Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Long, Kevin N.

Publications and source records attributed to Long, Kevin N..

On the effect of strain rate during the cyclic compressive loading of liquid crystal elastomers and their 3D printed lattices

Nematic liquid crystal elastomers (LCEs) are a unique class of network polymers with the potential for enhanced mechanical energy absorption and dissipation capacity over conventional network polymers because they exhibit both conventional viscoelastic behavior and soft-elastic behavior (nematic director changes under shear loading). This additional inelastic mechanism makes them appealing as candidate damping materials in a variety of applications from vibration to impact. The lattice structures made from the LCEs provide further mechanical energy absorption and dissipation capacity associated with packing out the porosity under compressive loading. Understanding the extent of mechanical energy absorption, which is the work per unit mass (or volume) absorbed during loading, versus dissipation, which is the work per unit mass (or volume) dissipated during a loading cycle, requires measurement of both loading and unloading response. Here, in this study, a bench-top linear actuator was employed to characterize the loading-unloading compressive response of polydomain and monodomain LCE polymers and polydomain LCE lattice structures with two different porosities (nominally, 62% and 85%) at both low and intermediate strain rates at room temperature. As a reference material, a bisphenol-A (BPA) polymer with a similar glass transition temperature (9 °C) as the nematic LCE (4 °C) was also characterized at the same conditions for comparing to the LCE polymers. Based on the loading-unloading stress-strain curves, the energy absorption and dissipation for each material at different strain rates (0.001, 0.1, 1, 10 and 90 s -1 ) were calculated with considerations of maximum stress and material mass/density. The strain-rate effect on the mechanical response and energy absorption and dissipation behaviors was determined. The energy dissipation ratio was also calculated from the resultant loading and unloading stress-strain curves. All five materials showed significant but different strain rate effects on energy dissipation ratio. The solid LCE and BPA materials showed greater energy dissipation capabilities at both low (0.001 s -1 ) and high (above 1 s -1 ) strain rates, but not at the strain rates in between. The polydomain LCE lattice structure showed superior energy dissipation performance compared with the solid polymers especially at high strain rates.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Exploring pressure-dependent inelastic deformation and failure in bonded granular composites: An energetic materials perspective

In polymer-filled granular composites, damage may develop in mechanical loading prior to material failure. Damage mechanisms such as microcracking or plastic deformation in the binder phase can substantially alter the material’s mesostructure. For energetic materials, such as solid propellants and plastic bonded explosives, these mesostructural changes can have far reaching effects including degraded mechanical properties, potentially increased sensitivity to further insults, and changes in expected performance. Unfortunately, predicting damage is nontrivial due to the complex nature of these composites and the entangled interactions between inelastic mechanisms. In this work, we assess the current literature of experimental knowledge, focusing on the pressure-dependent shear response, and propose a simple simulation framework of bonded particles to study four limiting-case material formulations at both meso- and macro-scales. Further, to construct the four cases, we systematically vary the relative interfacial strength between the polymer binder and granular filler phase and also vary the polymer’s glass transition temperature relative to operating temperature which determines how much the binder can plastically deform. These simulations identify key trends in global mechanical response, such as the emergence of strain hardening or softening regimes with increasing pressure which qualitatively resemble experimental results. By quantifying the activation of different inelastic mechanisms, such as bonds breaking and plastically straining, we identify when each mechanism becomes relevant and provide insight into potential origins for changes in mechanical responses. The locations of broken bonds are also used to define larger, mesoscopic cracks to test various metrics of damage. We primarily focus on triaxial compression, but also test the opposite case of triaxial extension to highlight the impact of Lode angle on mechanical behavior.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Calibrating constitutive models with full‐field data via physics informed neural networks

Abstract The calibration of solid constitutive models with full‐field experimental data is a long‐standing challenge, especially in materials that undergo large deformations. In this paper, we propose a physics‐informed deep‐learning framework for the discovery of hyperelastic constitutive model parameterizations given full‐field surface displacement data and global force‐displacement data. Contrary to the majority of recent literature in this field, we work with the weak form of the governing equations rather than the strong form to impose physical constraints upon the neural network predictions. The approach presented in this paper is computationally efficient, suitable for irregular geometric domains, and readily ingests displacement data without the need for interpolation onto a computational grid. A selection of canonical hyperelastic material models suitable for different material classes is considered including the Neo–Hookean, Gent, and Blatz–Ko constitutive models as exemplars for general non‐linear elastic behaviour, elastomer behaviour with finite strain lock‐up, and compressible foam behaviour, respectively. We demonstrate that physics informed machine learning is an enabling technology and may shift the paradigm of how full‐field experimental data are utilized to calibrate constitutive models under finite deformations.

Hamel, Craig M.↗

Stabilized Hyperfoam Modeling of the General Plastics EF4003 (3 PCF) Flexible Foam

Constitutive model parameterizations for the General Plastics EF4003 low density 3 pound per cubic foot are needed for design and qualification purposes in normal and abnormal mechanical simulations. The material is expected to be deformed in two ways: first during preloading, and second under impact conditions of the system (transient dynamic). All analyses are to be performed at room temperature. The goal is to provide the analysis community a robust constitutive model parameterization to represent the compression behavior of the EF4003 foam from small deformations up to massive compressive deformations when the foam is densifying. It is worth noting the EF4003 exhibits anisotropy in its stress-strain behavior between the rise and transverse directions (See figure 2.8c-d) as well as plateau behavior that is very likely to cause material stability issues, due to the buckling transition, (and has historically done so) when using Sandia’s current workhorse models for flexible foams, Hyperfoam and Flex Foam. A Stability-informed Hyperfoam parameterization procedure is developed and executed to calibrate a hyperfoam model for the EF4003 room temperature, transversely loaded data. A rise orientation parameterization was not attempted due to localization in the experiments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Constitutive Model Development for Aging Polymer Encapsulants (ASC P&EM FY2021 L2 Milestone 7836)

This SAND report fulfills the completion requirements for the ASC Physics and Engineering Modeling Level 2 Milestone 7836 during Fiscal Year 2021. The Sandia Simplified potential energy clock (SPEC) non-linear viscoelastic constitutive model was developed to predict a whole host of polymer glass physical behaviors in order to provide a tool to assess the effects of stress on these materials over their lifecycle. Polymer glasses are used extensively in applications such as electronics packaging, where encapsulants and adhesives can be critical to device performance. In this work, the focus is on assessing the performance of the model in predicting material evolution associated with long-term physical aging, an area that the model has not been fully vetted in. These predictions are key to utilizing models to help demonstrate electronics packaging component reliability over decades long service lives, a task that is very costly and time consuming to execute experimentally. The initiating hypothesis for the work was that a model calibration process can be defined that enables confidence in physical aging predictions under ND relevant environments and timescales without sacrificing other predictive capabilities. To test the hypothesis, an extensive suite of calibration and aging data was assembled from a combination of prior work and collaborating projects (Aging and Lifetimes as well as the DoD Joint Munitions Program) for two mission relevant epoxy encapsulants, 828DGEBA/DEA and 828DGEBA/T403. Multiple model calibration processes were developed and evaluated against the entire set of data for each material. A qualitative assessment of each calibration's ability to predict the wide range of aging responses was key to ranking the calibrations against each other. During this evaluation, predictions that were identified as non-physical, i.e., demonstrated something that was qualitatively different than known material behavior, were heavily weighted against the calibration performance. Thus, unphysical predictions for one aspect of aging response could generate a lower overall rating for a calibration process even if that process generated better quantitative predictions for another aspect of aging response. This insurance that all predictions are qualitatively correct is important to the overall aim of utilizing the model to predict residual stress evolution, which will depend on the interplay amongst the different material aging responses. The DSC-focused calibration procedure generated the best all-around aging predictions for both materials, demonstrating material models that can qualitatively predict the whole host of different physical aging responses that have been measured. This step forward in predictive capability comes from an unanticipated source, utilization of calorimetry measurements to specify model parameters. The DSC-focused calibration technique performed better than compression-focused techniques that more heavily weigh measurements more closely related to the structural responses to be predicted. Indeed, the DSC-focused calibration procedure was only possible due to recent incorporation of the enthalpy and heat capacity features into SPEC that was newly verified during this L2 milestone. Fundamentally similar aspects of the two material model calibrations as well as parametric studies to assess sensitives of the aging predictions are discussed within the report. A perspective on the next steps to the overall goal of residual stress evolution predictions under stockpile conditions closes the report.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Anisotropy evolution of elastomeric foams during uniaxial compression measured via in-situ X-ray computed tomography

We have characterized the three-dimensional evolution of microstructural anisotropy of a family of elastomeric foams during uniaxial compression via in-situ X-ray computed tomography. Flexible polyurethane foam specimens with densities of 136, 160 and 240 kg/m 3 were compressed in uniaxial stress tests both parallel and perpendicular to the foam rise direction, to engineering strains exceeding 70%. The uncompressed microstructures show slightly elongated ellipsoidal pores, with elongation aligned parallel to the foam rise direction. The evolution of this microstructural anisotropy during deformation is quantified based on the autocorrelation of the image intensity, and verified via the mean intercept length as well as the shape of individual pores. Trends are consistent across all three methods. In the rise direction, the material remains transversely anisotropic throughout compression. Anisotropy initially decreases with compression, reaches a minimum, then increases up to large strains, followed by a small decrease in anisotropy at the largest strains as pores collapse. Compression perpendicular to the foam rise direction induces secondary anisotropy with respect to the compression axis, in addition to primary anisotropy associated with the foam rise direction. In contrast to compression in the rise direction, primary anisotropy initially increases with compression, and shows a slight decrease at large strains. These surprising non-monotonic trends and qualitative differences in rise and transverse loading are explained based on the compression of initially ellipsoidal pores. Microstructural anisotropy trends reflect macroscopic stress-strain and lateral strain response. These findings provide novel quantitative connections between three-dimensional microstructure and anisotropy in moderate density polymer foams up to large deformation, with important implications for understanding complex three-dimensional states of deformation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The 3D printing and modeling of functionally graded Kelvin foams for controlling crushing performance

Mechanical impact protection is an important consideration in many applications, ranging from product transportation to sports. Cellular materials are typically used due to their desirable energy absorption properties and light weight. However, their large deformation and rate dependent responses (especially of polymer foams) are challenging to consider in design. Additionally, the use of foams with uniform properties, such as uniform density and uniform stiffness, often restricts the designed foams to only be suitable for a narrow range of mechanical impact conditions whereas real applications commonly face unpredictable situations. 3D printing offers fabrication flexibility and thus opens the door to create foams with tailored properties. In this work, we investigate the feasibility of using 3D printing for functionally graded foams (FGFs) that are optimal over a broad range of mechanical environments. The foams are fabricated by the recently developed grayscale digital light processing (g-DLP) method which can print parts with locally designed properties. These foams are tested under drop test conditions and with slower displacement control. We also model the large deformation behavior of FGFs using finite element analysis in which we account for the different viscoelastic behaviors of the distinct grayscale regions. We then use the model to examine the impact mitigation capabilities of FGFs in different loading scenarios. Finally, we show how FGFs can be used to satisfy real-world design goals using the case study of a motorcycle helmet. In contrast to prior work, we investigate continuous, functionally graded foams of a single density that differ in their viscoelastic responses. This work provides further insight into the benefits of viscoelastic properties and modulus graded foams and presents a manufacturing approach that can be used to produce the next generation of flexible lattice foams as mechanical absorbers.

3D printing↗

3D Printing of Liquid Crystal Elastomer Foams for Enhanced Energy Dissipation Under Mechanical Insult

Polymer foams are an essential class of lightweight materials used to protect assets against mechanical insults, such as shock and vibration. Two features are important to enhance their energy absorption characteristics: the foam structure and the matrix phase mechanical behavior. This study investigates novel approaches to control both of these features to enhance the energy absorption capability of flexible lattice foams. First, we consider 3D printing via digital light processing (DLP) as a method to control the foam mesostructure across a suite of periodic unit cells. Second, we introduce an additional energy dissipation mechanism in the solid matrix phase material by 3D printing the lattice foams with polydomain liquid crystal elastomer (LCE), which undergo a mechanically induced phase transition under large strains. This phase transition is associated with LC mesogen rotation and alignment and provides a second mechanism for mechanical energy dissipation in addition to the viscoelastic relaxation of the polymer network. Here, we contrast the 3D printed LCE lattices with conventional, thermomechanically near-equivalent elastomer lattice foams to quantify the energy-absorbing enhancement the LCE matrix phase provides. Under cyclic quasi-static uniaxial compression conditions, the LCE lattices show dramatically enhanced energy dissipation in uniaxial compression compared to the non-LCE equivalent foams printed with a commercially available photocurable elastomer resin. The lattice geometry also plays a prominent role in determining the energy dissipation ratio between the LCE and non-LCE foams. We show that when increasing the lattice connectivity, the foam deformation transitions from bending-dominated to stretching-dominated deformations, which generates higher axial strains in the struts and higher energy dissipation in the lattice foam, as stretching allows greater mesogen rotation than bending. The LCE foams demonstrate superior energy absorption during the repeated dynamic loading during drop testing compared with the non-LCE equivalent foams, demonstrating the potential of LCEs to enhance physical protection systems against mechanical impact.

3D printing↗

Comparing field data using Alpert multi-wavelets

In this paper we introduce a method to compare sets of full-field data using Alpert tree-wavelet transforms. The Alpert tree-wavelet methods transform the data into a spectral space allowing the comparison of all points in the fields by comparing spectral amplitudes. The methods are insensitive to translation, scale and discretization and can be applied to arbitrary geometries. This makes them especially well suited for comparison of field data sets coming from two different sources such as when comparing simulation field data to experimental field data. We have developed both global and local error metrics to quantify the error between two fields. Additionally, we verify the methods on two-dimensional and three-dimensional discretizations of analytical functions. Furthermore, we then deploy the methods to compare full-field strain data from a simulation of elastomeric syntactic foam.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Failure of brittle micro-spherical shells embedded in elastomer matrix under indentation

Silicone elastomer filled with glass micro balloons (GMB) is an elastomeric syntactic foam used in electronics and component packaging for encapsulation, potting, stress-relief layer, and electrical insulation purposes. Under mechanical loading, the reinforcing phase, namely the GMBs embedded in the elastomer matrix, may break or delaminate, leading to internal damage and macroscale stiffness degradation, which can alter the material's protective capacity against mechanical shock and vibration. The degree of damage is controlled by the loading history, delamination, and failure behavior of the GMBs. In this work, we investigate the GMB failure behavior in this work wherein we present an indentation experiment to measure the force required to fail individual GMBs that are either embedded in the elastomer matrix or adhered to the surface of an elastomer layer. The indentation apparatus is augmented with an inverted optical microscope to enable in situ imaging of the GMB. Failure modes for the embedded or non-embedded GMBs are discussed based on the morphology of the broken GMBs and the measured failure forces. We also measure the adhesion energy between the glass balloon and the elastomer, based on which the possibility of delamination between the GMB and the surrounding elastomer matrix during the failure process is evaluated. Our results can facilitate the development of a failure criterion of GMBs which is necessary for establishing a physics-based constitutive model to describe the macroscopic damage mechanics of elastomeric syntactic foams.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Predicting the counter-intuitive stress relaxation behavior of glass forming materials

The ability to relax a macroscopically applied stress is often associated with molecular mobility, or the possibility for a molecule to move outside the confines of its current position, within the material of which the stress is applied. In this paper, a viscoelastic constitutive analysis is used to investigate the counter-intuitive experimental observation of “mobility decrease with increased deformation through yield” for a glass forming polymer during stress relaxation while under compressive and tensile loading conditions. The behavior of an epoxy thermoset is examined using an extensively validated, thermorheologically simple, material “clock” model, the Simplified Potential Energy Clock (SPEC) model. This methodology allows for a comparison between the linear viscoelastic (LVE) limit and the true non-linear viscoelastic (NLVE) representation and enables exploration of a wide range of conditions that are not practical to investigate experimentally. The model predicts the behavior previously described as “mobility decrease with increased deformation” in the LVE limit and at low strain rates for NLVE. Only when loading rates are sufficient to decrease the material shift factor by multiple orders of magnitude is the anticipated deformation induced mobility or “mobility increase with increased deformation” observed. While the model has not been “trained” for these behaviors, it also predicts that the normalized stress relaxation response is indistinguishable amongst strain levels in the “post-yield” region, as has been experimentally reported. At long time, which has not been examined experimentally, the model predicts that even the normalized relaxation curves that exhibit “mobility increase with increased deformation” “cross back over” and return to the LVE ordering. Finally, these findings demonstrate the ability of rheologically simple models to represent the counter-intuitive experimentally measured material response and present predictions at long time scales that could be tested experimentally.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Open stack thermal battery tests

We present selected results from a series of Open Stack thermal battery tests performed in FY14 and FY15 and discuss our findings. These tests were meant to provide validation data for the comprehensive thermal battery simulation tools currently under development in Sierra/Aria under known conditions compared with as-manufactured batteries. We are able to satisfy this original objective in the present study for some test conditions. Measurements from each test include: nominal stack pressure (axial stress) vs. time in the cold state and during battery ignition, battery voltage vs. time against a prescribed current draw with periodic pulses, and images transverse to the battery axis from which cell displacements are computed. Six battery configurations were evaluated: 3, 5, and 10 cell stacks sandwiched between 4 layers of the materials used for axial thermal insulation, either Fiberfrax Board or MinK. In addition to the results from 3, 5, and 10 cell stacks with either in-line Fiberfrax Board or MinK insulation, a series of cell-free “control” tests were performed that show the inherent settling and stress relaxation based on the interaction between the insulation and heat pellets alone.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

The kinetics of polyurethane structural foam formation: Foaming and polymerization

We are developing kinetic models to understand the manufacturing of polymeric foams, which evolve from low viscosity Newtonian liquids, to bubbly liquids, finally producing solid foam. Closed-form kinetics are formulated and parameterized for PMDI-10, a fast curing polyurethane, including polymerization and foaming. PMDI- 10 is chemically blown, where water and isocyanate react to form carbon dioxide. The isocyanate reacts with polyol in a competing reaction, producing polymer. Our approach is unique, though it builds on our previous work and the polymerization literature. This kinetic model follows a simplified mathematical formalism that decouples foaming and curing, including an evolving glass transition temperature to represent vitrification. This approach is based on IR, DSC, and volume evolution data, where we observed that the isocyanate is always in excess and does not affect the kinetics. Finally, the kinetics are suitable for implementation into a computational fluid dynamics framework, which will be explored in subsequent papers.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The mechanics of network polymers with thermally reversible linkages

Encapsulated printed circuit boards typically use conventional thermosetting polymers which are difficult to remove without damaging the electronics if upgrades are needed. To improve the efficiency of maintaining printed circuit boards, network polymers with thermally reversible linkages were developed to provide an alternative class of encapsulation thermosets that could be easily and non-destructively removed and later reapplied. These polymers include functionalities that dynamically break and form covalent bonds. Over time, the connectivity of the network evolves, which causes the macroscopic stress in the material to relax and the permanent shape to change even if these processes are in equilibrium. With respect to removal, the equilibrium behavior of these processes changes if the thermodynamic state of the material is changed, which alters the number density of chains. If the number density of chains is reduced below the percolation threshold, the material exhibits a gel-point transition beyond which, it behaves as a viscous liquid. These two properties contrast sharply with conventional thermosetting polymers, which do not exhibit this relaxation mechanism nor a gel-point transition.

Long, Kevin N.↗