Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Lewis, E. E.

Publications and source records attributed to Lewis, E. E..

VARI3D & PERSENT: Perturbation and Sensitivity Analysis (Revision 5)

The nodal diffusion method is one of the most widely used approaches in modern reactor analysis. In the nodal diffusion method, a coarse multi-group set of “homogenized” parameters is constructed such that the complex geometry of a reactor core along with the energy dependence of neutron and gamma ray cross sections in a nuclear reactor are conserved in the simpler geometry. The homogenization is typically done on a fuel assembly level as is the case in the DIF3D code developed at Argonne National Laboratory. The nodal methodology is used primarily to predict fuel cycle behavior of nuclear systems of which there is a substantial amount of validation in the literature. Another use of the nodal method is to obtain reactivity coefficients and kinetics parameters for use in a safety analysis of a given nuclear reactor. While there are many ways to obtain reactivity worth and kinetics parameters, the work presented in this manuscript is unique as it provides the user with the ability to compute reactivity worths, kinetics parameters, and cross section sensitivities with a Cartesian and hexagonal geometry-based transport code.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

VARI3D & PERSENT: Perturbation and Sensitivity Analysis

The nodal diffusion method is one of the most widely used approaches in modern reactor analysis. In the nodal diffusion method, a coarse multi-group set of “homogenized” parameters is constructed such that the complex geometry of a reactor core along with the energy dependence of neutron and gamma ray cross sections in a nuclear reactor are conserved in the simpler geometry. The homogenization is typically done on a fuel assembly level as is the case in the DIF3D code developed at Argonne National Laboratory. The nodal methodology is used primarily to predict fuel cycle behavior of nuclear systems of which there is a substantial amount of validation in the literature. Another use of the nodal method is to obtain reactivity coefficients and kinetics parameters for use in a safety analysis of a given nuclear reactor. While there are many ways to obtain reactivity worth and kinetics parameters, the work presented in this manuscript is unique as it provides the user with the ability to compute reactivity worths, kinetics parameters, and cross section sensitivities with a Cartesian and hexagonal geometry based transport code.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

VARI3D & PERSENT: Perturbation and Sensitivity Analysis

The nodal diffusion method is one of the most widely used approaches in modern reactor analysis. In the nodal diffusion method, a coarse multi-group set of “homogenized” parameters is constructed such that the complex geometry of a reactor core along with the energy dependence of neutron and gamma ray cross sections in a nuclear reactor are conserved in the simpler geometry. The homogenization is typically done on a fuel assembly level as is the case in the DIF3D code developed at Argonne National Laboratory. The nodal methodology is used primarily to predict fuel cycle behavior of nuclear systems of which there is a substantial amount of validation in the literature. Another use of the nodal method is to obtain reactivity coefficients and kinetics parameters for use in a safety analysis of a given nuclear reactor. While there are many ways to obtain reactivity worth and kinetics parameters, the work presented in this manuscript is unique as it provides the user with the ability to compute reactivity worths, kinetics parameters, and cross section sensitivities with a Cartesian and hexagonal geometry based transport code.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

A Variational Nodal Approach to 2D/1D Pin Resolved Neutron Transport for Pressurized Water Reactors

A two-dimensional/one-dimensional (2D/1D) variational nodal approach is presented for pressurized water reactor core calculations without fuel-moderator homogenization. A 2D/1D approximation to the within-group neutron transport equation is derived and converted to an even-parity form. The corresponding nodal functional is presented and discretized to obtain response matrix equations. Within the nodes, finite elements in the x-y plane and orthogonal functions in z are used to approximate the spatial flux distribution. On the radial interfaces, orthogonal polynomials are employed; on the axial interfaces, piecewise constants corresponding to the finite elements eliminate the interface homogenization that has been a challenge for method of characteristics (MOC)-based 2D/1D approximations. The angular discretization utilizes an even-parity integral method within the nodes, and low-order spherical harmonics (P N ) on the axial interfaces. The x-y surfaces are treated with high-order P N combined with quasi-reflected interface conditions. Furthermore, the method is applied to the C5G7 benchmark problems and compared to Monte Carlo reference calculations.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Variational Nodal 2D/1D Transport/Diffusion Solutions of the C5G7 Benchmark Problems

This work is the continuation of our effort to generalize the variational nodal method (VNM) for application to pin-resolved whole-core PWR problems. To this end, a 2D/1D VNM method without spatial homogenization is formulated and implemented in the PANX code. We employ diffusion theory in the axial direction combined with two-dimensional transport in the x-y plane. In our initial work, we employed the standard spherical harmonics method. To increase accuracy and reduce computational effort, we present two refinements: First, the even-parity integral method within the nodes reduces the computational effort required to form the response matrices. Second, the use of quasi-reflected interface conditions reduces the dimension of the resulting response matrices and therefore the CPU time required to solve the equations. We apply the method to the three-dimensional, un-rodded C5G7 benchmark problem. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

A Variational Nodal Approach to 2D/1D Pin Resolved Neutron Transport: I Diffusion Theory

The variational nodal method (VNM) as implemented in the VARIANT code has been widely employed to fast reactor cores, but much less so for thermal reactors. In what follows we report the initial phase of development of the PANX code (Purdue - Argonne - Northwestern - Xi'an) for three-dimensional pin resolved PWR transport calculations. In two dimensions, prototype modifications of VARIANT using finite elements to obtain heterogeneous nodes and quasi-reflected interface conditions to reduce the high angular-order interface conditions, have been successfully employed to the 2D C5G7 benchmark. In three dimensions, however, the polynomial interface conditions employed in VARIANT smear fuel and coolant at each axial interface, leading to lack of convergence as the axial mesh is refined. This problem is also encountered in the 2D/1D approximations in MOC based methods. The intent of this work is to eliminate these interface homogenization effects from VNM calculations. For clarity, in this work we examine these phenomena in diffusion theory. The next stage of development will incorporate spherical harmonic trial functions to achieve more accurate transport solutions. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

A Variational Nodal Approach to 2D/1D Pin Resolved Neutron Transport: II Spherical Harmonics

The variational nodal method (VNM) as implemented in the VARIANT code has found wide application to fast reactor problems where fuel assembly homogenization does not result in unacceptable errors. The objective of this research is to generalize VNM for application to PWR problems, where homogenization even at the pin-cell level often results in unacceptable errors. To accomplish this, we are developing the PANX code (Purdue - Argonne - Northwestern - Xi'an) to implement a 2D/1D VNM transport method without spatial homogenization employing spherical harmonics and diffusion theory, respectively, in the radial and axial directions. In the preceding paper, we employed diffusion theory in conjunction with finite element methods to implement heterogeneous VNM nodes, in which the problem of fuel-coolant smearing at axial interfaces, found in existing 2D/1D approximations, is eliminated. In this work, we generalize the resulting VNM nodes to couple spherical harmonics in the x-y plane with axial diffusion theory. We then apply the method to the three-dimensional C5G7 benchmark problem. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Variational Nodal 2D/1D Transport/Diffusion Solutions of the C5G7 Benchmark Problems

This work is the continuation of our effort to generalize the variational nodal method (VNM) for application to pin resolved whole-core PWR problems. To this end, a 2D/1D VNM method without spatial homogenization is formulated and implemented in the PANX code. We employ diffusion theory in the axial direction combined with two-dimensional transport in the x-y plane. In our initial work, we employed the standard spherical harmonics method. To increase accuracy and reduce computational effort, we present two refinements: First, the even-parity integral method within the nodes reduces the computational effort required to form the response matrices. Second, the use of quasi-reflected interface conditions reduces the dimension of the resulting response matrices and therefore the CPU time required to solve the equations. We apply the method to the three-dimensional, unrodded C5G7 benchmark problem.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

DIF3D-VARIANT 11.0: A Decade of Updates

The DIF3D code has been a workhorse of fast reactor analysis work at Argonne National Laboratory for over 30 years. In 1995, a transport option called VARIANT was added to DIF3D to improve the flux solutions for fast reactor problems. VARIANT performs nodal neutron transport calculations using PN or SPN theory in Cartesian and hexagonal two- and threedimensional geometries. Because of the computing capabilities at that time, VARIANT was restricted to 33 group P3 flux approximations with P1 scattering. Clearly computer memory capabilities have increased since then and thus large space-angle-energy approximations are possible. This manuscript serves as an update to the theory section of the original manual and details more than a decade worth of changes made to DIF3D to make DIF3D 11.0.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

VARI3D & PERSENT: Perturbation and Sensitivity Analysis

The nodal diffusion method is one of the most widely used approaches in modern reactor analysis. In the nodal diffusion method, a coarse multi-group set of “homogenized” parameters is constructed such that the complex geometry of a reactor core along with the energy dependence of neutron and gamma ray cross sections in a nuclear reactor are conserved in the simpler geometry. The homogenization is typically done on a fuel assembly level as is the case in the DIF3D code developed at Argonne National Laboratory. The nodal methodology is used primarily to predict fuel cycle behavior of nuclear systems of which there is a substantial amount of validation in the literature. Another use of the nodal method is to obtain reactivity coefficients and kinetics parameters for use in a safety analysis of a given nuclear reactor. While there are many ways to obtain reactivity worth and kinetics parameters, the work presented in this manuscript is unique as it provides the user with the ability to compute reactivity worths, kinetics parameters, and cross section sensitivities with a Cartesian and hexagonal geometry based transport code. This manuscript serves as a single manual for two separate codes: VARI3D and PERSENT. The VARI3D code (VARiational 3D) is based upon the classic finite difference diffusion theory solver available in DIF3D. The PERSENT code (PERturbation and SENitivity for Transport) is based upon the variational nodal method employed in DIF3D termed VARIANT. The VARIANT solver was added to DIF3D in 1995 and has seen continued development and use for the last 18 years. Because VARI3D primarily uses deprecated coding practices, rather than incorporate the perturbation and sensitivity treatments for transport within VARI3D, a new coding development was built using modern Fortran coding. The primary purpose of this manual is to describe the theory behind PERSENT (and by convenience, that of VARI3D) and discuss the input and output of PERSENT along with giving potential users an idea of how to use it. While this manuscript does describe the input and output of VARI3D, the PERSENT code is intended to be the replacement capability of VARI3D as PERSENT can generate nearly identical (if not superior) diffusion theory results. In this manuscript, the relevant aspects of generalized perturbation theory that are relevant to both VARI3D and PERSENT are covered. The input and output of VARI3D is displayed by excerpting several of the example problems. Similarly, the input and output of PERSENT is displayed along with tips on how best to use the code. Note that the input and output of the inhomogeneous solver wrapped around DIF3D (DIF3D_IFS) is also discussed as it is needed to carry out some of the sensitivities in PERSENT such as reaction rate ratios. This manuscript describes several perturbation theory problems and sensitivity problems and the results computed using PERSENT. From these sections, potential users should find that PERSENT provides not only the typical tables of numbers desired in perturbation and sensitivity analysis work, but also can visually plot the result for a more thorough understanding of the space and energy distribution (Section 5). Overall, PERSENT is observed to produce accurate reactivity worths and sensitivities for the displayed set of test problems and clearly demonstrates the need to have a transport based sensitivity capability as evident from the thousands of percent errors observed in the 21 group hexagonal fast reactor problem (covered in Section 7).

Smith, M. A.↗

Development Status of PROTEUS-MOC

The PROTEUS-MOC solver is intended to resolve the outstanding computational challenges that the PROTEUS-SN is limited by and bridge the gap between PROTEUS-SN and existing homogenized structured grid solvers. The primary push behind all of this work is to carry out coupled thermal-mechanical, fluid dynamics, and neutronics physics problems. The PROTEUS-MOC development has taken advantage of the combined experience with PROTEUS-SN and DeCART with the goal of producing a tool which combines the best features of both tools. Taking the DeCART tool as the model, it merges a subgroup cross section interpolation technique with a 2D method of characteristics approach and a 1D SN formulation. DeCART has been specifically demonstrated to be accurate on PWR and VHTR problems, but it has displayed several issues with regard to accuracy on thin axial mesh sizes which are attributable to the 2D1D scheme it is built upon. There are also notable problems with performance and scalability all of which we hope to resolve in PROTEUS-MOC. PROTEUS-MOC is at its core, based upon the success achieved with MOCFE which demonstrated excellent parallelization with respect to angle and good parallelization with respect to space. More recent efforts have indicated parallelization with respect to energy is also feasible. The work completed yielded a novel methodology where the axial basis functions are treated separately from the radial ones, but the geometry is extruded. This eliminates the need to carry out and store 3D ray tracing data and simultaneously allows the coarse axial node sizes typical with DeCART. To rapidly build a prototype, a standard power iteration algorithm was constructed using an unpreconditioned GMRES solution algorithm for solving the flux vector in each fission source iteration. The new PROTEUS-MOC solver was deployed on two test problems: Takeda and a heterogeneous cylindrical heavy water system. The Takeda benchmark problem is a standard homogeneous test problem which was previously found to be too difficult for the 3D MOCFE code to solve. Using the PROTEUS-MOC we were able to show space-angle convergence although full convergence requires further improvements in performance. The second benchmark problem was constructed more for future work than this year, but the results generated are promising indicating that it will be very useful in highlighting the weaknesses and strengths of the PROTEUS-MOC tool. While we are far from a production tool, the results included in this report give us confidence that we are on the right path to constructing an interceding code between the plethora of structured grid homogenized assembly solvers and the supercomputer consuming PROTEUS-SN code. With time, the creation of a suitable preconditioner along with typical optimization should reduce the performance shortcomings that are observable today.

Marin-Lafleche, A.↗

Comparison of homogenized and enhanced diffusion solutions of model PWR problems

Model problem comparisons in slab geometry are made between two forms of homogenized diffusion theory and enhanced diffusion theory. The pin-cell discontinuity factors for homogenized diffusion calculations are derived from homogenized variational nodal P1 response matrices and from standard finite differencing. Enhanced diffusion theory consists of applying quasi-reflected interface conditions to reduce variational nodal Pn response matrices to one degree of freedom per interface, without homogenization within the cell. As expected both homogenized diffusion methods preserve reaction rates exactly if the discontinuity factors are derived from the P 11 reference solutions. If no reference lattice solution is available, discontinuity factors may be approximated from single cells with reflected boundary conditions; the computational effort is then comparable to calculating the enhanced diffusion response matrices. In this situation enhanced diffusion theory gives the most accurate results and finite difference discontinuity factors the least accurate. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

A parallel in energy Krylov solution algorithm for the variational nodal method

To reduce the computational expense caused by the large number of energy groups in thermal and fast reactor calculations, we researched using parallelization in energy (i.e. group) of the multi-group response matrix equations derived from the Variational Nodal Method. This study focuses on solving steady-state eigenvalue problems in diffusion theory that are typically needed for depletion and reactivity coefficient calculations. To examine serial and parallel performance, GMRES, a Krylov algorithm, is applied to the multi-group system of equations at each fission source iteration. We also study the impact of using Wielandt acceleration on the eigenvalue/eigenvector problem. Numerical results based on a 72 group thermal and a 216 group fast reactor core problems are obtained for both serial and parallel calculations. The results show reduced CPU times when using GMRES and Wielandt acceleration in both serial and parallel calculations. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

FY2010 Status Report on Advanced Neutronics Modeling and Validation

UNIC is the neutronics component of the massively parallel, multi-physics SHARP (Simulation for High-efficiency Advanced Reactor Prototyping) framework under development at Argonne National Laboratory. During this fiscal year, the SN2ND solver, MOCFE solver, and NODAL solver received significant development to meet the needs of the SHARP project. Additional follow-on analysis of the ZPR-6/6A from the previous year was performed in addition to new analysis of the ZPR-6/7 experiments where UNIC predictions of ZPR foil activation were made against experimentally measured values.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

General Monte Carlo reliability simulation code including common mode failures and HARP fault/error-handling

A Monte Carlo Fortran computer program was developed that uses two variance reduction techniques for computing system reliability applicable to solving very large highly reliable fault-tolerant systems. The program is consistent with the hybrid automated reliability predictor (HARP) code which employs behavioral decomposition and complex fault-error handling models. This new capability is called MC-HARP which efficiently solves reliability models with non-constant failures rates (Weibull). Common mode failure modeling is also a specialty.

Platt, M. E.↗