Lechner, Eric | Search NASA

DOE OSTI2024

Oxide dissolution and oxygen diffusion scenarios in niobium and implications on the Bean–Livingston barrier in superconducting cavities

We generalize a native Nb2O5 dissolution model [G. Ciovati, Appl. Phys. Lett. 89, 022507 (2006)] to sequential overlayer dissolutions, multilayer dissolution, and realistic temperature profiles, which may be applicable to other materials. The model is applied to secondary ion mass spectrometry depth profile measurements for varying temperature profiles and two-step oxide dissolution in Nb and found to agree well. In the context of the Meissner screening response due to impurity profiles on the length scale of the London penetration depth, the shallow diffusion of O impurities results in a substantial decrease in the peak supercurrent density near the surface. In this framework, oxide dissolution and oxygen diffusion can account for a rise in peak supportable magnetic field in SRF cavities with baking time and a suppression after the optimal baking time is reached, in good agreement with peak-field baking temperatures and times as well as recent quench field measurements.

Lechner, Eric↗

DOE OSTI2023

Topographic Evolution of Heat-Treated Nb Upon Electropolishing for SRF Applications

Surface finish plays an essential role in the performance of superconducting radio frequency cavities. Several surface treatments have been developed to reduce surface resistance at a moderate accelerating gradient. We investigated the effects of sequential electropolishing on samples vacuum heat-treated at 300 and 600 °C and N-doped Nb samples using atomic force microscopy. The N-doping process precipitates niobium nitrides within grains and, most notably, continuously and deeply along some grain boundaries. Upon electropolishing, the nitrides are preferentially removed leaving behind a topographically imperfect surface marked by relatively deep holes and grooves with low radius of curvature edges. The progression of magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors upon electropolishing were investigated using atomic force micrographs. While minor changes in magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors are observed for the 300 and 600 °C heat-treated Nb, substantial improvements are observed for N-doped Nb. In this system, the most severe topographic defects are the grain boundary grooves which substantially suppress the superheating field. We find that the severity of topographic defects is related to the N-doping process.

Lechner, Eric↗

DOE OSTI2023

SURFACE ROUGHNESS REDUCTION AND PERFORMANCE OF Nb3Sn FILM FOR SRF APPLICATIONS

Nb3Sn offers better RF performance (Q and Eacc) than Nb at any given temperature because of its superior superconducting properties. The potential deployment of Nb3Sn-coated SRF cavities at 4 K, delivering similar performance to that of Nb cavities at 2 K, will be a transformational technology to enable new classes of SRF accelerator applications. A clean and smooth surface can enhance the performance of the Nb3Sn-coated cavity, typically, the attainable acceleration gradient. The reduction of surface roughness is often linked with a correlative reduction in average coating thickness and grain size. A new approach to enhance the nucleation centers using the pre-deposition of Sn on Nb is introduced for surface roughness reduction. Besides Sn supply's careful tuning, the temperature profiles were varied to engineer the coating surface with reduced roughness as low as ~40 nm in 20 µm × 20 µm AFM scans, one-third that of the typical coating. Electropolishing of coated sample shows surface a clear surface smoothening. A few sets of coating parameters were used to coat 1.3 GHz sin-gle-cell cavities to understand the effects of roughness variation on the RF performance. This presentation discusses ways to reduce surface roughness with results from a systematic analysis of the samples and Nb3Sn-coated single-cell cavities.

Pudasaini, Uttar↗

DOE OSTI2023

SIMS CHARACTERIZATION OF NITROGEN DOPING OF LCLS-II-HE PRODUCTION CAVITIES

The thermal diffusion of nitrogen into the surface of niobium has been shown to yield superior low-loss SRF performance. An effective solution was identified and promptly employed in the production of cryomodules for LCLS-II. With added experience and R&D, a modified process was chosen for use in the upgrade for LCLS-II-HE. Largely motivated by this circumstance, supporting research has significantly refined the technique for making calibrated secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) measurements of the N concentration depth profiles produced by production processes. Standardized reference samples were included with four HE production cavities in their N-doping furnace runs. We report the calibrated dynamic SIMS depth profiles of N, C, and O for these samples, together with the cryogenic acceptance test performance of the associated cavities. Interpretation and comparison with similar samples acquired in other furnaces highlights the importance of intentional process quality control of furnace conditions.

Reece, Charles↗

DOE OSTI2023

Topographic Evolution of Nb Surfaces Subjected to Electropolishing

Surface quality plays an important role in the performance of SRF cavities. We report the topographic evolution of H degassed, N and O doped Nb surfaces subjected to electropolishing using atomic force microscopy. N doped Nb shows a substantial increase in roughness due to formation of niobium nitrides into the surface. Implications of the topography on magnetic field enhancement and vortex entry are discussed.

Lechner, E.M.↗

DOE OSTI2023

SIMS CHARACTERIZATION OF NITROGEN DOPING OF LCLS-II-HE PRODUCTION CAVITIES

The thermal diffusion of nitrogen into the surface of niobium has been shown to yield superior low-loss SRF performance. An effective solution was identified and promptly employed in the production of cryomodules for LCLS-II. With added experience and R&D, a modified process was chosen for use in the upgrade for LCLS-II-HE. Largely motivated by this circumstance, supporting research has significantly refined the technique for making calibrated secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) measurements of the N concentration depth profiles produced by production processes. Standardized reference samples were included with four HE production cavities in their N-doping furnace runs. We report the calibrated dynamic SIMS depth profiles of N, C, and O for these samples, together with the cryogenic acceptance test performance of the associated cavities. Interpretation and comparison with similar samples acquired in other furnaces highlights the importance of intentional process quality control of furnace conditions.

Reece, Charles↗

DOE OSTI2022

Challenges to Reliable Production Nitrogen Doping of Nb for SRF Accelerating Cavities

Over the last several years, alloying of the surface layer of niobium SRF cavities has been demonstrated to beneficially lower the superconducting RF surface resistance. Nitrogen, titanium, and oxygen have all been demonstrated as effective alloying agents, occupying interstitial sites in the niobium lattice within the RF penetration depth and even deeper, when allowed to thermally diffuse into the surface at appropriate temperatures. The use of nitrogen for this function has been often termed ’nitrogen doping’ and is being applied in the LCLS-II and LCLS-II HE projects. We report characterization studies of the distribution of nitrogen into the exposed niobium surface and how such distribution is affected by the quality of the vacuum furnace environment in which the doping takes place, and the complexity of nitride crystal growth on different grain orientations of surface niobium. Using state-of-the-art quantification methods by dynamic secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) depth profiling in niobium, we identify several phenomena involving furnace-sourced contamination. We also highlight a potential issue with N₂ flow constraints from the flange ’caps’ used during heat treatments.

Reece, Charles↗

DOE OSTI2022

Modeling O and N Alloying in Nb for SRF Applications

N and O-alloyed superconducting radio frequency cavities exhibit extraordinary quality factors. Developing diffusion models that describe interstitial N and O in Nb is important for optimizing alloyed cavity quality factors and accelerating gradients. N and O-alloyed Nb samples are examined with SEM AND SIMS and their diffusion profiles modeled.

Lechner, Eric↗