Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Lumpkin, Forrest E., III

Publications and source records attributed to Lumpkin, Forrest E., III.

High Fidelity Simulations of Plume Impingement to the International Space Station

With the retirement of the Space Shuttle, the United States now depends on recently developed commercial spacecraft to supply the International Space Station (ISS) with cargo. These new vehicles supplement ones from international partners including the Russian Progress, the European Autonomous Transfer Vehicle (ATV), and the Japanese H-II Transfer Vehicle (HTV). Furthermore, to carry crew to the ISS and supplement the capability currently provided exclusively by the Russian Soyuz, new designs and a refinement to a cargo vehicle design are in work. Many of these designs include features such as nozzle scarfing or simultaneous firing of multiple thrusters resulting in complex plumes. This results in a wide variety of complex plumes impinging upon the ISS. Therefore, to ensure safe "proximity operations" near the ISS, the need for accurate and efficient high fidelity simulation of plume impingement to the ISS is as high as ever. A capability combining computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and the Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) techniques has been developed to properly model the large density variations encountered as the plume expands from the high pressure in the combustion chamber to the near vacuum conditions at the orbiting altitude of the ISS. Details of the computational tools employed by this method, including recent software enhancements and the best practices needed to achieve accurate simulations, are discussed. Several recent examples of the application of this high fidelity capability are presented. These examples highlight many of the real world, complex features of plume impingement that occur when "visiting vehicles" operate in the vicinity of the ISS.

Lumpkin, Forrest E., III↗

Orion Service Module Reaction Control System Plume Impingement Analysis Using PLIMP/RAMP2

The Orion Crew Exploration Vehicle Service Module Reaction Control System engine plume impingement was computed using the plume impingement program (PLIMP). PLIMP uses the plume solution from RAMP2, which is the refined version of the reacting and multiphase program (RAMP) code. The heating rate and pressure (force and moment) on surfaces or components of the Service Module were computed. The RAMP2 solution of the flow field inside the engine and the plume was compared with those computed using GASP, a computational fluid dynamics code, showing reasonable agreement. The computed heating rate and pressure using PLIMP were compared with the Reaction Control System plume model (RPM) solution and the plume impingement dynamics (PIDYN) solution. RPM uses the GASP-based plume solution, whereas PIDYN uses the SCARF plume solution. Three sets of the heating rate and pressure solutions agree well. Further thermal analysis on the avionic ring of the Service Module was performed using MSC Patran/Pthermal. The obtained temperature results showed that thermal protection is necessary because of significant heating from the plume.

Wang, Xiao-Yen↗

The Plume Impingement Contamination II Experiment: Motivation, Design, and Implementation Plan

The International Space Station (ISS) will have a long service life during which it must be able to serve as a capable platform for a wide variety of scientific investigations. In order to provide this capability, the ISS has, at the system level, a design requirement of no more than 100 Angstroms of contaminant deposition per year from "non-quiescent" sources. Non-quiescent sources include the plumes resulting from the firing of reaction control system (ReS) engines on space vehicles visiting the ISS as well as the engines on the ISS itself. Unfortunately, good general plume contamination models do not yet exist. This is due both to the complexity of the problem, making the analytic approach difficult, and to the difficulty in obtaining empirical measurements of contaminant depositions. To address this lack of flight data, NASA Johnson Space Center is planning to fly an experiment, Plume Impingement Contamination-II, to measure the contamination deposition from the Shuttle Orbiter's primary RCS engines as a function angle from plume centerline. This represents the first direct on-orbit measurement of plume impingement contamination away from the nozzle centerline ever performed, and as such is extremely important in validating mathematical models which will be used to quantify the cumulative plume impingement contamination to the ISS over its lifetime. The paper will elaborate further upon the motivation behind making these measurements as well as present the design and implementation plan of this planned experiment.

Lumpkin, Forrest E., III↗

Comparison of continuum and particle simulations of expanding rarefied flows

Comparisons of Navier-Stokes solutions and particle simulations for a simple two-dimensional model problem at a succession of altitudes are performed in order to assess the importance of rarefaction effects on the base flow region. In addition, an attempt is made to include 'Burnett-type' extensions to the Navier-Stokes constitutive relations. The model geometry consists of a simple blunted wedge with a 0.425 meter nose radius, a 70 deg cone half angle, a 1.7 meter base length, and a rounded shoulder. The working gas is monatomic with a molecular weight and viscosity similar to air and was chosen to focus the study on the continuum and particle methodologies rather than the implementation of thermo-chemical modeling. Three cases are investigated, all at Mach 29, with densities corresponding to altitudes of 92 km, 99 km, and 105 km. At the lowest altitude, Navier-Stokes solutions agree well with particle simulations. At the higher altitudes, the Navier-Stokes equations become less accurate. In particular, the Navier-Stokes equations and particle method predict substantially different flow turning angle in the wake near the after body. Attempts to achieve steady continuum solutions including 'Burnett-type' terms failed. Further research is required to determine whether the boundary conditions, the equations themselves, or other unknown causes led to this failure.

Lumpkin, Forrest E., III↗

Resolution of differences between collision number definitions in particle and continuum simulations

The use of the same symbol, Z, representing a 'collision number' for thermal relaxation, has led to confusion regarding its definition in the context of both continuum and particle simulations. Examination of the relaxation mechanics employed in particle simulations demonstrates that these definitions differ by a numerical factor that depends upon the intermolecular potential. Particle and continuum simulations employing appropriate definitions of Z lead to identical results during isothermal and adiabatic stationary relaxation.

Lumpkin, Forrest E., III↗

Accuracy of the Burnett equations for hypersonic real gas flows

Burnett solutions for the structure of normal shock waves for Mach numbers ranging from 1.1 to 50 have been obtained by using the time-dependent equation set in conjunction with modern computational fluid dynamic techniques. The current work seeks to provide corrected and improved high-resolution direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) results for hypersonic shocks in monatomic gases. These DSMC results will serve as a reliable test base for assessing the accuracy of various continuum equations more advanced than Navier-Stokes, such as the Burnett equations. The main conclusion of Fisko and Chapman (1988) that the Burnett equations are more accurate than the Navier-Stokes equations for all gases and at all Mach numbers in matching DSMC shock wave results is reassesed by comparing the improved and corrected DSMC results with continuum Burnett results. Various Burnett results for shocks in a diatomic gas, nitrogen, which include improvements to the work of Lumpkin and Chapman (1989) are presented. It is concluded that the Burnett equations represent a significant improvement over Navier-Stokes equations for flows exhibiting translational nonequilibrium.

Lumpkin, Forrest E., III↗

A new rotational relaxation model for use in hypersonic computational fluid dynamics

The theoretical basis for the Landau-Teller equation commonly used to model rotational nonequilibrium is reviewed. Several assumptions underlying this model are indicated to be unrealistic for rarefied hypersonic flow. A new rotational nonequilibrium model based on recent measurements up to 2000K of quantum state transition rates is presented. The new model is applied to the continuum study of normal shock wave structure using both the Burnett equations and a simplified nonlinear constitutive relation. Comparisons are made between shock wave temperature profiles generated from the new model and those generated using the Landau-Teller model. Comparisons of shock reciprocal thicknesses between experimental data for nitrogen and continuum solutions using both rotational models are made. The new rotational model agrees well with experiment up to Mach 6, and under predicts shock thickness at higher Mach numbers. The Landau-Teller model agrees well with experimental shock thickness up to Mach 3, and over predicts the thickness at higher Mach numbers. A modification to the rotational collision number in the Landau-Teller model is found to give results which agree with experimental shock thicknesses at all Mach numbers up to 11.

Chapman, Dean E.↗