Understanding this critical Nausite reaction pathway has allowed us to simplify the mixing heat treatment to only one stage at 350 °C for 400 h which minimizes Nausite formation while encouraging the formation of the higher melting point ε phase through better Cu–Sn mixing. Finally, at a D s of 41 μm, the Nausite control heat treatment increases the J c at 16 T by 36%, reaching 1300 A mm -2 (i.e. 2980 A mm -2 at 12 T), and moving RRP ® closer to the FCC targets.
Evidence from EXAFS for Different Ta/Ti Site Occupancy in High Critical Current Density Nb 3 Sn Superconductor Wires
To meet critical current density, Jc, targets for the Future Circular Collider (FCC), the planned replacement for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the high field performance of Nb 3 Sn must be improved, but champion J c values have remained static for the last 10 years. Making the A15 phase stoichiometric and enhancing the upper critical field H c2 by Ti or Ta dopants are the standard strategies for enhancing high field performance but detailed recent studies show that even the best modern wires have broad composition ranges. To assess whether further improvement might be possible, we employed EXAFS to determine the lattice site location of dopants in modern high-performance Nb 3 Sn strands with J c values amongst the best so far achieved. Although Ti and Ta primarily occupy the Nb sites in the A15 structure, we also find significant Ta occupancy on the Sn site. These findings indicate that the best performing Ti-doped stand is strongly sub-stoichiometric in Sn and that antisite disorder likely explains its high average H c2 behavior. These new results suggest an important role for dopant and antisite disorder in minimizing superconducting property distributions and maximizing high field J c properties.
Improvement of small to large grain A15 ratio in Nb 3 Sn PIT wires by inverted multistage heat treatments
The next generation of superconducting accelerator magnets for the Large Hadron Collider at CERN will require large amounts of Nb 3 Sn superconducting wires and the Powder-In-Tube (PIT) process, which utilizes a NbSn 2 -rich powder core within tubes of Nb(7.5wt%Ta) contained in a stabilizing Cu matrix, is a potential candidate. But, the critical current density, J c , is limited by the formation of a large grain (LG) A15 layer which does not contribute to transport current, but occupies 25-30% of the total A15 area. Thus it is important to understand how this layer forms, and if it can be minimized in favor of the beneficial small grain (SG) A15 morphology which carries the supercurrent. The ratio of SG/LG A15 is our metric here, where an increase signals improvement in the wires A15 morphology distribution. We have made a critical new observation that the initiation of the LG A15 formation can be controlled at a wide range of temperatures relative to the formation of the small grain (SG) A15. The LG A15 can be uniquely identified as a decomposition product of the Nb6Sn5(Cu x ), surrounded by a layer of rejected Cu, thus the LG A15 is not only of low pin density, but is not continuous grain to grain. We have found that in single stage reactions limited to 630 °C - 690 °C, the maximum SG A15 layer thickness prior to LG A15 formation is very sensitive to temperature, with a maximum around 670 °C. This result led to the design of four novel heat treatments which all included a short, high temperature stage early in the reaction, followed by a slow cooling to a more typical reaction temperature of 630 °C. We also found that this heat treatment (HT) modification increased the SG A15 layer thickness while simultaneously suppressing LG A15 morphology, with no additional consumption of the diffusion barrier. In the best heat treatment the SG/LG A15 ratio improved by 30%. Unfortunately, J c values suffered slightly, however further exploration of this high temperature reaction region is required to understand the limits to A15 formation in Nb3Sn PIT conductors.