Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Lyons, B. C.

Publications and source records attributed to Lyons, B. C..

At least 19 records

Examining transport and integrated modeling predictive capabilities for negative-triangularity scenarios

This paper investigates the predictive capabilities of TGYRO and TGLF models in assessing the performance of negative triangularity (NT) plasmas compared to positive triangularity (PT) plasmas in fusion devices. TGYRO predicts kinetic profiles, while TGLF analyzes turbulent transport. The study reveals that TGYRO reasonably predicts NT profiles similar to PT, although it overpredicts the high-power scenarios where there is increased experimental MHD activity. TGLF analysis finds reduced linear growth rates in NT and altered flux spectra relative to PT. Additionally, the TGLF SAT0 saturation model is observed to predict high-k transport and a reduction of particle transport with the electron temperature gradient. These findings are further corroborated by core-pedestal modeling using the Stability Transport Equilibrium Pedestal workflow, showing stronger confinement improvements in NT, particularly at higher power densities for the SAT0 saturation model. Furthermore, the study underscores the importance of accurately capturing turbulence saturation mechanisms for NT in order to project its performance accurately in fusion reactors.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Influence of triangularity on the plasma response to resonant magnetic perturbations

The effect of the axisymmetric plasma shape on the non-axisymmetric plasma response to resonant magnetic perturbations is investigated in experiment and modeling for the DIII-D, EAST and ASDEX Upgrade tokamaks. Systematically modeling the effect of the triangularity, whilst keeping other equilibrium quantities largely unchanged, reveals that the plasma response is strongly suppressed at high triangularity compared to that at low triangularity. This is validated through targeted comparison with experiments at DIII-D, EAST, and ASDEX Upgrade. DIII-D and EAST magnetic measurements are used to validate simulations, while at ASDEX Upgrade the plasma edge displacement is measured. Both experiments and modeling find a reduced magnetic plasma response on the high-field side at high triangularity across devices. Multi-modal analysis of the simulation results extracts the mode structure and applied spectrum dependence of each mode. The amplitude of the dominant mode reveals similar trends with the edge resonance and radial displacement near the X-point, which suggests that the multi-mode plasma response provides another way to understand the edge localized mode (ELM) control physics. The plasma response is strongly reduced at high triangularity compared to that at low triangularity, which implies different ELM control effects as shaping is varied. Furthermore, these findings indicate that the plasma shape should be taken into consideration when designing an RMP-ELM control strategy in experiment, and that predictive plasma response calculations can be used to maximize access to RMP-ELM control in future devices by maximizing the coupling between coils and the plasma.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Controlling the size of non-axisymmetric magnetic footprints using resonant magnetic perturbations

The structure of the non-axisymmetric heat load distribution at the divertor plates is determined not only by the toroidal but also from the poloidal spectrum of non-axisymmetric field perturbations. Whether they are intrinsic, like error fields, or they are applied through 3D coils, the non-axisymmetric fields produce complex 3D edge magnetic topologies (footprints) that alter the properties of the heat and particle flux distributions on the divertor target plates. In this manuscript, a study of the impact of applied 3D field poloidal spectrum on the footprint size and structure is done for the DIII-D tokamak using the resistive MHD code M3D-C1 coupled with the field line tracing code TRIP3D. To resolve the impact of the poloidal spectrum of the magnetic perturbation, the relative phase of the two rows of in-vessel 3D coils used to produce both a n = 2 and a n = 3 perturbation is varied, where n is the toroidal harmonic of the magnetic perturbation. This shows that the largest footprint is predicted when the relative phase of the two rows is close to zero, which is also where the resonant coupling with the plasma is maximized. These results suggest that it will be challenging to decouple the footprint size from the requisite resonant coupling for RMP–ELM control. The correlation between the measured heat load and particle flux distributions at the outer divertor plates in DIII-D and the magnetic measurements is in good agreement with the predicted dependence of the magnetic footprint size on the amplitude of the resonant component of the plasma response.

3D fields↗

Simulation of pellet ELM triggering in low-collisionality, ITER-like discharges

3D nonlinear, as well as 2D linear M3D-C1 simulations are used to model ELM triggering by small pellets in DIII-D discharges in the ITER relevant, peeling-limited pedestal stability regime. A critical pellet size threshold is found in both experiment and modeling depending on pedestal conditions, pellet velocity and injection direction. Using radial injection at the outboard midplane, the threshold is determined by M3D-C1 for multiple time slices of a DIII-D low-collisionality discharge that has pellet ELM triggering. Experimental observations show that a larger pellet size than the standard 1.3 mm diameter is necessary for ELM triggering; 1.8 mm pellets triggered several ELMs in cases where a smaller pellet failed. The M3D-C1 simulations are in good agreement with these observations. While the 2D linear simulations give insight into the change of growth rates for various toroidal modes with pellet size, the 3D nonlinear simulations apply a pellet ablation model that mimics the actual injection with good match to the experiment. The 3D nonlinear simulation confirms the pellet ELM triggering for a pellet size larger than the threshold found by the linear simulations.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Benchmarking NIMROD continuum kinetic formulations through the steady-state poloidal flow

In this work, continuum kinetic formulations are employed as a mechanism to include closure physics in an extended magnetohydrodynamics model. Two continuum kinetic approaches have been implemented in the plasma fluid code NIMROD [Sovinec et al., “Nonlinear magnetohydrodynamics with high-order finite elements,” J. Comput. Phys. 195, 355 (2004)] including a Chapman–Enskog-like (CEL) formulation and a more conventional df approach. Ion kinetic closure schemes are employed to describe the neoclassical flow properties in axisymmetric toroidal geometry. In particular, predictions for steady-state values of poloidal flow profiles in tokamak geometry are provided using both the df formulation and two different solution techniques for the CEL approach. These results are benchmarked against analytic theory predictions as well as results from the drift kinetic code DK4D. The continuum kinetic formulations employed here show agreement with both the analytic theory and DK4D results, and offer a novel velocity space representation involving higher-order finite elements in pitch angle.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Neural-network accelerated coupled core-pedestal simulations with self-consistent transport of impurities and compatible with ITER IMAS

pedestal structure, current profile, and plasma equilibrium physics has been developed and tested against a DIII-D discharge. Here, key features of the achieved core-pedestal coupled workflow are its ability to account for the transport of impurities in the plasma self-consistently, as well as its use of machine learning accelerated models for the pedestal structure and for the turbulent transport physics. Notably, the coupled workflow is implemented within the OMFIT framework, and makes use of the ITER integrated modeling and analysis suite (IMAS) data structure for exchanging data among the physics codes that are involved in the simulations. Such technical advance has been facilitated by the development of a new numerical library named OMAS.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Modeling plasma toroidal flow profile control via NTV torque with n = 2 3D fields in MAST-U

Toroidal modeling utilizing the MARS-Q code shows that large (compared to electromagnetic torque) neoclassical toroidal viscous (NTV) torque can be achieved in the plasma core region in reference MAST(-U) L-mode plasmas, by applying the n=2 (n is the toroidal mode number) 3-D fields generated by the magnetic coils used for controlling the edge localized mode and/or by the error field correction coils. Large NTV torque, occurring at relatively slow plasma flow, in combination with strong variation of the torque amplitude versus the coil phasing of the 3-D coils, offers a tool to control the plasma toroidal rotation profile in spherical tokamaks. To effectively employ the toroidal NTV torque, the potentially fast initial flow needs to first be damped by 3-D fields. In conclusion, MARS-Q quasi-linear initial value simulations demonstrate that this is achievable in MAST-U, within the designed 3-D coil current capability for the device.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Transport at high ${\beta_p}$ and development of candidate steady state scenarios for ITER

On DIII-D, the high β p scenario has an internal transport barrier (ITB), β N ~β p ~3,q 95 ~10, and very high normalized confinement H 98,y2 ~1.6. Recently, plasmas starting with these conditions have been dynamically driven to q 95 ~6 and β p ~2, where we find the ITB and high performance persist for five energy confinement times. These conditions are projected to meet the ITER steady-state goal of Q = 5. The ITB is maintained at lower β p with a strong reverse shear, consistent with predictions that negative central shear can lower the β p threshold for the ITB. There are two observed confinement states in the high β p scenario: H-mode confinement state with a high edge pedestal, and an enhanced confinement state with a low pedestal and an ITB. It has been observed in a scan of external resonant magnetic perturbation amplitude that when there are no large type-I ELMs, there is no transition to enhanced confinement. This is consistent with the proposed mechanism for ITB formation being a type-I ELM. Quasilinear gyro-Landau fluid predictive modeling of ITER suggests that only a modest reverse shear is required to achieve the ITB formation necessary for Q=5 when electromagnetic physics including the kinetic ballooning mode (KBM) is incorporated.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Topological bifurcation of magnetic islands in NSTX-U

The topological bifurcation of magnetic islands is observed in two M3D-C1 linear resistive MHD calculations of model NSTX-U equilibria during the application of small 3D magnetic perturbation fields. In comparing to a DIII-D ELM suppression case, reconstructed from shot 147170 at time slice 3745 ms, we propose that stronger kink response in the NSTX-U plasma may be the primary causes of the bifurcations. Island evolution and bifurcation in both the DIII-D and the two NSTX-U cases with the increase of perturbation current are analyzed. Further, a hypothesis is proposed that such magnetic island topology bears an intrinsic property to confine charged particles and cause their density inside the islands to rise, which is examined by implementing a random kick algorithm in the magnetic field line integration code TRIP3D-GPU to approximate electron collisional transport. Although full consideration of all forces between electrons is missing as it requires 3D large scale kinetic simulation in toroidal geometry, the positive result of this approximate transport simulation does provide first step confirmation towards fully validating the hypothesis.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Axisymmetric benchmarks of impurity dynamics in extended-magnetohydrodynamic simulations

A verification benchmark has been carried out between the M3D-C1 and NIMROD extended-magnetohydrodynamics (xMHD) codes for simulations of impurity-induced disruption mitigation. Disruptions are a significant concern for future tokamaks, and high-fidelity simulations are required in order to ensure the success of disruption-mitigation techniques (e.g., shattered-pellet injection) in large-scale fusion reactors. Both MHD codes have been coupled to the KPRAD code for impurity dynamics. The codes show excellent agreement in four axisymmetric, nonlinear simulations, particularly during the thermal quench. This agreement is seen in the time histories of global plasma quantities such as thermal energy, radiated power, and total number of electrons, as well as 2D contours of temperature and current density. The simulations predict that, given the same number of atoms injected, argon quenches the plasma two-to-three times as fast as neon. Furthermore, the inclusion of temperature-dependent Spitzer resistivity causes the current to diffuse and to decay, inducing axisymmetric MHD instabilities that result in a current quench. As a result, this work represents an important verification of the coupled impurity and MHD models implemented in M3D-C1 and NIMROD, giving greater confidence in the ability of both codes to perform more sophisticated disruption-mitigation simulations.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

The effect of plasma shape and neutral beam mix on the rotation threshold for RMP-ELM suppression

Varying the neutral beam injection (NBI) mix reveals a clear pedestal-top rotation threshold for edge localized mode (ELM) suppression by resonant magnetic perturbations. Guided by expectations for the RMP penetration mechanism, the rotation threshold is found to correspond to a critical radius for the ExB rotation zero-crossing. No such critical radius is observed for the electron perpendicular rotation zero-crossing. Varying the amount and ratio of power in different NBI source geometries (termed the NBI mix) also reveals that the rotation threshold can be crossed at widely varying total injected NBI torques. Computing the local torque density at the edge, the rotation threshold is found to be crossed when the local edge NBI torque is negative in nearly all discharges. Reducing the upper triangularity (delta_up ) from the ITER-similar value of 0.3 to 0.1 significantly reduces the pedestal height and width. This in turn: 1) Increases the rotation threshold and yields a more outward critical ExB rotation zero-crossing location. 2) Decreases the density threshold, consistent with a comparable collisionality range at lower pedestal temperatures. 3) Increases the input torque requirement, due to observed lower confinement and smaller intrinsic torque. These findings represent an important step along the road to predicting ELM suppression access conditions in future tokamaks such as ITER, where the toroidal rotation is expected to be low and consequently the rotation zero-crossing far from the pedestal-top.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Predict-first experimental analysis using automated and integrated magnetohydrodynamic modeling

An integrated-modeling workflow has been developed in this paper for the purpose of performing predict-first analysis of transient-stability experiments. Starting from an existing equilibrium reconstruction from a past experiment, the workflow couples together the EFIT Grad-Shafranov solver [L. Lao et al., Fusion Sci. Technol. 48, 968 (2005)], the EPED model for the pedestal structure [P. B. Snyder et al., Phys. Plasmas 16, 056118 (2009)], and the NEO drift-kinetic-equation solver [E. A. Belli and J. Candy, Plasma Phys. Controlled Fusion 54, 015015 (2012)] (for bootstrap current calculations) in order to generate equilibria with self-consistent pedestal structures as the plasma shape and various scalar parameters (e.g., normalized β, pedestal density, and edge safety factor [q 95 ]) are changed. These equilibria are then analyzed using automated M3D-C1 extended-magnetohydrodynamic modeling [S. C. Jardin et al., Comput. Sci. Discovery 5, 014002 (2012)] to compute the plasma response to three-dimensional magnetic perturbations. This workflow was created in conjunction with a DIII-D experiment examining the effect of triangularity on the 3D plasma response. Several versions of the workflow were developed, and the initial ones were used to help guide experimental planning (e.g., determining the plasma current necessary to maintain the constant edge safety factor in various shapes). Subsequent validation with the experimental results was then used to revise the workflow, ultimately resulting in the complete model presented here. We show that quantitative agreement was achieved between the M3D-C1 plasma response calculated for equilibria generated by the final workflow and equilibria reconstructed from experimental data. A comparison of results from earlier workflows is used to show the importance of properly matching certain experimental parameters in the generated equilibria, including the normalized β, pedestal density, and q 95 . On the other hand, the details of the pedestal current did not significantly impact the plasma response in these equilibria. A comparison to the experimentally measured plasma response shows mixed agreement, indicating that while the equilibria are predicted well, additional analysis tools may be needed. In conclusion, we note the implications that these results have for the success of future predict-first studies, particularly the need for scans of uncertain parameters and for close collaboration between experimentalists and theorists.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Helical variation of density profiles and fluctuations in the tokamak pedestal with applied 3D fields and implications for confinement

Small 3D perturbations to the magnetic field in DIII-D ( δ B / B ~ 2 × 10 - 4 ) result in large modulations of density fluctuation amplitudes in the pedestal, which are shown using Doppler backscattering measurements to vary by a factor of 2. Helical perturbations of equilibrium density within flux surfaces have previously been observed in the pedestal of DIII-D plasmas when 3D fields are applied and were correlated with density fluctuation asymmetries in the pedestal. These intra-surface density and pressure variations are shown through two fluid MHD modeling studies using the M3D-C1 code to be due to the misalignment of the density and temperature equilibrium iso-surfaces in the pedestal region. This modeling demonstrates that the phase shift between the two iso-surfaces corresponds to the diamagnetic direction of the two species, with the mass density surfaces shifted in the ion diamagnetic direction relative to the temperature and magnetic flux iso-surfaces. Finally, the resulting pedestal density, potential, and turbulence asymmetries within flux surfaces near the separatrix may be at least partially responsible for several poorly understood phenomena that occur with the application of 3D fields in tokamaks, including density pump out and the increase in power required to transition from L- to H-mode.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

ELM suppression in helium plasmas with 3D magnetic fields

Experiments in DIII-D, using non-axisymmetric magnetic perturbation fields in high-purity low toroidal rotation, 4 He plasmas have resulted in Type-I edge localized mode (ELM) suppression and mitigation. Suppression is obtained in plasmas with zero net input torque near the L–H power threshold using either electron cyclotron resonant heating (ECRH) or balanced co- and counter-I p neutral beam injection (NBI) resulting in conditions equivalent to those expected in ITER's non-active operating phase. In low-power ECRH H-modes, periods with uncontrolled density and impurity radiation excursions are prevented by applying n = 3 non-axisymmetric magnetic perturbation fields. ELM suppression results from a reduction and an outward shift of the electron pressure gradient peak compared to that in the high-power ELMing phase. Here, the change in the electron pressure gradient peak is primarily due to a drop in the pedestal temperature rather than the pedestal density.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Equilibrium drives of the low and high field side n = 2 plasma response and impact on global confinement

The nature of the multi-modal n=2 plasma response and its impact on global confinement is studied as a function of the axisymmetric equilibrium pressure, edge safety factor, collisionality, and L-versus H-mode conditions. Varying the relative phase (ΔΦ UL ) between upper and lower in-vessel coils demonstrates that different n=2 poloidal spectra preferentially excite different plasma responses. These different plasma response modes are preferentially detected on the tokamak high-field side (HFS) or low-field side (LFS) midplanes, have different radial extents, couple differently to the resonant surfaces, and have variable impacts on edge stability and global confinement. In all equilibrium conditions studied, the observed confinement degradation shares the same ΔΦ UL dependence as the coupling to the resonant surfaces given by both ideal (IPEC) and resistive (MARS-F) MHD computation. Varying the edge safety factor shifts the equilibrium field-line pitch and thus the ΔΦ UL dependence of both the global confinement and the n=2 magnetic response. As edge safety factor is varied, modeling finds that the HFS response (but not the LFS response), the resonant surface coupling, and the edge displacements near the X-point all share the same ΔΦ UL dependence. The LFS response magnitude is strongly sensitive to the core pressure and is insensitive to the collisionality and edge safety factor. This indicates that the LFS measurements are primarily sensitive to a pressure-driven kink-ballooning mode that couples to the core plasma. MHD modeling accurately reproduces these (and indeed all) LFS experimental trends and supports this interpretation. In contrast to the LFS, the HFS magnetic response and correlated global confinement impact is unchanged with plasma pressure, but is strongly reduced in high collisionality conditions in both H- and L-mode. This experimentally suggests the bootstrap current drives the HFS response through the kink-peeling mode drive, though surprisingly weak or no dependence on the bootstrap current is seen in modeling. Instead, modeling is revealed to be very sensitive to the details of the edge current profile and equilibrium truncation. Furthermore, holding truncation fixed, most HFS experimental trends are not captured, thus demonstrating a stark contrast between the robustness of the HFS experimental results and the sensitivity of its computation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Steady-state benchmarks of DK4D: A time-dependent, axisymmetric drift-kinetic equation solver

The DK4D code has been written to solve a set of time-dependent, axisymmetric, finite-Larmor-radius drift-kinetic equations (DKEs) for the non-Maxwellian part of the electron and ion distribution functions using the full, linearized Fokker–Planck–Landau collision operator. The plasma is assumed to be in the low- to finite-collisionality regime, as is found in the cores of modern and future magnetic confinement fusion experiments. Each DKE is formulated such that the perturbed distribution function carries no net density, parallel momentum, or kinetic energy. Rather, these quantities are contained within the background Maxwellians and would be evolved by an appropriate set of extended magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations. This formulation allows for straight-forward coupling of DK4D to existing extended MHD time evolution codes. DK4D uses a mix of implicit and explicit temporal representations and finite element and spectral spatial representations. These, along with other computational methods used, are discussed extensively. Steady-state benchmarks are then presented comparing the results of DK4D to expected analytic results at low collisionality, qualitatively, and to the Sauter analytic fits for the neoclassical conductivity and bootstrap current, quantitatively. These benchmarks confirm that DK4D is capable of solving for the correct, gyroaveraged distribution function in stationary magnetic equilibria. Furthermore, the results presented demonstrate how the exact drift-kinetic solution varies with collisionality as a function of the magnetic moment and the poloidal angle.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗